Who am I and Who are you?...And what do you want me to be!

chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

And now I feel just numb...You explained it only too well... Who am I to you? How well do you know me?

I am the woman who would leave her child for her selfish gains...Though I know even your mother is not that.

I am the woman who would mercilessly plot to make someone's life miserable,also the one who would carelessly and selfishly go about demanding my wishes be fulfilled...

Thank you for letting me know who I am, Shravan...You have just opened my eyes.

And also for letting me know who you want me to be. You want me to be the woman who warms her husband's bed, and gets her wishes fulfilled in return! The uncomplicated woman who would allow herself to be manipulated like a doll...and be happy so long as she can be a doll...Thank You. That is the greatest advice anyone has given me so far.

Why is it that you can't see me? Is it because you choose to see only what you want to see? Why do you think the worst of me at all times? Why does that come so easily to you?

Do I have to beg you to stop for a second and see me as I am?

Who am I, Shravan?

I am just a girl. If I say I am an orphan, you'd say I am digging for sympathy- so I will not say that.

I am just a girl. But I do know I am not the only girl. For I belong to generations of women who have had to adjust, sacrifice, give up on their dreams...for their parents, their brothers, their husbands, their children.

Some have been acknowledged for the same, some have been taken for granted. But I know I am not alone.

I have been asked to compromise many a time...why do you think I see to it that my li'l sister's dreams are never shattered...why do I make sure her every whim comes true...It is because I don't want her to go through what I have gone through. If she can have a life every woman deserves to have, let her. Let her live her life for every dream of mine that has been refused.

Who am I? I am just this girl. What do I want? ... There was a time I thought you'd understand...

...

I just want to make sure the people around me are happy, Shravan. I don't have any big dreams anymore. I am scared to wish for anything for myself...Just plain scared.

I'd rather live knowing my reality...that I cannot bank on anyone...and if I ever do that , that'd be a debt I would be asked to pay up. It is just like you said. You did this for me, You did that for me...what have I done for you?

What have I done for you, Shravan?...Will whatever I do ever measure up to what you have done for me? Now we both know the answer.

How much do you want me to compromise? Do tell me.

And you told me about the compromise you'd have to make tonight...

I am cold and numb...I don't even feel the pain anymore. I just hope I'll never have to regret I gave my heart to you. And I don't even know why I wish anymore.

Good Night.



PS: The episode was so gripping.👏 Back in the Sumo bashing days, I remember arguing over so many posts about Shravan getting to know Suman and appreciating her for WHO SHE IS. Yesterday was the script getting just there. I am so very much bowled over by the writing, I must say.😳

It is not about a hate wedding or a triangle or a mother- son reconciliation.

When I watched the promo of this show, what struck me was Shravan's attitude towards women...it was such a realistic portrayal of a man who calls himself cultured, yet he is narrow minded enough not to see that he is blind...Had been such a fascinating aspect of his character. It is so benign on the outside..After all, he is handsome, he is young and successful..and all he is asking for is a wife who would stick to him. But how well does he know this person he has loved for so many years? What in the world does he know of her!

Excited for the answers Shravan himself will be seeking in the coming episodes.

😊


Created

Last reply

Replies

76

Views

4k

Users

20

Likes

331

Frequent Posters

poppinss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Res... lots to say. For Shravan... for a change 😃
Unres

Chick, beautiful post as usual. Thank you for making this one.

I am basically a hardcore Sumo girl. But... I feel the story at the moment, is skewed towards the FL and the ML is looking like the villain. I know the cvs WILL bring things around but... time for me to do some Sumo bashing for a change... Please bear with me 😉

Cause and effect and Snowball effect. These are the two things that come to my mind when I think of the current conundrum.

I would not discount Shravan's contribution of blunders in all this.. but Sumo has her equal share too. Her mistakes are not current, but that does not give her cover either.

Mistake 2:

The whole thing started with Sumo's promise to Ramu. She promised to not reveal her feelings to Shravan. The cvs slipped here and added 2 additional clauses

1. Shravan declares his love... Sumo would not stop and promise broken
2. Shravan is in danger she would not stop herself.

So... Sumo wouldn't want 2 to come true... so she guns for 1.

She promises Ramu for her sister and lets Shravan go. But, instead of sticking to the promise tried to steer Shravan towards goal no 1 😃. The stupid girl knew how possessive and jealous her man is about her... BUT did it stop her? She teases Shravan in front of Adi... Sumo was aware of Shravan's state of mind, his confusions but still pretends to lead on Adi. And Shravan reacted, and rest is history!

Mistake 1:

Sumo is someone who talks about honesty... so why was she not honest with Shravan about Ramu's offer. Irrespective of the consequence.

Is it fair for Preeti to get married to Pushkar inspite of his mother's non acceptance? (we live in India and we marry into the family mother is the family especially if the son has no say!!).

If the Tiwaris knew that Pushkar would never say yes... and when everyone in Tiwari killa had given up on the marriage what made Mahan Sumu to sacrifice her love? Beats me... Sumo.

Why does Sumo take decisions alone? Decisions that need to be taken in a consultative fashion with the family. Mind you, Preeti is not her daughter, not even her sister...(cousin). So why take responsibility, especially when this might not result in a happy situation. Kamini is dead against this match and that might spell doom to Pretti in the future. Why did he not reveal this to Nanu?

Having said that... in the current scenario Shravan has behaved despicably and is the bigger sinner of the two...

BUT... if we do a root cause analysis we know where it all started. THAT does not excuse Shravan of the mistakes he has committed till now or the ones he is going to commit in the near future.

But the end result is.. they are both hurting. And neither will find happiness without the other. Both have failed the other... as friend and lover.

What I would like to see is for Sumo to find a way to call off this marriage with Adi and focus on her work and family. Like any sane, independent girl would do.

And Shravan to find a way out of the grave that he has dug for himself.

Looking forward to what the CVs have in store for us...
Edited by poppinss - 9 years ago
noexcuse thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Sumon's perspective ---touched my heart. You wrote so beautifully.
I hope you are right and CVs do not lose the grip and Shravan seeks answers to those questions for himself.
Edited by noexcuse - 9 years ago
sanfan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
RES...I have lots to say too...😉
Updated on page 9
Edited by sanfan - 9 years ago
poppinss thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sanfan

RES...I have lots to say too...😉


I am jumping to the Shravan club for this particular post 😆
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: noexcuse

Sumon's perspective ---touched my heart. You wrote so beautifully written.
I hope you are right and CVs do not lose the grip and Shravan seeks answers to those questions for himself.


Pretty sure they are headed in that direction! 😊
It is not just her perspective..This is what Shravan is, IMO.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: poppinss


I am jumping to the Shravan club for this particular post 😆


Haan jee...Toh shuroo kijiye.😆
KostinsQueen thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
NO WORDS CHICK
THIS POST IS EVERYTHING , U GAVE REPLY TO ALL THOSE WHO R ASKING AGAIN & AGAIN FOR SUMAN'S BREAK DOWN & TO THOSE WHO R SO CONCERNED ABOUT HER REVELATION OF HER FEELINGS .👏
FOR ME IT'S SUMAN WHO IS STRONG MORE THAN SHRAVAN , SHE IS NOT SELFISH , SHE IS NOT MANIPULATIVE, SHE IS RESPONSIBLE & SUCCESSFUL. ANYONE CAN CONNECT TO SHRAVAN , BUT ONLY FEW CAN CONNECT TO SUMAN.
FROM
" MAIN BAAKI AURATHON KE BAARE MEIN JO SOCHTHA HOON USE THUME KOI LENA DHENA NAHI , MAIN THUMHARI BAARE MEIN AISA KABHI NAHI SOCHTHA, THUM UN SAB SE ALAG HO "
TO
" IN SAB MEIN SE KAHATHARNAK THUM HO JIS MEIN DHOKA , ZEHER , SWARTH SAB HAI " TOTALLY SHOWED HOW HE IS THINKING ABOUT HER RN.AND WHEN HE SAID THAT A LADY MUST SATISFY HIS MAN IN BEDROOM TO GET ALL HER DEMANDS FULFILLED, EVEN THEN HIS ACTIONS R JUSTIFIED SAYING HE IS IN PAIN , HE IS HURT. .THIS & THAT , THEN Y NOT SAME JUSTIFICATIONS TO HER ?
THANKFULLY HE FEELS THE PAIN , BUT SHE NO MORE SENSES THE PAIN, SHE IS NUMB.

I DON'T MEAN TO BASH SHARAVAN & SUPPORT SUMAN , THEY BOTH R MY OTP , I LOVE SHRAVAN, SUMAN , SHRAMAN .AS PER ME , THEY BOTH R WRONG ,NO ONE IS RIGHT , THAT'S IT ..


CHICK , THANKS A TON FOR WRITING THIS .
spshastr thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
waiting for this since morning
So.true this.is. The journey of him knowing her and accepting her for who.she is

👏

And she is numb .. we cant expect her to act under these circumstances at all.

Edited by spshastr - 9 years ago
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: KostinsQueen

NO WORDS CHICK

THIS POST IS EVERYTHING , U GAVE REPLY TO ALL THOSE WHO R ASKING AGAIN & AGAIN FOR SUMAN'S BREAK DOWN & TO THOSE WHO R SO CONCERNED ABOUT HER REVELATION OF HER FEELINGS .👏
FOR ME IT'S SUMAN WHO IS STRONG MORE THAN SHRAVAN , SHE IS NOT SELFISH , SHE IS NOT MANIPULATIVE, SHE IS RESPONSIBLE & SUCCESSFUL. ANYONE CAN CONNECT TO SHRAVAN , BUT ONLY FEW CAN CONNECT TO SUMAN.
FROM
" MAIN BAAKI AURATHON KE BAARE MEIN JO SOCHTHA HOON USE THUME KOI LENA DHENA NAHI , MAIN THUMHARI BAARE MEIN AISA KABHI NAHI SOCHTHA, THUM UN SAB SE ALAG HO "
TO
" IN SAB MEIN SE KAHATHARNAK THUM HO JIS MEIN DHOKA , ZEHER , SWARTH SAB HAI " TOTALLY SHOWED HOW HE IS THINKING ABOUT HER RN.AND WHEN HE SAID THAT A LADY MUST SATISFY HIS MAN IN BEDROOM TO GET ALL HER DEMANDS FULFILLED, EVEN THEN HIS ACTIONS R JUSTIFIED SAYING HE IS IN PAIN , HE IS HURT. .THIS & THAT , THEN Y NOT SAME JUSTIFICATIONS TO HER ?
THANKFULLY HE FEELS THE PAIN , BUT SHE NO MORE SENSES THE PAIN, SHE IS NUMB.

I DON'T MEAN TO BASH SHARAVAN & SUPPORT SUMAN , THEY BOTH R MY OTP , I LOVE SHRAVAN, SUMAN , SHRAMAN .AS PER ME , THEY BOTH R WRONG ,NO ONE IS RIGHT , THAT'S IT ..


CHICK , THANKS A TON FOR WRITING THIS .


😳 Thanx.

And thank U for bringing both those dialogues from the same person at least on the same page...

What I found interesting is that Suman is still not a feminist...she is not a doormat either. She knows her limitations..tries to stay within that.

After all, if she had been a boy, Nanu would not have done all this drama with her na.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".