Prateek trying to do a Beyhadd 2 ?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Reine Lobo

@Rein123

Rocker

Posted: 7 years ago

#11

Shiv aur saanjh mein zameen aur aasmaan ka farq hai! As far as maya is concerned then even she cant be compared with vyom as his character graph is just beginning and so is Shiv's

I agree with Ashi, we all know about Maya's abusive childhood so we can understand the cause of her mental illness but vyom ke baarein we cant exactly say the same looking at his family...

And coming to Shiv and Saanjh? Like really? You think Shiv is the Saanjh of EDT? Shiv is clearly the main and titular character plus he was already in a relationship with Sharanya unlike saanjh who was friendzoned initially

We cant make comparisons as the EDT has much left to reveal especially the backstory.. so i disagree with your post here

Quote

indranigupta

@indranigupta

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: jahapona

It is fine if you disagree but that still does not change much.

As i said, the characters of Maya-Vyom, Arjun-Sharanya-, Saanjh-Shiv, are not exact copies, but the basic plot and view point of treating the story and there contribution in the story is infact 70% similar.

If Maya was a victim of child abuse and Vyom was not abused (still his back story has to be revealed by his parents who are obsessed with him), that still does not justify that why treat a mental disorder as something black and outright negative? Maya was made into a criminal too, in our world anyone who commits a murder is a criminal, but the reasons behind their crimes are again similar, treated in the evergreen prateek style.

Arjun's love was as spineless as Madhvi in the show now, he was torn between two women, Sharanya is torn between two men, where is the difference? Sharanya has married Vyom legally so even if she claims to never love him, if she was never meant to be with Vyom then the marriage could be averted, Arjun friend-zoned Saanjh and later married her, Sharanya friend-sone Vyom and then married him, it is another thing that he is the real game now.

Well, i understand that you feel this is ShivaNya's story, but I would disagree here, writers has taken a complete U-turn now, ShivaNya does not or did not have anything interesting to reveal, on the other hand they are making Vyom into a second Maya, if you have watched tonight's episode then you could understand what I am trying to say. At the end Vyom will walk away with the title of Deewana. Deewangi is not defined by death or turning into a ghost, but crossing every moral and social norms to win over the person you love, i remember watching a movie Deewangi and as a Kid i thought Akshaye Khanna was the one who was the hero there but then I grew up and realized Ajay devgan was the real deal, Vyom's character is looking exactly similar to Ajay's character now.

@bold- You can mock and laugh at my timing, but obviously i do not care. If you are satisfied with Shiv's BS and everything now then congratulations, there is no point in debating then since everything seems okay to you. I must say Prateek is smart, he can satisfy fan bases in a jiffy and can trick them to believe something which is actually not the case.😉
I am complaining now because i did not expect Shiv to be as useless as he was shown tonight, a deewana who cannot even save his lover from a freaking water tank? HAHAHAHA, sorry for this, but all the best with you concept of epicness in this stale love story. Prateek did do a wonderful job if he has actually convinced you withing five episodes and could not convince many with 65 episodes now.

I am not replying to you anymore, please stop taking this personally.

Murdering, molesting and maybe stalking is the sign of passion!! I hope you are joking when you say this...If thisis deewangi please do tell me how do you define love? Is this how you justify the irrationality shown in the episode?This is shocking. Women are being raped, murdered killed on the streets everyday and you justify these acts as acts of passion.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Kavila

@Kavila

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#13

I don't understand why people comment without watching the proper scenes..

Vyom was shown fishy from the day 1 itself..

To why hallabulla...😆

The unending of shiv accusing saga...😆

Leave it guys kuch nahi ho sakta. .

Quote

sumz_d

@sumz_d

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: jahapona

I did watch Beyhadd till they turned Maya completely black and i lost hope of seeing anything logical. In Beyhadd also, i did predict that Arjun will Marry Saanjh and Maya will be cursed for everything and later die, which obviously was not what i wanted to see.
Arjun did not love Maya, not according to me, Love can make you tolerate anything, mental disorder of your spouse is something which only love could cure, Prateek treated this track better in JNDSD. If you observe there is a pattern in all Prateek's shows, since I compared EDT with Beyhadd, but that ofcourse does not mean that EDT is an exact copy, but the basic plot of a psycho.mentally challenged lover trying to win his/her love via vicious plots and crazy behavior and the other lover behaving all helpless and goody shoes is nothing new in EDT. The only good thing is that Vyom will stop going to the hospital now😉

Well i watched Beyhadh. In one of the episodes Arjun himself confessed that he is selfish of not treating Maya. He feared of loosing Maya's beyhadh love. This was most weird and head breaking explanation of Arjun. Lol

And due to this, not only Maya's life but Arjun's life was also destroyed.

Hence I say EDT and Beyhadh are two very very different story.

Quote

486792

Hibernated

Posted: 7 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: jahapona

It is fine if you disagree but that still does not change much.

As i said, the characters of Maya-Vyom, Arjun-Sharanya-, Saanjh-Shiv, are not exact copies, but the basic plot and view point of treating the story and there contribution in the story is infact 70% similar.

If Maya was a victim of child abuse and Vyom was not abused (still his back story has to be revealed by his parents who are obsessed with him), that still does not justify that why treat a mental disorder as something black and outright negative? Maya was made into a criminal too, in our world anyone who commits a murder is a criminal, but the reasons behind their crimes are again similar, treated in the evergreen prateek style.

Arjun's love was as spineless as Madhvi in the show now, he was torn between two women, Sharanya is torn between two men, where is the difference? Sharanya has married Vyom legally so even if she claims to never love him, if she was never meant to be with Vyom then the marriage could be averted, Arjun friend-zoned Saanjh and later married her, Sharanya friend-sone Vyom and then married him, it is another thing that he is the real game now.

Well, i understand that you feel this is ShivaNya's story, but I would disagree here, writers has taken a complete U-turn now, ShivaNya does not or did not have anything interesting to reveal, on the other hand they are making Vyom into a second Maya, if you have watched tonight's episode then you could understand what I am trying to say. At the end Vyom will walk away with the title of Deewana. Deewangi is not defined by death or turning into a ghost, but crossing every moral and social norms to win over the person you love, i remember watching a movie Deewangi and as a Kid i thought Akshaye Khanna was the one who was the hero there but then I grew up and realized Ajay devgan was the real deal, Vyom's character is looking exactly similar to Ajay's character now.

@bold- You can mock and laugh at my timing, but obviously i do not care. If you are satisfied with Shiv's BS and everything now then congratulations, there is no point in debating then since everything seems okay to you. I must say Prateek is smart, he can satisfy fan bases in a jiffy and can trick them to believe something which is actually not the case.😉
I am complaining now because i did not expect Shiv to be as useless as he was shown tonight, a deewana who cannot even save his lover from a freaking water tank? HAHAHAHA, sorry for this, but all the best with you concept of epicness in this stale love story. Prateek did do a wonderful job if he has actually convinced you withing five episodes and could not convince many with 65 episodes now.

I am not replying to you anymore, please stop taking this personally.

1.Sharanya had lost her memory.Ever since she woke up people were drilling it into her head that Vyom is her lover,Vyom cared for her and stuff.On top of all that Vyom himself presented his elaborate version of events in front of her.His fake story where they were lovers.On top of all that Vyom himself clinged on to her and didn't allow her to investigate her past.Add the emotional manipulation on top of it.

2.After everything he has done you think Vyom will walk away with the title of Deewaana?? He is just a creepy,cold blooded murderer.

3.Timing is what matters the most.I really wish to know where your logical queries were when the events you mentioned were happening.

Yeah you weren't expecting Shiv to be useless.What were you expecting then?That he would have actually possessed Vyom been the villain?

4.FYI in the movie Ghost,the protagonist who is a Ghost couldn't even touch objects for a considerable period of time before he gained those powers.Similarly Shiv's powers are limited.

5.Nope Prateek has not convinced me about anything.I am watching coz of ShivAnya.If you still feel the show is trash then it's totally your POV.

It was trash then.It's trash now.But people enjoyed it then and so are they doing now.It's just that a different group of people are enjoying it.

6.Everyone on this forum is used to Indian TV shows and their illogical storylines.Normal shows aren't spared so why should a supernatural show be any different?

Naagin 1 topped the TRP charts with all the stuff it showed.So I don't understand what people were expecting from EDT.Stranger Things??

7.You might feel that Vyom is the 'real game' now and ShivAnya are boring but a large number of people don't think so.ShivAnya's chemistry has appealed to a majority of the audience while Shar...Om didn't.And as a JNDSD fan you must be aware that the shippers of the lead pair watched the show through all its illogical tracks just coz they loved the lead pair's chemistry.

Similarly over here ShivAnya have the superior chemistry and they will always grab more eyeballs.

I didn't take this personally.Just brought some things to light.

Even I am not gonna reply anymore.

Quote

sumz_d

@sumz_d

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 7 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: ..preethi..
war again😆

"Angoor khate hote hai" lol

Some people just can't digest the fact. Now that EDT's real story has started.

Quote

486792

Hibernated

Posted: 7 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: jahapona

If it makes you happy then yes I am a hypocrite. I hope MODs are reading this since it is a personal attack. and thank you for making me realize that Namik fans are not as nice as him😳

Did I mention you anywhere in my post?

And since you did bring in Namik fans then lemme remind you of how Vikram fans behaved previously.

Also I was just stating the facts which happened in this forum and in which Vikram and Vanya fans were open participants.

1.I never bashed a character.Just stated what that character did

2.About the hypocrisy line then this has happened in the forum and yeah it's a fact.

3.I never bashed any actor but the other fandom did.Shiv was called names and Namik himself was bashed.

So why don't you look at your own fandom before pointing fingers at others??

Edited by --BlackSheep-- - 7 years ago

Quote

shreya

@.Lilith.

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 7 years ago

#18

Well, I do agree with those who're saying that EDT is not like Beyhadh. I think Sharma Ji watched my vm and took it too seriously! 🤣

Shiv is neither like Saanjh nor, let's say, Samay? Despite being indifferent to him/disliking him for a long time, I did feel that his past story does have potential, especially if Shivanya were a thing. I'm still hoping against hope that makers will retain that grey streak in him (because the FB of him saying "Sharanya sirf meri hain", holding a blood-stained knife) is still not explained, but I'm not being too optimistic after tonight's episode. 😆

Quote

664269

Suspended

Posted: 7 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: jahapona

Yes, I like the way Prateek tells his TALES .
Unfortunately, JNDSD was the only show where he somewhat justified his leads, in Beyhadd he chose a wrong actor to play the male lead, i could never connect with Arjun and Jennifer was brilliant as Maya. In EDT, i was patient that since a ghost angle is here it could be different and should not have inspirations from JNDSD and Beyhadd, but i was wrong, he has taken inspirations from both the shows and seems like he stalked the forum to make up the story of Shiv-Sharanya, which does not make sense because Sharanya is clueless as always and Shiv is like those 90s heroes who does not know anything and only knows that he has died

I am a fan.of JNDSD and hence i will say that yes the writing in that show was terrific as long as prateek was there. EDT was always meant to be mysterious and since day 1 most of us had assumed that probably Vyom is lying and is the master plan but it us surprising if prateek plans to show nothing more than what we have already seen or predicted.

I didn't watch Beyhadd but I can talk about jndsd. But for Vyom if he indeed has the disorder then i don't understand that how come his parents didn't try to treat him? It's really important to show why Vyom is like this? I remember saying in one of my posts that Vyom has always seen his parents physically fighting which does not bother him anymore, he basically grew up in a loveless and shady parental upbringing who was fed with money and luxuries. So it will be interesting to see Rajan and Madhvi's side of the back story. Why was Rajan against sharanya and why was madhvi in support of sharanya? Who killed Ram and who stabbed vyom? So much to be revealed.