Madras Cafe Reviews & Box-office Collections - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

218

Views

21.9k

Users

45

Likes

508

Frequent Posters

chimchimcher-ee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#31

Faridoon Shahryar @iFaridoon 54m

Shoojit Sirkar should be proud of having made a gritty objective umbiased film with high technical finesse.Do watch Madras Caf... !


Faridoon Shahryar @iFaridoon 57m

John Abraham rises in stature as Actor-filmmaker with Madras Caf.The belief in good straight intriguing storytelling is praiseworthy...


Mihir Fadnavis @mihirfadnavis 1h

Madras Cafe is not a terrible film by any stretch. Shoojit is a talented guy. Really wish it had a better, non hammy non wooden cast.
SudhaSangeet thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#32
Twitter is mess...kitna tweet karte hai...all lost therehehe...

Good night everyone...keep posting tweets/reviews. Tomorrow going to watch movie ...Yayyy...
pari_roxx thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#33
Shoojit Sircar's talent finally getting recognised.
Nargis and John getting good reviews . Wow.
Hope to catch the flick soon
chimchimcher-ee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#34

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Madras Cafe - Not a Review

I was too lazy to write a whole review, so here€™s the snack version:

* Madras Caf is not a terrible movie by any stretch. Shoojit Sircar is a talented filmmaker. The plot is very, very intriguing but Shoojit€™s direction is clearly the highlight of the film.

* How often do you see a mainstream Bollywood Hindi movie that has no songs? Shoojit and producer John Abraham have gigantic balls, and full credit to them for making such an honest effort.

* 99.99% of the thrillers, especially the €˜political€™ or €˜military€™ ones made in India are either tacky, or jarringly commercialized or just plain turds. Madras Caf is not f**king bullshit like Tango Charlie . This is a genuinely slick, decently put together thriller, almost as good as the first half of D Day.

* This isn€™t the Zero Dark Thirty of India, and expecting anything even remotely close to that film€™s quality is stupid. If anything the film is a wannabe Blood Diamond. Shoojit borrows heavily from Blood Diamond €" the style, the camera angles, the blocking, the action scenes, the editing, the music, it€™s all reminiscent of that movie. Except instead of an emotional Leo DiCaprio there€™s an Oak tree in the lead role.

* The action scenes are staged well. There is a lot of violence, but it€™s not sensationalist or gratuitous. And the military tactics are (passably) well done. The CGI and special effects are also not shitty . That€™s rare in Hindi cinema. That said, keep your kids at home.

* While it€™s not a bad film, it isn€™t an Oscar winner. It stumbles a lot of times as the narrative swings from taut to gripping to cringe inducing. It€™s as if Shoojit vacillated between sticking to a non-commercialized gritty thriller and often gave in to the masala style to cater to the €˜mainstream junta€™.

* It€™s also over-edited. Some of the important plot points just race past, and the film doesn€™t stop to focus on them. It€™s a little unfortunate but given the running time I am not sure slowing it down further would€™ve helped the film.

* It is endlessly frustrating to watch John Abraham in the lead role because someone more talented would€™ve really elevated the film to a higher order of cinema. He tries very hard, but his facial muscles just don't budge. Clearly John is a better producer than an actor.

* The rest of the cast isn€™t any better either. Everyone from Nargis Fakhri to Siddharth Basu are hilariously bad. There is enough ham in this film to feed Pepperoni Pizza to Versova for a month. Really wish the film had a better cast.

* I do not know how factually accurate the film is. I am not an expert on LTTE and Sri Lanka. I am only acquainted with the surface level facts. And I am too lazy right now to research the topic. But I can tell you that the politics shown in the film is Chetan Bhagat level. So don€™t expect much. The procedural action anyway glosses over the police work, and it€™s sure as hell better than the likes of A Wednesday and the misbegotten Special Chabbis. And you can make good films without being factually 100% accurate.

* In any case none of these shortcomings mean that you should avoid this film. Watch it. Ignore the ham acting. Ignore John€™s military beard. Occupy yourselves with something else every time Nargis Fakhri comes on screen - count prime numbers, take a Komal Nahta style loo break, whatever. But watch the film. It€™s interesting.

* As for the MDMK outraging over the film portraying the LTTE in €˜bad light€™, I offer them the following tweet by my pal Over Rated.
They assassinated a former pm & committed countless atrocities, but appearing in a John Abraham movie was really bad for LTTE's reputation.
€" Overrated Outcast (@over_rated) August 22, 2013
Posted by ElmerFuddnavis
chimchimcher-ee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#35
Mihir Fadnavis @mihirfadnavis 33m

Those too lazy to even read reviews, yes, Madras Cafe is a good film. Surprisingly decent. So watch it. http://mihirfadnavis.blogspot.in/2013/08/madras-cafe-not-review.html
tomnjerry2 thumbnail
IPL 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail IPL 2023 Match Winner Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 11 years ago
#36
Devansh Patel @PatelDevansh

Saw #MadrasCafe and have to say COSTA is way more delicious and frothy.

Is the movie set in the past ? Madras is no more Madras... Chennai Caf could hav been it is !!!😆
tomnjerry2 thumbnail
IPL 2024 Match Winner Thumbnail IPL 2023 Match Winner Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 11 years ago
#37
Kamaal R Khan - KRK@kamaalrkhan

There is nothing in the film #MadrasCafe which is objectionable so I am sure tat all the controversy is by makers only but still can't work.

Suchitra@suchitrak

Just back from watching #MadrasCafe, SUPERB film loved it. The best in the genre to come out of India.Now lets hope its gets its due at BO

DB_reloaded thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#38
i hv my doubts on john as a actor he hv to prove he can pull of such a project with his acting skills and star power!!!
870349 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#39
Flop



Too bad guy who made vicky donor has such promise 😳
MR.KooL thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#40

Madras Cafe Review

John Abraham And Nargis Fakhri in Madras Cafe Poster

Rating: 4/5 stars (Four Stars)

Star cast: John Abraham, Nargis Fakhri and Siddhartha Basu

Director: Shoojit Sircar

What€™s Good: An engrossing monologue which excavates one of India€™s most overbearing conspiracies left back in the dusty pages of history.

What€™s Bad: There is no commercialism, which has been smartly avoided so as to not dilute the subject matter. Music, background score has been kept limited to create any unwanted flavor to the drama than the story already contains. They are not really negatives just slightly deterring for the general public.

Loo break: None

Watch or Not?: Shoojit Sircar and John Abraham have teamed up again to come up with one of India€™s most bold and matured political thrillers! Designed with a deep rooted sense of urgency, the film builds an overwhelming tale around the darkest phase of the Lankan Civil War that marshal to conclude with a rushing end which we are all familiar with. In between the flashbacks and conspiracies, Madras Caf is a film with a gritty, convincing and engrossing plot that will revel in its ability to leave you with an uneasy and helpless feeling!

User Rating:

2 Votes

Vikram Singh is deployed on a covert oppression to Jaffna. After India and Sri Lanka signed the peace accord in the mid 1980s, India took it as their mission to help its neighbors relieve themselves from the ethnic strife between the Sinhalese and the Tamils. Hatching a plot to bring down Anna, a popular Tamil leader in the zone, Vikram begins with trying to team up with Anna€™s opponents in the beginning.

Falling prey to a leak, he loses his first shot with Anna and gets kidnapped by his forces! However, now hell bent on getting Anna to bow down, he teams with Anna€™s own men and manages to ambush his army. However, Anna manages to survive and returns even more powerful by eradicating Indian forces off Jaffna and Lanka.

Plotting ways to kill the former Indian Prime Minister fearing that he will return to power, the film is a tussle between the war makers to safeguard their interests! And for Vikram, it is the story about how India lost its Prime Minister in an assassination which the nation has still not forgotten!

John Abraham in Madras Cafe Stills

Madras Cafe Review: Script Analysis

Recreated out of real life instances, Sircar doesn€™t cheat us at any level. His story is a dramatized version of real life instances, with the parallels so apparent that they aren€™t very difficult to decipher. There are no false jingoistic traps laid or judgment calls commanded. Luckily for the good of its audiences, the film invokes a strong sense of realism largely as the director doesn€™t waste time in creating ornate sham of filmi-ness. The script itself gives very few problems to hang around as it envelopes a rather clear cut story which is a coalescence of history and drama which is a quasi fictional account of India-Lanka Peace Accord which culminates into the death of Rajiv Gandhi.

Writers Somnath Dey and Subhendu Bhattacharya dynamically build a piquant movie which has a stirring premise. Folding in well the background of ethnic strife in Sri Lanka, the film carefully holds its ground with an antagonist whose motives are beyond power. The film€™s forte is how it tells such a volatile story with utmost sensitivity without taking sides. It is pro human and definitely not anti any group, culture or leader.

The unlikely twists and pauses build consistently the right aura and mood of the film. Keeping it somber and dull, the film€™s pace is rightly packed with thrills. In no part of the film is there a single dull moment which sags or falls loose. It has no allegations or derogatory remarks but a simplistic narration of the course of events. The film€™s trajectories don€™t foster any shade of righteousness and strictly refrains from evoking any wrong sentiment.

The drama factor doesn€™t take fancy to over the top melodrama thankfully; its pace doesn€™t slack or the momentum of its happenings doesn€™t veer away. Our hero is a faltering human who doesn€™t end up saving his wife or the life of the Prime Minister who is slayed eventually. It is this realistic approach that popular cinema misses and Shoojit Sircar, along with his writers, whose toiling at assembling the film€™s skeletal groundwork shows in terms of the film€™s clarity, have put up a bravura show!

Madras Cafe Review: Star Performances

John Abraham as Vikram Singh topples all his previous performances. He isn€™t a very flattering actor but his clever choice of role and wicked acting surely shows a remarkable improvement. He isn€™t the John who couldn€™t emote. He is the John who isn€™t afraid to take up challenging roles and carry them out gracefully.

Nargis Fakhri with her British accent is confident. She may not be a show stealer but does her bit with lan retaining the correct persona for it.

Siddhartha Basu is quite a natural as he smoothly slips in the role of R.D. His intelligence shows in his eyes, and he manages to command respect in his character! Never stepping a wrong stone, the man should have taken up acting long back!

The supporting actors are all impressive but in the end, this film is more about its intent and plot than about its actors!

Madras Cafe Review: Direction, Editing and Music

Shoojit Sircar is back after a long hiatus since Vicky Donor. He strings into the same plot, the emotional wreckage and physical devastation of war to emphatically put forth the futility of it all. In the climax, Shoojit concludes with, €œOne man€™s revolutionary is another one€™s villain!€ followed by a few stellar lines of Tagore! Truly, in the clashes of mindsets the only people who suffer are commoners who seek only peace and happiness from their lives.

As Lankan leader Anna strives to garner power and Indian Government attempts to achieve their political motive of maintaining monopoly in the subcontinent by maintaining friendly relations with Lanka to obtain access into the South East Asia, Sircar wonderfully relates the story of anarchy, bloodshed and meaningless war which continued for 27 long years killing thousands. In the end, he does have a potent message about the nugatory nightmare of the wrath of war! Shoojit intelligently executes a crisply written story which is executed breathtakingly. The editing of the film is quite well done, as the docu-drama style stir up any boredom. Shantanu Moitra€™s music is pristine and haunting as the climax wraps up with Papon crooning Maula Re.

Madras Cafe Review: The Last Word

Madras Caf is a hypnotically created masterpiece which thrives in the freshness of its conception. Using history with drama to build a persuasive tapestry of enthralling action, energetic plot and skillful narration of the grim phase of Lankan War, Shoojit Sircar astonishes with this fascinating docu style dramatic movie. I am going flatly with a 4/5 this triumphed work of passionate and compelling cinema.

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

24 days ago

Metro In Dino - Reviews And Box Office

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/metro-in-dino-review-its-a-musical-love-letter-to-the-lost-the-lonely-and-the-longing_224199

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/metro-in-dino-review-its-a-musical-love-letter-to-the-lost-the-lonely-and-the-longing_224199
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

23 days ago

Reviews - The Hunt - Rajiv Gandhi Assassination

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/the-hunt-rajiv-gandhi-assassination-case-review-focused-fearless-retelling-of-the-famous-political-k_224259

https://www.indiaforums.com/article/the-hunt-rajiv-gandhi-assassination-case-review-focused-fearless-retelling-of-the-famous-political-k_224259
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Heads of State reviews (Priyanka Chopra) Heads of State reviews (Priyanka Chopra)

Heads of State reviews (Priyanka Chopra)

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Sitaare Zameen Par reviews & box office- success party

Sitaare zameen par reviews and box office Review below https://www.instagram.com/reel/DKtb65Hx9tE/?igsh=bmdvamVka3B2MW16 Member reviews Page 23...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".