Balika Vadhu Episode Discussion Thread #4 DT NOTES PG 68/86/93/129 - Page 106

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

58.9k

Users

43

Likes

3k

Frequent Posters

SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Kamili went against her mother and despite her threats gave statement against her father in Gopal's case because it was important for her. Not only getting justice for Gopal but revenge against her parents for all that they have done to her and how they brutally seperated her from Gopal.

So in that case she will against all odds because it is important to her.

She came back to Jhalra despite being angry with her father for killing Gopal because her husband's safety was important.

If she has to chose between getting justice to Mangala and her husband's safety she obviously will chose her husband's safety.

Urmi is concerned about justice for herself and her life and her baby's life.She will obviously chose her baby's life over justice for Mangala.

Just like Mangala just sat and watched Urmi suffer even when she knew a way out for Urmi because she didn't want to part with Nandini.

Serves Mangala right.Today the girls when it came to chosing between helping her get justice and their own interests they chose their interests just like she did.



Is Mangala fighting only for her husband? Or Kamli only for her Gopal? Or Urmi just for her unborn child? No, all of them are united against Akhera - it is just that they could not help Mangala prove her husband's case - that case was anyway the weakest link. Just by bringing those kadas could not prove anything. How could she prove that those kadas actually belong to her husband? Or her husband was actually wearing those when he was murdered. There was actually no proof in that case.

@bold - so people think the way out for Urmi was Anandi? 😆 Mangala was ignorant - so she thought of calling Anandi. Would Urmi go to Anandi when she chose not to go to her mother? And even after all the lecture in court and judge agreeing to her - did the so called social worker take Urmi with her?
Edited by SPuja - 9 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: SPuja


Is Mangala fighting only for her husband? Or Kamli only for her Gopal? Or Urmi just for her unborn child? No, all of them are united against Akhera - it is just that they could not help Mangala prove her husband's case - that case was anyway the weakest link. Just by bringing those kadas could not prove anything. How could she prove that those kadas actually belong to her husband? Or her husband was actually wearing those when he was murdered. There was actually no proof in that case.

@bold - so people think the way out for Urmi was Anandi? 😆 Mangala was ignorant - so she thought of calling Anandi. Would Urmi go to Anandi when she chose not to go to her mother? And even after all the lecture in court and judge agreeing to her - did the so called social worker take Urmi with her?

Murder case of Mangala's husband was weak.Those kadas would not have proved anything.

They are united against Akheraj for their own purposes their common enemy is Akheraj but they all put their interests over helping each other if push comes to shove.
But the fact is they chose their interests over helping Mangala.

Mangala herself wanted to call Anandi and chose not to because along with Urmi she will take her teddy bear also away 😛
So instead of calling Anandi she put up her useless Devi act which didn't serve any purpose.

Kamili is already wondering why Mangala lied about Nandini not liking Anandi's place.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Mangala would have done nothing if Jagya did not come along.
If Jagya had not come along Akheraj would have continued to do what he has been doing all his life.

That is the truth.

People keep saying that Dsa and Ganga's stories were like fairy tales.

Mangala didn't want to take Anandi's help for her own selfish reasons but took Jagya's help and how did that become empowerment?

Had Mangala decided enough is enough and did something on her own like going to the villagers like Anandi is doing now and got them together to expose Akheraj then it could have been empowerment.

She was just sitting there and waiting fro paap ka ghada fill up.

Empowerment is not about just sitting and waiting for help empowerment is all about finding a way by themselves

Empowerment is about finding resources which are within and not about taking help from outsiders.

People were appreciating that Mangala Kamili and Urmi and Nimboli are fighting but when Anandi joins in that fight how did it become so unpalatable?

Were Kamili Urmi Nandini Mangala fighting for the villagers? No.

Doesn't Anandi have a lot more in common with these women and villagers than Jagya has?

Anandi's daughter suffered in this village in front of the very eyes of these villagers for years so why can't Anandi ask these villagers to help nail Akheraj?
fly2meee thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Where is Anant and his police friend who is supposed to look for Kisna (Mangala's Husband's murderer)?
fly2meee thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Shinya

What a boring and filler episode. Nimboli is getting more and more boring.

I dont know why mangala is doing Anandi a favor by staying in BH and helping her daughter to accept her as mother 😒... Anyhow that girl is going to show her color soon and become exactly like her mother (ungrateful).

She is so awestruck by the wealth and food... she does not mind kicking anyone out for the luxuries.

Mangala is wasting her time on ungrateful people... it is time for mangala to wake up and leave that Badi Hell.

Vow mangala is doing a favour to Anandi by helping her daughter to accept her mother? Really??? She is the one who said Issa Jajam mein isko(nimboli ko) aapka nahi hone doongi and she is the one who is hurting N constantly because she didn't want her to be loved by BH people or mingled with them. Yet you think she is helping?? In what way?? May be she told you that she is helping, I don't know. She even lied to Kamli also.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Mangala would have done nothing if Jagya did not come along.

If Jagya had not come along Akheraj would have continued to do what he has been doing all his life.

That is the truth.

People keep saying that Dsa and Ganga's stories were like fairy tales.

Mangala didn't want to take Anandi's help for her own selfish reasons but took Jagya's help and how did that become empowerment?

Had Mangala decided enough is enough and did something on her own like going to the villagers like Anandi is doing now and got them together to expose Akheraj then it could have been empowerment.

She was just sitting there and waiting fro paap ka ghada fill up.

Empowerment is not about just sitting and waiting for help empowerment is all about finding a way by themselves

Empowerment is about finding resources which are within and not about taking help from outsiders.

People were appreciating that Mangala Kamili and Urmi and Nimboli are fighting but when Anandi joins in that fight how did it become so unpalatable?

Were Kamili Urmi Nandini Mangala fighting for the villagers? No.

Doesn't Anandi have a lot more in common with these women and villagers than Jagya has?

Anandi's daughter suffered in this village in front of the very eyes of these villagers for years so why can't Anandi ask these villagers to help nail Akheraj?


@bold - how do u know that unless you are on BV creatives team.

@blue - what could Anandi do? Mangala was naive to think about Anandi and her help. J was a politician and has power - what does Anandi has? It is true that cretives will show their lead doing everything - but can a so called social worker help people like Urmi or Mangala? Anandi going to villagers is empowerment? It was Mangala who exposed and sent Akhera to jail. Just to give their lead something to do - creatives made a khichadi of court case and let Anandi talk about Akhera's past - that she knew only through others and the Jhalra women were given only one case to each - and they are not even mentioned as witness 😲. Only Nimboli witnessed Gopal's murder? 😆.


@red - yes Mangala was fighting for the villagers - anandi is not.

@pink - really? Anandi has got whatever she has with help of others - even setting up of Bhaili was helped by Shakhers and even the idea was given by them. SN - we have not seen how it was built - but given the track record - it must be Singhs and their help.

Edited by SPuja - 9 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Then what was the purpose between hit and miss scenes between Akheraj and Anandi that too in Jagya's office and BH?
They seemed to be so important that they ran those scenes as precaps for weeks.


Jagya can be shown interacting with Akheraj but why somuch importance given for Anandi missing Akheraj by a whisker? Logical explanation for those scenes should be that Anandi will bump into Akheraj and then tell Jagya about him. That is how one would expect the story to go.
So obviously it was either changed or CVs brought these ridiculous scenes to explain why Anandi is kept out of exposing Akheraj. This is not the first time they gifted tracks to others.Notable one being career in politics.
----------------------

The fact that Anandi has a good and strong reason to see Akheraj punished fro what he has done to her and her daughter and so ganging up with the other people who has an axe to grind with Akheraj cannot be an illogical track.

Doesn't Anandi have a reason to take on Akheraj after the way he separated her baby from her?

----------------
Shekhars gave Anandi idea about Bhaili?😛
It was the brain child of Anandi and Shiv solely borne out of Anandi's desire to reach out to people like Chanda and given a form by Shiv named by Anandi herself.

Chanda was working for Shekhars for years before Anandi stepped into that house as DIL.

How is that the modern educated family never thought of doing anything for the under privileged apart from going and donating money to orphanages etc once in a while?


Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
The hit and miss scenes between akhiraj and anandi were only to prove that anandi was busy with other irrelevant issues and was not even remembering her daughter or that she had to find her daughter's kidnapper.



SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Then what was the purpose between hit and miss scenes between Akheraj and Anandi that too in Jagya's office and BH?
They seemed to be so important that they ran those scenes as precaps for weeks.


Jagya can be shown interacting with Akheraj but why somuch importance given for Anandi missing Akheraj by a whisker? Logical explanation for those scenes should be that Anandi will bump into Akheraj and then tell Jagya about him. That is how one would expect the story to go.
So obviously it was either changed or CVs brought these ridiculous scenes to explain why Anandi is kept out of exposing Akheraj. This is not the first time they gifted tracks to others.Notable one being career in politics.
----------------------

The fact that Anandi has a good and strong reason to see Akheraj punished fro what he has done to her and her daughter and so ganging up with the other people who has an axe to grind with Akheraj cannot be an illogical track.

Doesn't Anandi have a reason to take on Akheraj after the way he separated her baby from her?

----------------
Shekhars gave Anandi idea about Bhaili?😛
It was the brain child of Anandi and Shiv solely borne out of Anandi's desire to reach out to people like Chanda and given a form by Shiv named by Anandi herself.

Chanda was working for Shekhars for years before Anandi stepped into that house as DIL.

How is that the modern educated family never thought of doing anything for the under privileged apart from going and donating money to orphanages etc once in a while?



The hit and miss - don't we all know why? Just to create suspense - what will happen now type and to stretch the serial. Was Akhera going to fear Anandi? @blue is correct - but then the way they have changed Anandi's character - too selfish and too arrogant and ungrateful - it is not even a pleasure to see how she wins now.

@red - if I remember correctly - daddu suggested about this idea - not name but the idea of helping women like Chanda (I will check the episode update though).
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
hahaha...Mangala would have done nothing if Jagya did not come along?? ... Mangala was waiting for the right time to strike and through jagya she found the opportunity and grabbed it...It was not like after she met jagya, she thought of taking her revenge.


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".