Chandra Nandini 101-105: Dhai rang prem ke - Page 15

Originally posted by: shailusri1983

The mystery plotter whom Roopa was about to name should be:

A) Aapma and Helena
B) Sunanda
C) Malayketu
D) Avantika since I was unable to think about anybody else, and since nobody suspects her of anything. When I come to think about it, she does have an axe to grind against CGM as he killed all her sons, and this will also be major twist. I don't know why but I am suspecting her. It's just my hunch but I could be wrong.
E) Nobody whom we know till now. A character who may be introduced in future
F) Pandugrath who is really not so mad as he pretends to be. Taking advantage of his special mental condition, he could plot against CGM. We still do not know his degree of insanity and sanity.

These are few options I could think based on what we know.

Originally posted by: sashashyam

👏[😆And her ideas never seem to work either!

Shyamala Aunty

QUOTE=amina1]Apama has nothing to do besides giving her daughter rotten ideas,so much for yawani brain😆 and helena is equally foolish no wonder chandra runs from both his patnis ek bhatkeli dusri satkeli😆

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Very nice, my dear Shailaja, It is always good to tabulate the possibilities systematically. It clears the mind.

Now let us test all the hypotheses one by one.

A is a known quantity, and of strictly limited application: their earlier plot to use Roopa to distance Chandra from Nandini. They still think Nandini is dead, and so they would hardly be plotting against her, but only against Roopa. And as usual, they are too late!

B is also fully known to Chandra as Roopa's collaborator, so that would be no revelation for Roopa to make to him with her dying breath. Moreover, I do not see her as a grand conspirator with some sort of overarching plan, and against whom? Hers seems to be a solo track, against Padmanand.

C is more promising, but he is just not in that complex mould, and his plotting is to destroy Chandra and get Nandini for himself, not to destroy her too. Plus I am sure he has no idea of Roopa's existence.

D is in the pattern beloved of mystery story writers: the Least Likely Suspect. I would not mind her at all, but her love for Nandini is genuine and she would never risk her life. And she is always boosting Chandra to Nandini. So it is tough to imagine what she would be working for in trying to destroy Chandra

E is rank cheating by the CVs, and is thus the most likely solution!😉😉

F would be fascinating, and Pandugrath might well have recovered from his original mental retardation (which has to be genuine) under the treatment he received, and might be hiding it. Add to that the fact that he is missing in action. But he is with Nand and Rakshas, and why would he plot against Nandini as well as against Chandra? And he would not know about Roopa at all, would her? But it is the most intriguing choice of them all- the true identity hidden under the mentally challenged mask.

Summing it all up, I would choose between E and perhaps F, with a tilt towards E. That would tie in with the sense of urgency in Roopa's voice as she struggles to reveal the name. It has to be somebody known to Chandra but most unlikely to be suspected by him.

Good! I am rubbing my hands in anticipation! Nothing like a Mystery Plotter to keep one alert!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Very nice, my dear Shailaja, It is always good to tabulate the possibilities systematically. It clears the mind.

Now let us test all the hypotheses one by one.

A is a known quantity, and of strictly limited application: their earlier plot to use Roopa to distance Chandra from Nandini. They still think Nandini is dead, and so they would hardly be plotting against her, but only against Roopa. And as usual, they are too late!

B is also fully known to Chandra as Roopa's collaborator, so that would be no revelation for Roopa to make to him with her dying breath. Moreover, I do not see her as a grand conspirator with some sort of overarching plan, and against whom? Hers seems to be a solo track, against Padmanand.

C is more promising, but he is just not in that complex mould, and his plotting is to destroy Chandra and get Nandini for himself, not to destroy her too. Plus I am sure he has no idea of Roopa's existence.

D is in the pattern beloved of mystery story writers: the Least Likely Suspect. I would not mind her at all, but her love for Nandini is genuine and she would never risk her life. And she is always boosting Chandra to Nandini. So it is tough to imagine what she would be working for in trying to destroy Chandra

E is rank cheating by the CVs, and is thus the most likely solution!😉😉

F would be fascinating, and Pandugrath might well have recovered from his original mental retardation (which has to be genuine) under the treatment he received, and might be hiding it. Add to that the fact that he is missing in action. But he is with Nand and Rakshas, and why would he plot against Nandini as well as against Chandra? And he would not know about Roopa at all, would her? But it is the most intriguing choice of them all- the true identity hidden under the mentally challenged mask.

Summing it all up, I would choose between E and perhaps F, with a tilt towards E. That would tie in with the sense of urgency in Roopa's voice as she struggles to reveal the name. It has to be somebody known to Chandra but most unlikely to be suspected by him.

Good! I am rubbing my hands in anticipation! Nothing like a Mystery Plotter to keep one alert!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Very nice, my dear Shailaja, It is always good to tabulate the possibilities systematically. It clears the mind.

Now let us test all the hypotheses one by one.

A is a known quantity, and of strictly limited application: their earlier plot to use Roopa to distance Chandra from Nandini. They still think Nandini is dead, and so they would hardly be plotting against her, but only against Roopa. And as usual, they are too late!

B is also fully known to Chandra as Roopa's collaborator, so that would be no revelation for Roopa to make to him with her dying breath. Moreover, I do not see her as a grand conspirator with some sort of overarching plan, and against whom? Hers seems to be a solo track, against Padmanand.

C is more promising, but he is just not in that complex mould, and his plotting is to destroy Chandra and get Nandini for himself, not to destroy her too. Plus I am sure he has no idea of Roopa's existence.

D is in the pattern beloved of mystery story writers: the Least Likely Suspect. I would not mind her at all, but her love for Nandini is genuine and she would never risk her life. And she is always boosting Chandra to Nandini. So it is tough to imagine what she would be working for in trying to destroy Chandra

E is rank cheating by the CVs, and is thus the most likely solution!😉😉

F would be fascinating, and Pandugrath might well have recovered from his original mental retardation (which has to be genuine) under the treatment he received, and might be hiding it. Add to that the fact that he is missing in action. But he is with Nand and Rakshas, and why would he plot against Nandini as well as against Chandra? And he would not know about Roopa at all, would her? But it is the most intriguing choice of them all- the true identity hidden under the mentally challenged mask.

Summing it all up, I would choose between E and perhaps F, with a tilt towards E. That would tie in with the sense of urgency in Roopa's voice as she struggles to reveal the name. It has to be somebody known to Chandra but most unlikely to be suspected by him.

Good! I am rubbing my hands in anticipation! Nothing like a Mystery Plotter to keep one alert!

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: liberty2

As usual canny reasoning, for all the suspects ,either ruling them in or out. I still will go with C, I think his is a joint venture with Roopa, to distance Nandini and Chandra. Surely he wouldn't want N destroyed, but then Roopa has mind of her own. So the poison fiasco, and he was MIA during the court sentencing of N.

If it turns out to be Pandugrath,that would be bolt from the blue. Yeah...zero cool

But Roopa's dying words were bhahut bada khiladi hain, sabse khela khel rahe hain. Sunanda has to know Malay, right? , since he was engaged to Nandini.

Interesting, it better not be khoda pahad, nilkla Chuha🤢

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Thank you, my dear P2!

For writers, amateur or professional, and actors, there is no such thing as too much praise! They lap it up greedily and then, like Oliver Twist, ask for more!😉

But one can always distinguish genuine, knowledgeable praise from the pro forma variety. Yours comes in the former. And it gladdens my heart.

And not just for me. See now, you have paid Chandra-Nandini one of the greatest compliments that could be imagined for a lead pair: that they have made you fall in love with them despite yourself!

Shyamala Aunty,

See aunty, I don't remember seeing this side of your writing. Of course we all agree unanimously, there wasn't any perm on the previous show.😉 Sunlight on a butterfly's wings was top notch⭐️. Last bit of sahi mahine main vivah was A-rate. So was instinctive faith.👏. Trust me this is not to butter up, if I simply read your scene charming possessiveness, dinner comedy it plays out right on the dot,in the show.

In a way it works in my favor too. I can precisely jump to the scenes I want to watch. And zoom through the unwanted stuff.😉

Gosh-darn ! I wanted the hideout to just remain secret, for this cool kids, 😳grrr...now Mr. Chankya knows about, hope he doesn't come down flog them both😉

[/QUOT

Originally posted by: shailusri1983

We really cannot rule out the possibility of Malayketu just as you said. But he is a known proposition and in such cases I doubt if the CVs would go with the obvious and most under suspect option. The only thing I could make out after seeing the way Roopa was contorting and trying to round the lips a number of times, two things seemed obvious. The name was a bit big. The second was that she was either trying to produce a 'K' or 'T' sound or both the sounds one after the other. Malayketu is a big name by that yardstick and it has both the 'K' and 'T' sounds. So is the name of Avantika. The same goes for Pandugrath as well. Did anyone observe the lip movements Roopa was trying to make? Any guesses based on that? The CVs had better make this mystery plotter track full of suspense. I don't want to be disappointed with something paltry!

Avantika would be way up on the suspect list, if it was western show, but Indian show, can't make a mother go rogue. That's always entitled to step mom. Haven't got into lip reading yet😉😆. It better not turn out a dud.😡

Originally posted by: shailusri1983

The mystery plotter whom Roopa was about to name should be:

A) Aapma and Helena
B) Sunanda
C) Malayketu
D) Avantika since I was unable to think about anybody else, and since nobody suspects her of anything. When I come to think about it, she does have an axe to grind against CGM as he killed all her sons, and this will also be major twist. I don't know why but I am suspecting her. It's just my hunch but I could be wrong.
E) Nobody whom we know till now. A character who may be introduced in future
F) Pandugrath who is really not so mad as he pretends to be. Taking advantage of his special mental condition, he could plot against CGM. We still do not know his degree of insanity and sanity.

These are few options I could think based on what we know.