Ravinder Ravi Voted Out, who’s next? - Page 4

Originally posted by: shimmeryf

ani11 why do u bring qazi in discussion ?
he is winner and not a part of this competition.
we are discussing the current contestants and now they are no less than others.They all are really good at performances also .i hope u have observed it .

i was writing in reference to panny's post .She is talking about the X factor and if u mention X factor the mention of Qazi becomes unavoidable.I just used it as an example to highlight my point.

Originally posted by: shimmeryf

jatayau u r getting in to another debate altogether
FG was not a talent hunt we all know it. how many good singers left early bcoz of the drama indian janta craved for ,we all know .
Mona is good but i just wished to say that since she has "PERFORMED " well once or twice ,u cannot put her on the top at this moment in this competition only.

If FG was not a talent hunt then what was it?

But Mona IS on top at the moment no? She's in the last 3.

still i feel X- factor is now present in many singers who performed in dus ke dus .

Originally posted by: shimmeryf

still i feel X- factor is now present in many singers who performed in dus ke dus .

yes i agree with u but how many of them use it like Qazi.I have seen so many singers perform but I have not seen the same response from the audience that Qazi generated.(excuse my using Qazi's name again)

ani11 i wont respond to you bcoz for it i ll have to comment on Qazi and that i dont want to.I want to keep my posts for the present contest only.
bcoz many of us think that they dont make bring in their favs in wrong perspectives but they do .

I disagree with Jatayu completely. If he thinks Mona is a complete package then I have to compare her to Ruprekha whom he syupported who was though a good singer but an average performer at best. She could not dance and still cannot. She was out of breath most of the times. But because JA encouraged her and pushed her forward she won.

Going by Jatayu's complete package criteria she fits in nowhere. Sorry if i have hurt someone.

If that was the criteria then undoubtedly Rex-Qazi should have been the fame jodi.

Again Mona was also voted out by judges, contestants, faculty and the junta. She is in the same boat as Arijit and Shamit.

Arijit is very good. Noone can doubt his talent and as far as performance is concerned he has improved a lot.Even Shamit is improving. To bring Mona up you cannot put down these two I am sorry.

Originally posted by: shefali_123

I disagree with Jatayu completely. If he thinks Mona is a complete package then I have to compare her to Ruprekha whom he syupported who was though a good singer but an average performer at best. She could not dance and still cannot. She was out of breath most of the times. But because JA encouraged her and pushed her forward she won. Going by Jatayu's complete package criteria she fits in nowhere. Sorry if i have hurt someone. If that was the criteria then undoubtedly Rex-Qazi should have been the fame jodi. Again Mona was also voted out by judges, contestants, faculty and the junta. She is in the same boat as Arijit and Shamit. Arijit is very good. Noone can doubt his talent and as far as performance is concerned he has improved a lot.Even Shamit is improving. To bring Mona up you cannot put down these two I am sorry.

😆 no hard feelings i assure you.

Actually it all boils down to personal choice. You like Shamit. I like Mona. No probs there.

Same goes for my liking Ruprekha. Not comparing, but of you have seen any public program of Usha Uthup, u'll know that to bring an audience alive, the artist doesn't need to dance at all.

ok where then ur list of micheal jackson ,madonna and britney goes now ?

Originally posted by: shimmeryf

ok where then ur list of micheal jackson ,madonna and britney goes now ?

😆 That list stays as the purpose of my mentioning it was to show how entertainment scene is moving from "only singing" to "total package" (which came from explaining to another poster that pure singing is slowly yielding some place to performance).

Usha Uthup's example was to show that an artist doesn't need to prance about on stage to connect with the audience (which came from your point that RR can't dance).

same goes for shamit and arijit too then 😊 they dont need to perform as per your say yet they can connect as you can see from the audience response.