Appreciation thread no 1 episodes discussion - Page 8

My review -

The director is putting unneccesary elements in this crucial point of the show.

Yest was that 1 min dance. Today is that fire and wind, jabhir looked like they were standing on some high cliff 🤔

If those werent there im sure that scene would have been much much better.

Rani baby has lost it completely 😆

Wonder what will happen that time if she gets to hear that Jabir is in love 😆

They should keep “ tashan “ once in a while than showing in every episode cos it will get boring.

Kabir being calm is nice to watch for now 😃

Rani doesn't care! Her character is super inconsistent too - she was okay watching Kabir being humiliated in the past, and even accepted what Janhvi said about not getting attached to the Mittal brothers. All of a sudden, she forgets everything her own sister has done for her, for a man who has never shown an iota of interest in her. Wow.

Zain said he is doing lovey dovey scenes already in an intv 😕

Isnt love too early ? 🤔

Morrow and next week’s trp will tell us how the audience will react to the revamp since the whole of last week was full of jabir’s promotion.

I guess we are reading the situation differently. Kabir is not saying that his family is faultless, but they are his family at the end of the day. He cannot change what they did years ago, but he can stop Pooja from becoming yet another PK Mittal, who had no regard for anyone's emotions.

Even Pooja being shown unhappy - the way I saw it was that she would never find peace until she breaks out of the revenge cycle because no matter how she punishes the Mittals, it wouldn't change what happened in the past and it wouldn't make her feel any better. Whatever happiness she would derive out of that would be transient, and I saw the scenes as reflecting just that. The Mittals are not happy, but those scenes are being shown to show us the difference between someone like Kabir and someone like Dhruv. At the end of the day, Kabir would help Pooja break out of that cycle, and that is when she would truly be at peace. The Mittals would have to pay for their actions, but she doesn't need to be the one to do it.

Originally posted by: Euphoria.

I guess we are reading the situation differently. Kabir is not saying that his family is faultless, but they are his family at the end of the day. He cannot change what they did years ago, but he can stop Pooja from becoming yet another PK Mittal, who had no regard for anyone's emotions.

Even Pooja being shown unhappy - the way I saw it was that she would never find peace until she breaks out of the revenge cycle because no matter how she punishes the Mittals, it wouldn't change what happened in the past and it wouldn't make her feel any better. Whatever happiness she would derive out of that would be transient, and I saw the scenes as reflecting just that. The Mittals are not happy, but those scenes are being shown to show us the difference between someone like Kabir and someone like Dhruv. At the end of the day, Kabir would help Pooja break out of that cycle, and that is when she would truly be at peace. The Mittals would have to pay for their actions, but she doesn't need to be the one to do it.

No I agree with your observation.

And this is what I have a problem with. I didn't like the shift in the tone of the show (as someone pointed out in the chat thread)

Senior Mittals were murderers too, and complicit in the crime. They should suffer. I don't feel an iota of sympathy for them.

But instead of showing them suffering, the show is showing Pooja is suffering.

If Pooja was suffering because she hurt Kavya and Aarush, I would still understand, they were innocent.

What I didn't like was the juxtaposition of happy Mittals and sad Pooja (over Rani). It makes no sense that Senior Mittals should not suffer.

I loved the scene with Kabir, Sonali and Jai. Not just Kabir, in a way empowered Sonali, but I loved the sibling bond there. The siblings are together in their bad times, and that is acceptable because they are innocent. That part was done correctly.

I have a problem with happy senior Mittals v/s unhappy Jahnvi. And that was the exact thing they showed today. Senior Mittals should also be in jail like the commissioner, because they also hid the truth. Why should only commissioner and his wife be punished?

I understand Kabir is right from his perspective, he is thinking like a son and grandson, thats why he cannot see his mother, aunt's and grandpa's crimes.

But Pooja is also right in punishing those 3 (not others, I guess). So, I didn't like the moral tone the show took that Kabir is right, and Pooja is wrong.

The moral judgment was shown in that song sequence. It irritated me so much that I had to ffwd. 😵😆

Originally posted by: SRKisLove

No I agree with your observation.

And this is what I have a problem with. I didn't like the shift in the tone of the show (as someone pointed out in the chat thread)

Senior Mittals were murderers too, and complicit in the crime. They should suffer. I don't feel an iota of sympathy for them.

But instead of showing them suffering, the show is showing Pooja is suffering.

If Pooja was suffering because she hurt Kavya and Aarush, I would still understand, they were innocent.

What I didn't like was the juxtaposition of happy Mittals and sad Pooja (over Rani). It makes no sense that Senior Mittals should not suffer.

I loved the scene with Kabir, Sonali and Jai. Not just Kabir, in a way empowered Sonali, but I loved the sibling bond there. The siblings are together in their bad times, and that is acceptable because they are innocent. That part was done correctly.

I have a problem with happy senior Mittals v/s unhappy Jahnvi. And that was the exact thing they showed today. Senior Mittals should also be in jail like the commissioner, because they also hid the truth. Why should only commissioner and his wife be punished?

I understand Kabir is right from his perspective, he is thinking like a son and grandson, thats why he cannot see his mother, aunt's and grandpa's crimes.

But Pooja is also right in punishing those 3 (not others, I guess). So, I didn't like the moral tone the show took that Kabir is right, and Pooja is wrong.

The moral judgment was shown in that song sequence. It irritated me so much that I had to ffwd. 😵😆

Maybe Kabir can take senior Mittals to Pooja and make them apologize infront of the world that Ashok Sharma is innocent. Her anger might tone down a bit.

Ydays face off scene was not impressive.

The way Kabir was taking care of the family was adorable. The song which they played was apt.

Pooja should humiliate the senior Mittals instead of Kabir.

@SRKisLove: I don't think the writers want us to sympathise with the Sr. Mittals. Kabir is right in doing what he is doing, but that doesn't make me feel sorry for the Sr. Mittals (plus Dhruv), at all.

I agree with Kala, Pooja should target the Sr. Mittals instead of Kabir, which I suspect is going to come up soon based on the BTS segments. Right now, for me, it is hard to sympathise with Pooja because she is going after the wrong person, but that doesn't mean I feel bad for the Sr. Mittals.

You are right, they deserve a stricter punishment, but I still feel that Pooja shouldn't be the one to do it. She should leave it to karma, and make peace with it, because after everything she has been through - she deserves true happiness, which she won't get if she continues to seek revenge.

Again, this is what I felt the song was trying to show (from Pooja's side at least). I doubt they were trying to show that the Sr. Mittals were happy, it was more from Kabir's side, who is finding a ray of positivity in this situation because he has his entire family with him.

LOL I'm too lazy to type, so make do with my tweets. Can't repeat the same stuff here.

About today's episode

https://twitter.com/jaanebhidoyaron/status/1146631689667432448