What went wrong with Tashan, by filmigirl

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

desigal90

@desigal90

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower
@kareena k fans a question for u : have u ppl said the same thing for this movie if a mallika sherawat or a deepika padoukone? for god sake come out of ur closets...all it seems tht since kareena is involved u found the film enjoyable...

and @smarie_pants : few days back u posted long discussions to criticize 'RANGEELA' and now ur supporting this movie TASHAN...seriously i really don't know should I laugh or do something to remove my acidity coz people talks so undigestable sometimes tht acidity is bound to happen😆

A) YES

Kareena has starred in a LOT OF CRAP, but Tashan is not one of them. Kambakkht Ishq, yes. MAMK, YES. Golmaal Returns, YES.

Tashan, NO.

B) It is entirely Smarie's opinoin if she wants to criticize a film or not. Atleast she doesnt comment on FANS, or INDIVIDUALS for their choice. Live and let live. Give your opinion on the film/blog/topic, and move on. No need to extend the same judgement on members or fans.

Quote

desigal90

@desigal90

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#32

For the last time, targetting at fans needs to stop.

I dont know if you people even bother to read the rules, but that's not allowed.

So unless you want a warning from teh mods for asking kareena fans to come outta the closet, I suggest you edit your post.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

4492

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: smartie_pants

did u read the article properly??

It dosent blame the mass audience or anything of tht sort...it states tht its the films fault tht it didnt cater towards the majority because it tried to fuse two contrasting styles of filmmaking...as far as i know, that is a critisism of the film and not the audience...

She didnt say ppl who dunt like it are dumb, she said she likes it... thats it...and some of us on the forum agree...but questioning that opinion saying that "oh i cant believe some ppl like this film" is condescending...the blog dosent say people who "dont" like the film are stupid...but your post questions people who did like the film as if they did something wrong...

get the difference?

I think you have not read the blog properly!

The more I watch popular "throwback" films like Dabangg, the more I see that Tashan failed at the box office because it wasn't accessible. An audience who would have enjoyed the masala elements, most likely found the meta elements either dull or incomprehensible.---really? is the audience dumb?

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower
@kareena k fans a question for u : have u ppl said the same thing for this movie if a mallika sherawat or a deepika padoukone? for god sake come out of ur closets...all it seems tht since kareena is involved u found the film enjoyable...

and @smarie_pants : few days back u posted long discussions to criticize 'RANGEELA' and now ur supporting this movie TASHAN...seriously i really don't know should I laugh or do something to remove my acidity coz people talks so undigestable sometimes tht acidity is bound to happen😆

okay so anyone who likes the film is living in a closet?? gr8 thanks for the gyaan...but id rather not be lectured about what film to and not to like...

and yes, i critisised rangeela coz i found parts of it vulgar...i didnt say "OMG...how can anyone like the film?? they are clearly living in a dream world"...nope...i NEVER said that...

the problem is not with people disliking the film...the problem is with people questioning and catcalling people who did like the film...

u say u disliked the film and no one will come and argue with u...u point fingers at people who do like it, then expect retaliation

Edited by smartie_pants - 14 years ago

Quote

623577

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#35

@desigal90 : let me remind u ur own thing...discussion forum...whatever judgements there u take...u be prepared for the replies...

i asked smarie_pants becoz she thinks her judgement of movies is really upto the mark...she hates the film RANGEELA fair enuff..yet she supports a thrashy film which wasn't even well received by anyone...just a handful of people no need to mention why...so next time u make a judgement u better prepared to face the replies

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: nkapoor
I think you have not read the blog properly!
The more I watch popular "throwback" films like Dabangg, the more I see that Tashan failed at the box office because it wasn't accessible. An audience who would have enjoyed the masala elements, most likely found the meta elements either dull or incomprehensible.---really? is the audience dumb?

she said incomprehensible OR dull FOR the audience who enjoyed the masala part of the film...not many people like to see masala and meta elements fused in a single movie, and hence, the fusion maybe incomprehensible (or difficult to digest) for some...that is NOT questioning the audience's intelligence...its a matter of choice...

Quote

4492

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: smartie_pants

she said incomprehensible OR dull FOR the audience who enjoyed the masala part of the film...not many people like to see masala and meta elements fused in a single movie, and hence, the fusion maybe incomprehensible (or difficult to digest) for some...that is NOT questioning the audience's intelligence...its a matter of choice...

I am sorry I also love masala movies! but that does not mean I cannot comprehend the meta elements! enough said, I do not want to argue further

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower
@desigal90 : let me remind u ur own thing...discussion forum...whatever judgements there u take...u be prepared for the replies...

i asked smarie_pants becoz she thinks her judgement of movies is really upto the mark...she hates the film RANGEELA fair enuff..yet she supports a thrashy film which wasn't even well received by anyone...just a handful of people no need to mention why...so next time u make a judgement u better prepared to face the replies

so if a film is well recieved, i HAVE to like it, and if a film is not well recieved and i happened to like it, Im wrong?????

touche to the LOGIC.

Quote

desigal90

@desigal90

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#39

What reminder? I've always debated with people on their viewpoints.

I'm always welcome for replies for my VIEWS. But no, that does not mean, an open invitation to come and judge the fans/members who like a certain film. You and nkapoor on the other hand are preoccupied more with the members rather than the topic.

That's the difference. Once again, I dont know if you cant see it, or if you are pretending not to.

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 14 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: nkapoor

I am sorry I also love masala movies! but that does not mean I cannot comprehend the meta elements! enough said, I do not want to argue further

i said the fusion was incomprehensible...not masala or meta by itself...anyways..i give up too..

I'm not here to convince u to like the film...

But please dunt shove ur opinion down other's throats by questioning people who did like it...

Edited by smartie_pants - 14 years ago