Shiv was too harsh towards his mother - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

126

Views

11.9k

Users

29

Likes

406

Frequent Posters

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#71

Originally posted by: JuhiRockz

Redapple, Libs,


Well said. I lost all respect for Ira today. She should have apologized on behalf of her Bahu to UD and discussed this matter behind closed doors. I for sure don't see any class in Ira Aloke Shekhar.





What Ira's samdhan sa Kalyani Devi did was even more shameless. And she did it in public place unlike Ira who spoke at her own house.

There is also no class in her samdhan sa, son and DIL who lied to her and kept her in dark, taking her for granted and expecting they'd lead her any way they wanted to.

If a mother feels angry at slandering of her son then she has no class. If she is angry and feels betrayed at being lied to then she has no class. Great logic.

Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#72
Actually in today's episode, Ira's ire was seen to stem more from her perceived insecurity that her son is not supporting her the mum but his wife. She did not stress on the lie. She stressed on the fact that 'hamara Sikha Khota nikla because he is happy with his wife so what can we do'. And she still felt that Shiv lied and took the blame on himself to save his wife. She was more angry about that. Where was her trust on her son? She is like a pendulum because she is easily swayed by her wayward daughter, realizes her mistake, tries to make good and then makes the same mistake. Anandi has to constantly prove herself to Ira.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#73
@Parri

I did not say those who do not agree with "me" are MIL haters. There are a couple of others who had same views.

And my response is directed more at bashing of Ira. The sheer scale of it.

Madam this is true that MILs want docile DILs. But this is also true no one likes MILs or SILs and other hassle of in laws like devrani, jethani etc.

They fear it even before their time to marry comes.

And they all hope for an MIL who says nothing, or one who can be controlled or one who is no more at all.

Neither of MILs or DILs are saints in Indian society (or any society). There's always a tussle between them.
Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: Skepblun

@Parri

I did not say those who do not agree with "me" are MIL haters. There are a couple of others who had same views.

And my response is directed more at bashing of Ira. The sheer scale of it.

Madam this is true that MILs want docile DILs. But this is also true no one likes MILs or SILs and other hassle of in laws like devrani, jethani etc.

They fear it even before their time to marry comes.

And they all hope for an MIL who says nothing, or one who can be controlled or one who is no more at all.

Neither of MILs or DILs are saints in Indian society (or any society). There's always a tussle between them.


You did not say it but you implied it when you stated that 'you were not surprised by the tone of responses here' within the context that females are MIL haters. That's what I interpreted in your entire post.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: parri814

Actually in today's episode, Ira's ire was seen to stem more from her perceived insecurity that her son is not supporting her the mum but his wife. She did not stress on the lie. She stressed on the fact that 'hamara Sikha Khota nikla because he is happy with his wife so what can we do'. And she still felt that Shiv lied and took the blame on himself to save his wife. She was more angry about that. Where was her trust on her son? She is like a pendulum because she is easily swayed by her wayward daughter, realizes her mistake, tries to make good and then makes the same mistake. Anandi has to constantly prove herself to Ira.



Ira is making assumptions because Anandi and Shiv were and are still being foolish in not teling truth to her. Explain calmly what happened. Then she will shut up!

Why should she still trust her son now if she has found he's been lying to her to shield his wife and her family? Her trust was broken by him!

Anandi has to constantly prove herself to Ira because she is still more loyal to Singhs than Shekhars and she is not entirely open & honest with Shekhars.

And she's also inviting more trouble for herself in future by continuing to remain in touch with ex husband while she is stil new in Shekhar family and is to make her place there!

In trying to shield her DS, Anandi failed to be honest to her MIL.

Even now she's sitting and moping in her room with Shiv instead of taking immediate steps to talk to MIL. She did not even try to talk to Ira!

Her action should have been swift. Her silence again indicates how much priority she gives to Shekhars.
Tulasi14 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#76
I love my. MIL and also hate at the same time.you really need lot of patience.She drains my energy.if she Is wrong I correct her and viceversa!
Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#77
Poor Anandi is still learning how to navigate her way around her new family and she is already being accused of controlling her saas.
JuhiR thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: Skepblun



What Ira's samdhan sa Kalyani Devi did was even more shameless. And she did it in public place unlike Ira who spoke at her own house.

There is also no class in her samdhan sa, son and DIL who lied to her and kept her in dark, taking her for granted and expecting they'd lead her any way they wanted to.

If a mother feels angry at slandering of her son then she has no class. If she is angry and feels betrayed at being lied to then she has no class. Great logic.


Could not she have discussed it behind closed doors? Was it nice of her to call her own DIL a BV and a divorcee? No one is justifying DS here, but Anandi has no role in it. She confessed the incident to Shiv, but Shiv stopped her from telling his family. Ira being the elder, should not she use some judgement? At least to chide her DIL in private? Now Anandi and Shiv are married, and they love each other. At least Ira could have heard out Anandi before pronouncing a judgement? If she had all the time and patience to hear out Saanchi and UD, she should have given few minutes of time to Anandi to explain herself? Is this justice? Is not she blinded? Just because she is the mother of Shiv, she cannot take the liberty to insult his wife.

I am not saying that she does not have class because she is showing her anger and hurt. I am saying she should have used better judgement because she is older, she is Shiv's mother, and she is a MIL. Surely she could be restrained and not use the words Balikavadhu and divorcee to Anandi.

I find the logic to justify Ira's insensitive and crude behavior quite unique and strange!

As for class, Singhs are rural and old-fashioned people. DS did something totally wrong in her zeal to get Anandi married. But Singhs are not classless people. They are kind and in general good-hearted people. Yes, they are meddlesome, we do not like their interference in Anandi's life, but that is partly because of their rural upbringing. I am at times out of patience with them but no I do not find them jungly and classless.
Edited by JuhiRockz - 12 years ago
731627 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#79
in precap anandi speak lie for good to sumitra that everything is ok she hide her pain which means no matter ira sanchi has harsh feeling towards anandi but anandi still has soft corner for sanchi and mil .she does not want her sil mil to be down infront of singhs .she cares about respect of her sil mil
Edited by surabhi01 - 12 years ago
Jan50 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#80
I dont undertand this pendulum business. All of us are pendulums too. We praised Ira when she was nice and supportive to A but suddenly she becomes a typical bad saas the minute she is upset with
Anandi and her family. Skepblum is right. Here no body is looking at Ira's problem as a problem of
A human being who was hurt by her son. So what if she said A was a divorcee and Bv . This is
A choti soch but deliberately slandering some one for your own purpose is not chotinsoch but done
out of pure unadulterated love?.
Ira always readily accepted A for the sake of her son. But A's behaviour right from the begining is more like it is "for shiv and me , my Dadisa and mom come first". Ira is doing her best to cope up with that, but
Every time sme thing new turns up. People are saying things like Ira is interfering in the personal
Life of Shiv and A. Is being concerned about consummation of your kid interfering? Knowing the background of A? Comon guys we are not like westerners. Even among them something like this
Will bother the mother. If people think a person like Ira is interfering, then Shiv and A should have just
Eloped and got married and live separately only keeping relations with her DS.
What is Mahi the lakshman going to do? I would like to remind that Ram and Lakshman never disrespected their mothers ever if one made him go to the forest.
Any way party time for Anandi, now that her crying is over.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".