Peeping through the curtains - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

152

Views

11k

Users

23

Likes

423

Frequent Posters

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#41
Anandi living in BH is really ridiculous and it is obvious that she and her kids just stay there and not live there
When there are so many women who are single mothers either because their marriages are broken or they are widowed and they are in real world bringing up their children on their own.
CVs here made Anandi go to BH under ridiculous pretensions and the story never works.I hope the viewers teach a big lesson to these arrogant writers
Even if they want to show J Dsa bonding with Anandi - there is never any need for her to continue to live in that house.
Less said about the kidnapped baby never being found story the better it will be
Nandini and Shivam my interest on them depends on the fact whether I can see Anandi and Shiv in them otherwise they are just some characters which I can't even connect to right now.
Don't understand how the writers thought they could make Anandi live with the family which had been her sasural when she was child and still make her fight against child marriage.
The reason for Anandi fighting child marriage was because how her child marriage turned out to be and how it left scars on her and she continues stay in the place that had given her those never healing wounds?
---------------
I really hope they show Shivam and Anandi bonding - because this seems the only natural relationship she has in her life now - A mother and son relationship and at least let her son know that he had a great father even if he has never known so that he won't feel like an orphan.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: tellygeek



Totally agree Aparna, this is the comment I heard from elderly ladies of my house yesterday while watching the episode.

This is what Vijaya
Message is just not coming across - I am terribly pissed off with the writers but I do believe that they don't endorse child marriage and they are showing all the ill effects of child marriage
They want to show the bonding between J A is because they have known each other for years and grew up together therefore it is like a bond between two people who were friends from the time they were kids but where is the need to show them remembering those days when they were married?
They want to show that J A are better off as friends rather than life partners because they realised that they are not meant to be life partners.
Kundan and Nandini won't be at peace with each other until they realise that thye are not meant to be husband and wife at that age.
There could be much better ways to make this point.
Anandi should be leading her own life and BH people their own lives and helping out each other like friends and well wishers do in times of need or getting together once in a while and that's how it should be.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#43
Jagya and anandi and ganga are comfortable with one another. there is no awkwardness between them. Even Jagya reminiscing is from a comfort level that nothing can change their present day equation. If Ganga can tolerate anandi's physical presence on a daily basis, Jagya reminiscing wont make any difference. Here I must applaud Ganga.

Shivam can connect with Jagya too as Jagya is so nice to Shivam. It should be like Nandu Jagya relationship. I dont understand why Abhimanyu and Shivam are portrayed as antagonists? I want to see Jagya and Shiv type of relationship or friendship between them.

Anandi will never forget Shiv. She sees Shiv in everything that is good and just. She may not be that expressive now but I dont think she will ever forget even his fraction of memories.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

Jagya and anandi and ganga are comfortable with one another. there is no awkwardness between them. Even Jagya reminiscing is from a comfort level that nothing can change their present day equation. If Ganga can tolerate anandi's physical presence on a daily basis, Jagya reminiscing wont make any difference. Here I must applaud Ganga.

Shivam can connect with Jagya too as Jagya is so nice to Shivam. It should be like Nandu Jagya relationship. I dont understand why Abhimanyu and Shivam are portrayed as antagonists? I want to see Jagya and Shiv type of relationship or friendship between them.

Anandi will never forget Shiv. She sees Shiv in everything that is good and just. She may not be that expressive now but I dont think she will ever forget even his fraction of memories.

Jagya Shiv - type relationship didn't happen straight away - It started off on a wrong note and only because of Shiv's respect for Dsa and Singhs made Shiv to reach out to Jagya in between all these there was a teeny weeny bit of insecurity in Shiv when he saw Anandi's concern towards J and once he was very sure of all the equations he became comfortable with J
And of course Anandi showed him in many ways how her feelings for him were so different as when compared to what she feels towards J. A lot of work went into making Jagya and Shiv relationship - how can we forget how Jagya tried to ruin Shiv's career Anandi's life with Shiv tried to get her to break off with Shiv and marry him?
So it is unrealistic to expect Abhimanyu Shivam bonding - There may be rivalry simply because J is soft towards Shivam out of compassion for that fatherless displaced child and Abhimanyu may take it as his father liking Shivam more.
Ganga also in order to keep Abhimanyu in check seems to indulge Shivam

All these things do matter.

All said and done I'd rather see Shivam taking his OWN father as an inspiration and may be J helping the boy become like the man that his OWN father had been.If at all they want to show how selfless friendship can be they can show Jagya helping Shivam to be a son a man like Shiv would be proud of.
-----------------------
Anandi Shiv relationship - Yes Anandi wouldn't ever forget Shiv and she may not express them like we as a viewers who have seen this beautiful relationship evolve with time and how it got better and better.
CVs did invest a lot to showcase this relationship and this is the kind of relationship and the love that went into building this would not fade away but it does become a huge source of strength even after the death of one partner.That's how it happens in real life too.
I have seen this kind of marriage in real life too.Yes the surviving partner did not cry or spent all the time remembering the dead spouse and instead got busy raising her children but all her own happiness came from those memories she had of her husband and she used to work hard to give the kind of life her husband would have given to their children.
This is what we would expect to see in case of Anandi and Shiv love story and their marriage.
Anandi is not the type to ignore her duties and wallow in her past but there should be a way to show that love amounts to something in her life.
Otherwise it just feels like the only thing that her husband contributed to her life was the twins.
We know it was not like that and a marriage is not just for the sake of producing kids but it is about sharing and comapnionship too which could be shown very well through Anandi wanting to share her happiness worries and sadness regarding their children with her husband who is not there physically
tellygeek thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

Jagya and anandi and ganga are comfortable with one another. there is no awkwardness between them. Even Jagya reminiscing is from a comfort level that nothing can change their present day equation. If Ganga can tolerate anandi's physical presence on a daily basis, Jagya reminiscing wont make any difference. Here I must applaud Ganga.

Shivam can connect with Jagya too as Jagya is so nice to Shivam. It should be like Nandu Jagya relationship. I dont understand why Abhimanyu and Shivam are portrayed as antagonists? I want to see Jagya and Shiv type of relationship or friendship between them.

Anandi will never forget Shiv. She sees Shiv in everything that is good and just. She may not be that expressive now but I dont think she will ever forget even his fraction of memories.



Yes, Ganga should be applauded. She is now a doctor and looks good in her new look. She has come a long way.

Anandi can never forget Shiv, that's true. But I would want to see her remembering him expressively from time to time, and Shivam should know what a fabulous father he had ! Hope they show us such scenes as well. Anandi should also recollect the happiest moments of her life and narrate them to Shivam. I miss Shivraj Shekhar very much. So CVs have been successul in creating that void and making the viewers feel it. But that's more to do with the bond that we established with AnSh.
tanvismile thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#46
Cvs aren't at fault here, shiv is no more part of show so they don't show his FBs, when a track comes up; like abhi taunting Shivam about his father due to jealousy. That time Shivam might inquire of shiv.
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#47
Anandi is nothing if not expressive
Its a bit odd to see that when Anandi wanted to feel motivated she uses to remember her past with Jagya with all the humilation, she used to constantly remember Jagya and their happy moments in lonliness or during so festival...it stucks me odd that she did not recall Shiv much when there has been so many moments in her life to do so...if CVs are good at showing JaAn's memories then why not AnSh's...surely that relationship matters more to Anandi than her former one.
Anandi might be daughter of Singhs but at the same time she is Jagya's ex and since Anandi has already shown her discomfort about living with her ex then its quiet clear that all this BH-Anandi frndship is actually forced.
Besides Anandi had Bhaili in Udaipur and her husband's house then why does she need Singhs for any kind of support that is more than emotional...CVs are unable to complete anything related to Anandi...everything she ever did or had is stuck in middle or is incomplete...due their their illogical reasons to show Anandi as a girl for everyone they have made a complete mess of her own life...Bhaili is now without her direct support and in same way they had made her leave her school midway...her marriage is incomplete with Shiv n her family is incomplete without Nandini...has she really achieved anything complete in her life?...they could have shown her happy with shiv, amol and twins in udaipur where she is handling her Bhaili and taking care of her family plus she has been successful in eradicating all the negativity bal vivah gave her in her life.
this story is incomplete...she lost her husband, her house, her Bhaili and is trying to rebuild her life once again in Jaitsar...she took 5 steps of progress in her life and now took 10 steps backward by coming back to Jaitsar...her life is again affected by bal vivah even if indirectly...whats the point? Again she will leave all this for some other majboori! The message is that once a balika vadhu will alway be under the curse of bal vivah...whats the use of moving on when her life is back to square one...had anandi lived independently in udaipur then at least we would seen some progress despite the incompleteness...a divorcee anandi had singhs but a widow anandi has become mature enough to live her life on her own terms.
I cannot compare Dadisa with Anandi becoz Dadiaa had no one to help plus the burden of two kids...she had a life far more difficult than Anandi and yet she made it...her life story is far more inspiring
Anandi is said to be a strong character but whats the use of such strenght that might help the society but is useless when it comes to living her own life...CVs has always done one wrong thing tht is they have shown Anandi's strenght is good for others but useless for her own good. This stupid theory started after AnSh's marriage otherwise i used to appreciate Anandi as a divorcee...god knows why such a downfall for this character after her remarriage?
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: tellygeek



Yes, Ganga should be applauded. She is now a doctor and looks good in her new look. She has come a long way.

Anandi can never forget Shiv, that's true. But I would want to see her remembering him expressively from time to time, and Shivam should know what a fabulous father he had ! Hope they show us such scenes as well. Anandi should also recollect the happiest moments of her life and narrate them to Shivam. I miss Shivraj Shekhar very much. So CVs have been successul in creating that void and making the viewers feel it. But that's more to do with the bond that we established with AnSh.

CVs have been successful in creating that void and making the viewers feel it. That means AnandiShiv love story and Shivraj Shekhar;s character have worked well.
But now if only the viewers feel the void and Anandi not shown feeling the void means that the CVs have failed big time or implying that AnandiShiv marriage and Anandi's love for Shiv don't mean much to Anandi.
This is the same Anandi who has been so dedicated to her marriage to Jagya even if she didn't know the meaning of marriage and had no idea what husband and wife relationship is all about.
There was that moment shown in Anandi Shiv's wedding where Anandi had been shown reflecting over the wedding vows taken during those Saat Phere around the fire.She was shown telling herself that this is what she had been doing from the time she married Jagya.
-------------
How can a woman who gives her all to all her relationships is not shown missing this great relationship she had with Shiv?
Even when she is senseless like the time she was drunk on Bhang or the infamous drug drama only thing that was there in her mind was Shiv - He was shown to be that deeply entrenched in her mind and heart and suddenly the man dies and she is shown moving on so smoothly and never remember him at all? How is that possible?
It is not just because I am so fond of AnSh or because I miss Shiv but it doesn;t make sense from story point of view too.

leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
It is not anandi's fault. She tries to adjust and make the best use of what she is given.

Anandi had to deal with Sanchi, Ira and DB in Shiv's house. Yet she adjusted and went on in life inspite of her personal pain.

In BH she adjusted when Gauri was there and she adjusted with Gehna and Sumitra when they turned briefly against her.

If she can forgive Dadisa who almost drove her to desperation, why cant she forgive Jagya who was good to her in her childhood, turned bad for a while and again became good with her?

As for remembering Shiv, she can remember him by thinking about the kids. At present, losing a small child Nandini whose fate is so uncertain will occupy her thoughts than the memories of Shiv.
If she remembers those sweet moments of hers with Shiv, it will be doing injustice to Nandini. For me, motherhood comes before everything else.

Memories of Jagya have no significance in her life except likening them to Nandini's life at present as balikavadhu.
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

It is not anandi's fault. She tries to adjust and make the best use of what she is given.

Anandi had to deal with Sanchi, Ira and DB in Shiv's house. Yet she adjusted and went on in life inspite of her personal pain.

In BH she adjusted when Gauri was there and she adjusted with Gehna and Sumitra when they turned briefly against her.

If she can forgive Dadisa who almost drove her to desperation, why cant she forgive Jagya who was good to her in her childhood, turned bad for a while and again became good with her?

As for remembering Shiv, she can remember him by thinking about the kids. At present, losing a small child Nandini whose fate is so uncertain will occupy her thoughts than the memories of Shiv.
If she remembers those sweet moments of hers with Shiv, it will be doing injustice to Nandini. For me, motherhood comes before everything else.

Memories of Jagya have no significance in her life except likening them to Nandini's life at present as balikavadhu.

oh...motherhood of anandi! Ya i remember tht
unfortunately that motherhood didn't made it to top in her priority list while helping Pooja or else Nandini would have been in Singapore now

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".