THE DIRTY PICTURE: All Reviews Here (Index Page 1) - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

450

Views

57.2k

Users

84

Likes

948

Frequent Posters

-Mmmmm- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
PritishNandy Pritish Nandy
Vidya Balan in Kahaani poster rocks. Vidya Balan in The Dirty Picture rocks. Vidya Balan rocks. Period.
ladasingh Lada Guruden Singh
#VidyaBalan rocks it in #TheDirtyPicture. The best hands down we have when it comes to versatility. Congrats to the team!
sweeetstarr1 Shimmery Saleha ?
THE DIRTY PICTURE is the bestestestestest Movie of 2011 ! Whole DUBAI is going mad about the movie ! Full on paisa vasool
Purba_Ray Purba Ray
The only thing dirty about Dirty Picture is Tusshar Kapoor!
jhunjhunwala Rakesh Jhunjhunwala
HAHAHAH! RT @TheUnRealTimes: @jhunjhunwala Hehe.. And the dirty in the 'dirty picture' is actually emraan hashmi
rameshsrivats Ramesh Srivats
Must see The Dirty Picture. Silk Smitha. Nylex Nalini. Polyester Padmini. They are the ones who formed the er... fabric of our society.
ShaliniSharma_ Shalini Sharma
Vidya Balan is going to win all the awards this year for #TheDirtyPicture
atulkasbekar atul kasbekar
Advance reports seem to indicate that #TheDirtyPicture is a potential game changer...Oo la la to that
amul_mohan Amul Mohan
#TheDirtyPicture has some killer lines, that Oh La La song is a definite highlight... Emraan and even Tusshar are good in it.
amul_mohan Amul Mohan
Also the awards people should hand over the best actress trophy to VidyaBalan right now only. #justsaying#TheDirtyPicture
Harneetsin Harneet Singh
Heartening to see writer Rajat Arora's name displayed prominently on all promos, posters of #TheDirtyPicture. That's how it ought to be done
keeratgrewal Keerat Grewal
#TheDirtyPicture has been seen. Can I please get my hands on the script? I need to memorize at least 6 to 7 of those punchlines! :)
Edited by -Maddy- - 13 years ago
qwww thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: Heat

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nF7rm4zOsKk[/YOUTUBE]

Someone should tell this man that reviewing a movie does not mean giving out the entire story of the movie. He basically gave away the entire plot including how Silk dies 😡
401366 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago

Originally posted by: -Maddy-

Purba_Ray Purba Ray
The only thing dirty about Dirty Picture is Tusshar Kapoor!
rameshsrivats Ramesh Srivats
Must see The Dirty Picture. Silk Smitha. Nylex Nalini. Polyester Padmini. They are the ones who formed the er... fabric of our society



LMAO 🤣
Polyester Padmini! 😆

Edited by bamboocopter - 13 years ago
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago

The Dirty Picture review: A touch of raw Silk

  • Dec 01, 2011
  • By Khalid Mohamed
Genre:
Drama
Directed by:
Milan Luthria
Movie Cast:
Vidya Balan, Naseeruddin Shah, Emraan Hashmi

Good

  • Ms Balan rocks big time.

Bad

  • Dialogue by Rajat Aroraa is overwritten.

All's well. Or is it? At a key junction of an award function, she throws caution to the winds. A tinny trophy in her hand, the actress lambasts the double-triple-quadruple standards of the show business bosses. They make her dance in cleavage-popping outfits but are scared to admit that they get their socks off salivating over the strip tease. Ditto the audience, which throws coins at her screen cabarets but anoints her a s**t. Wow.

She says it the way it is. Director Milan Luthria's The Dirty Picture, is remarkable for creating a woman of spunk who's had it with assorted skunks. Danger ahead: will she get away with her poison darts in an industry which believes it as sweet as strawberry tarts? Obviously, 'inspired' by the real life story of Silk Smitha, the Chennai-domiciled sex symbol - who is said to have committed suicide at the age of 35 in 1996 - here's an audacious, auto-critical take on the unchecked exploitation of women in Cinemapuram. Presumably Chennai is the backdrop, but the tongue-lashing sex siren could belong to Bolly, Tolly or Hollywood. The story could be true of Marilyn Monroe or Jean Harlow, adored by the world, and yet compelled to go over the brink. Just think.

Luthria's triumph is in creating a woman who's steel strong, hypocritically regarded as morally wrong. Elements from the life of Silk Smitha have been used as clay to mould the character. Plus there are recognisable prototypes of the vulturous men who must have preyed upon her flesh. Literally. Doubtlessly, the fictionalised screenplay is bold but here comes the catch: it is also ridden with cliches, vulgarity and dialogue which is so bombastic that every second sentence is a punch-line, robbing the narrative of its reality bytes. Verbosity abounds.

Gratifyingly, the outburst on the award function stage, just before the intermission, at long last cuts to the chase. Before that there's been a torrent of the trials and tribulations of the impoverished Reshma aka Silk (Vidya Balan), sleeping her way to stardom. An ageing hero (Naseeruddin Shah) treats her like a sex object, his cowardly writer brother (Tusshar, terribly miscast) breaks into cartwheels on the prospect of losing his virginity. And a gossip queen (Anju Mahendru, terrific) does this foxy number of admiring Silk's guts and yet savaging her in print. Ho-hum, such is life dearies.

Critics and psst psst reporters are disparaged, naturally, the queen bee obviously modelled after yesteryear's legendary Devyani Chaubal. Luthria, at no point, considers the fact that she could have been exploited by the top film stars, who desperately crave publicity but expect the media to overlook their lapses. Chamchagiri anyone? Be that as it may, post-intermission, the dramaturgy becomes intense, replete with twists and turns. So far, you've been wondering why on earth sequenes have been punctuated with the sonorous voice-over of an artsy-fartsy film director (Emraan Hashmi). Frustrated because of his flops, he's a pesky mosquito till you understand why. Aha, he has been on a denial mode about admiring the rags-to-Scotch-swilling Silk.

As her descent into an alchohol haze begins, his attraction mounts, culminating in a belated, doomed love story.

Suffice it to say that the film's trump card is the supportive stand taken for a woman who knows what she wants and will get it, never mind the rude shocks ahead. She is shown as incapable of love, because she has never received that four-letter-word from anyone, including her mother who shuts the door on her when she needs emotional sustenance.

Vignettes showing Silk's no-holds-barred sensual display before film crews, retro-recreations of kitschy dance numbers and a fiercely competitive showdown with the new sex kitten on the block, are extremely well conceived and directed.

On the yuck side, the dialogue by Rajat Aroraa (he did Once Upon a Time with Luthria) is overwritten and relentlessly titillating. Some bacterial germs: "You like to play on Holi but your pichkari has no dum", "You will untie everyone's lungi", "The chicken is so spicily marinated that the tandoor is blazing hot, "I want some tuning at nights with you, not once but 500 times." Words like khujli, ghagra, pant, nasbandi are used, reviving the Kadar Khan double entendre era. Yipes.

On the techfront, the production design is sophisticated embellished by Bobby Singh's cinematography. The music score is worth a toe tap.

Of the cast, Naseeruddin Shah is bankably first-rate, often chivalrously standing back for the leading lady , the sign of a secure actor. Emraan Hashmi is correctly restrained.

Above all, the enterprise belong to Vidya Balan. She's extraordinary: gutsy, consistently in character and unafraid of exposing her darker side. Here's the kind of complex performance which you haven't evidenced in years and years. This award-winning act bookended by her contrasting portrayal in No One Killed Jessica, reaffirms her as the finest artiste on the scene today. No contest!

You may have some issues with The Dirty Picture. Never mind because Ms Balan rocks big time. Cheers.

you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
Printed from

The Dirty Picture

Nikhat Kazmi, TNN, Dec 1, 2011, 09.04PM IST
The Dirty Picture More Pics
Critic's Rating:
Cast: Vidya Balan, Naseeruddin Shah, Emraan Hashmi, Tusshar Kapoor
Direction: Milan Luthria
Genre: Drama
Duration: 2 hours 20 minutes
Avg Readers Rating:
More from The Dirty Picture
Trailer
Ooh La La
Ishq Sufiyana
Twinkle Twinkle
Nakka Mukka
Story: Reshma ( Vidya Balan), a small town girl with dreams of stardom in her eyes, sets out for Chennai, with nothing but her passion to stir her on. After the usual period of struggle and rejections, she gets her break as an item girl who's got the most sensuous moves in town. It doesn't take her long to storm the box office as Silk, the sex symbol who's driving a whole generation crazy with her oomph. The industry too can't stay immune to her earthy charms and her list of worshipers -- and lovers -- keeps multiplying, until it's downhill time. Will simpleton Silk be able to survive the rigours of a heartless work place that discards faster than it accepts?

Movie Review: All she had was her well endowed body, her in-your-face sexuality, her seductive moves and her rock hard confidence to carry her through a world that was more than willing to exploit a lone woman, seeking sustenance in a man's world. That was enough to transform Reshma into Silk, a storm that refused to be quelled by anything or anybody. Determined to take on the industry single-handedly and carve a niche for herself as a sex symbol in a hypocritical world, Silk was the steroid shot that sent the world in a tizzy. Journalists and holier-than-thou art film makers like Abraham (Emraan Hashmi), hysterical women's groups and the ubiquitous moral police branded her the scum of the earth. But her legion fans were ready to lay their lives for her and the industry heroes, like Suryakant ( Naseeruddin Shah) couldn't keep their eyes and hands off her. One dirty picture followed another and name, fame and success peaked to unimaginable heights for our girl from nowhere who unabashedly lived out her dreams. Her survival policy: savour the bouquets, ignore the brickbats. Life was literally on song.

So where did the problem lie? It lay in the duplicity of a world which was hungering for sex, but was ashamed to acknowledge this primordial need. So that, serenading Silk was okay in the darkness of the auditorium or behind closed bedroom doors. But accepting her as part of the social pecking order was taboo, for Silk, in a sick society, was a synonym for dirt. Did Silk care? Of course, she did, although she gave the impression she gave a damn to the moral custodians and the double standards of society. But reality began to pinch -- and really hurt -- when her mother shut the door on her face, journalists, hungry for her interview otherwise, refused to entertain her in their page 3 parties and her lover (Naseeruddin Shah), who a minute ago was showering her with compliments, shunted her to the bathroom when his wife unexpectedly arrived. She tried to hide her pain through binge drinking and by changing her lovers ( Tusshar Kapoor), but the sense of rejection just refused to go away.

Partially responsible for her angst too was the arrogance that stars acquire with the onrush of success. One by one, she began to lose her friends in the industry and work stopped coming her way due to her cocky attitude. Didn't take long for the superstar to hit the road to destruction and end up as a sorry picture of failure and ruin. In this decrepit state -- the fate of most erstwhile Bollywood heroines -- her only friend was the man who hated her the most, Emraan Hashmi. But was it already too late to resuscitate a broken soul...

The Dirty Picture is essentially Vidya Balan's film, all the way. She gives a towering performance as the protagonist who remains unapologetic about her life till the very end. The high point of her act is the fact that despite portraying a sex bomb, her sexuality never ever gets vulgar and crude. Instead, there is an endearing quality to her attempts to shock and awe a staid society that thrives on the fake. Her tour de force act however doesn't throw the male leads into the shadows. They manage to hold their own in full measure, despite the relative meagerness of their roles. Also, it is the naughty dialogues (Rajat Arora) of the film which add immense flavour to the proceedings. It's a no-holds-barred screenplay which rightly refuses to treat sex as a four letter word. Kudos to Milan Luthria for handling such a controversial theme with such sensitivity and boldness.

The Dirty Picture is definitely not only your film for the week, but is a seminal work that will be studied in feminist discourses.
you2 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
CULTURE & SOCIETY
FIRST SHOW

Entertainment, entertainment, entertainment' and a raw nerve

Ekta Kapoor is the real heroine of The Dirty Picture, and psychedelic Hindi cinema of the 80s is the real star, says Karuna John

Cleavage so intense that it heaves on its own. This is what The Dirty Picture's teasers featuring a voluptuous Vidya Balan in a shiny pink apsara outfit would want you to believe. A teaser is meant to tease you into walking into the theatre. We suggest you bite the bait and walk in. It is the strong story, which will make you want to sit right through the film.

The Dirty Picture is also not a biopic in the true sense that intellectual analysis would want us to believe. The marketing genius Ekta Kapoor, and her banner Balaji Motion Pictures, has paid a rich homage to the kitschy genre that the 80s cinema birthed. The 80s also gave us the jumping jack moves of Ekta's father Jitendra atop giant earthenware pots and amidst citrus fruit rolling down a slope. The daughter has observed closely as has the film's director Milan Luthria. The 80s vintage is on full show in The Dirty Picture, for some of a certain age it's a nostalgia trip, for the younger audiences it a quick tutorial in the cinema of the time.

Virginal villager Reshma (Balan) dreams big shiny, filmy sequences. The dreams are so big that she has no option but bust out of her obscure village existence into big bad Madras. The city proves to be a kind-hearted pimp who teaches Reshma the ropes and tricks as she grabs at every flicker of opportunity. Nothing is too small to try, no challenge too big.

Somewhere along the way, Reshma frees herself from the pavadai-dhavani (half-saree) cocoon and turns into Silk who wears pink nylex apsara styles outfits with ease. She packs oomph and attitude in a choli a size too small. A size perfect for Silk's loyal fans, who keep rhythm with her gyrations. Three cheers to a healthy body image. Three cheers to bad girls.

Silk learns the survival skills essential for a good performance on screen and off volunteering to be 'fine-tuned' on the casting couch, ruled by matinee idol Surya (Naseeruddin Shah, who is either naturally irritating or just too good an actor). The ageing superstar Surya with the title 'Smashing' before his name is Silk's childhood crush and adulthood passport that helps launch her career.

Survivors of the time may or may not admit it, but many would recognise themselves on screen here. Abraham (Emraan Hashmi) plays a black-shirt wearing brooding director who does not want to be a pimp selling sex in his movies. Emraan does not do angst well. Tushaar Kapoor (who plays Surya's younger write-brother Ramakant), however, does whiney-wimpy very well. Silk has no such pretenses and goes on to upstage both.

The technical team also does well in terms of details, the over-the-top interiors of star houses, the paparazzi and their magazine covers. The original postbox red Maruti 800 is almost a character in itself. Cheesy lines like "filmein sirf teen wajaon se chalti hain' Entertainment, entertainment, entertainment' aur mein entertainment hoon" catch on at times, however, the rest of the dialogue, not so much. Too many one-liners for too many characters. Thankfully, Vishal-Shekhar's music and Bappi Lahiri's vintage voice make up for that.

Don't let that stop you, a bit of cringe is a part of paisa vasool. Those who buy a ticket for skin show and Silk's sensuality oozing out of costumes will get their money's worth in the first half of the film. Balan, who mastered the come-hither look and languid dialogue delivery with husky tempering in Ishqiya, uses that to full advantage in The Dirty Picture. Those who will go see this movie for the "story" of a star's tragic life, will find something post interval. The dirty secret does not want to feel dirty anymore. Heartbreak. Angst. And an attempt at sweet revenge take over Silk's live and its tag of "being entertainment, entertainment, entertainment". She has a heart, she has a brain and circumstances have stirred up a crazy conflict between the two.

However, Silk does not have the inner strength, and the weaklings she has for lovers do not help matters. Surya, his younger brother Ramakant and even Abraham, they all fail her eventually. Silk is left to take care of herself, like she did in the beginning. Back to square one. But this time she decides to call a pack up. A mirror to the 80s film industry. Across the language divide.

Karuna John is Associate Editor, Tehelka.com.
karuna@tehelka.com

Edited by you2 - 13 years ago
31609 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
any leads from Masand or anupama yet?

I really hope this movie does well at the BO...would be awsome to see that. A woman, giving a super hit in ages...
Kal El thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
Masand don't you dare dislike this. 😡😆
31609 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
masand's really unpredictable sometimes...remember he dissed OUATIM when all critics were going ga ga over it? and he liked delhi 6 when all critics said it sucked balls...

but i think he'll like this one. Hes in love with the promos so far, going by his twitter reactions..

so i finally convicned my Bua (dad's sister) and my sister to watch movie with me.....maybe going sunday or monday...
grounder thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
Emraan is slowly and steadily getting what he truly deserves. He is such a kool and different actor. I like him and Abhay for their different movies and subtle acting.

Vidya has always been good from Parineeta to Dirty Picture. I always look forward to her and Priyanka's movies. They are a class apart from Kareenas and Katrinas who just gyrate to some silly dance numbers in the name of acting.

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: iamrebelheart

1 months ago

Rashmika dirty cut poster

https://www.instagram.com/p/DL1WEMFKQod/?igsh=N29ha3Y3bnZkOXMy

https://www.instagram.com/p/DL1WEMFKQod/?igsh=N29ha3Y3bnZkOXMy
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

28 days ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

27 days ago

Dhadak 2 - Reviews And Box Office

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

1 months ago

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim Released on hotstar 25/7

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

1 months ago

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".