THE DIRTY PICTURE: All Reviews Here (Index Page 1)

-Mmmmm- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
anupamachopra Anupama Chopra
Watch #TheDirtyPicture for Vidya's brave performance. She isn't afraid of being frankly sexual or frankly ugly. She is an absolute original.
chetan_bhagat Chetan Bhagat
Few Indians make me proud of being Indian. Vidya Balan is one. She isn't just an actor, she is an artist. Superb performance.
@ohkhalid khalid mohamed
Vidya Balan is to die for in The Dirty Picture. Gutsy, emotionally volatile...haven't seen a performance like hers in years and years...!
vivek_oberoi Vivek Oberoi
Jst watched #TheDirtyPicture -vidya balan is beyond brilliant! Hats off to a phenomenal performance! Fabulous film all round!!!
9 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply
@RajaSen Raja Sen
Will review Dirty Picture on Friday, but hats off to Vidya Balan. Incredible commitment to the role, very brave for a mainstream heroine.
@MehraAmod Amod Mehra
If heroine oriented films don't work then how come Ishqiya NOKJ & now DP are Hits.. The reason is simple.. Vidya Vidya & Vidya.. SUPERHIT !!
@OQSpot Omar Qureshi
Never felt purer than after #DirtyPicture. Pure intent pure sordid story of a goldenheart #VidyaBalan is sensational. Well done Ekta, Milan
@SaritaTanwar
Sarita Tanwar
Saw Dirty Picture. Mind = blown. Full entertainment Super impressed by Vidya's performance and Rajat Arora's lines #DirtyPicture
arbaazSkhan Arbaaz Khan
Saw a preview of THE DIRTY PICTURE last night. Its outstanding. Loved the film, the performances,the direction,the writing, loved everything
ohkhalid khalid mohamed
Vidya Balan is to die for in The Dirty Picture. Gutsy, emotionally volatile...haven't seen a performance like hers in years and years...!
kjohar25 Karan Johar
take a bow team balaji!!! Super film!!! Rajat's brilliant dialogue...milan's nuanced and superb control over the plot...dirty picture rules!
kjohar25 Karan Johar
Her performance in DIRTY PICTURE is by far the bravest and best performance I have seen of any actor in years...she is the benchmark!!!
kjohar25 Karan Johar
take a bow team balaji!!! Super film!!! Rajat's brilliant dialogue...milan's nuanced and superb control over the plot...dirty picture rules!


MaheshNBhatt Mahesh Bhatt
Dirty Picture is a blockbuster! Vidya Balan,Naseer & Emraan set the screen ablaze with their outstanding performances.
smiliesuri smilie suri
Dirty picture is a full on commercial entertainer!I had so much fun in a trial show for the first time! Hats off to milan lutharia
ShirishKunder Shirish Kunder
Unbelievable buzz on The Dirty Picture. Haven't seen such in a long time. If I had to turn distributor, I would have started with this.
annavetticad Anna M.M. Vetticad
After ages, the marketing of a seemingly commercial film rests on its heroine's shoulders. Kudos to Balaji for #TheDirtyPicture promotions
annavetticad: IF #TheDirtyPicture does well, it will open new doors for women in this for-too-long-male-dominated industry"
Edited by -Maddy- - 13 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

450

Views

57.2k

Users

84

Likes

948

Frequent Posters

-Mmmmm- thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Twitter Reviews: Page 15
Bollywood Hungama(Taran Adarsh): Page 15
DNA ( Aniruddha Guha ) : Page 16
Daily Bhaskar: Page 17
Times of India ( Nikhat Kazmi ): Page 17
Rediff ( Raja Sen ): Page 18
Komal Nahta : Page 18
Glamsham: Page 19
Rediff ( Sukanya Verma ): Page 19
Movietalkies.com: Page 22
Gaurav Malani: Page 24
Reuters.com: Page 25
India Today ( Kaveree Bamzai ): Page 25
Kunal Guha: Page 26
Mid-day: Page 27
Hindustan Times ( Mayank Shekar ): Page 28
Mihir Fadvis: Page 28
IBN Live ( Rajeev Masand ): Page 34

Masand: 'The Dirty Picture' is eminently watchable

Cast: Vidya Balan, Emraan Hashmi, Naseeruddin Shah and Tusshar Kapoor

Director: Milan Luthria

Vidya Balan goes where few have gone before, putting it all out there, literally, for the sake of her art. Pity it's for a film as unremarkable as 'The Dirty Picture'.

Vidya Balan goes where few have gone before, putting it all out there, literally, for the sake of her art.

At one point in this movie, her character, a titillating dancing star of the 80s, says there are only three ingredients in a film that can guarantee its success: "Entertainment, entertainment, and entertainment." It's a point director Milan Luthria and his writer Rajat Arora seem determined to beat into our heads. For The Dirty Picture seems to have been made specifically to shock you.

All those lured in solely by the promise of skin-show are unlikely to complain. Yet, despite its masala scenes, heavy dialoguebaazi and liberal sexual innuendo, in the final analysis, this film is far from perfect. The Dirty Picture takes an unconventional idea and bakes it in a predictable oven.

What it suffers most from, unfortunately, is lazy writing. With a plot straight out of a Madhur Bhandarkar film, and a screenplay that follows a familiar graph, The Dirty Picture offers a superficial, simplistic view of the seamy, exploitative side of the 80s film business. There is little attempt to treat this material with sensitivity and depth. No sir, this film unfolds as a series of provocative scenes strung together on the strength of their sexually loaded dialogues.

Despite repeated testimonials on the part of its makers that their inspiration isn't Silk Smitha, The Dirty Picture still comes across as a thinly-veiled life-story of the famous South Indian screen siren. In typical filmi fashion, the story opens with Reshma, a village girl, running away to Madras to realize her impossible dreams. Reshma is a Plain Jane, but she wants to be a star. Grabbing an opportunity with both hands, Reshma gyrates seductively in her first break before the camera. She acquires the name Silk, falls into an affair with a much-married superstar, and a siren is born. Her downfall, incidentally, is as quick as her rise ' Silk's recklessness makes her overdose on a cocktail of disastrous love affairs, alcohol, bad debts and excess.

Over the course of the film's 2 hours 20 minutes running time, we're introduced to the men in Silk's life. Naseeruddin Shah is expectedly first-rate as the egotistical, ageing superstar Suryakant, who exploits Silk, then cuts her off ruthlessly. Heartbroken, she takes up with his younger brother Ramakant, played by Tusshar Kapoor. This character seems forced into the plot, and Tusshar is miscast, as is evident by a bizarrely comical dance he breaks into, straight out of those Golmaal movies. Emraan Hashmi is appropriately restrained as Abraham, a director who believes in film as art, and who abhors the idea of inserting steamy numbers in his movie to lure in the crowds. His hatred for Silk seems misplaced, and so does his sudden change of heart'and yet he has the most interesting dynamic with the siren. Alas, it's too little too late.

Despite the film's shortcomings, you go the distance for Vidya Balan, who's riveting as Silk. She plays the part with gusto ' it's a rare performance, one that's this brave and uninhibited. Vidya pushes the envelope in the way she bares herself both physically and emotionally. Watch how she stops traffic by dancing on the bonnet of a car to disrupt a party she isn't invited to, or the scene in which she saucily lounges naked in a bathtub while giving an interview to a journalist. Vidya's lack of vanity and complete surrender to her craft reinforces why she's miles ahead of her contemporaries.

Alas, one can't muster up the same enthusiasm for the film. For although The Dirty Picture is nicely shot and comes with a foot-tapping score from Vishal-Shekhar, the makers seem too preoccupied with the style and the fashion of those times. The film is refreshingly judgment-free, but leaves you confused about your feelings for Silk in the end ' is she a victim, or just someone who made her bed and had to lay in it?

I'm going with two out of five for the film, and an additional one for Vidya Balan alone, which makes it three out of five for The Dirty Picture. It's an average film made eminently watchable by its courageous star. Go on, give her the awards already!

Rating: 3 / 5

By Taran Adarsh, November 30, 2011 - 11:14 IST


Intermittently, real life is far more appealing and compelling than fiction. And a biopic -- which attempts to recount a person's life story or at least the most historically momentous years of his/her life -- is most demanding for not just the storyteller/s, but also the actors who bracket together with those films. Occasionally, a dash of some imaginary anecdotes are incorporated in biopics, since the moviegoer seeks some diversion and entertainment in a movie, besides enlightenment.

Write your own movie review of The Dirty Picture
Having said that I'd like to add that it's easier to take a recognizable route, to opt for the tried and tested, but it's frightfully difficult to be diverse. Producers Shobha Kapoor and Ekta Kapoor are known for accepting challenges and backing films like LOVE SEX AUR DHOKHA, RAGINI MMS and SHOR IN THE CITY and along with director Milan Luthria and writer Rajat Aroraa had successfully recreated the bygone era with flourish in ONCE UPON A TIME IN MUMBAAI. Now THE DIRTY PICTURE fires all powerful bullets to stir your mind's eye.


The general feeling is, THE DIRTY PICTURE is a biopic on the life and times of Silk Smitha, a sought-after actress of the 80s. I personally feel that THE DIRTY PICTURE draws inspiration from the struggling female actors in the 80s, whose insurmountable and indomitable spirit made them emerge triumphant and create a distinctive space for themselves in the male-dominated industry. It's a recreation of an era, with the makers seeking motivation from a lot of characters to create this one woman.

Let me clear this at the very outset. THE DIRTY PICTURE not only draws attention to the life of a sex goddess, but also makes us responsive of the catastrophe behind the facade. Silk -- the principal character in THE DIRTY PICTURE -- provides titillation to millions of viewers, but dies a forlorn and heartbreaking death. She battles fame, fortune and alcohol. Brave, daring and provocative, THE DIRTY PICTURE doesn't cross the line into impropriety and offensiveness.

Envisage a junior artist who became the most sought after female protagonist of the early 80s. Chronicling the meteoric rise and steep fall of a screen sensation, THE DIRTY PICTURE is set against the colorful and entertaining setting of the South film industry of the 80s.

The quintessential siren, Silk, knew her spectators and it didn't seem like anything would stop the intensely motivated starlet, till it did, in the shape of unrequited love. To the world, she was the queen of sensuality. But, at heart, Silk was just another woman craving for true love. An unfortunate encounter with deceit and infidelity led to dire consequences!

First things first! Milan Luthria is brave and intelligent. Brave, because Milan steps out of the comfort zone to narrate the tragic story of an actress. Intelligent, because THE DIRTY PICTURE does not develop into a dry and depressing fare at any juncture. This one stresses on -- as Vidya puts it -- entertainment, entertainment and entertainment. Well narrated and wonderfully executed, THE DIRTY PICTURE is sure to strike a chord with the avid moviegoer. I'd like to give brownie points to Rajat Aroraa's dynamic script and razor-sharp dialogue. The riveting screenplay and power-packed dialogue will remain etched in our memory for a long, long time, eliciting a similar response like ONCE UPON A TIME IN MUMBAAI. The writing holds the spectators' interest and doesn't let you digress from the screen, except for a few minutes in the post-interval portions. The portions between Emraan and Vidya slows the narrative, though, I'd like to add, it picks up dramatically when Vidya gets conned by a maker of po*n movies. The sequences thereafter, right till the finale, take the film to the crescendo again.

THE DIRTY PICTURE is embellished with several powerful sequences. Note the sequence when Vidya convinces/seduces Naseeruddin Shah, after he refuses to work with her. It's remarkable. Also, the first encounter with Emraan Hashmi. Noteworthy! Much later, the volatile sequence at the awards ceremony [the intermission point] is amongst the highpoints of the enterprise. The second hour has its share of super moments as well. The one featuring Vidya outside Anju Mahendroo's mansion is super. Vidya's interaction with the two women [individual sequences, both] -- with Naseer's wife first and Shakila, the dancer, next -- packs a solid punch. Vidya's interaction with the maker of po*n movies is another shocking twist. The finale, of course, moves you no end.

Vishal-Shekhar deliver a good soundtrack. 'Ooo La La' is easily the song of the year [rendered brilliantly by Bappi Lahiri and Shreya Ghoshal], while 'Ishq Sufiyana' has long legs too. Another striking track is 'Honeymoon Ki Raat'. The choreography of these tracks [Pony Prakash Raj], especially 'Ooh La La', is straight out of the 80s. Bobby Singh's cinematography is magnificent.

Vidya's sizzling show and dare-bare act is sure to seize the viewers by complete astonishment. It's a novel casting because it is nothing like what Vidya has done before and is completely diverse to her image. But let's give Vidya the due: She delivers an astounding performance, pushing the envelope yet again. It wouldn't be erroneous to state that Vidya will walk away with the awards for the sterling act in this film. Besides, she carries off the hot attire without making her character look vulgar or tasteless. In fact, Milan and costume designer Niharika Bhasin Khan have ensured that the sexy-looking persona is aesthetically depicted. Vidya had put on oodles of weight to get the look of the character right and the flabby body only adds a lot of authenticity to the character she depicts on the big screen.

Naseeruddin Shah, who has been cast as an ageing South Indian superstar, sports wigs, dark glasses and painted moustache, reminding people of the stars of that era. He plays to the gallery, provoking claps, laughs and whistles, thus pulling off the role with lan. One has to credit Emraan Hashmi for willing to take on bold, aggressive characters. I actually wondered what prompted the actor to share screen space with Vidya, who has a meatier role and enacts the central character, but he walks his own path throughout the film. He plays the headstrong, hot-blooded, rebellious director to the hilt. Tusshar is wonderfully restrained in a significant role. His sequences with Naseer and Vidya, both are truly fantastic.

Anju Mahendru is first-rate, reminding people of a real-life lady journo, who was hugely popular for her writings in the 80s. Rajesh Sharma, the film-maker who 'discovers' Silk, is outstanding. An actor to watch out for! Shivani Tanskale, enacting the role of Naseeruddin Shah's wife, is perfect. Mangal Kenkre [as Ratnamma] and Imran Hasnee are adequate.

On the whole, THE DIRTY PICTURE banks heavily on shock-value, sex-value and most importantly, script-value. It's an exceptional portrayal of an ordinary person's rise from scratch to extraordinary heights and her subsequent fall. Without doubt, it is one of the most comprehensive scripts to come out of the Hindi film industry in 2011. A film with a universal theme and terrific mass connect, it has remarkable potential to set the cash registers ringing for one more valid reason -- entertainment, entertainment and entertainment.

Edited by -Maddy- - 13 years ago
Kal El thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
Nice! Waisey Khujli King had nothing to say about how well his nephew played him?
360297 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Kal El

Nice! Waisey Khujli King had nothing to say about how well his nephew played him?



whaaat? Emran played Mahesh Bhatt's character?
Kal El thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: eraser



whaaat? Emran played Mahesh Bhatt's character?



His character is supposedly based on Mahesh, yes.
noseasync thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
This movie will rock!!
cant wait to see it=)
ruky786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
Yipee! I'm not going to get my hopes high too much but still I can't wait!😍

Oooh la la ooh la la tu hai meri fantasy
360297 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: ruky786

Yipee! I'm not going to get my hopes high too much but still I can't wait!😍

Oooh la la ooh la la tu hai meri fantasy


Coookieee 🤗

I dont wanna get my hopes up either but BOY, I am so darn eager to watch this movie!!!
ruky786 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: eraser


Coookieee 🤗

I dont wanna get my hopes up either but BOY, I am so darn eager to watch this movie!!!



I love my nickname!😆😆😆 Coookieee😆😆😆😆

eraserrr🤗🤗🤗

And I'm totally in lala land!😍
.khoobsurat. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
totally excited for this movie. The only movie I went to see in theater recently is Ra.one...because movies are expensive these days...i don't have the kind of money to go see every movie that comes out. And I will def go see DP but it's not a movie where you wanna see with others. lol☺️
Edited by beboholic - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: iamrebelheart

1 months ago

Rashmika dirty cut poster

https://www.instagram.com/p/DL1WEMFKQod/?igsh=N29ha3Y3bnZkOXMy

https://www.instagram.com/p/DL1WEMFKQod/?igsh=N29ha3Y3bnZkOXMy
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

23 days ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

22 days ago

Dhadak 2 - Reviews And Box Office

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

28 days ago

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim

Sarzameen reviews- Kajol and Ibrahim Released on hotstar 25/7

Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

1 months ago

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".