Things taken into consideration:
- Taking 8 plus rated movies and 5000 plus views. (in most cases, when a filmography couldn't complete top 4 at-least with 8 or the said votes, I had to go lower).
- In-case of more popular titles and Khan movies the number of votes jump up to 10 and 15 thousand (to negate a lot of bogus zeros and tens).
- Lesser known titles with low votes have been allowed. Less chance of stupid 10's or 0's.
Aamir Khan;
PK - 8.4; 3 Idiots - 8.5; Andaaz Apna Apna - 8.8; Taree Zameen Par - 8.5; Rang De Basanti - 8.4; Dil Cahata Hai - 8.2; Lagaan - 8.2, JJWS - 8.3.
All the movies have a very huge percentage of votes as well. Only AAA and DCH (40,000) are below 50,000 votes. Which comes of as a surprise; not concrete but surely an indication that Aamir enjoys the most audience worldwide (now audiences can people who watch it on the net or DVD's)
By far the clear winner. 3 movies in IMDB top 250 (Lagaan, TZP and 3 Idiots)👏👏. RDB and PK were there for a while too and will be back soon after a couple thousand more votes (when bogus zero's and tens are filtered out).
Tabu;
Hera Pheri - 8.5, Haider 8.4, Maqbool - 8.3, Life of Pi - 8.0.
👏👏. Absolutely Terrific. I have said it before, to me she is one of the best actress in the world today.
Shahrukh Khan;
CDI - 8.4 , Swades - 8.3 , DDLJ - 8.3, Khabi Haan Khabi Na (Lesser known little hence included despite low votes)- 8.3, Kaal Ho Na Ho - 8.1, Dar - 8.0, My Name is Khan- 8.0(How??).
Top three are really solid movies. Apart from that, not much.
Akshay Kumar;
Hera Pheri - 8.5, OMG - 8.2, Special 26 - 8.0 , Baby - 8.3.
Again top three are really solid.
Ajay Devgn;
Omkara - 8.2, Company - 8.1, Legneds of Bhagat Singh - 8.1, Ghanjaal - 7.9.
Farhan Akhtar;
BMB - 8.4; ZNMD - 8.1; Rock On - 8.0.
Surprising and I think Wazir will join the list too. A pretty good outing overall and beats a lot of big names.
Salman Khan;
Andaz Apna Apna - 8.8; Khamoshi - 7.5 ; MPK and HAHK at 7.6, HDDCS - 7.6.
Just a solitary movie over 8. No surprises really. Majority of his filmography is full of mediocre movies.
Ranbir Kapoor,
Barfi - 8.2 , Rocket Singh - 7.5, Rockstar - 7.6, WUS -7.6.
Hrithik Roshan;
ZNMD - 8.1, Lakshya -7.9, JA - 7.6, Guzaarish - 7.5.
If you look at it Hrithik hasn't really done that many good movies. Pretty mediocre if you ask me, considering he has been in the industry for 15 years.
I haven't listed everybody, so feel free to add to the list. If you feel that I have missed somebody that deserves to be in the the list, please post his top 5 and I will slot him in the OP.
4