Just a suggetion - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

2.3k

Users

13

Likes

84

Frequent Posters

mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: ramki1

Well said Minaxi👏...Its always good to read your posts

Thanks dear, appreciate your cooperation😊
jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
Mina i visit Mahalaxmi temple very often. There is something magical there. the vibrations are all around.. One look at the three beautiful faces and the world comes to a standstill.
Often there is a huge crowd. But it stops bothering u. ur focused on them.
Their hands always raised in blessings for every person who enters mumbai.
Today they glittered in their Navratri special dressings .
Stood in the queue for about 1 and half hour but every second was divine
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
Jayshree this will enhance your divine feelings.
The Ashta Lakshmi stotra is very good hear, including the Mahalaksshmi temple's aarati
kkr531 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: mnx12

This is just a suggetion,
Watch this show without any expectations, accept what appeals to you, don't bother about the rest. We are watching the maker's interpreted version, which is excellent at time, ridiculous too some times, so never bother so much.
We all are aware some aspects of how our real Gods are, no one can claim they know everything. We have been reading, hearing,, experiencing about their various aspects since we are born.
So what we know & experience is more important then anything else. Good things shown about them will enhance out faith, will make us understand them better. That doesn't mean some distorted versions can change our mind. This may never happen because what we know & have read since many years is deep rooted in our mind & life.
There are 18 puranas & many Up-puranas. Every puran glorifys the Deity whose story it is.
It is found very often that the same incident is interpreted in different manner, giving importance to the lead deity of that Purana. Some tracks of DKDM are found in other scriptures too. eg. about Kundalini Chakras, Tantra is found in detail in Yoga.
Creative discussion & criticism is good but beyond a limit it starts changing our frame of mind towards bit of negativity, which should be carefully avoided by us.




Yes i completely agree but since television is a powerful medium and since some of the viewers only get their knowledge about puranas by watching such shows it is prudent and needed to discuss about correct version of the events that are being shown it will do following things

1) People will read puranas with inquisitiveness as such discussions always contain references to them

2) educate viewers about true versions of story and help them in not getting mislead by the portrayal

3) Finally such discussions lead to healthy debates on many issues which are quite educational

regards
Krishna
sanju01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35
Few days back i saw two posts in this forum where the members said that whatever is shown in the serial is correct and we are unnecessarily criticising the show and the makers.
So what reply are you going to them?They said that parvati might be weak in reality too that's why they are showing her like that.
See,people watch mythological serials to get knowledge,to know what happened in the past,to know the stories of Gods.It's not possible to read the puranas to know everything in this busy world so people watch mythological serials because they think they will get knowledge(without reading the puranas) through these serials.These are like a shortcut to know the stories of Gods.
That's why people like Ramanand Sagar and B.R.Chopra showed everything correct and precise in Ramayan,Mahabharat and Srikrishna.They didn't change the stories(unlike Mahadev or show something different like Kamdev's arrow not hitting Mahadev,Rati cursing Parvati,Sati meeting Parvati,Mahadev making Kamdev alive,Mahadev helping Kartikeya in killing Tarakasur,etc.)Such things should not be shown as these events never happened.So why fool the viewers and giving them wrong information?
People watch the show thinking that they will get true and correct knowledge about Gods but here they are cheating the viewers by showing the events which did not happen at all.People who don't know anything about the puranas are going to believe whatever is shown to them.Isn't it fraud and cheating?Who is responsible for this?We are watching this show and giving them high trps and those people are cheating us by showing wrong information.
So what's wrong if we protest and criticise them?This is not a fictional show.Mahadev and Parvati are not fictional characters so why should we tolerate the makers fooling us and why shouldn't we complain?Only because this forum will remain clean and members won't get cranky reading the posts?But what about those members who feel cranky when they watch such episodes?What about those people who are being given wrong information and cheated by the makers?
Can someone answer this?
Btw,i felt so bad for Kartikeya when Indra insulted him saying that he killed Tarakasur only because of Mahadev's help otherwise he couldn't have done that.That was ridiculous.First of all,Mahadev didn't go to the war so no such thing happened in reality.Indra never insulted Kartikeya and gave all the credit to Mahadev.That's bad.I agree Mahadev is main character in the serial but giving credit to Mahadev for others hard work is wrong.Mahadev was given credit for the Kali episode too and now the Kartikeya episode too.
Edited by sanju01 - 12 years ago
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
im not saying critisising them is wrong
it definately isnt,but too much critism becomes unbearable!So Many times it happened i have liked a scene,and i come online to see people up in arms over it!
even if something nice is shown someone gets offended!
i understand expressing anger,but DKDM is a mythological based daily soap!its meant for entertainment and is only roughly based on them
and this has been the format they followed since day one-its nothing new!they have shown ridiculous stuff i admit,but they have always shown it!its nothing nothing new!

regarding what people think-im sure every person in India knows his or her stories of thier Gods well enough to know what to take seriously and what not to take seriously!Infact every region every family every person for that matter has thier own belief and theory of a particular story?so how many people can they possibly please?

regarding true knowlege etc-tell me one book that can give TRUE knowlege about the EXACT thing that happened?
is there any book like that?
also there are so many Puranas and other scriptures,some say they have info put in later etc-which one to believe?
the truth is that centuries have passed since those events have occured,do me or you know what really happened?
maybe one of the events we belive so much may be added on much later?how do you know whats true or no?
every story can be seen in many many many ways,there is no one way of interpretation here!

every book we read, including every scripture is ultimately someones interpretation of what happened?were you and me alive at that time to know how correct it is or isnt?

the writers put together stories with the ibjective of enetertainment-take it or leave it

reg any part of the show you find offending-my suggestion,DONT WATCH it!
i dont understand the objective of finding something bad and irritating,STILL sitting in front of the TV watching it and then coming and crtitizing it
dont like it,dont watch it and spare your self of the headache!shows like DKDM whatever they show are bound to offend someone
so if you feel its a fraud and you are being cheated,kindly do not spend your time watching it
thats entirely my POV,beacuse thats what i would have done if a show buggged me so much!
shruti
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
@krishna, there is a difference between criticism & healthy discussion, atleast that's what it leads to here as noticed many times. Many posts are made to criticise a pt, other members add their views with added criticism, sarcastic remarks, all that is anything but educational. Such posts leas to more & more -vity, which needs to be avoided. as you've mentioned many don't have knowledge about puranas, they see & try to understand. We have many such members here. What impression are we giving them by such addeded criticism? Believe me atleast 90% of us have heard or read some of the stories as a child, or while growing up, that's why we are drawn to most of the Mytho shows to know more. They do read Puranas, I have read many Puranas as a story book, they are quote interesting. .
A healthy discussion is always a delight to read. But not increse crirticising threads.
-Nymphadora- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
off late the discussion is going in a negative direction-and its not good for anyone and is genuinely off putting

there can be criticism a give and take and knowledge,which is one of the greatest plus points of this forum that we get to learn so much!

i dont think anyone will disagree with me on that ground that the environment of this forum is going downhill-youll find atleast one topic that effectively manages to spoil your mood.

Criticism is fine,but it needs to be done properly without igniting a fire of negativity-has anyone read the topics of late?

I cant watch this show
this is rubbish
this is crap!
this is fraud


does such kind of critisim work any where?this is more bad mouthing than critisim!does it even give rise to anything?this infact will only anger and infuriate the makers!

infact i suggest everytime you do not like something-rather than making a post saying this is wrong,this is rubbish etc that is most likely going to make things go negative
make a post stating the real story,stating the story as per what you think,and share various aspects that havent been shown
that will be better that bad mouthing anyone!
youll can make more knowledgeable posts expressing the real story in your opinion and make it a better more constructive way of putting forth crtitism!

infact whatever the show puts forth can lay a ground for knowing more as Krishna said over bringing about negativity!
Edited by shruti.nil - 12 years ago
mnx12 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
@sanju, there is a very big difference between those & this posts. In this I have suggested, not told anyone to stop criticising or accept whatever is shown in the show. Do read it again.
Even B. R. Chopra had not shown everything given in the scriptures.
You can protest & criticise them but how much & for how long? Does this mean most the posts have to be for voicing it again& again even if that track has got over long back. Will it serve any purpose now?
Over criticism turns into -vity, making others too fall for it. Many members have said they have stopped coming to this forum because of increased -vity here.
Any comment about an epi should be made in written update. Regarding getting cranky, that is a human emotion, one has to learn to keep under control. Even in our practical life will anyone tolerate us if we are cranky most of the time?
Read the main post again, no one can change out deep rooted thoughts or sanskars by showing it differently. Our mind will accept what appeals & reject what doesn't.
Makers give disclaimer things shown in this show is made from entertainment purpose only. They have no intention of hurting religious sentiments. That says a lot. Infact this she is much better then DBSK.
Edited by mnx12 - 12 years ago
jayvenk thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
Mina thanks for the link .. simply great the aarti and stuti .. loved it..
I am guilt too of protesting against some of the stuff shown .. but looking at ur point of view seems u and shruti are right..
:))) thank u girls

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".