1) Amitabh orJaya : I find Big B's acting to be over the top more often than not.
2) Aish or Abhishek (Both: They have both had their share of good and bad performances and its hard to pick just one person).
3) Saif or Kareena I would pick Saif on the basis of Being Cyrus, Omkara, Parineeta and Ek Haseena Thi which for me beat Kareena's best 4 performances (Omkara, Dev, JWM, Chameli). I don't really care for most of the other Kareena performances, but Saif was actually good to decent in Dil Chahta Hai, Love Aaj Kal and Hum Tum.
4) Ranveer or Konkona : Ranveer hasn't really got the opportunity to do many leading roles though he was fabulous in Mithya. Relatively I feel Konkona has experimented more.
5) Deepika or Ranbir (Both: Ranbir overacts and Deepika needs to open up more on screen. I haven't seen WUS yet though).
6) Salman or Katrina (None: neither of them can act)
7) Bipasha or John : John is hot. The acting not so much.
8) Dharmendra or Hema (Both I guess, but I haven't seen many of their films).
9) Shahid or Kareena (I would say on the basis of JWM, Vivah and Kaminey that both of them are just as capable actors as each other but Kareena has shown more versatility in the roles she chose. I hope Shahid does the same)
10) Harman or Priyanka She was one of the only redeemable things about Fashion for me. I have only seen half of WYR and on the basis of that I would definitely pick Priyanka. Kaminey is definitely her best.
4