CC thread - CC # 4 for JA, siyaasat and RT - Page 115

Originally posted by: munnirony

Sumtimes I feel when things were gud? To establish so called feminism every time jalal was degarded. Trp audience literally enjoyed it. Who cared tht jalal was trapped by abul mali? People only clapped for the mirchi war. Yes now things had become worst with more rubbish script nd horrible actors. Now since jo is effected trps r also effected. Until nd unless this blind feminism nd love for meladrama is off ekta will rule. honestly were ja viewers really bothered about akbar? Do they think anything logically? No. So now why ask for logic? This is wht they deserve but unfortunately noone will accept the reality.

when we think about some really good episodes of JA , I fail to understand that how can someone kill a product or idea which had so much potential ? It ignited so many readers to write good FF/OS etc. This is the hallmark of good fiction.

Originally posted by: sp108

Noor is a mysterious charcter to me. I have heard she was power hungry. And many say she was a good administrator and promoter of women's education. Some say she was a bad administrator and she was the reason for the beginning of downfall of the Mughal Empire. Enigmatic indeed

Originally posted by: jayaks02

Mandy - Now thinking back I feel all this would have been forced if there is no emotional locking between the two - Not the teacher - student who keeps on implementing teacher's pet projects - Forget it it 0% history - I do not relate to a love story where female lead GPSing male lead. It is against the concept of love or love story - Once in a while is OK - whereas all her mistakes/ blunders are brushed aside and she never even apologizes while Jalal goes about fixing it.

Pakistan serials grow on you- I mean the good ones - Watched Humsafar first 6 episodes - Oh boy - Is Faward Khan good ? he is a killer actor coupled with very good looks. 😃

jaya in all good pakistani serials what captivates you is that even without touching the actors convey romance and emotions so beautifully!..i would give all the credit to talented directors, script writers and the actors! like they say nothing can be more damaging than great talent and bad script and that is why i want rajat to quit because the current situation of JA is damaging his career...! now i cannot even relate him as akbar he looks more like a joke due to the bad script!

Originally posted by: jayaks02

See - When Emperor or Prince set sights on a female there is no way a female is going to act otherwise - Then all roads lead to zanena 😆

But Noor was so cunning, clever and power hungry she started manipulating Jahangir. If this is how it is shown in Siyasat, it is good - Anything else is contrary to history, IMO.

And Siyasat is not even available 12 hours after the original telecast in online - 😡

jaya she is shown very sharp and calculative but seems like she kinda have some feelings for salim too which is too early to say as salim has a crush on her and she is using her tactics to make him crave for her more!

Originally posted by: sp108

Noor is a mysterious charcter to me. I have heard she was power hungry. And many say she was a good administrator and promoter of women's education. Some say she was a bad administrator and she was the reason for the beginning of downfall of the Mughal Empire. Enigmatic indeed

i have not read much about noor but as the serial is going its very much in accordance with history and is portraying noor as i have heard or read a bit in history,,what i have heard is that she was very ambitious and intelligent and it was due to her intelligence salim got so dependent on her for all his political decisions!

Originally posted by: jayaks02

She may have been capable in some sense but definitely sown the seeds of mistrust and fall of Mughal Empire - He may have married her as he may have been attracted but giving such a free hand in matters of state has boomeranged big time. Women have less vision when it comes to large scale governance , IMO. They are guided by emotions which is not suited for governing a large empire - But Noor was evil, cunning and plotted to retain power within her - A different daring woman in 16th Century, for sure.

Originally posted by: jayaks02

See - When Emperor or Prince set sights on a female there is no way a female is going to act otherwise - Then all roads lead to zanena 😆

But Noor was so cunning, clever and power hungry she started manipulating Jahangir. If this is how it is shown in Siyasat, it is good - Anything else is contrary to history, IMO.

And Siyasat is not even available 12 hours after the original telecast in online - 😡

jaya it is as i have been watching it on and off all week!

Originally posted by: munnirony

Sumtimes I feel when things were gud? To establish so called feminism every time jalal was degarded. Trp audience literally enjoyed it. Who cared tht jalal was trapped by abul mali? People only clapped for the mirchi war. Yes now things had become worst with more rubbish script nd horrible actors. Now since jo is effected trps r also effected. Until nd unless this blind feminism nd love for meladrama is off ekta will rule. honestly were ja viewers really bothered about akbar? Do they think anything logically? No. So now why ask for logic? This is wht they deserve but unfortunately noone will accept the reality.

munni cannot agree more and i still remember the forum during mirchi war it went all ga ga over naari shakti but no one cared about the bad script and bad NR and i have still to read in history that akbar was made captive and his wives won the war for him😆

Originally posted by: jayaks02

when we think about some really good episodes of JA , I fail to understand that how can someone kill a product or idea which had so much potential ? It ignited so many readers to write good FF/OS etc. This is the hallmark of good fiction.

But look at the show now - no one is active in forum and people are fed up.

jaya now nothing is making sense, after salim's entry right from taking food in his mouth to how the food is digested in the digestive track until it comes out all is shown in details about him which makes one wonder what on earth one is watching?..am i watching what salim used to do in details or something about JA?..they should have kept the main focus on the main title leads and then incorporated salim and his love stories slowly but not taking the center stage and most importantly a good script with interesting captivating script and also doing justice to the the historical facts as any historical with just NRs and no facts is bound to crash!