Biggest problem with Durga

nuckts thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I like her character,she is righteous,she is playing these games to justice for her sister all that is nice but the problem is that she always judges everyone,she is making everyone part of her game plan fine when that trio-shaurya n his parents suffer but why is she playing with innocent people as well

dev-a guy who actually did nothing yes he didn't support her due to his unavailabilty ,circumstances but atleast he did not support goenkas directly by giving a false statement in court! yes she never thinks of the possibility that his account must have got hacked, as he childhood best friend would never do such a thing and even to be honest if he did something like that still i won't be angry at him as he is still neutral rather than breaking her heart directly at the court n proving payal as a characterless girl

dev's mom-she still doesn't believe somewhere about payal n nitya being wrong, but still that mother is suffering whose son did nothing?

bagchi family- bagchi's daughter saw that heinous crime in front of her eyes,still she was ready to give her statement in court in favour of payal but what happened durga first made shaurya give bagchi his eyes and then it striked saakshi and she created a situation where bagchi family could get burnt alive ,yes durga saved them but what if she could not? why are they paying in her fight?

payal herself-now after 2 years she is recovering and when however she was living suddenly just for her game plan just to see shaurya's reaction she brought shaurya in front of payal where she remembered all those horrifying memories why? remember when once dr.thakur said that payal is recovering and durga didn't pay attention because she was thinking about her plan to get even with ganguly now somewhere she is becoming obssessed with revenge
sagarika-ganguly's daughter what was her fault that she had to witness such a horrible truth of her father, and even after she comes back home and tells her mom about it,her mom tells her to be quiet and here durga doesn't understand her situation but feels "mera badla kaise pura hoiga"? she wanted to control her reaction to that truth,she expected sagarika to come out of that truth immediately and do only what durga wants 😕 but i appreciate one thing that durga still made them incharge of their property 👏

nandini-yes in the bookish term she was wrong as no one puts their values on stake but whatever it was she was ultimately doing it due to her conditions where she had no option except that and she also must be having some reasons
but durga did not do anything to protect her dignity in front of the whole public where whole world could witness what she is doing


according to durga she is doing all this for her sister but what about her sister who feels that her sister ,her nitya di is dead?already thee is no one from payal's family and if she could feel a ray of hope after knowing that nitya is alive she could atleast feel happy as her 1 family member is there
Somewhere though may not Durga but the makers try to show her character as resemblance to maa durga but the point is that maa durga would never let innocent people suffer like dev,dev's mother,payal,bagchi family,sagarika,nandini and if innocent people suffer,show should stop showing her as self proclaimed durga maata(though she never says but the show projects that way)
i know many people might feel that even though innocent people are suffering so its like "jung mei to qurbaani deni hi padti hai" but the people who are bringing their life in danger are not soldiers whose life should be at stake for one person's fight
these were my views!😊

Edited by nuckts - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

2.4k

Users

10

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

bookworm-ALS-- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
I agree on your take on Dev and his mom but not on the ones for Payal and Divya.

As far as Divya was concerned Durga did everything she could to shield Bagchi and his daughter. It is not her fault that Sakshi decided to kill them. She is not to be blamed for them.


As far as Payal is concerned, I don't remember making her meet Shaurya. What I remember is her being pretty helpless to stop Shaurya who had already arrived at the clinic. Not Durga's fault. And she cannot risk Payal knowing who she is! What if Payal lets out something???


Durga has faults too but they make her real. Durga's main fault is being judgemental but I think, if I went through her situation, I would hate Dev too.
I don't want Durga to be perfectly nice. She is the better of for having a few faults.

:)


xXRzmastiXx thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
True durga's main motive is now to take revenge from the goenka family. The thing i didnt like about durga was taking revenge on dev. I feel it wasnt justified well enough. I mean shes knows him since childhood so before thinking negative about him she could have gave second thoughts maybe someone hacked into his email id. Why did dayal have to point it ? Why did she not make that assumption. But then again she went thru alot during the whole rape case n her parents died and had no suppport. So perhaps all that builded up n did not want to trust anyone.

But the other things u said i dont agree. For e.g divya and her dad who was witness to rape case. No durga is not just concerned about her revenge. Yes she should have been more careful . If she was then saksi never would have been able to kidnap them n attempt to burn them alive. But coz she cares for divya and her dad she sent them abroad asap so goenka doesnt cause anymore harm to them.she does realise for her revenge divyas life could be in danger. She could have easily re opened the case using divyas help but durga was more concerned about their safety.

Same goes for nandini and sagarika.
Durga saved them both from that creep ganguly.
Edited by xXRzmastiXx - 11 years ago
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
@nuckts you said it right maa durga never punishes wrong people. And every time Durga's moves have wavered maa durga herself has shown her the right way. Also Dr Dayal who acts as her conscience nudges her on the right path.
In bringing Shaurya to Payal she too suffered, now in Dev's accident she too will suffer. But if you want justice the path is harder. Pain will be there on both sides.

It is just like telling in MB for avenging Panchali's insult a war ensued in which even Pandavas loss their kith and kin. Especially the young Abhimanyu who was brutally killed. So what is the solution. The war should not have been fought. Panchali should feel guilt and accept the injustice done to her. Pandavas should suffer more injustice in the hands of Kauravas.

When you are fighting a war the cause is important. Why you are fighting. Durga's cause is right and it is exactly why Maa Durga is there guiding her always.

Her fight is not only for Payal it is for hundreds of Payal's for whom justice is denied
nuckts thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: bookworm-ALS--

I agree on your take on Dev and his mom but not on the ones for Payal and Divya.

As far as Divya was concerned Durga did everything she could to shield Bagchi and his daughter. It is not her fault that Sakshi decided to kill them. She is not to be blamed for them.


As far as Payal is concerned, I don't remember making her meet Shaurya. What I remember is her being pretty helpless to stop Shaurya who had already arrived at the clinic. Not Durga's fault. And she cannot risk Payal knowing who she is! What if Payal lets out something???


Durga has faults too but they make her real. Durga's main fault is being judgemental but I think, if I went through her situation, I would hate Dev too.
I don't want Durga to be perfectly nice. She is the better of for having a few faults.

:)


thanks for replying
yes i do agree durga did whatever she could to shield bagchi but it was shown that it was durga who though indirectly but makes shaurya make the payment of operation which he does to impress durga but immediately sakshi comes to know that the person who shaurya helped was bagchi and before this incident saakshi had forgotten about bagchi but after this incident her instinct caught that something is fishy and thus she tried to kill him n also his daughter
and about payal well yes it is shown once that akash(before its revealed that he sides durga) clicks pics of durga with payal and shows it to saakshi n saakshi forwards them to shaurya,and to prove him that for her payal is her favorite patient she brings shaurya in front of her eyes
and payal's condition becomes miserable
nuckts thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: xXRzmastiXx

True durga's main motive is now to take revenge from the goenka family. The thing i didnt like about durga was taking revenge on dev. I feel it wasnt justified well enough. I mean shes knows him since childhood so before thinking negative about him she could have gave second thoughts maybe someone hacked into his email id. Why did dayal have to point it ? Why did she not make that assumption. But then again she went thru alot during the whole rape case n her parents died and had no suppport. So perhaps all that builded up n did not want to trust anyone.


But the other things u said i dont agree. For e.g divya and her dad who was witness to rape case. No durga is not just concerned about her revenge. Yes she should have been more careful . If she was then saksi never would have been able to kidnap them n attempt to burn them alive. But coz she cares for divya and her dad she sent them abroad asap so goenka doesnt cause anymore harm to them.she does realise for her revenge divyas life could be in danger. She could have easily re opened the case using divyas help but durga was more concerned about their safety.

Same goes for nandini and sagarika.
Durga saved them both from that creep ganguly.

thanks for replying i agree with your points
and even i appreciate what you said about bagchi n nandini
but what i am only pointing out is that this all could have been avoided if she would not have been the reason for shaurya treating bagchi as till that time saakshi had forgotten about bagchi n family but after this incident she became alert n once a powrful person becomes alert in a negative manner there is no limit to such person's evil intentions
the fire within saakshi to protect her child was given more heat and thus she became dangerous for them
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I agree with point on Payal. I disagreed with her action of producing her before Shaurya.
And Dev perhaps.

But not others. Durga united Bagchi with daughter and did everything to save them.

Truth of Ganguly had to be out. Not her fault if his family suffered. She rather encouraged them to break free from abuse and arranged lawyer and financial help for the mother-daughter duo.
She should have respected Nandini's privacy though. But she arranged job and financial help for her.

Tomorrow she has to take down doctor, pandit etc so does it mean she ruined their families?

She was harsh with Dev. A problem at work would have been better if she wanted to trouble him. But revenge makes less sense. It was more anger at bestie's betrayal than his role in case.


taani_20 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Hey I agree these might be seen as the flaws in Durga, but I'm kind of happy that they are showing it this way. In my opinion, there is a thin line between "justice" and "revenge." I personally never refer to Durga's mission as revenge. Instead she's seeking justice, which she rightfully deserves, for her sister and her family, which she didn't get from the law so she is getting her own way. But in reality, when people set out to get justice on their own, it's tricky, and it's easy to cross over into the personal revenge zone. Durga has done that with Dev I think. Whenever she talked about bringing down Mathur, Ganguly or Goenka evil trio, she always referred to the wrong they had done with her sister. Ruining them meant giving them what they deserved, giving justice to Payal and deaths of her parents, and doing good to the entire society by getting rid of such unethical people. But whenever Durga rants about revenge on Dev, it is never about Payal. It is always about her own feeling of betrayal by a best friend. Dev had no direct role in Payal's case, neither positive or negative. And I think this happens when you're out for justice, sometimes you start feeling like everyone is an enemy and everyone must be taken down. Hopefully now with her knowing Dev's "innocence" she will go back to focusing on getting even with the right people.

I agree with your point on Payal too. I noticed that scene too where Dr. Dayal talks of Payal's progress but Durga is too busy with justice talk. And even that I think happens in reality. Why do some people say "if you're going to take revenge, dig a grave for yourself too" or some saying like that. Because the revenge feeling is like that. It is so easy to get completely blinded by it and Durga does sometimes (I'm glad she does because it shows she's a normal person flawed at times). Luckily, Dr. Dayal is perfect support who tries to stop her from getting too blinded by revenge desire. Anyways, I'm glad they are showing the so-called "negative" impacts that a revenge mission can have on the person too.

Btw, I'm Taani and this is my first post here, although I have been a silent reader on the forum since the beginning. Nice to meet you all. 😊
Preternatural thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
I agree. esp about Payal. Durga is somehow forgetting Payal in her game-plan. Payal needs care from her own people. Whenever we see Payal either had an attack or she's with the doctor. In only one episode we saw Dayal caressing her that too in her sleep. Well I think she needs to be with people whom she can talk or cry. Because loneliness makes a person (esp a victim like Paya) worse.
Dolly-heart thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
Nitya has adorned this Avatar of Durga to get justice for her sister.

And to do that she sometimes does end up hurting innocent people around people that have done wrong.

I am sure she does keep a close check on her sister Payal. If she was constantly shown where Payal is ,then this show will drag on forever.

It is given that she loves her sister and has gone through two years of her life to come back and fight for justice for Payal.

Payal would not have made this much progress if she was completely ignored.

In the cases where Durga has taught a lesson too the culprit she has helped the family of the culprit that needed it.

Durga was very emotional when she saw Gunguly beat his wife and daughter, she was also feeling the pain but to get the two faced Gunguly she had to bear with it.

But Durga knows to get all the people that destroyed Payal and her family she will have to sometimes harm some people around Evil doers.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".