How is Aishwarya Rai rated so highly here? - Page 3

Ash in raincoat choker bali/Raincoat/Kandukondain Kandukondain/Guzarish beats the shit out of Deepika.

Also, ash can dance like a dream be it Dola re or Crazy Kiya re..but Deepika fails in songs modern dance numbers lovely/raabta/dum maro dum

All in all Kareena>Ash>Deepika

Ash is a strange case- when she does period epics or when she plays more conventional women, she nails them like nobody's business. She was great is all SLB movies of course but also stuff like Jodha Akbar, Raincoat and Chokher Bali.

But when she does typical, modern "heroine" roles she is screechy and hammy. So it's difficult to judge but it's possible that she's a director's actress and does excellently in material she connects with and tanks when the roles are beyond her level of connection. Like Sunehri in Dhoom 2.

Originally posted by: mintyblue

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mc5mlJUZ6CI

She is overacting here also.

But she does look beautiful, no doubt about that.

Oh man, Dhoom 2 is epitome of her over-acting ... Don't even get me started 😂... are you like, checking me out and the way she runs after stealing whatever she steals from the palace... pathetic...

She is good until she opens her mouth, a la Hema Malini!

Originally posted by: ffkhan

In which angle Deepika is a better actress than Aish? Can't agree with you. Aish might not be the best among the lot but she is thousand times better than Deepika in terms of both look and acting. And I can see nothing wrong in Aish's acting or dialogue delivery in the video which you have shared here. She did a decent job in HDDCS.

Originally posted by: Anika80

time will tell who is better and who was more succesful. Deepika is still acting and active in her carrer so she's still in between the fans wars certainly Deepika is more succesful at box office than Aishwarya in general but Aishwarya is the bw star more known in western world and on screen I find Aishwarya beauty more magnetic

HDDCS is one of Aish's beginning career films and she was good since ever she started, but Deepika was cringeworthy in the beginning when she started. DP was hamming like anything in Love Aaaj Kal, the only film where I liked her performance was in Chennai Express. Even in SLB's movies DP was strictly average. Had Aish been active like Deepika always has been, then Aish could be much more successful as an actress in Bollywood. But Aish sounds like lazy types. But since the TM compared Aish's acting to DP's acting skill, so there is no point of comparing their rate of success. But as you have already started to compare so lemme tell, Aishwarya had already been very well known all over the world at the current age of Deepika and it's unlikely for Deepika to ever catch that level of success. DP's English accent is also not up to the mark.

She's bashed a lot in here too actually.

I personally find her the prettiest woman I've ever seen. She can be a good actress too.

Ash was one of the most beautiful woman in Bollywood. Even in this age she looks graceful.

Aishwarya > Deepika > Kareena

yeah I don't give a ** about geet 🤔

Originally posted by: ffkhan

HDDCS is one of Aish's beginning career films and she was good since ever she started, but Deepika was cringeworthy in the beginning when she started. DP was hamming like anything in Love Aaaj Kal, the only film where I liked her performance was in Chennai Express. Even in SLB's movies DP was strictly average. Had Aish been active like Deepika always has been, then Aish could be much more successful as an actress in Bollywood. But Aish sounds like lazy types. But since the TM compared Aish's acting to DP's acting skill, so there is no point of comparing their rate of success. But as you have already started to compare so lemme tell, Aishwarya had already been very well known all over the world at the current age of Deepika and it's unlikely for Deepika to ever catch that level of success. DP's English accent is also not up to the mark.

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

Aishwarya Rai is a directors actor, period. With the right direction, she has always done well and excelled in periodic movies. That being said, Aishwarya Rai is not a perfect actress and has her fair share of bad and good performances. Deepika as Mastani and Padmavat was the most vomit-inducing crap I've ever had the misfortune to endure. I would take Aishwarya Rai's Paro and Jodha any day over Deepika's emotional filled flaring nostrils, arched eyebrows of grand superiority, permanent case of watery conjunctivitis eyes, lip quivering with desire and her painfully seductive voice sprouting out poetic nonsense. The only reason I survived Mastani and Padmavat is because of the gloriously massive nose ring that covered half her face and kept me distracted from bashing my head against a wall. NOSE RING ZINDABAD!

Anyhow, I'd rather watch a bad performance of Deepika and Aish than watch Kareena Kapoor. She is the one that's hailed as a good actress in this forum despite the shitfest called Mein Prem Ki Dewaani Hoon, Khushi, KKKG, Yaadein, Ashoka, Mujhse Dosti Karogi, Ajnabee, Kambakh Ishk, Jeena Sirf Mere Liye blahblahblah

You are yet to see Deepika as Dhoom girl and Anarkali. The former won't have massive nose rings for sure, so I am genuinely concerned about your head. 😆