Created

Last reply

Replies

986

Views

48.7k

Users

53

Likes

1.5k

Frequent Posters

MagicalMadness thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Vsapras



Awww look who's here .😃



Two kameenis 😆
Cinnamonn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Asgard_Nim

For the confused minds who can't seem to understand what happened.

Creative Writing 101: No two characters are the same in any written piece in this world. ( Taken from Akira's comment which is an actual creative writing point from a creative writing class)

Why is that so? Because the second set of characters would have obviously been taken from the first.

Your friend started this story /after/ reading heartbeat and professing her love for ReyKaash.This can simply be proven by the dates both stories were ongoing. Even in the recent comments here she confessed that there are some same characteristics with her RagNa and ReyKaash.

Hmmm Correct. Also Correct That The Both Stories Were Ongoing. I Confessed They Had Same Characteristics. I did. But Not all Are the Same.



Reyansh: Arrogant, rude, playboy, smokes, has some daddy issues, popular guy around, involved in a sport.

This Raghav: Has all of the above characteristics too.

My Story Is Based On Childhood Love,Then Growing Into Teens Then Adults. I Chose an Idea From a Korean Show,The Academy, Where Rich People Go. Raghav. Does Have It all. Playboy Etc Etc. This story is also Based "Like" a American Show.Many Teen Tv Shows,Have those Effects. Though I said Raghav was Involved In a Sport,It was Never Shown In The Story. He Is The Popular Guy,Just Like Prem,Aryan,Abhay and Sammy. those are all Rich People. Raghav Has Normal Father Issues Which Can Be seen Everywhere,I Can Take That Idea From "Real Life Itself". He Loves His Father But His Father was Away,I Am Sure There are Many Shows Where Children Grow Apart From Their Parents Who Always Go Abroad. Though It Is Shown That Rey Has Father Issues,I Did Not Copy One Single thing From It. Raghav Does Love His Father But Is also Angry He was Never There to Raise Him. In Your Story Rey Hates His Father and His Father Hates Him Right? Plus Most of My Stories Showed Raghav That ,Slept Around, he was Drinker and a Smoker. "Tortured Love,Obsession,,Most Of Them and I Never Read Your Story Before. Those Stories are Ended Now. ,Even twisting kaleidoscope. I have Never Read that Story.



Kaashvi: Innocent, protective family, nerd, doesn't like smoking and even told Reyansh this and wears a pendant given by her mother.

This Kalpi: All of the above even down to the ( and this is quite comical) to wearing a pendant as well. If you want to defend that she is a /bookworm/ the two terms /nerd/ and /bookworm/ are used interchangeably.


Kalpi Is Indeed Innocent,I am Innocent,You are Innocent and Girls all Over the Word are Innocent. Some aren't. Sorry to say Vidya,I can Create a Character Based on real Life too Not Only Stories or Movies. Kalpi is a Bookworm,I Never said she was a Nerd. Bookworms Doesn't Have to be Nerds. The Term Bookworm "A Person Who Enjoys Reading" I read,I am Sure you read. Everyone Reads. Yeah I Get It's Interchangeably But My Aim Was Not For A Nerd But A Bookworm Which Has Many Meanings. But I Made Her Strong and Fierce That She Fights Back With Others the same way. She's Not Meek. Kalpi Doesn't Like Raghav Smoking,But who Likes Smoking?. It's Normal with Girls Who Is Around Boys. Pendant. Now When I Think Of a Pendant,I Think Of Mines. A Girl can Have Bracelets,Earrings,Pendants Etc Etc. and was Gifted By Her Parents By Birth. Protective Family, Do I Seriously Have to Have a Story Hinting Protectiveness? When You Sit And Think About Creating a How a Father would Be, Obviously he'll protect His Offspring,He Won't go shooting it.. Vitthal In EMA Was always Protective Of Kalpi so I took That,Any Father would Be Protective of Their Daughter and I also Hinted Kamla Had Hurt Her daughter and Learnt Her Lesson.

Aside from taking these characteristics some plot points were also conveniently taken as well.

Hmm I didn't read your story and wrote down your plot

-Kaash doesn't like Rey smoking.

Same with this Kalpi and Raghav.

All Young Boys Smoke,It's Something Around and Normal Which People think It's Cool. As I Made Raghav's Character Reckless,I Made Him Smoke,,But Not all People Like smoke,am I supposed to Let Kalpi Sit next to raghav and Inhale the Smoke Instead Of Telling Him She doesn't Like it?

-There is an outside setting where the two characters ( in an effort on the part of the writer to show their growing bond) they dance to a song.

I Made Many Outdoor Settings,Where they Spoke and Laughed.But Dance to a Song,Which Song. I've Never Done a Setting Like that. I've Never written Them Dancing to a Song Outdoors.😕

Same with this story.

-Introducing a school project in an effort to bring the characters closer.

Same with this story.

Yeah,Since there were In an Academy I Decided that a school play would bring them closer and they did dance to a song "Fitoor" I would say more man handling. School's Have Drama Class Which I Think It's Normal to Have a Play. Your Characters are Married and No Longer In School.


-Male character has a strained relationship with his father.

I mentioned before about his strained relationship

Same with this story.

-Male character who is very bold stands up to the family ( in heartbeat Rishav) to show that he is not going to let anyone come in between his relationship with Kaashvi or be daunted by the brother and will continue to be with female character.


This story male character who is bold also stands up to the family and shows that he is not going to be daunted by the family and will continue being with the female character.

Raghav Is Reckless and Careless. But I wanted to show That Though He's Like that,He does care for Others. Your Character has been changed throughout the whole story,My character has never been changed,he will always be reckless. Movies From Bollywood,Have Inspired Us as Well,There are Many Movies,Books With Careless and Reckless Boys. Who Also Drink,Smoke and Sleep Around. It doesn't Have to be one story,You can put many ideas together. I Wrote a Story,When Ema Ended Named "Kalpana's Love" I showed RagNa's Daughter Hated Her Father, Was Rude to Him Openly In front Of Her Mother. She Hated Her Grandmother and took revenge on Kapoors..


-Male character threatens to shoot his father if he interferes in the relationship.

Same with this story.

I Haven't Caught Up on all the Chapters Vidya. The Idea Of Raghav Shooting was To Allow him to release Anger. So I Got the Idea From a Korean Show. A Shooting Range. I have No Plans Of Following Your Story. Where Your Character had Boxing not shooting.

I asked you friend to show me /another story/ where /these same things were at play all at once too/. She failed to show me another story because there are only two we know of which have /these same things at play all at once/ and that is "In A heartbeat" and This "Fated to love you."

I Cannot show You All At Once,That's something you expect me to do. But I can't. Few. I cannot Get The Same Exact Things,But you will get it separated and All Over. Arshi Stories I Had Read, Had The Same Playboy thing. Even Maan and Geet. Same Playboy things.Even Tv Serials. If You go on their Forums So Can See it All. Movies and Life Itself Shows Things In Your Story. and Someone can easily take it from Life and write something. This Story Has a Little Sleeping around.



These are just some things, I honestly don't have the time to state anything more since this alone glaringly proves that characteristics and plot points were taken. If you all still can't understand, ask someone to translate it in french for you then. Because it will mean you just rather turn a blind eye to it.

Peace.


I Understand My Fault In This,Because Everything Seems Copied,But Trust Me. I Had No Intentions Of Stealing Anything From Anyone. When I Look Back,At The Points You Threw Out,Things Make Sense But I Also Said Some Facts As Well. But It Doesn't really Matter If You Trust Me Or Not. But I Didn't Wake Up One Day Deciding That I Would Take Your Hard work and Make a Story out of it. I Will Change My Two Characters and Keep Things That is Normal and Needed. Many Stories Around Have The "Angry Young Man Who Sleep,Drinks and Smokes." Not Only Yours Nor Mines. Because If Your Story alone In the World Have That, Then I Am Certainly A Major Thief and Others Before You Are Thiefs,Life Is a Thief. truth Be Told,I Cannot Name All The Stories That Have Drinking and Smoking,I Can Name Many Shows and I Can Say people In real Life Does It. But I cannot Say Which Story,After All the Same Shows are A Story Just Turned Into Film. So,I Will Change My Characters,Plot stays the same. RagNa to Fall In Love and That was It. Story is Done.

I Apologize Not Confess. I Apologize That It Came to This. That My Characters Have a Resemblance To Yours. And I Am Sure,There are a Few Resemblance To yours as Well, from Other Stories or shows. Really,I am Being Honest,When I Came of This Story. I didn't think Of Rey and Kaasvhi at All. Kalpi is Nothing Like Your Character. But In Ema. Raghav Did Drink and He was An Angry Young Man. That I Would Keep. Some of The Things I Mentioned Had Never Happened In The Story as yet. But I will Say This, I may Be Young But I'm Not Stupid. ,Everything It's Ended. You Don't Have to Worry About Anything Now. I'm Certainly Not After Your Story. You Can Go to your Blog In Peace. if I didn't Make any Sense Then 🥱 I Have nothing else to say. Not all stories will Have the Same thing as Yours. And I Did Love Reykaash But I didn't decided to steal them and write about them.
If I Can't Prove My Innocence Then,It's Pitiful for Me. But I haven't took a Character Out of a Book Or Anything,It was From Life and Movies as Well. But I'll Change them if you find a Bad fault.. I'm Sorry Once Again

I Apologize to You Once Again and To Your Readers,Sincerely,It's Humble From My Side. 😊
I Will Make My Changes and That's It. Talk is Done. End of story.


Edited by -Ariaana- - 9 years ago
Cinnamonn thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Asgard_Nim


Of course they can be inspired by life Arianna. Of course. But considering you read heartbeat /first/ with /all of these thing is play/ and /then got inspired for your story/ I don't see how you can actually come now and attempt to say that all of this in your story was probably inspired from life. And also you did say before that you loved ReyKaash and some of your RagNa characteristics are similar. But the way you claimed you wanted to explain something to me by facts and you were going to, I am waiting for you to show me another story as well with all of these things in play too.

Because Arianna in case this is eluding you, the issue here, is that your story share these similarities to my story. All of these similarities that are on ONE of my story is on ONE of your stories.

So if you want to show my someone else actually came up with these exact things for ANOTHER STORY, because that is really the only way you can show why I shouldn't have a problem with this, then I would like you to point me to that story because I will like to read it too. I honestly didn't know another story like this existed with all of these things in play too and I would like to read it. And I am sure my readers will like to read it too.

Also creating a character from a /book/ with the /same characteristics as the book character/ is plagiarism so tread carefully. Plagiarism is why I am here now and why I am awaiting this explanation you have to give me to prove your innocence.



Thank You For Explaining. I Understand What You're Saying. It's a lesson learnt From this. If My Explanation seems Shitty Then. I will Happily Change Everything,There's Not Bad Thing with That.
IronThor thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Your explanation is so comical it is making me laugh, no offence. The mere fact that you said your character isn't involved in sports, you can't use that show as reference because I can used my story as reference where all of the characteristics are present. Also if you got this idea from the show, why did you say in the beginning of the thread that /you/ got this /different concept/ and want to try it out? That simple sentence made it look like you were saying you came up with this on your own really. Writers sometimes mention their source of inspiration or where they got the idea from. I know I did for Lion and Panther and even Face in clouds.

The characters being married, hello Aria, I am sure you read the initial chapters of heartbeat. They were not married there they were in school.

As for dancing in outside, I know I saw that but to go back to the chapter, now I don't know if that is edited out. But there was a scene with them slow dancing outside something along that line to show a growing bond <----- Now that I have double checked it again, it wasn't slow dancing but they were outside. You used a song, they were hugging or something like that. So that was my mistake. With the song, I thought it led to slow dancing. However can't help but think the aim was the same. Show them outside with a song in play to show bond growing closer. But I am sure you got that conveniently from a movie.

Also don't get me started on the overly possessiveness, you don't need a boyfriend. I can point to heartbeat which you did read where Rey showed the same possessiveness of telling her that he wasn't going to allow her to have a boyfriend if he knew her.

" Many Stories Around Have The "Angry Young Man Who Sleep,Drinks and Smokes." Not Only Yours Nor Mines. Because If Your Story alone In the World Have That, Then I Am Certainly A Major Thief and Others Before You Are Thiefs,Life Is a Thief. truth Be Told,I Cannot Name All The Stories That Have Drinking and Smoking,I Can Name Many Shows and I Can Say people In real Life Does It" <---- I honestly feel like you are just not understanding what I am saying by trying to use this useless justifications. Yes other stories have these things. But do those stories also have, involved in sports, daddy issues, standing up to family boldly to show they are going to do what they want to be with the person they like, arrogant and rude but still shows kindness to those he loves, overly possessive, threatens to shoot father for interfering with his relationship. No right? Again let me point you to two stories that has all of this going on. In a heartbeat and fated to love you.

And just so you know Rey is reckless. He is a motocross racer which is a reckless sort of sport. He still has his temper and you saw it. And yes my character showed changes but he was nice to those he loves, his friends, his mother. So again don't know what you were trying to prove here by saying Raghav is still reckless but you wanted to show he still cares for others because you actually confirming this is another characteristic that is similar with Rey and your Raghav. WELL DONE.

"But I Made Her Strong and Fierce That She Fights Back With Others the same way. She's Not Meek." <------ Wow. You are trying to show originality here?And Kaashvi didn't show her fiery nature when she had too? Should I point to the updates where she shows her fiery nature with Reyansh particularly during the school project?

As for everything else where you want to say stuff are from other stories, movies, it has been done before. AGAIN. I was ASKING YOU to POINT ME to a story or movie THAT HAS ALL OF THESE THINGS AT PLAY AT ONCE. Your story has these things in play AT ONCE, down to the pendant, down to every damn thing. The only story that has ALL OF THESE THINGS AT PLAY AT ONCE, is mine.

TWO STORIES. BOTH WITH TWO CHARACTERS WITH SIMILAR CHARACTERISTICS. BOTH WITH SIMILAR PLOT POINTS. COINCIDENCE? And you want to give me this rather patchy explanation to say you pulled it from here and there. Yes other stories have playboys. Yes other stories have innocent nerds and bookworms. BUT WITH THESE SAME CHARACTERISTICS, IN TWO STORIES WITH SIMILAR PLOT LINES, I haven't seen another story like that.

Oh and again with the lies? AGAIN WITH THE LIES ARIA? You never read twisting??????????? OH REALLY? Kind of like you never read lion and panther and then admitted, oh yeah you read some chapters. I HAVE SCREEN SHOTS OF YOU LIKING TWISTING UPDATES. ENOUGH WITH THE LIES. I think you just managed to dig yourself into a bigger hole here by proving you are a liar.


This is the height of despicableness. Disgusting that you still think you are innocent here.

Change these characters. REMOVE THESE PLOT POINTS. This explanation IS NOT ACCEPTED.
Edited by Asgard_Nim - 9 years ago
redpetal thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Hi sweeties please stop this. A kind request to both of you. I don't like to see 2 wonderful writers like this😭.
sampa79 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
Dear is there any problem
Is there any chance of update
7APK thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Yayyy !!!! Raghav and Kalpana are Boyfriend and Girlfriend ...
Super - Duper Amazing ...
Awesome Update ...
Loved it...
Continue Soon 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".