How SRK's response differed from Salman's on Preity Zinta case Read

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

chimchimcher-ee

@chimchimcher-ee

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: blue-ice

Of course ...SRK should have suffered huge losses...but should have carried on with Aishwarya who left with Salman that day leaving the shooting in between...and it was not as if he threw her out because it happened one time...The shooting was being disrupted almost every day...What did people expect Shahrukh to do at that time...Salman-Aish were a couple...

Charity. 😒

Quote

959877

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#32

Another SRK excuse to flirt with Preity.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

blue-ice.

@blue-ice.

Achiever

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: chimchimcher-ee

My moral support comment was not for Preity; it was for Aish. & my main point was not about moral support... main point was SRK fired someone who was not at fault. Being apathetic is something else, & being cruel is something else. I found dropping Aish from CC cruel.

When a movie is made there is not just the producers ...but a lot of people whose efforts and money is at stake...it was not SRK's personal thing...think of it as the work in the office getting disrupted everyday...what is anyone supposed to do...there were news of SRK trying to sort things out...trying to calm down Salman...but at the end of the day it was between Aish and Salman...and she was leaving the shootings and going away with him...I don't understand why SRK should take the blame for throwing her out

Quote

Rida Fareed

@qazplm

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: blue-ice

When a movie is made there is not just the producers ...but a lot of people whose efforts and money is at stake...it was not SRK's personal thing...think of it as the work in the office getting disrupted everyday...what is anyone supposed to do...there were news of SRK trying to sort things out...trying to calm down Salman...but at the end of the day it was between Aish and Salman...and she was leaving the shootings and going away with him...I don't understand why SRK should take the blame for throwing her out

And SRK has talked about this incident quite a few times. He was the only one who was sticking up for Ash at that time. But the fact that Ash wasn't showing up to the shoots herself or not stopping Salman's violent visits was not helping in any way. He had two other producers with him who had as much right to make the decisions as him. And in the end, they did. He had to take the blame and Ash's wrath for quite some years.

I'll make it clear. I still feel what he did was wrong. He should have fought harder. And Ash did not deserve to be thrown out of that film. But over the years, with other details coming in, I also understand that SRK TRIED to do something atleast. He broke up quite a few fights between Salman and Ash himself. But he wasn't supposed to be handling their mess during that film. Also, he has apologized to her like a million times both publicly and personally. He has clarified that he was completely at fault. If a man is willing to admit his mistake and ask for forgiveness, then I'm good with it. Even Ash has commented many a times how Gauri and SRK have apologized for that incident.

And the fact that Ash forgave him, which she has not for Salman, Vivek or even Rani, says a lot about what might have happened on that set.

Quote

Koiza

@-koiza-

Sparkler

Posted: 11 years ago

#35

I think ash deserved to be kicked out of CC- rightly so..srk did nothing wrong. There is a thing called professionalism and ash wasnt being one by leaving the set every other day. Also she was such a big star ..how tough it is to get more security rather than leaving the sets and dealing with it yourself...there are no free lunches in the world..so many spot boys..crew every one was suffering coz of that..not srk alone

Quote

mnmj

@mnmj

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

#36

i agree, it was completely wrong of shahrukh to have dropped out aishwarya from chalte chalte...very unprofessional

Quote

959877

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: mnmj
i agree, it was completely wrong of shahrukh to have dropped out aishwarya from chalte chalte...very unprofessional

I agree. Very SRK.

Quote

Cutiepie_Rani

@Cutiepie_Rani

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#38

I don't see anything wrong in Shahrukh's reply. It is a personal matter and it's much better to talk to Preity in person rather than commenting about it to the media.

As far as Salman's response goes...He was there for his film. Not to discuss personal issues. Though his response came out a bit harsh or more like a slap in the face to Preity.

But it is a personal matter. And if anyone wants to lend Preity some moral support they don't need the media or social networking sites to do so. They can meet her personally and talk to her.

Quote

-stigma-

@-stigma-

Navigator

Posted: 11 years ago

#39

And What we really expect them to say ?!

To support Preity just because she is a friend?

without knowing what really happened? and before the law says it words?

Quote

niksidfan

@niksidfan

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 11 years ago

#40

sorry , why srk is being blamed for removing ash...?

not onyl him but many oder people were associated with the film...

salman and ash's relation was going thorugh lots of trouble at dat time and ash was nt being proffesional in a way ...and for dat the whole unit cant suffer..

i m sure SRK didnt take the decision 'coz of that dat single day ..but the problem has been there from before and dat day was the final nail in the coffin.

and moreover removing a heroine is never an easy decision whn half the film has been shot...