Fandom overboard? I think so. - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

130

Views

11.9k

Users

54

Likes

825

Frequent Posters

bunnylovessunny thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#51
certain overrated actor who will not be named.

careful there buddy!! the fandom may go overboard yet again!
showviewer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: varma.nishi1

@bold that is not true ,..the data is defo checked n stuff but cos of the faulty system it's not taken into account ..as in not a widespread ,measure ...
Anyway chuck it it's very complicated n Difficult to understand ...sigh
And yes the system sucks that is true and an undeniable fact BAS


Oh! OK! Did not know the info is checked, but not accounted for...Yes, TAM system has too many loop holes.
AmazingAmy thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#53
RC šŸ¤—

I'm just glad you finally made a post here! You've always been objective with your thinking so I hope no one misunderstands you, especially those unfamiliar with your posts.

See regarding the TRPs, none of us blamed Farhan for it. At least I never saw that in this forum. We know this show is on Sony and the storyline was very average, there were no high expectations from the TRPs. That is something Farhan made up in his head, apparently.

It is true that many of us found the show hard to watch with Farhan opposite Sanaya. I mean, did you see him act? It was pure torture. His creepy facial expressions, excessive blinking, horrid body language and dialogue delivery...its like you didn't want him to go near Sanaya, that's usually not a good sign for the male lead. It was driving a lot of people away from the show and I'm sure he knows that. Its okay, everyone is not perfect at acting in their first show. He should have moved on quietly. My biggest problem with him is how he handled his exit...he made it personal by dragging Sanaya, her boyfriend, her previous show into it...it was a bad move. If I was Sanaya, I'd be offended that he tried to suggest she didn't like him because she wanted her boyfriend for his role. There is NO basis for that assumption of his, its very insulting to her integrity as a professional.

I stopped watching the show after the first week and it was 90% because of Farhan and 10% because of the story. That is how much he bothered me. Its still not the best show on TV but at least I get to watch my favorite actress with Anuj, a good actor, so that will be better than nothing.

/end rambling šŸ˜›
764734 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
Okay lemme tell u either u watch his acting n then talk because Sanaya has not complained about him despite of her going thru tough time acting with him, but co-stars like Himanshu n Rugved did... Himanshu said he takes 30-40 retakes which makes any actor frustrated... But Sanaya tolerated everything n never demanded for his replacement... It was PH who changed him due to fan's demands... So ur point of proving Sanaya as wrong here falls flat... Last 2 episodes of CC has been fantastic ever since his replacement happened n I am thankful to PH for replacing that fellow... N that guy should stop being arrogant after this n learn from his mistakes instead of accusing the gr8 Ekta Kapoor n calling Sanaya "Madam ya Senior Artist" Kameena Kahika...😔
golpokobita thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#55
Hearsay and limited knowledge on a fact.. is always dangerous.
It seems that you haven't ever watched Farhan's acting.

Please do watch his episodes with patience (because it really needs patience to watch FK's acting)..

Then, just forget about sanaya irani, trp, CC ... everything about the show and on the basis of FK's acting only, make an honest opinion -- "do you think, by any standard, FK deserves to be an actor, that also as a lead, in Indian TV industry??"

He was replaced because he was a terrible actor. And instead of accepting the fact, he started making negative comments about his co-star, who happens to be a popular and brilliant actor (given SI has two back to back hit shows).

And you expected her fans not to react??

My bottom line is, please watch FK's acting and decide on him, not on Sanaya's fandom!
Edited by golpokobita - 12 years ago
Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#56

Originally posted by: AyeReKhushi

RC šŸ¤—


I'm just glad you finally made a post here! You've always been objective with your thinking so I hope no one misunderstands you, especially those unfamiliar with your posts.

See regarding the TRPs, none of us blamed Farhan for it. At least I never saw that in this forum. We know this show is on Sony and the storyline was very average, there were no high expectations from the TRPs. That is something Farhan made up in his head, apparently.

It is true that many of us found the show hard to watch with Farhan opposite Sanaya. I mean, did you see him act? It was pure torture. His creepy facial expressions, excessive blinking, horrid body language and dialogue delivery...its like you didn't want him to go near Sanaya, that's usually not a good sign for the male lead. It was driving a lot of people away from the show and I'm sure he knows that. Its okay, everyone is not perfect at acting in their first show. He should have moved on quietly. My biggest problem with him is how he handled his exit...he made it personal by dragging Sanaya, her boyfriend, her previous show into it...it was a bad move. If I was Sanaya, I'd be offended that he tried to suggest she didn't like him because she wanted her boyfriend for his role. There is NO basis for that assumption of his, its very insulting to her integrity as a professional.

I stopped watching the show after the first week and it was 90% because of Farhan and 10% because of the story. That is how much he bothered me. Its still not the best show on TV but at least I get to watch my favorite actress with Anuj, a good actor, so that will be better than nothing.

/end rambling šŸ˜›


Darling šŸ¤— First up, how are you love? 😊

I'm in no way or form defending FK, he's nothing special from the few episodes I've seen. In fact the new guy, he's the one from the Nivya add with Aushka right? He's cute.

Frankly i found SI's performance lacking in this show as well. FK was bad, no denying. But the entire direction, screeplay, everything is so mediocre. the director is simply un able to get the best out of the actors.

I've seen other Sony shows like Rishtha.com and they all had less TRPs, but were really enjoyable. CC for me is lacking by a long shot somewhere.


Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: golpokobita

Hearsay and limited knowledge on a fact.. is always dangerous.

It seems that you haven't ever watched Farhan's acting.

Please do watch his episodes with patience (because it really needs patience to watch FK's acting)..

Then, just forget about sanaya irani, trp, CC ... everything about the show and on the basis of FK's acting only, make an honest opinion -- "do you think, by any standard, FK deserves to be an actor, that also as a lead, in Indian TV industry??"

He was replaced because he was a terrible actor. And instead of accepting the fact, he started making negative comments about his co-star, who happens to be a popular and brilliant actor (given SI has two back to back hit shows).

And you expected her fans not to react??

My bottom line is, please watch FK's acting and decide on him, not on Sanaya's fandom!


I have seen FK's performance. Enough of it to judge.

And i'm not a stranger to the Sanaya fandom what so ever.

My debate was not about FK's replacement but rather all the obsessive defending that takes place on IF. IMO rather pointless.
tiahalder thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#58
Fandom is always flawed..now i just prefer to be an individual admirer of sanaya..and yes ofcourse not a blind one..and so i agree to some of your points!!!!
but here FK had some faults too..he could have left in a dignified way..maintaining a little bit diplomacy..earning respect!he lacked skill..which he failed to realize although some of his grievances are justified!but cant accept the way he's venting out his frustrations..
Rockerchic thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Gemsal678

@Rockerchic - I agree with you and I disagree with you. šŸ˜† You can read my opinions on the show in a post I wrote yesterday. https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/chhan-chhan/3624232/chanchan-and-offscreen-drama-an-objective-view
I am definitely not a blind Sanaya fan. And, I'm a casual CC watcher. I watched in the beginning solely for SI, and quickly realized that - as you mentioned - CC just simply is not a great show. With or without FK.
But, being a reader on this forum, I disagree that the majority blame FK for the show not succeeding. But, he was a factor. Even though CC is not marketed as a love story, the first few months of the show focused on ChanChan and Manav getting together. FK and SI had zero chemistry. And, alot of that is because FK was just not a good enough actor. But, still, the entire blame of the show is not on him.
As for the actor who shall not be named. Whether or not he is overrated remains to be seen. He was brilliant in the role he was given, and that's why he has so many fans. If FK had been brilliant in the role he had been given, he would have many fans too. Comparisons are not needed to form an opinion on someone's acting ability. Also, I do think the reaction to Anuj has been mostly positive. Viewers are not blind - we can tell immediately that he has an ease in front of the camera which will fit better with Sanaya. But, nobody is sitting here expecting CC to be the second-coming of IPK.
Anyways, let's see if the show improves now that FK is gone. That is the real litmus test.


Oh my šŸ˜†the over rated actor who cannot be named couldn't act either. And you'd respond to this statement of mine by saying majority think otherwise.

Have you seen the SP shows? None of them can act and yet the shows are popular. CC doesn't really appeal to any fixed range of audience. CC isn't popular online or world wide either.

And i know Sony doesn't have the reach but it's produced some amazing shows like Rishtha.com. CC is just very poorly written.

There are bigger problems for CC than just FK, that's all i'm saying.
Edited by Rockerchic - 12 years ago
spirit thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#60
This is gonna sound so irrelevant, but the STARKS died!! WTH!!
Sorry! Let me get back to your post!!
šŸ˜†

Lets be honest RC, Most (a friend argues All of them are) of these shows are average, below average or mediocre., even the ones leading the ratings. It's really about what crap you chose and decide to waste time over. I know your post deals with fandome but I just had to share. Just ignore, I'm stuck on this work problem that refuses to solve itself., so just needed some distraction.šŸ˜†
Edited by spirit - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".