Does Sandhya deserve BCT now?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#11

its cvz mistake.they shouldnt show zak as perfect cadet if they want to show sandy as a winner

Yes . Agree .

Quote

HalleNJ

@HalleNJ

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#12

see koolsadhu, Im not in defense of sandy should win BCT, in fact i didnt like the whole idea of BCT from the beginning itself...I wanted her to lose and get posted away from RP zoo...😛

whether sandy deserves BCT or not, it is still debatable because the main problem is sandy was shown very weak in the beginning...after that she improved, again, the problem is they fast forwarded the 11 months (which was full of time line blooper) and suddenly showed that sandy has improved and becomes a title contender for BCT...if only they showed some scenes of sandy winning other different tasks in a fast forwarded mode, this may look more convincing...

as we are debating about BCT and doing character analysis deeply, we overlooked that the mistake as mentioned by sindu above is in the screenplay in which the CVs skipped the part of showing sandy improving but moved the track suddenly to some jungle task and start butchering other characters to prove a point that sandy is the best cadet...

Edited by niruba - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Liebe-

@-Liebe-

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#13

I agree completely to those thoughts. An IPS officer winning that trophy because her MIL wanted is rubbish to say the least.

We can say that Sandhya was putting up good fight with other cadets trying to get that trophy because Sooraj believed she can get it.

both r wrong if u said bold part s wrong.

she has to get bct for herself or for both.not for bhabo but for suraj??? its not right.

she has to come out of that circle and to think independently.

Quote

koolsadhu1000

@koolsadhu1000

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#14

I don't want sandy to win BCT not coz i don't like her or coz i like Zakir more

nothing of the sort am nobody's fan .

I don't want her to win coz i genuinely see her perfomance as average only . Right to the point she shot Manorama she was unsure .

I don't agree that BCT is given without giving other squads a fair chance .

Besides i want that domineering saas of hers to know and accept IPS as it really is . She went right upto the level of interfering in bahu's career by using political contact to coerce bahu's superior . Its too much .

That saas needs a jolt .

And Sandhya needs a special mention and a prize rather than BCT .

Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 11 years ago

Quote

-Ramya-

@-Ramya-

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#15

no sarcastic or tit for tat replies pls. if u r able to argue beautyfully do it otherwise stay away frm the thread. i hv seen one to two members reply quite rude

Quote

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#16

@Sindhu I didnt justify her trail either for Sooraj. I mean you cant win it because your husband wants it so that he is able to balance between you and his mother.

To control Bhabo is not Sandhya's job, to help Sooraj balance mother and wife by know towing to Bhabo's unreasonable demand is not Sandhya's job.

Her focus on BCT for Pushkar posting itself was wrong whether it is for Bhabo or for Sooraj. She can try to be the best.

But the CVs have butchered Zakir's chara to make it look like Sandhya deserve BCT on her own. Even with intentional butchering Sandhya is not standing above Zakir, that's where the screenplay has failed. They are equal.

Edited by shruthiravi - 11 years ago

Quote

arjuhi4evr

@arjuhi4evr

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#17

Well written

Zakir was always a tough competition for Sandhya

And now they both are going to prove themselves deserving the BCT and not Roma..I'm just waiting for Officer Singh to appreciate them

Quote

Sonali_11

@Sonali_11

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#18

Zakir comes from an army background and when the training track started he was shown investing his time on the ground ,so practice wise he was ahead of Sandhya .. the problem is he's very impatient , such people do adopt unethical means to win when things are not in their favour, , the way his character is portrayed is realistic ... if he had worked hard to give his best and competed with passion , it woud have been better

Another trait , his over confindence, tht too can make u lose at any point in life..If he overcomes all these issues then I would think of him being deserving atleast.

Sandhya on the other hand was a slow starter , but tht doesn't mean such ppl cant win big competitions..If it was shown to be that easy for her then we would have thought sandhya is a super woman...When Keith made an exit she was shown working hard on her stamina, she was shown improving slow and steadily ..Then sky diving and through out this jungle task, it was her presence of mind which made her caught Roma and now they are saving officer singh.

She deserves BCT for sure..I believe for being a good police officer u need to be intelligent , honest , hardworking ...and she does have these qualities. If Sandhya wants to win the trophy for Suraj , then its ok he was worked really hard to make her achieve this dream and now has given up eating sweets as well.

Constant remindals from Bhabo are irritating but she wants sandhya to get posted in pushkar so tht surya can stay together , its fine.

Also CV's want to maintain this family touch in the show ..Bhabo and Suraj will always stay in picture

Edited by Sonali_11 - 11 years ago

Quote

coolmausam

@coolmausam

Voyager

Posted: 11 years ago

#19

I Totally Oppose the way of Highlighting Trophy in the Whole Track

Training Officers Should concentrate on the Training instead the obessiveness of Zakir's Trophy and Sandhya's Suraj-Bhabo wish is Highlighted in the Track in Each Day of Training..

Quote

shruthiravi

@shruthiravi

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#20

@Sonali CVs know what they are doing. If winning for Bhabo or Sooraj was right Sandhya would have hit that bulls eye and that's it. She would have got BCT .

By making Sandhya ineligible for BCT they have made it clear that " Best Cadet Trophy" cannot be win for Pushkar posting or for other selfish motives. Even Zak is out of TA.

You have to win it like a cadet. Yes all her points will be added. But that trophy will have some more twist for sure before it comes to Sandhya.

CVs very well know they cannot butcher IPS beyond a point. This track itself has shown very clearly that TA get maximum TRPs whereas RP and Bhabo comes TRP goes down.

IPS is a profession for the nation, where duty to nation comes first. If you cannot keep it or if you cannot learn to keep nation upfront you shouldnt be in it. There are many other careers available.

I maintain it very strongly. If Sandhya shown keeping parivaar above nation, keeping bhabo above duty then it will be a failure of the script.