My review
I thought the movie was ok, imtiaz made the movie well however the story did not wow me.
A r rahmans music went very well with the story, it added the right emotion to the scenes
The cinematography was very nice and visually they did a good job, however there were moments in the movie where I just kept asking myself 'ok this is sudden'
Like how a girl like veera falls in love with a guy like mahabir, I mean he kidnapped her, I know he isn't a totally bad person but even with the bad experience veera went through in her childhood it still didn't make sense to me that she was leave everything to set up house with him.
Also in the scene with her outburst about her uncle, her family doesn't care about her at all that when she decides to leave they let her? There was no confrontation with the uncle, no fighting for their daughter to stay?
I don't know the story didn't really flow as well as I hoped it wud.
The travelling scenes were also too long and I agree with faridoon that you need to give the film patience to watch it.
Alia did well, baring in mind its only her second movie, she has improved alot, however there is still stuff she can improve on
Randeep played his character very well, the quiet brooding guy with secrets.
For me it's a one time watch, a film with good performances but not enough story to keep me completely interested.
Edited by zarak65 - 11 years ago
65