Prateek trying to do a Beyhadd 2 ?

sumz_d thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Ummm did you really watch Beyhadh?
In beyhadh Maya and Arjun both loved each other. Saanjh was only a friend to Arjun.

Because Arjun couldn't handle Maya's illness their relationship died. However in the last episode Arjun himself had confirmed that he did genuinely "Love" Maya but was very weak in protecting Maya and himself from Maya's illness.

In my opinion the moral of beyhadh was that married couple should love unconditionally and take responsibilty of each other. They Should not allow a third person to interfere.

Hence your comparison of EDT to Beyhadh is inappropriate.
Both the shows EDT and Beyhadh have a different story. Its like comparing Apples with Oranges lol

PS: This is just my opinion.

Edited by sumz_d - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

2.3k

Users

9

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

.Lilith. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
1) Vikram and Jennifer, both are great actors, why not cast them in Behadd 3 instead of remaking a Behadd for the same channel in the same slot ? Good question. 😆 I personally love Jenny as an actress, but I feel that they won't exactly make a good match onscreen, since Jenny's personality is on another level, while Vikram has this bit of childishness to him. I know your question was sarcastic, just being nice. 😆

2) Why cannot the writers feed with at least 10% of Vyom and Rajan's brains to Sharanya, why cannot she stick to her questions instead of forgetting? She asked why Shiv did not save her father, but the episode completely forgot to show Shiv's response?

The episode completely forgot about it and so did the editing team- don't know whom to blame. 😕

3) Why reveal Shiv's backstory in a rush? No build up, no depth, just four random scenes of cheesy and stereotypical romance and boom, he died and sharanya loses her memory due to that easy fall? Prateek go re-watch your own show, yes i mean JNDSD, where Atharva had to be freaking hammered to erase his memory, here Sharanya tumbled over the stairs of the temple and she woke up as someone who never knew what love was 😆

It may sound like a lie now, but trust me when I say that I genuinely felt that DoMik had great potential as an on-screen pair, when I watched a short clip of theirs from a gym. This was before the show started. Once it started, I naturally felt that DoVik had amazing chemistry on-screen but I never outright refuted the possibility of DoMik looking equally good on-screen. And then the wretched BS started.

The leads looked visibly uncomfortable and it projected on-screen! The romance was wayyy too cheesy, the editing was horrible, the direction was equally bad, and as you mentioned, there was zero build up. It was like some sort of wish fulfillment and hence the lack of effort! Also, +1 on Sharanya losing her freaking memories on falling on the road...I have fell head first so many times, I should have been a blank page by now according to this logic. 🤪

4) If Vyom is so smart and vicious, then why did you waste 60 episodes on showing him taking hospiatl tours for no reason. He killed shiv, and shiv could not kill him in multiple attempts even though shiv is the ghost and has super natural powers. How on earth?

We were tricked, that's why. Vyom is the supernatural element. 😎

5) If Vyom is the main culprit, then why rush VaNya marriage and make Sharanya marry him and Shiv did nothing to stop the marriage since it is shown that he did not possess Vyom, so all Shiv did was be an uninvited guest for both the possession and marriage drama and still claim that he louuusss sharanya 🤪

Bigger question is- What made Vyom DO that in the first place? Socha ek boring shaadi se achha, AAJ KUCHH TOOFAANI KARTE HAIN! 😈 🤣

6) When Vyom was trying to molest and drown sharanya, why was Shiv watching with a popcorn instead of saving her ? Or should i think that Shiv does not care unless sharanya is actually raped or drowned? hell yeah Nawab, a dog seemed to have more concern for sharanta instead of Shiv, Vyom is psycho but shiv is not, explain the reasons for his zero reaction during sharanya's accidents.

Maybe Shiv is the new Bran. Next thing I know, he'll say "I saw you during your Haldi day, in that yellow Lehenga. You looked beautiful that night".

Related image

7) At the end, I know Vyom will be killed by Sharanya, the way Arjun killed off maya, and then you will seal a mental disorder as something negative and that should be hated, it is really disappointing that in all of your shows, be it JNDSD, Beyhadd and now EDT, you had given your main leads with some mental disorder and you treated that poorly to a point that 90% of the audience thinks that this man/woman is mad and deserves to be hated. Let me tell you, exploiting the issues in such a manner only refers to the limited creativity. At least in JNDSD, Atharva's mental condition was induced whereas in Maya and Vyom if they are victims of life long disorders then instead of painting them completely black, you could have set an example which i am sure you will not. May be that is the reason why Psycho characters are still considered a risk and out of the idiot box in indian tv, mostly actors feel proud that they played a psycho in indian tv irrespective of the fact that it is no great deal if the audience would really understand the root of the problem.

I will reserve my judgements till I see how Sharma plays this one out, since it's his own production and there's zero external influence. Beyhadh was ruined because of repeated extensions. EDT hopefully will have a better ending and no extension.


To all the forum members, please do discuss and argue but do not bash each other, I am loving the episodes but then i do not want to see a Maya again, it is only because i know at the end i will probably end up sympathizing with a black character which is not right, but that is what Prateek does mostly. I expected something mysterious from the past, but we got served with something that was predicted from the first episode. And yes kudos to all the VaNya shippers, i like the way you people have taken everything positively, may be because you knew that this was coming, but i guess story is bigger than any ship, so yes, and there is no doubts that Donal and Vikram shares a scorching chemistry onscreen.

Thanks a lot! 🤗

Mostly I ship VaNya because of DoVik and their AWE-FRIKKIN-SOME chemistry. I have shipped worse couples in the past, so this is nothing. 😆
Edited by .Lilith. - 7 years ago
664269 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Jahapona !!!!
I can smell a Prateek fan in you, ohh damn you watched both JNDSD and Beyhadd? ..🥳
Reserved.. Will edit this one ..
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Beyhadh 2 is it?? I wholeheartedly disagree.

1.Maya in Beyhadh was a victim of child abuse who suffered from a mental ailment which was not tended to.
Vyom is a rich entitled brat who believes in having everything he wants and when he doesn't he goes on a killing spree.He is nothing but a cold blooded criminal.


2.Arjun was a confused character but he did love Maya at a time.He was eternally torn in between Maya and Saanjh.
Sharanya's priorities were clear from the beginning.She loved Shiv and only Shiv.


3.Shiv and Saanjh have a heaven and hell difference.Shiv was always Sharanya's lover whereas Saanjh was the friendzoned girl for whom Arjun later fell for.Shiv was a victim to Vyom's cruelty.He was in love with Sharanya and Vyom came in between them.He lost his life due to that.Yet even after his death he returned for his love.


Above all the main difference.Beyhadh was Maya's story.She was the protagonist as well as the antagonist.The story revolved around her.She represented the Beyhadh form of love.
EDT is ShivAnya's story.And in particular Shiv's story.He was the Deewaana,the lover who defied death.
Here Vyom came in between Shiv and Sharanya.

As far as the rest of your questions for Prateek are concerned,then I wanna ask where these questions were when these tracks were actually taking place?Instead you remember all this stuff the moment Vyom is revealed as the villain.
At that time everyone was busy condemining Shiv as the villain and enjoying Shar...Om's so called amar prem katha.🤪
Logic jaaye bhaad main.Not a single soul lifted a finger at that time.And why would they do it?Coz they were so confident that Shiv was the baddie and Vyom would turn out to be the hero.Now you guys will play the logic card? 🤣


The backstory ain't rushed.Prateek simply got his brains back.And don't get me started on the mahaan JNDSD.That was a show where a girl married two brothers turn wise.So as a JNDSD viewer you must be used to Prateek's illogical stuff.

Back to the topic yeah!! There are zero similarities between this show and Beyhadh.

Kavila thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

Beyhadh 2 is it?? I wholeheartedly disagree.

1.Maya in Beyhadh was a victim of child abuse who suffered from a mental ailment which was not tended to.
Vyom is a rich entitled brat who believes in having everything he wants and when he doesn't he goes on a killing spree.He is nothing but a cold blooded criminal.


2.Arjun was a confused character but he did love Maya at a time.He was eternally torn in between Maya and Saanjh.
Sharanya's priorities were clear from the beginning.She loved Shiv and only Shiv.


3.Shiv and Saanjh have a heaven and hell difference.Shiv was always Sharanya's lover whereas Saanjh was the friendzoned girl for whom Arjun later fell for.Shiv was a victim to Vyom's cruelty.He was in love with Sharanya and Vyom came in between them.He lost his life due to that.Yet even after his death he returned for his love.


Above all the main difference.Beyhadh was Maya's story.She was the protagonist as well as the antagonist.The story revolved around her.She represented the Beyhadh form of love.
EDT is ShivAnya's story.And in particular Shiv's story.He was the Deewaana,the lover who defied death.
Here Vyom came in between Shiv and Sharanya.

As far as the rest of your questions for Prateek are concerned,then I wanna ask where these questions were when these tracks were actually taking place?Instead you remember all this stuff the moment Vyom is revealed as the villain.
At that time everyone was busy condemining Shiv as the villain and enjoying Shar...Om's so called amar prem katha.🤪
Logic jaaye bhaad main.Not a single soul lifted a finger at that time.And why would they do it?Coz they were so confident that Shiv was the baddie and Vyom would turn out to be the hero.Now you guys will play the logic card? 🤣


The backstory ain't rushed.Prateek simply got his brains back.And don't get me started on the mahaan JNDSD.That was a show where a girl married two brothers turn wise.So as a JNDSD viewer you must be used to Prateek's illogical stuff.

Back to the topic yeah!! There are zero similarities between this show and Beyhadh.


Wakil sahiba I love you bass🤗l
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6
Dear Mod Ji,
How long are you gonna take to close this topic??You see its a comparison post😛
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7
When the scenes were actually taking place,
Folks:Shiv is such a creep.A cruel monster.He doesn't have values.My Vanya are eternal.Gosh!! I love their chemistry.

Now when the show is finally on track with what majority of the audience wanted to see.aka.Shiv and ShivAnya.

The same folks:LOGIC!! Where is the logic in this??🤓Vyom is Maya though Maya was a mental patient and Vyom is a creepy criminal,Shiv is a weak character,blah,blah.


HAIL HYPOCRISY!!🤣
indranigupta thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Haven't seen Beyhadd but while your questions are valid why wasn't it posed while Shiv was merely lurking in the background and accused for every nincompomp? As for Vanya chemistry they are quite hot ...having been build up over the course of 50 episodes or more. While Shiv just had to do it in a single episode. Did he do it well? You bet he did. As for your posing the logical questions.. completely agree with you. But I also feel Shiv was lying so better wait for a day or two...may be V will emerge the hero and you won't feel it's another version of beyhadd😃
486792 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jahapona


Seriously mate? Are you this much hurt with my post ? I thought Shiv fans were mature, and i did not even bash Namik or any actor. This was a genuine post about the story.🥱

Did I ever mention any actor anywhere?? I only stated the rules of the forum.
Comparisons aren't allowed.
sumz_d thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: --BlackSheep--

Beyhadh 2 is it?? I wholeheartedly disagree.

1.Maya in Beyhadh was a victim of child abuse who suffered from a mental ailment which was not tended to.
Vyom is a rich entitled brat who believes in having everything he wants and when he doesn't he goes on a killing spree.He is nothing but a cold blooded criminal.


2.Arjun was a confused character but he did love Maya at a time.He was eternally torn in between Maya and Saanjh.
Sharanya's priorities were clear from the beginning.She loved Shiv and only Shiv.


3.Shiv and Saanjh have a heaven and hell difference.Shiv was always Sharanya's lover whereas Saanjh was the friendzoned girl for whom Arjun later fell for.Shiv was a victim to Vyom's cruelty.He was in love with Sharanya and Vyom came in between them.He lost his life due to that.Yet even after his death he returned for his love.


Above all the main difference.Beyhadh was Maya's story.She was the protagonist as well as the antagonist.The story revolved around her.She represented the Beyhadh form of love.
EDT is ShivAnya's story.And in particular Shiv's story.He was the Deewaana,the lover who defied death.
Here Vyom came in between Shiv and Sharanya.

As far as the rest of your questions for Prateek are concerned,then I wanna ask where these questions were when these tracks were actually taking place?Instead you remember all this stuff the moment Vyom is revealed as the villain.
At that time everyone was busy condemining Shiv as the villain and enjoying Shar...Om's so called amar prem katha.🤪
Logic jaaye bhaad main.Not a single soul lifted a finger at that time.And why would they do it?Coz they were so confident that Shiv was the baddie and Vyom would turn out to be the hero.Now you guys will play the logic card? 🤣


The backstory ain't rushed.Prateek simply got his brains back.And don't get me started on the mahaan JNDSD.That was a show where a girl married two brothers turn wise.So as a JNDSD viewer you must be used to Prateek's illogical stuff.

Back to the topic yeah!! There are zero similarities between this show and Beyhadh.


Lol i really don't understand how EDT can be compared to Beyhadh.
Beyhadh was a very subjective story. It was based on perspective.
Some people say Arjun didn't love Maya genuinely while some say he did. And my opinion is the later one.

However as far as EDT is concerned then I don't think its right to compare it with Beyhadh. Dono main zameen aur asmaan ka fark hai.

I think vyom fans are just disappointed with the real story. But since episode one Vyom's character was shown as fishy.

Its just that Vyom fans didn't want to see the truth they always denied and accused Shiv for everything. And now when things are getting clearer and Vyom's character is revealed they can't digest it.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".