25th Sept WU | Ek Hoke Bhi Ek Na Reh Sake - Page 3

Originally posted by: malikakas

Thanks Bucky. After watching I feel confused. A part of me wonders if Suman didn't mean what she said. If she said it only to break up with shravan and follow the path her dad set out for her. Like we saw her follow him out the door. I don't feel someone in anger would have done that. I feel like she was ending the relationship as a punishment to herself. But that part of the sequence did feel a bit rushed for me so I could be wrong as well.

Also I feel Shravan wasn't right to bring up his dad's issue right at that time. She was in the midst of mourning her dad.

@bold

could that be just a silly way from the makers to show them in one frame apart while Edkv is playing..

a bit like yesterday when Suman looked at him till that line played out completely..

since post lockdown, we had this edkv played out soo many time with both of either facing each other or opp..

but then can she really hate him for something that supposedly his dad did (well as per the tiwari and army)

I am totally confused with the way they rushed everything..

after today, I was like is that it? They broke up?

other shows spends one month on a simple wedding sequence.. well we can go through a time lapse of ob month in a blink of an eye

Originally posted by: Nailah_EjFian

@bold

could that be just a silly way from the makers to show them in one frame apart while Edkv is playing..

a bit like yesterday when Suman looked at him till that line played out completely..

since post lockdown, we had this edkv played out soo many time with both of either facing each other or opp..

but then can she really hate him for something that supposedly his dad did (well as per the tiwari and army)

I am totally confused with the way they rushed everything..

after today, I was like is that it? They broke up?

other shows spends one month on a simple wedding sequence.. well we can go through a time lapse of ob month in a blink of an eye

@bold. very possible. Yesterday's I thought was okay though because it was at least revealing her thought process that she wasn't totally against him even though she was experiencing guilt. It was the letter and the idea of Devraj's crime that was the double whammy that guided her reaction today. If they wanted to show them in the same frame today it could have been a split screen reaction too.

@underlineedTo be honest, I think at this point she hates herself more than anyone else. I think the main issue is that after that letter she really can't be with him not in this phase at least. Him pushing the Devraj issue may have just been the excuse she needed. Whether she consciously hates him or is just fooling him so that they could break up would just be the defence mechanism of dealing with the cognitive dissonance. Although I do think it would be very hard to be with someone if you think their parent was responsible for your father's death. In this case, she also accused her dad of allowing his personal animosity with Devraj to impact his judgement of her relationship with Shravan. So to find out that his dad may have indeed been in the wrong leading to her father's death would just compound the guilt she feels towards how she treated her father in her love blindness.

@italics: Word, lol. This was a bit too fast. Although we do have the potential for some flashbacks in the army phase. Most probably we'd see Shravan try to meet her again but she left for Pune as her dad wanted.

TFS....you described the incidents in so simple but also in realistic ways...yes, indeed it was very intense and uttermost painful to even watch...but looks like so many things coupled together and jostled up...might be the team is in hurried up to reach in the climax. Many incidents like Devraj's arrest looked more dramatic than reasonable for sure. ....

Originally posted by: malikakas

@bold. very possible. Yesterday's I thought was okay though because it was at least revealing her thought process that she wasn't totally against him even though she was experiencing guilt. It was the letter and the idea of Devraj's crime that was the double whammy that guided her reaction today. If they wanted to show them in the same frame today it could have been a split screen reaction too.

@underlineedTo be honest, I think at this point she hates herself more than anyone else. I think the main issue is that after that letter she really can't be with him not in this phase at least. Him pushing the Devraj issue may have just been the excuse she needed. Whether she consciously hates him or is just fooling him so that they could break up would just be the defence mechanism of dealing with the cognitive dissonance. Although I do think it would be very hard to be with someone if you think their parent was responsible for your father's death. In this case, she also accused her dad of allowing his personal animosity with Devraj to impact his judgement of her relationship with Shravan. So to find out that his dad may have indeed been in the wrong leading to her father's death would just compound the guilt she feels towards how she treated her father in her love blindness.

@italics: Word, lol. This was a bit too fast. Although we do have the potential for some flashbacks in the army phase. Most probably we'd see Shravan try to meet her again but she left for Pune as her dad wanted.

@R...you explained Suman's state of mind so efficiently.....she has a combination of all of those expressions.

@ Blue...I think all of those are the main causes which lead her to take this decision...TBH...Bunty was so correct to resist Shravan not to visit Suman...she needs time to put her thought together....but he is as usual....wear his heart on his sleeve....honestly Suman has her tons of own grieving to do and this guy's whining for his own father...what made Suman releases all the blame on them......I was honestly irritated to the core ....on Shravan... when I was watching this epi....not to mention that they acted so well.....

You are correct....they're rushing everything just like supersonic jet.........speed.....

Originally posted by: Pranushka_723

Thanks Bucky....well written...

Somehow I felt the things were rusheddidn't get the feel to that extent in the latter half

@ B...I do agree with you...I already posted a couple of messages about this...when I was watching my feeling was what's this rush all about?

Originally posted by: malikakas

Thanks Bucky. After watching I feel confused. A part of me wonders if Suman didn't mean what she said. If she said it only to break up with shravan and follow the path her dad set out for her. Like we saw her follow him out the door. I don't feel someone in anger would have done that. I feel like she was ending the relationship as a punishment to herself. But that part of the sequence did feel a bit rushed for me so I could be wrong as well.

Also I feel Shravan wasn't right to bring up his dad's issue right at that time. She was in the midst of mourning her dad.

@B....I am so agreed with you on this....I did mention this in one of my messages...everything has a proper time to discuss....and Suman needs time to grieve.......doesn't look like to me Suman did the breakup at the correct mind set....she is grieving and full of guilt for her behaviour at last moment with her dad...it might be a spontaneous reaction to punish herself...what she is going to regret later on.....she may go back to old, determined Suman phase but it most likely to complete erase Shravan phase...

Originally posted by: Isabel

@R...you explained Suman's state of mind so efficiently.....she has a combination of all of those expressions.

@ Blue...I think all of those are the main causes which lead her to take this decision...TBH...Bunty was so correct to resist Shravan not to visit Suman...she needs time to put her thought together....but he is as usual....wear his heart on his sleeve....honestly Suman has her tons of own grieving to do and this guy's whining for his own father...what made Suman releases all the blame on them......I was honestly irritated to the core ....on Shravan... when I was watching this epi....not to mention that they acted so well.....

You are correct....they're rushing everything just like supersonic jet.........speed.....

@bold. To be honest it was a bit out of character for shravan to behave like that too. Normally he tries to hide anything that would make Suman sad from her. And if there was any moment to do that it was this one. I get he was stressed out but it just felt really inconsiderate to start talking about his dad. The acting was superb though.

Originally posted by: Isabel

@R...you explained Suman's state of mind so efficiently.....she has a combination of all of those expressions.

@ Blue...I think all of those are the main causes which lead her to take this decision...TBH...Bunty was so correct to resist Shravan not to visit Suman...she needs time to put her thought together....but he is as usual....wear his heart on his sleeve....honestly Suman has her tons of own grieving to do and this guy's whining for his own father...what made Suman releases all the blame on them......I was honestly irritated to the core ....on Shravan... when I was watching this epi....not to mention that they acted so well.....

You are correct....they're rushing everything just like supersonic jet.........speed.....

Originally posted by: malikakas

@bold. To be honest it was a bit out of character for shravan to behave like that too. Normally he tries to hide anything that would make Suman sad from her. And if there was any moment to do that it was this one. I get he was stressed out but it just felt really inconsiderate to start talking about his dad. The acting was superb though.

Thanks For WU Bucky👍🏼