How is Aishwarya Rai rated so highly here? - Page 5

Ash better actress than Kareena?!? 🤣

Aishwarya is a better actress than Deepika. The only decent performance of Deepika is Piku.

Aishwarya was amazing in Raincoat, Raavan, Guru and Provoked. She gives some amazing performances out of her SLB world.

In movies like Dhoom 2 she was horrible no doubt.

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

Aishwarya Rai is a directors actor, period. With the right direction, she has always done well and excelled in periodic movies. That being said, Aishwarya Rai is not a perfect actress and has her fair share of bad and good performances. Deepika as Mastani and Padmavat was the most vomit-inducing crap I've ever had the misfortune to endure. I would take Aishwarya Rai's Paro and Jodha any day over Deepika's emotional filled flaring nostrils, arched eyebrows of grand superiority, permanent case of watery conjunctivitis eyes, lip quivering with desire and her painfully seductive voice sprouting out poetic nonsense. The only reason I survived Mastani and Padmavat is because of the gloriously massive nose ring that covered half her face and kept me distracted from bashing my head against a wall. NOSE RING ZINDABAD!

Anyhow, I'd rather watch a bad performance of Deepika and Aish than watch Kareena Kapoor. She is the one that's hailed as a good actress in this forum despite the shitfest called Mein Prem Ki Dewaani Hoon, Khushi, KKKG, Yaadein, Ashoka, Mujhse Dosti Karogi, Ajnabee, Kambakh Ishk, Jeena Sirf Mere Liye blahblahblah

Bold

Lmao 🤣

I find it funny when dp lovers concentrate on aloo's nostrils when their favourite is just as bad

Aish is less mechanical than Deepika. She did roles like guzarish, taal, raincoat, choker bali, hum dil, guru, kunanadein kunanadein, provoked which I honestly dont think Deepike could have done. But I don't see Aish doing a cocktail. She needs more Indianized characters with the exception of Bride and Prejudice (for which western critics actually gave her better reviews than Indian ones. Gurinder Chadda did a great job pointing out the bias in India against Aish becasuse she had upset some powerful forces. )

Aish less mechanical

Deepika more versatile

Originally posted by: AutumnColors

Aishwarya is a better actress than Deepika. The only decent performance of Deepika is Piku.

Aishwarya was amazing in Raincoat, Raavan, Guru and Provoked. She gives some amazing performances out of her SLB world.

In movies like Dhoom 2 she was horrible no doubt.

Yeah, right🤣

What about Tamasha, Cocktail, Ram-Leela, Chennai Express, Yeh Jaawani Hai Deewani and Chapaak?

Because she is worth it!

Originally posted by: grumpydwarf

Aish is less mechanical than Deepika. She did roles like guzarish, taal, raincoat, choker bali, hum dil, guru, kunanadein kunanadein, provoked which I honestly dont think Deepike could have done. But I don't see Aish doing a cocktail. She needs more Indianized characters with the exception of Bride and Prejudice (for which western critics actually gave her better reviews than Indian ones. Gurinder Chadda did a great job pointing out the bias in India against Aish becasuse she had upset some powerful forces. )

Aish less mechanical

Deepika more versatile

Grumpy, for the first time I don't agree with you.

See these two scenes and I think you will see what I'm talking about. Ash is screechy and over-the-top. Deepika is nuanced and balanced.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R79XZlueFjw&t=99s

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gPp1w0t5LXA&t=82s

Originally posted by: mintyblue

Well, we can always agree to disagree. Deepika is miles ahead of Aishwarya in stardom and acting both.

ACTING? What great acting has Deepika done? Stardom is debatable as stardom doesn't equate to acting skills. The only improvment I've seen in Deepu over the years is her sense of script.

Originally posted by: Cookies..

ACTING? What great acting has Deepika done? Stardom is debatable as stardom doesn't equate to acting skills. The only improvment I've seen in Deepu over the years is her sense of script.

Acc. to me her acting in movies like Lafangey Parindey, Cokctail, Piku, Tamasha, YJHD, Ram-Leela and Chapaak are amazing.

Aishwarya's only amazing perf. is Raincoat.

So Deepika>>>>Aishwarya

Originally posted by: --Pro.vo.King--

Aishwarya was rated poorly as an actress on this forum not so long ago ..

Not sure what changed all of a sudden ..

Aishwarya's biggest weak point as an actress is comedy .. She cant be funny even if her life depended on it .. All great actors are good at comedy .. Aish is too plastic ( personality wise ) .. She cant goof around or be real .. She is too classy and elegant .. And that restricts her as an actor ..

But she shines in serious roles under good direction .. Not to mention she is impossibly beautiful .. So certain roles are more suited for her than any other great actor ..

I could not have explained it better. You should be awarded something to write such a pitch perfect answer