To those who have read the book - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

4.3k

Users

8

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

archanajoseph thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Binti's character is the realistic and most practical one! Today she enters the show :)

My personal favorite is Sudha. While reading the book I cried for her many times.
archanajoseph thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK


creatives av made changes in sudha's character. d gal in book is nt that strong. her strength lies in chander. d kashmir sequence wasn't a part of d book.
pammi has seen a lot. i would say dey both belong to different prespectives n bgs.
pammi has seen a life whr lust comes first. betrayal is wat she has seen in her life n that's y she want to achieve happiness. she wants chander at any cost becoz she knows chander ll never hurt her.

yes binti is nt on the extremity like sudha n pammi n may be that's y she has not been introduced till nw. bt lets see hw dey portray binti. bcoz she is an imp character n a new angle of this luv v/s lust.



I think in the show also they have not shown Sudha to be strong. Had Chandar not already present at Kashmir she would never have gone there.
archanajoseph thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

thanks kaush22 for letting me know that binti has not been introduced. as per d book she should av entered d show. nyways u know wat wen i started reading d book i luved d way writer had portrayed sudha n chander's true luv. no expectations nothing at all jst true luv n devotion. dere is a particular scene which i shouldn't reveal bt i don't know whether dey r going to show it in d show or not so i ll jst say that sudha is soul n chander is body. dey r incomplete without each other. pammi is a destroyed gal. she isn't bad. she doesn't luv chander true bt she really respects him. she wanted chander to overcome sorrows of her life. yes a selfish luv or lust watever we say. bt she understands chander better than sudha. she knows hw to manipulate chander bt she knows all her efforts are not going to succeed because ultimately its always d true luv that wins.
bt yes i do like pammi for honesty her upfront nature.
d book is such that u can't hate any character u simply cannot.
to ur last qstn is pammi older than chander yes she is



Which scene are you talking about? Give me hint I will know it.
snehaHCAPK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: archanajoseph

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" color="#006600" size="2">Binti's character is the realistic and most practical one! Today she enters the show :)

My personal favorite is Sudha. While reading the book I cried for her many times.

</font>


yes binti is d most realistic n practical. wow such a gud news d8 finally she has entered in d show..
i felt bad for sudha while reading d book bt sudha was madly in luv wid chander n she made her life miserable herself.
i did cry for sudha n chander's luv n i was literally in shock wen i read wat happens wid gesu. poor girl. gesu again is a very nicely written character. though it was a supporting character bt a very nice one.
there are so many definitions n point of views of luv it becomes really difficult to choose which definition is real n true.
snehaHCAPK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
archna d scene m talking abt is one of d last scenes of sudha n chander. wen chander realises his mistake n sudha comes back to her hometown to meet gesu jst for three four days. a lovely beautiful scene between sudha n chander. i hope d makers will keep the scene as it is. it was one of d best scenes of d book..
archanajoseph thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

archna d scene m talking abt is one of d last scenes of sudha n chander. wen chander realises his mistake n sudha comes back to her hometown to meet gesu jst for three four days. a lovely beautiful scene between sudha n chander. i hope d makers will keep the scene as it is. it was one of d best scenes of d book..




Oh yes!! That is very beautiful scene.. but I doubt they will show that scene without modification!! Let's hope they keep it original :)
kaush22 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK


yes binti is d most realistic n practical. wow such a gud news d8 finally she has entered in d show..
i felt bad for sudha while reading d book bt sudha was madly in luv wid chander n she made her life miserable herself.
i did cry for sudha n chander's luv n i was literally in shock wen i read wat happens wid gesu. poor girl. gesu again is a very nicely written character. though it was a supporting character bt a very nice one.
there are so many definitions n point of views of luv it becomes really difficult to choose which definition is real n true.


Yes I really like Binti's character! she is the best! and I'm really worried about Geesu! Oh is something bad going to happen to her? Ahhh! I hope not but anyways I think the reason why Chander is not going to ask Dr.Shukla to marry Sudha is because they are from different castes! do you think I'm right?
snehaHCAPK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: kaush22



Yes I really like Binti's character! she is the best! and I'm really worried about Geesu! Oh is something bad going to happen to her? Ahhh! I hope not but anyways I think the reason why Chander is not going to ask Dr.Shukla to marry Sudha is because they are from different castes! do you think I'm right?



yes u r right bt its only one of d reasons. dr. shukla has done a lot of favours on him so he can't break his trust. he has made sudha's character n he can't let his teachings fail in the name of luv. he wanted sudha to grow n make everyone proud. he wanted her to be an ideal woman. so he refused to marry her.
snehaHCAPK thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19
i wanted to ask u gyus that the show is of 20 episodes or 20 hrs. i mean each episode of 20 mins is very less. becoz the finite series are of generally 1 hr episodes each n if we go by this then its just 10 episodes.
Edited by snehaHCAPK - 9 years ago
kaush22 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: snehaHCAPK

i wanted to ask u gyus that the show is of 20 episodes or 20 hrs. i mean each episode of 20 mins is very less. becoz the finite series are of generally 1 hr episodes each n if we go by this then its just 10 episodes.


Yeah it is 20 episodes of 20 mins, it is very less and a short time for a finite series! but what to do

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".