My dear Sri,
Thank you so much, my dear. But then you were always more than kind to my posts!
Since you have written more or less the same thing in my third
Moonrise thread, I am simply pasting my response to you there here as well, with some additions. Saves me a good bit of typing!
How you do rush to judgement, Sri! Two lousy opening episodes which, curiously enough, seem to have had some sort of historical backing (though not for Nand being a barber!😉), followed by 2 better ones, and already you are crying that Chandragupta is being shown as too good. But why on earth should he be shown as bad, or even as a grey character? This is NOT Jalal the Jallad. This is a wonder boy whose genius Chanakya recognised very early on.
Chanakya will now have to cut and shape this rough diamond, and he will do precisely that. And why is it bad that Chandragupta saves Chanakya's life? Fighting off a wild boar would not have been a specialty of Chanakya's, for Heaven's sake!
That scene is tailor-made to convince Chanakya of the boy's courage, but not the kind of reckless courage that wants to show off. It is courage with a specific purpose, and even at this age, the boy knows what the odds are for his achieving that purpose. Which is precisely what Chanakya was looking for.
And he does achieve it. Both against the boar now, and against the enemies of Bharatmata later.
Similarly, I would not say that Chanakya was the "saviour" of young Chandragupta. Each needed the other, and it was a perfect partnership, though not one of equals. It was just a case of Lady Luck, who is a fickle jade at the best of times, producing a burst of glorious serendipity.
Chandragupta Maurya was one of the greatest warriors of all time - he never lost a battle - and Chanakya used him to splendid effect, first against the Macedonians and then against Nand.
You say that the build up of Chandra's anger should have been done differently. I feel that what was shown here is far, far better than the way it was done in Jodha Akbar. Now tell me what precisely you feel they should have done with that track. I am sure you would have some ideas, and it would be interesting to discuss them.
For the rest, do relax, Sri, and try and go with the flow. We all suffered thru a lot of junk in Jodha Akbar, remember? Even in the beginning.
Shyamala Akka
Originally posted by: jayaks02
Enjoying the NON-CGM Conversations more 😃
Sorry - But the presentation and pitch of serial beginning looks very boring to me.
Your commentary as always spectacular Akka.
If Chanakya is going to work on CGM to make him conquer Magadh, it will be good. Else we will still watch it.
I am not liking the DO ALL GOOD CGM avatar But this is EKTA show so no complaints. She shows what she wants to .
Edited by sashashyam - 9 years ago