Why so suddenly? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

52

Views

5.9k

Users

22

Likes

211

Frequent Posters

leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Shinya

No I dont find Ira wrong today .. Ira had initially asked Anandi for her opinion about this rishta. At that time, she kept mum. She rather said jagya is now a reformed man.

And now suddenly she announces loudly in front of all that this rishta is not good, that too after shagun is given ?... any woman would get angry at that silly behaviour of her bahu..

If she thought that rishta wasnt good enough, she should have put her foot down right in the beginning.



Anandi thought that Jagya will refuse and that will end the matter. Jagya's decision took her by surprise.
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves



Anandi thought that Jagya will refuse and that will end the matter. Jagya's decision took her by surprise.

why assume? Why not double check? And in the end if J does not have problem marrying Sa, then what is A's problem?
Anandi is doing wrong things at wrong time
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#23
I don't mind Ira getting furious with A, because A is wrong.
What is the point in telling all this now? If she wanted she could have stopped earlier. Anandi always knew that SaJa won't work because of compatibilty issues. So she should brought this up before Shekhars taking rishta to Singhs. And she should have let them make their decision.
Anandi chose to remain a mute spectator then (I don't blame her because matter was delicate), so why open up now, when the engagemnet has happened. If she had chosen to watch the game unfold, then let her watch it completely, why speak up now?
If she was so concerned about J's life she should have talked to him in advance, to help him out.
Anandi does not know how to handle delicate matters. She always complicates simple matters.
Anyways it was the decision of the heads of the two families and they are more at fault than A. So let them handle their own 'bachon ki khushi' in their own way. There is no need for A to jump in now. It will definately go against her. And Ira wlill think that A is not happy with Sa's happiness. It's natural for mothers to think that way.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#24
Initially when Sanchi threw this bomb on their faces they all got mad because they felt that of all people she has chosen to fall in love with Jagya and started abusing his character and started to say that he trapped her.

In defense of Jagya's character both Anandi and Shiv spoke up saying he is not like that and he is not the type to trap her.Sanchi also confirmed that it was not Jagya but it is she who is in love with him and he is unaware of her feelings.

At that time itself Ira had asked Anandi if she would like to see Sanchi get married to Jagya and she said NO SHE DID NOT WANT TO SEE THIS MARRIAGE HAPPENING.She has not changed her mind since then.

She kept protesting since then but it was Shiv who told her to let go of it and let it take it's own course.

Shekhars went to BH botched it up and presented themselves to Singhs like they are desperate to see SaJa get married when it was exactly the opposite thing they wanted to convey.

Singhs despite not being keen they didn't want to hurt the feelings so they ended up saying yes.
In all this .

In all this how could she open her mouth and tell them anything?

How can she warn Jagya when Sanchi herself has not confessed her feelings for him?

They all went there expecting J to refuse but he was not given a full picture so he said yes.

A doesn't know that J said yes because of her.

They all have seen for themsleves how Sanchi was behaving How J was reacting to Sanchi and they all have noticed how unsuitable they are for each other.

Nobody is willing to accept the truth.

If she says that they should call off the wedding I don't think there is anything wrong in it.It is better to call off a wedding than see a marriage break later on.

Any ways we don't really know under what circumstances she told Ira that they should break off the wedding.

Why is Ira angry with Anandi????She should be angry with herself for doing such a pathetic job of bringing up her daughter.It is very obvious that she only indulged her daughter's wishes and never actually sat and talked with her or listened to her.
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: aparnauma

Initially when Sanchi threw this bomb on their faces they all got mad because they felt that of all people she has chosen to fall in love with Jagya and started abusing his character and started to say that he trapped her.


In defense of Jagya's character both Anandi and Shiv spoke up saying he is not like that and he is not the type to trap her.Sanchi also confirmed that it was not Jagya but it is she who is in love with him and he is unaware of her feelings.

At that time itself Ira had asked Anandi if she would like to see Sanchi get married to Jagya and she said NO SHE DID NOT WANT TO SEE THIS MARRIAGE HAPPENING.She has not changed her mind since then.

She kept protesting since then but it was Shiv who told her to let go of it and let it take it's own course.

Shekhars went to BH botched it up and presented themselves to Singhs like they are desperate to see SaJa get married when it was exactly the opposite thing they wanted to convey.

Singhs despite not being keen they didn't want to hurt the feelings so they ended up saying yes.
In all this .

In all this how could she open her mouth and tell them anything?

How can she warn Jagya when Sanchi herself has not confessed her feelings for him?

They all went there expecting J to refuse but he was not given a full picture so he said yes.

A doesn't know that J said yes because of her.

They all have seen for themsleves how Sanchi was behaving How J was reacting to Sanchi and they all have noticed how unsuitable they are for each other.

Nobody is willing to accept the truth.

If she says that they should call off the wedding I don't think there is anything wrong in it.It is better to call off a wedding than see a marriage break later on.

Any ways we don't really know under what circumstances she told Ira that they should break off the wedding.

Why is Ira angry with Anandi????She should be angry with herself for doing such a pathetic job of bringing up her daughter.It is very obvious that she only indulged her daughter's wishes and never actually sat and talked with her or listened to her.



Anandi is not wrong in rejecting sanchi as a bride for Jagya because she knows, assumes, thinks that Jagya's decision is wrong. No one in their right mind will go for sanchi as she is now, a manipulating, hysterical go getter.
monamie111 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#26
yes...i was also very happy with ashima's entry..but now not sure why she is leaving again 😕...but i think CVs will show mahi & ashima again..may be they will be doing same project 😆
and i also didn't understand why Ira was so angry...Ira herself was opposing this marriage...now when anandi is bringing one point can't she listen to her that why she is telling this?..anandi is also a family member now...but i think i shouldn't comment more before watching the episode...
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#27
I think AShima's entry and exit is to lay a foundation to Mahi -Ashima relationship.

She probably will get over Shiv with the help of Mahi and probably Mahi will make her realise that Shiv was never hers to begin with and also make her that realise that she never really loved Shiv in the first place.

Ashima probably will make Mahi realise that all his girl friends who fell for Shiv were not actually meant for him.
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Aparna, when did Anandi say that she does not want Saja. She just defended saying that J is of good character and wouldn't go cheap to impress Saanchi. Which later got clarified by both Shiv and Saanchi.

Basically Anandi never expressed clearly to anyone (except Shiv) that she does not want to SaJa to happen. She was just a mute spectator, neither here nor there, even though when she had a clear mind-set that SaJa should not happen.

I honestly don't blame A for not opening up her mouth earlier. She was in a tough situation. But what's the point in opening up her mouth now?

The bigger fault here lies with Shekhars, for passing their ball onto J's shoulders for saying yes or no, then of course Singhs for getting hasty and then Jagya for blurting a yes. It is after all his life so he should have thought through. So all are at fault.

Anandi is at least fault. But her going and telling Ira now, is not appropriate either. Jab itna jaanti thi to pehle hi bol deti. It would have been more impactful then, but when she chose to keep quiet then, then why does she need to speak now. It is not a mess she created so why is taking the burden? And for J, if he is ok with Sa (since he has agreed for the marriage), then what is A's problem? Let him sort out his life his way.

Anyways as you said we need to watch the epis regarding Ira- An convo before coming to conclusion.

But from what I gauged, A wants SaJa break up because she has figured out that G loves him. That's not the appropriate reason. So what if there was no G, would she have agreed to SaJa?

GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#29
Esha - when Anandi started to defend Jagya's character Ira jumped on her and asked her if she thinks it is ok to see Sanchi marrying Jagya.then Anandi told Ira that she also holds the same views as them wrt Jagya Sanchi marriage and said they are not suitable for each other.She stuck to that line.Shiv said this kind of decisions should not be made in haste he was the one who sat on the fence from the begining.

It is the senior Shekhars who changed their line and decided to go to Jaitser and she was not even included in that decision making process.

Then also she told Shiv she is against it and he told her to sit back and watch.

Here Singhs also did not include her in the decision making process.They could be excused because they have not seen real Sanchi.Anandi does not know the reason for their saying yes.She only thinks that they said yes because they liked Sanchi.

So should she butt in and give her opinion?Would they have accepted it?
Did she not try and convince Sumi that Sanchi will not be suitable DIL?Sumi has gone blind deaf.How can she convince Suni without bad mouthing Sanchi?She can only say that Sanchi's upbringing is different they will have adjustment problems.

Even to Ira she only said they are not suited for each other.Will that change if Ganga was not in picture?



Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#30
Aprana, I am not blaming Anandi for anything. It was not her fault that Shekhars took rishta to Singhs and Singhs accepted it.
She even does not know why J said yes, so when everyone is ok (on surface), and when Anandi's opinion was not asked by either parties, not even by Jagya then why does she have to butt in?And that too after the engagement is declared.
In my POV it does not make sense that she talks about it now. She did what she could, she explained to Saanchi and she hinted to Sumi. Now when others don't want her opinion, why is she giving it? Obviously Saanchi will feel bad to hear all this now after the engagement is done.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".