Does Sandhya deserve BCT now?

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I was away for couple of days owing to Vishu and had not been able to put proper analysis posts after that BCT is taken away from Sandhya.
So today I read a lot of posts in which it was written that Sandhya doesnt deserve BCT. She cannot win it for Bhabo.
I agree completely to those thoughts. An IPS officer winning that trophy because her MIL wanted is rubbish to say the least.
We can say that Sandhya was putting up good fight with other cadets trying to get that trophy because Sooraj believed she can get it. Still the constant reminders of EV used to irritate me to the core. She was among the 5 best cadets when that review happened.
Shooting was an area of concern for her and many thought she would have used that opportunity to get special training. I disagree to that. She wanted to go for her SILs wedding and as a married woman she might have thought of meeting her husband. I mean somehow if you cannot go that will affect her. I mean you for long has been expecting to meet your husband and then suddenly it comes you cannot go, somehow I feel she took the right decision there. There was no issue concerning national security there and she could have anyways corrected her aim practicing hard which she was doing.

But still BCT for Bhabo was not going. And all her tasks were running around that. Now last week CVs made her move out of BCT race. I mean she was no longer eligible to compete in BCT.

The reaction of Sandhya after that was what made her different. She was still practicing. I mean it was then she started moving beyond BCT and was still trying to make her aim perfect to be a good IPS officer.
Now the naxal issue is happening. She along with Zakir is doing a good job there and both of them are doing it not for BCT but for national security. They are fighting like real IPS officers and are trying to get an upper hand in the mission.

If they do it successfully I would say not only Sandhya but Zakir too deserve that trophy because he was equally responsible in the success of that mission. Sandhya understood about Roma, but it was Zakir's plan that made her confess her crime.

Sandhya attacked from front , but Zakir moved equally well from behind and did good combat ( especially the throat slitting and rope cutting scene) to save sirjee. He was standing in front like the captain of a team.

If not for that cheating and I dont know how CVs are planning to undermine Zakir, but now in equal measure he looks as much eligible for BCT as Sandhya.

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.8k

Users

14

Likes

81

Frequent Posters

ayishas thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
nice post shruti ji!

wishing u very happy vishu!

i don't knw wheather zakir felt sorry for his cheat or not!

but it was the twist from officer singh's kidnaping and going well as a team work esply zakir and sandy!

and agree that other than cheating both sandy and zakir deserves the trophy!
_Nish_ thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
Lovely post di
Sandy will still get the trophy and I think she does deserve it
so does zak but he cheated...
winterdusk thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
BCT for the jungle task ???? nope its a unforseen event rest of the cadets dint get the oppurtunity to participate in such task so this shouldnt be the basis of BCT ! sayadari sandhya zakir rahul deepak should get a special prize for tht...my POV
now coming to the BCT do sandhya and zakir still need any xyz BCT wen they displayed the infinite courage in this task ?wat should these real IPS officers feeling right now ??? dont they understood the importance of national security ???? didnt they understood the duties and responsiblities of an IPS officers????? didnt each of them felt they have won more than a BCT by this rescue mission by killing naxalites ...who cares about BCT anymore ?😕 they have done something tht is above tht stupid trophy ! 😕 they should get arjun award for this which is highly prestigous !

they all have reached to the point where BCT looks so futile so meaningless all of them are the very best !

in cases like this the candidates are confered with bigger responsibilities as the country needs these passionate and determinate IPS ! why will the govt think to post sandhya on the hometown and solve some petty cases wen she has capabilites to fight against terriorist and naxalites ! oh ofc i forgot its bhabho world even after such a marvellous task in her sleeves she needs to prove her worth as a bahu she had to win BCT so yaa goodluck the spoliers are already out 😳
Edited by winterdusk - 11 years ago
Neel_M thumbnail
Fashion Feud Participant Thumbnail 12th Anniversary Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Nice post Sruthi..

Do not care for BCT anymore, by any means it will go to the lead. And Sandhya will stay two years in Pushkar and than she will get transfer, and so on...

So far I have equal respect for Sandhya and Zakir, because Sandhya knew she is out from BCT candidates, and still practicing to become an 100% IPS officer without any shortcomings. And also, she did came forward for saving A.Singh.

On the other hand, Zakir knew he is out from the troop, but still showed his 200% to bring the truth from Roma, and specially while saving the A Singh. Awesome, just like real combat.

HalleNJ thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
hi shruthi, happy vishu...

my take...it's no more about BCT or individuality, it's more about saving your people and team work as we have been questioning the Cvs all this while.

Just one thing which bothers me is despite the power packed epi, I find the logic is missing in the track...the logic of kidnapping sirji and Roma getting trained in IPS academy raises the issue of credibility of the academy, which I find it a joke now 😆

regarding Zakir being a deserving candidate, just like many said Sandy being lucky, I also find Zakir is lucky here as he has a teammate who managed to find out the culprit and Zakir smartly helped to expose her. The reason could be because he is out of BCT pressure and obsession, that makes him a more composed and sensible person.

I thought Zakir's character will be like AB in Sholay, but they yoyo him worse than bhabo and till now I cant have any opinion on him...if only his character was like AB, the whole track would have been much better, that's what I feel...


Edited by niruba - 11 years ago
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
no she doesn't deserve BCT simply coz other squads were not there and its unfair to them , this kind of judging but

if she is getting it anyway let there be a tie between her and Zakir as

Zakir was FANTASTIC . Hell , he was not an IPS trainee , he shone like a commando . The way he swiftly climbed diagonally and cut the rope , the way he slit the throat , the way he threw the stone and distracted the officer , Zakir was terrific . And i am no character fan . That actor acts superb .

Sandhya shot Manorama but she was scared and unsure . Zakir oozed confidence and the fierce killer look in his eyes simply made the episode . Zakir was at his best , he had nothing to gain , he was out of IPS for all he knew but he saved the very officer who decreed that .

So if Zakir is not given BCT with Sandhya it will be damn unfair .




-Liebe- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

no she doesn't deserve BCT simply coz other squads were not there and its unfair to them , this kind of judging but


if she is getting it anyway let there be a tie between her and Zakir as

Zakir was FANTASTIC . Hell , he was not an IPS trainee , he shone like a commando . The way he swiftly climbed diagonally and cut the rope , the way he slit the throat , the way he threw the stone and distracted the officer , Zakir was terrific . And i am no character fan . That actor acts superb .

Sandhya shot Manorama but she was scared and unsure . Zakir oozed confidence and the fierce killer look in his eyes simply made the episode . Zakir was at his best , he had nothing to gain , he was out of IPS for all he knew but he saved the very officer who decreed that .

So if Zakir is not given BCT with Sandhya it will be damn unfair .






agree with u..za deserves more but he cheated..bcz of that he s going to lose.but next to zak..sandy s going good..so bct will reach sandy.after all its a fiction😆
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
see Liebe i have no problems if he does not get it but then Sandhya shouldn't get it either . Her perfromance over the year was average and even the naxalites were joking about her shooting .

Where mistakes were concerned Agrima Singh has made a mistake too , not detecting that Roma was a terrorist inspite of being chief . In real life Agrima Singh will have to resign by taking responsibility . Press will hound her like anything .

What really should be shown is that Sandhya gets no BCT but Sahyadri squad is given special mention on prize giving day and she is given a special prize . Not BCT as other squads were not there to prove their worth .
Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 11 years ago
-Liebe- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000

see Liebe i have no problems if he does not get it but then Sandhya shouldn't get it either . Her perfromance over the year was average and even the naxalites were joking about her shooting .


Where mistakes were concerned Agrima Singh has made a mistake too , not detecting that Roma was a terrorist inspite of being chief . In real life Agrima Singh will have to resign by taking responsibility . Press will hound her like anything .

What really should be shown is that Sandhya gets no BCT but Sahyadri squad is given special mention on prize giving day and she is given a special prize . Not BCT as other squads were not there to prove their worth .

its cvz mistake.they shouldnt show zak as perfect cadet if they want to show sandy as a winner.zak s powerful cadet but just to show or help roma(also to accuse) they changed one characterization.not ony him cvz r bad at changing ones characterization just to move on storyline from bhabo( liquor chocolate) to zak(compass).before that their characterization was shown in one flow but now ufff all changed.also to make sandy the winner,they changed zak as bad guy.

PS cvz have to learn how to move story further without spoiling one character.its high time.

also one ay showing chavi as good sil,sis,beti other day ufff changing in characterization which i dnt like in cvz.

now zak s out as per fiction story,so next to zak,sandy s there...so she will win bct.only if she wins cvz can move story also add bhabo in all scenes thats it.JUST FOR A DRAMA.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".