groucho thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Some loved what Anandi said on the stand and some thought she left details of Jagya's past out.

This is what I believe and know a little about the law.

Firstly...it is up to the Shekhars lawyer as the prosecutor and the police to find out everything about Jagya... how else did the police know about them? After that they asked Shiv and sent summons to Anandi...must have done their own research to find Gauri as nobody knew where she was not even Jagya...once that was done...it is not difficult to find out all the other details.

Secondly...it is the correct thing for a witness to only answer what is asked of her...it is not her job to put words into the mouth of the lawyer...prosecution or defense...however Defense would have used the redirect questions wisely in Jagya's favor so I think prosecution only thought to ask what suited them. A big mistake on his part

Thirdly...a good prosecutor would have asked the right, awkward and difficult questions if he wanted to ...Jagya was questioned thoroughly so why not Anandi...that again was the prosecutor's mistake!!!! I think the Shekhars lawyer was so sure he had the case in the bag that he was lax...that is his problem not Anandi's.

I have had issues with Anandi's character in the past for being too docile when it comes to herself and a tigress when fighting for others...BUT in this case she was absolutely SPOT ON and correct.

Finally what Ira did was witness tampering...that is punishable by law...but I guess we will never see THAT happen.

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

3.8k

Users

12

Likes

77

Frequent Posters

adorablegirl thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Even Anandis answer to Shiv earlier in the night was spot on what her character is like.
After a long time I was happy Anandi was true to her character just like she says to all the other women.

I really hope she talks about the bribe to pandit too. i know its not in Anandis nature to bring up unnessary things against people but it is a big statement on Sanchis law breaking, lying behavior. CVs have carefully forgotten about that issue. they have even made Shiv not say anything about it. everyone needs to know about it
Dihiva thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail The Rang-Rasa Cronicles Winner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
Absolutely right! Anandi did what she always does.. answer truthfully and avoid digging up unnecessary past details which would be of no use except create troubles for a man who has evolved from his mistakes and trying to lead a better righteous life. Moreover, it is the PP's duty to ask the right questions.
And the Shekar's themselves confessed to the officer in the hospital that Jagya was a good person and never treated Saanchi badly when he questioned them after Saanchi's suicide. So, why should Anandi say anything now?!
Firstpref thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: groucho

Some loved what Anandi said on the stand and some thought she left details of Jagya's past out.

This is what I believe and know a little about the law.

Firstly...it is up to the Shekhars lawyer as the prosecutor and the police to find out everything about Jagya... how else did the police know about them? After that they asked Shiv and sent summons to Anandi...must have done their own research to find Gauri as nobody knew where she was not even Jagya...once that was done...it is not difficult to find out all the other details.

Secondly...it is the correct thing for a witness to only answer what is asked of her...it is not her job to put words into the mouth of the lawyer...prosecution or defense...however Defense would have used the redirect questions wisely in Jagya's favor so I think prosecution only thought to ask what suited them. A big mistake on his part

Thirdly...a good prosecutor would have asked the right, awkward and difficult questions if he wanted to ...Jagya was questioned thoroughly so why not Anandi...that again was the prosecutor's mistake!!!! I think the Shekhars lawyer was so sure he had the case in the bag that he was lax...that is his problem not Anandi's.

I have had issues with Anandi's character in the past for being too docile when it comes to herself and a tigress when fighting for others...BUT in this case she was absolutely SPOT ON and correct.

Finally what Ira did was witness tampering...that is punishable by law...but I guess we will never see THAT happen.


Yes Anandi answered what was asked of her - at last had the courage to speak out.

I hope that Ira gets punished - it is a criminal offence to try to threaten and intimidate a witness. She knows in her heart of hearts that this whole case is a farce, so is using this tactic with Anandi as a last resort. Shameful!
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
I agree.
I was not happy with the answer she gave.Not because I thought she was being biased in favour of Jagya but it looked like she gave an absolute clean chit which he did not deserve.
PP has called her as a witness in her capacity as Jagya's ex wife and he should have stuck to her marriage with Jagya and about what kind of a husband Jagya was and what was the reason behind the failure of the marriage.
But here he was asking her about what kind of a man she thinks Jagya is.She has answered that question.
She can only provide information by answering questions.It is upto the PP to get the information he needed from her.
PP has not gone about doing his job in a proper well thought out manner.
groucho thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: adorablegirl

Even Anandis answer to Shiv earlier in the night was spot on what her character is like.

After a long time I was happy Anandi was true to her character just like she says to all the other women.

I really hope she talks about the bribe to pandit too. i know its not in Anandis nature to bring up unnessary things against people but it is a big statement on Sanchis law breaking, lying behavior. CVs have carefully forgotten about that issue. they have even made Shiv not say anything about it. everyone needs to know about it


Oh the bribing fiasco will come out...once Shiv realises Saanchi's lies. Shekhars and Singhs will know.
But I personally am glad it did not come out in court because it is always easy to turn that into. ..." Saanchi was sooo in love with Jagya that she bribed the pandit to get engaged then married to him"
Then they would have to call the pundit. ...that would not have helped Jagya.
But yes...all her lies should get exposed to both families. ..specially Shekhars and dear old screaming Sumitra.
Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
I think Prosecuting Lawyer misjudged Anandi and the situation surrounding as well. He seems to have thought that ex-wife will surely bad mouth Jagya and jagya can be implicated easily. Despite Kabra's strong arguments shekhar's lawyer seemed confident, maybe because he expected anandi to say bad about Jagya. He should have enquired about all this before putting her on the stand.
Pehchaan.Kaun thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
I was mad at Shiv for stating facts selectively..
And with Anandi's reply to Shiv while depicting Jagya's truth in the court, it was a BANG ON reply to her egoistic husband 🥳 I have no more problems with Shiv's answers now.. Anandi has given him back ..
However, Anandi's clean chit to Jagya's character was a bit surprising.. But as I am favoring Jagya in this case pretty badly, I am happy with such blatant answer of Anandi which leaves no scope for prosecution to grill her 🥳
Way to go Anandi.. Jagya is a changed man now, and he totally deserves such character certificate from people 🥳
charuluv_SV thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
well done Anandi👍🏼
i start to like u for the first time😃
charuluv_SV thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Sunna_Deewani

I think Prosecuting Lawyer misjudged Anandi and the situation surrounding as well. He seems to have thought that ex-wife will surely bad mouth Jagya and jagya can be implicated easily. Despite Kabra's strong arguments shekhar's lawyer seemed confident, maybe because he expected anandi to say bad about Jagya. He should have enquired about all this before putting her on the stand.

Absolutely right,PP is stunned with Anandi's answer😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".