What went wrong with Tashan, by filmigirl - Page 3

Originally posted by: live_life

Good god?
All I said was that this blog seems biased, that she was in the minority of people who watched Tashan. And I didn't go to her blog, look her up to see what this girl's views were. They were posted in this forum and I wanted to see how it would be justified.

And I read it, the whole thing. She seems to love the actors, and how the director Victor wanted to reach the audience of Johny mera naam and wanted to get away from Hum Tum. And THEN he said its all about implausible plots and garish costumes, which is not what Johny mera naam was about all. That movie had a good story.

And according to me, Victor fell miserably in what he tried to do.
And that was my biased opinion.

But she also specifically states why teh film didnt work. Not because of promotions or whatever, but THE FILM itself.

Originally posted by: desigal90

But she also specifically states why teh film didnt work. Not because of promotions or whatever, but THE FILM itself.

How she says that Victor tried to combine two elements that just did not fuse properly together, and that in doing so, he alienated two sets fo audiences.

So while she personally liked the film, she also analyzes why it went wrong. I think her blog is BRILLIANT.
Its not, oh i love the flim blah blah, people who dont like it are stupid, blah blah. That would be biased.

But the reason I like the blog is coz she pointed out something new. A flaw that I couldnt pinpoint to before.

And thanks Smarie! Yeah even I noticed that international viewwers appreciated the film a lot!

I thought you liked it because she also liked a movie that you liked, which had been criticized and flopped..thanks for clearing that up.
The blogger had some decent points regarding why it went wrong, BUT nevertheless she still tries too hard to glorify the movie, even its bleakest points. She analyzed why it went wrong, and I have to disagree. She's a good writer, but Tashan's not too raw or bloody nor is it too hard for the audiences. Guess her opinion's very different than mine. And that's fine.
.

Haha no I like the movie, but it would have been pointless posting a blog just talkign about why the movie was good.

Originally posted by: desigal90

Smarie, nkapoor doenst seem to understand what "opinons" mean, lmao!

</div>
<div>I can betshe didnt read ONE sentence from the blog.

Why r u so mean? It is you who does not understand the meaning of opinions, if u did u wud let my opinion be, stop targeting me and for ur kind info I did read that blog

I dont know if you're ignorant or you think people are stupid, but your snide comments are digs, not "opinions".

atleast I do not mention a particular member and target them, if u found my tone condenscending, I will try not sound like that in the future, but I was just speaking honestly, this blog shares an opinion but it is most certainly not a fact, i think this blog is undermining people's intelligence, I am sure people can very well comprehend tashan! It's no matrix! satires do work, but this movie was just idiotic, I most definitely find it idiotic! and so did 90% of the audience and I cannot believe that this article is trying to put the mass audience down!

I watched the movie and for me it was a big joke... No more,no less... I still fail to understand what were the makers thinking while making this movie... Ok.. wait... Perhaps they weren't thinking 😆😆

Originally posted by: nkapoor

atleast I do not mention a particular member and target them, if u found my tone condenscending, I will try not sound like that in the future, but I was just speaking honestly, this blog shares an opinion but it is most certainly not a fact, i think this blog is undermining people's intelligence, I am sure people can very well comprehend tashan! It's no matrix! satires do work, but this movie was just idiotic, I most definitely find it idiotic! and so did 90% of the audience and I cannot believe that this article is trying to put the mass audience down!

@kareena k fans a question for u : have u ppl said the same thing for this movie if a mallika sherawat or a deepika padoukone? for god sake come out of ur closets...all it seems tht since kareena is involved u found the film enjoyable...

Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower

@kareena k fans a question for u : have u ppl said the same thing for this movie if a mallika sherawat or a deepika padoukone? for god sake come out of ur closets...all it seems tht since kareena is involved u found the film enjoyable...

and @smarie_pants : few days back u posted long discussions to criticize 'RANGEELA' and now ur supporting this movie TASHAN...seriously i really don't know should I laugh or do something to remove my acidity coz people talks so undigestable sometimes tht acidity is bound to happen😆

thankyou