Manikarnika review thread *Final Warning Pg115*(move to next thread) - Page 82

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

108.6k

Users

126

Likes

2.8k

Frequent Posters

ImagineMe thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: pallavi25


Watched Manikarnika yesterday evening show at my local multiplex, there were 7-8 more people in the small cozy theater, with reclining seats. The audience was all older people, no youngsters or kids.

My Review: May contain Spoilers

I found the movie engrossing, well made, action packed and at least 70% historically accurate.

Kangana was magnificient in her role, she WAS Manikarnika in every way, she lived the role of the warrior queen a hundred percent!
She is undoubtedly the BEST actress of her generation! 👏
She even modulated her voice to a deeper pitch, she controlled her accent to enunciate every dialogue clearly so I had no difficulty understanding every line.

And how beautiful did she look, in that red sari, in the royal dresses, in the beginning scene when shes hunting the tiger with open tresses ...she looked STUNNING! ⭐️

I dont know what the heck people were complaining abt that other actors roles were cut 😕
Jishu, Ankita, Danny all had ample screen space although the focus was on the queen which is expected since the movie IS abt her. Im glad focus was not shifted on other side characters but remained on the queen and the main people in her life, the Raja, her son, and her loyal friends and followers, Jhalkaribai, Ghaus Khan and later Tantiya Tope

Im glad that they cut off Sonu's macho role and replaced him with Zeeshan, Sadashiv was a ratty nasty traitor and he shd not have been portrayed as a macho antagonist to glorify him.
The British generals with their cruelty, their obnoxious arrogance were bad enough pitted against the defiantly brave queen.
Manu's journey from a spirited lass, to a defiant queen to a determined widow and mother to a deadly warrior was all portrayed brilliantly by Kangana

The battle scene inside Jhansi fort, the battle scene at the end, all were heart pumping, violently realistic, some of the best battle scenes Ive watched in Hindi cinema.
Everyone in the audience was laughing at Gen Hugh Rose when he had the nightmare of the Queen appearing as Maa Kali 😆

The Mahishashuramardini chants during battle preparations and war scenes really gave me goosebumps ⭐️ Also when Kashibai sees Manu standing in front of Maa Durga in warrior pose - goosebumps

Manu was fighting like a woman possessed, cutting thru British soldiers right and left with ferocious strength and agility.
That jump on horseback from fort wall with her kid tied on her back was a bit overdone but that much suspension of disbelief is allowed.

Raja and Manu scenes were very cute, hot and romantic and showed the deep respect, love and understanding between them. I hope Kangana and Jishu pair up again because now Im hankering to see them romance again 😳😆
The baby's death, the Raja's death scenes were very emotional, poignant, Manu's reactions were 😭
The British and Sadashiv were such evil monsters, it was infuriating to see their heinous acts!
Loved the scene when Manu trapped the General in a rope and dragged him along, she shd have killed him right then and not spared that 🤬
At the end when Queen burns herself in front of the General on the battlefield rather than fall into enemy hands, u could see Hugh Rose was in awe of her bravery and sacrifice.

The VFX wasnt that good but then at that budget it couldnt have been much better.

The palatial sets, design and art decoration was apt and tastefully done, loved Raja's library and throne. Hated it when that Captain Gordon burned down the Raja's library 😡

I always like to watch historicals and especially movies which try to show the story in a linear way, without getting sidetracked or focused on royal trappings, palace sets and costumes.
Overall Manikarnika was a satisfying and paisa vasool historical movie for me, I would recommend people to watch it on big screen for the full experience.

I think it can make upto 100 crores if it sustains for 2 more weeks. Im surprised that its not getting more appreciation that it should have, as it has some deeply genuine patriotic ethos and amazing performance from Kangana, Jishu, Danny and others.

My rating: 4 out of 5 stars




🤗 So glad that you watched it finally.

I agree with your observations. I think overall the team did well to execute this topic commercially. Krish, Kangana and entire cast/crew.

I liked how Zeeshan portrayed it. Sonu is a good actor too just didn't need that body building opening. 😛

I still can't get over the end credits. Was so emotional seeing those sketches. 😭


pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: ImagineMe


🤗 So glad that you watched it finally.

I agree with your observations. I think overall the team did well to execute this topic commercially. Krish, Kangana and entire cast/crew.

I liked how Zeeshan portrayed it. Sonu is a good actor too just didn't need that body building opening. 😛

I still can't get over the end credits. Was so emotional seeing those sketches. 😭



Krish did a good job, Im not sure how much portions Kangana directed but whatever it is, the movie is well directed and editing is also quite good.
Sonu would have made Sadashiv's character more impressive which would not go with the narrative, since that guy was a ratty traitor to his motherland, always hated those types in history, the ones who sold the motherland for greed and power 🤢
Yeah end credits were moving. Bachchan's voiceover in the beginning was good as always.
briahna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
BoxOfficeIndia
Manikarnika steady hold, no drop from Monday , target 90cr
👍🏼

https://boxofficeindia.com/report-details.php?articleid=4695
Edited by briahna - 6 years ago
ImagineMe thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: briahna

BoxOfficeIndia
Manikarnika steady hold, no drop from Monday , target 90cr
👍🏼

https://boxofficeindia.com/report-details.php?articleid=4695



Boond boond jo ghhat bharey 😆
AllThatCritique thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
Just got out. The movie was okay bordering good. I wasn't overtly moved by the performances per se but few scenes are well done.

I think Rajaji's death and the scene leading upto it where she is forced to fight beautifully done. Their helplessness was striking. Jisshu and Kangana nailed that scene. The various invocations of goddesses to put Manikarnika in light was striking too. The British were obnoxious enough for me to want to punch them so that's a win lol. They properly riled me up when they whipped and slapped and assaulted Jalkari Bai. And the way I laughed when Sadashiv told the British officers that they cared about him more than his own family. LMAOO. The worst kind of traitor. All the three battles or war scenes are well done. The CGI keeps you wanting a lil bit but that's a minute detail. Her diction is still kinda faulty but her acting makes up for it. The last scene with Bharat playing in the bg was fantastic. Overall the screenplay the dialogues everything is okayish but the acting is top notch. I wish the supporting cast had more to do to bring everything together. Those characters never stayed enough to make any impact.


PS : Really loved that one scene where she goes out wearing that colored saree just after Raja dies. That walk upto the throne. Powerful. Also contrary to most reviews I saw here I actually liked the first half. The circumstances leading upto to her taking charge wasnt boring for me at all.


Anyway, it has enough mettle to work atleast a hit tag. Deserves that atleast.
Edited by AllThatCritique - 6 years ago
EXOL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Love Couple India Season 2 Thumbnail + 7

Love Legion

Posted: 6 years ago
@allthatcritique...even I liked the first half..usually when u go for such movies..u expect more warfare etc..but here we could see glimpes for her life before the marriage . also all her scenes with king was really endearing to watch.
and the scene u mentioned ..the one after king dies..that was simply superb..especially the way she gets up from that bath ceremony and walks away..so well done 👏

also some of the frames like rani sitting with her child on that throne was ethereal... She looked so majestic..such perfect shots I must say..

It indeed deserves appreciation keeping all behind the stage issues aside..
--Pro.vo.King-- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: 4thPrincoholic


I never said that! ... Satellite and music rights help producers recover budget ... so they can afford to sell a movie for less to distributors! ...

While BO verdict is determined mainly based on "Distribution costs" by trade .. and may be other factors/formula we aren't aware of!.. But It isn't based on budget fosho! [that's the point I was refuting initially]! ... If you don't think so, it's fine too! ... I'll go by BOI and Taran when they tabulate the final result! ...

[ETA .. Attaching the link here for Housefull 3 .. just found... It was used as an example by Cougar! ... https://boxofficeindia.com/movie.php?movieid=3296 ... so you see budget here is 97cr .. BO return 107 cr ... Only 10cr more and it got a HIT tag! ...

https://boxofficeindia.com/movie.php?movieid=3550 ... For Tubelight ... Budget 135cr .. BO return 114cr .. yet got "below average" not "flop"! Hence, Verdicts are determined by "distribution cost" than "budget"!

For Manikarnika ... movie may not be declared a hit ... but it has a chance to do average business according to trade since it's distribution cost is around 60 to 65cr! .. so it all depends on how the movie fares this week! ...
FYI: BOI lists budget of 99cr for Manikarnika


I hope you were serious about this "discussion" since I have gone out and dug out some links from BOI] ... Rest if you still think otherwise, it's your prerogative! ...


@ Bold .. Whaat ? .. Oh .. OK .. Let's agree to disagree in that case .. 😆

@ Blue ... Distribution cost "than" budget ? .. So budget is "also" a contributing factor then ? .. So, then agree to agree ? .. 😆


If we go by your logic of "not determined by budget fosho" , then a movie doesn't need to recover its budget to get a "hit" status ( and I am not talking about average or below average status ) .. How many movies which failed to recover its budget in its domestic theatrical run have been declared a "hit"so far ? ..
--Pro.vo.King-- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: 4thPrincoholic

@Provoking ... Aigoo Why? .. She's looking great in the poster! ...Like a Queen! ... 😎


Well .. To me it looked like joke given the sad/less than enthusiastic expression on Kangu's face & the declaration of crossing 100 Crs worldwide .. It looked as though Kangu knows it is pathetic & she isn't happy with the results, yet made to pose for such a ridiculous achievement .. 😆


I don't get it , they could have used any of her kickass stills from the movie which would have looked better ..
Stargazing72 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: tina59

Kangana Ranaut's Manikarnika Enters The Profit Zone, Races Past 115 Crores Against A Budget Of 105 Crore

popdiaries
Pop Diaries5 February 2019
manikarnika kangana ranaut
More

Multiple National Award Winning Actress Kangana Ranaut has added a new feather to her cap by starting the year 2019 with her Directorial Debut, the magnum opus Manikarnika which broke several box office records and is on its way to becoming a milestone in Indian Cinema. In its second week itself it has registered itself in the 100 crore club.

Zee Studio's and Kamal Jain's Manikarnika The Queen Of Jhansi is successfully running at the box office worldwide with a collection of Rs. 115 Crore worldwide at the end of its second week. The film collected 94 Crores gross in India by the end of its second week and crossed 2.85 Million USD in the overseas market. The film was released in more than 3000 screens all over India and over 700 screens overseas.

Made in the Budget of 105 Crores ( 80 Cr Production and 25 Crores Print & Advertising) , Manikarnika was already in Profits even before its release. The digital distribution rights for the film were acquired by Amazon Prime Video for 40 crore and the satellite rights were purchased at 25 crore. The distribution rights for theater screening were purchased at 65 crore. The movie opened with 8.75 crore in domestic market. On its second day,which coincided with Republic Day holiday, the film collected 18.10 crore. On its third day the movie remained steady and collected 15.70 crore, taking its opening weekend domestic collection to 42.55 crore, making it the highest weekend collection for a female-led movie.

Shariq Patel, CEO of Zee Studios said that they are humbled with the overwhelming response for the film Manikarnika The Queen Of Jhansi from all around the world. Vibha Chopra, Head at Zee Studios International mentioned that the film has done really well in UAE, USA and Australia market and continues to hold strong. The film has resonated well with all age group people around the world.

Kangana Ranaut's Manikarnika is a biopic on Rani Lakshmibai and is running strong in Theatres crossing 115 cr Worldwide in just 12 days with a strong word of mouth and audience has been raving about her performance both as an actor as well as a Director.


This is so misleading its unreal. Worldwide figures are not taken into account for the success tag.It's just the hindi language numbers which interestingly noone is giving .

The budget is over100crs and must be recovered before a verdict is given . This film is a lesson on how to manipulate through the media and should be learnt by every star . There wouldn't be a flop in the history of cinema.
After cheating so many others she is now on a lying rampage . And then wonders why the industry is silent . They are staring in shock at the level of lying thats going on
--Pro.vo.King-- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
Can someone tell me why the f**k is this darling loosing her sleep over Kangana haters ?

She is helluva obsessed with us .. 😆

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 6 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/calls-for-ban-on-abir-gulaal-intensify-amid-pahalgam-attack-outrage_221151

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/karisma-kapoors-kids-move-delhi-hc-demanding-share-in-their-late-father-sunjay-kapurs-assets_226935

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 6 months ago

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/virat-kohli-and-anushka-sharma-move-to-london-as-they-cant-enjoy-their-success-here_221339

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Homebound review and box office...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Do you wanna partner review thread- Tamanna Diana Nakuul...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".