Lets not Absolve Child Marriage

NoOne12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
In Friday's episode a brilliant line was said by Anandi," We were married when we were kids. At that time the only bond we understood with others was of friendship. Love is something that we understand as an adult. And when I experienced it, you went away".
Whatever criticism we give to Jagiya, we cannot completely absolve Child marriage from this mess. Childhood is not the time of understanding the bond of marriage or feelings of love, or the deep attachment , the emotional baggage that comes with it". These are the things better understood in adulthood. Thus only as adults we can understand who we want as our soulmate, and what we want from our life, our goals, ambitions etc. Childhood cannnot be a time to define this!
I have to agree with the story teller, and the irony of the series is this. Adultery or realizing that you love someone as an adult is the best critique of Bal Vivah. And yes the worst sufferer is always the woman. Jagiya too is a victim, he cannot think of marrying Gauri, who he considers to be a better soulmate (!????) because the strong bond of marriage that tied him as a kid. He cannot move out. Though I do believe he could have resisted the adultery, but yes to be tied to this relationship as a kid is unfair.
The series depiction of Anandi's suffering is to be appaulded. A woman's suffering in this relationship is worse. A man like Jagiya can move out, can reject a woman. But can a woman do the same? Can she use the pretex of child marriage? When Jagiya committed adultery, the maximum society did was laugh at the woman, critize the man. But what if a woman dares it...
The next thing we know is the worst condemantion by the society. [I can already imagine crowds running after her ( in the villages)].
Thus Bal Vivah not just curtails man's right, but also woman's right to a good partner. Anandi never deserved Jagiya, a man who never understood her qualities. Our soulmates are suppose to lift us not break us, like Jagya tried. So by critiquing Bal Vivah I am not just defending Jagya's right to choose a soulmate but also Anandi's.
Childhood is not the time of marriage, but of happiness and carefree life. So lets not forget Bal Vivah, even though Jagya's actions are condemable, this is the irony, it is also the biggest critique of Bal Vivah.

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.5k

Users

10

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

bipasha01 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
even today in cities also, people are biased to women. Society cannot bear that a woman can stand out nd make her own grounds. she s always associated with a man who can TAKE CARE of her nt realising that she needs a soulmate not a caretaker. i donno hw mny will agree bt even today there s a difference in attitude of parents 2wards der daughtr nd son. I am nt tellin dat dey luv daughtr less bt ders a diffrence.
NoOne12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: bipasha01

even today in cities also, people are biased to women. Society cannot bear that a woman can stand out nd make her own grounds. she s always associated with a man who can TAKE CARE of her nt realising that she needs a soulmate not a caretaker. i donno hw mny will agree bt even today there s a difference in attitude of parents 2wards der daughtr nd son. I am nt tellin dat dey luv daughtr less bt ders a diffrence.

But in cities the attitudes have changed. I am seeing a lot of adultery and divorces and in most cases we choose not to interfere. We don't care about other person's personal life. Adutery can make make woman maximum a target of gossip, but nothing like crowds chasing her. In fact child marriages are more rampant in villages, I don't think metro's it happens! So I highlighted the aspect more in rural areas
bipasha01 thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: avantikasharma1

But in cities the attitudes have changed. I am seeing a lot of adultery and divorces and in most cases we choose not to interfere. We don't care about other person's personal life. Adutery can make make woman maximum a target of gossip, but nothing like crowds chasing her. In fact child marriages are more rampant in villages, I don't think metro's it happens! So I highlighted the aspect more in rural areas


Yah I totally agree wid u in cities it is nt evn 1% cmpared 2 rural areas. I am jst tellin dat deep in the minds of society sumwhere there s still a block which is more extensive in villages. In cities it is much much more improved but we cannot say dat it is absent. I belong frm a metro city nd at tyms I do face few thngs which proves dis.
NoOne12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
@bipasha:
Yes I want to accept your one point of difference in treatment of boy and girl. It exists even in urban areas. I remember once the woman's cell of my university did a reaserch in areas around Delhi and Delhi. They found startling attitude. Families see girl child as a burden and discriminate in her upbringing . There are areas like education, pocket money and sometimes medicine (😲)where family may be hesistant to spend money! Its alarming attitude.
Edited by avantikasharma1 - 13 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Very well put. together thoughts.Completely agree with you.😊
CoffeeCake thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
What I think about jagya is bal vivah was just an excuse to save his image and prove that he has not committed any mistake as he is victim of child marriage. Case of jagya and gauri is more about infidelity and less about child marriage.


NoOne12 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: -ASTHA-

What I think about jagya is bal vivah was just an excuse to save his image and prove that he has not committed any mistake as he is victim of child marriage. Case of jagya and gauri is more about infidelity and less about child marriage.



But we have to concede choice of a soulmate is best understood as an adult. Even though I do not justify Jagiya, I couldn't help feeling the idea of child marriage is equally responsible. The bond is very strong. Yes we do meet people at colleges and many of my friends are married to their college mates and are happy. This choice does work against Jagiya, he had accepted Anandi after adulthood, and that too afetr living for 5 years away. But being married at a young age is unfair too.
Patrarekha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
both anandi and jagiya were victim of bal vivah..but child marriage is not only responsible for anandi's pain..because jagiya after growing up loved (atleast pretended) anandi..otherwise who had physical relationship with childhood friend??Gauri was better choise for him(not true love what he claims😆)..jagia never learnt to love..that's why he doesn't deserve anandi...which was not understood in child marriage

i thought jagiya had right to move on from that relationship..but he should have told that earlier whenever he realized that..but instead that coward started insulting and abusing Anandi..

but society has always blamed woman for everything..even in metros too a divorcee woman has to bear unnecessary curiosity
Anurulz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
see i would see jagya as a victim TILL he decided to cheat both women..if child marriage was responsible for the mess, thn its acceptable tht he fell for gauri and would want to end his marriage wid anandi in a RESPECTFUL manner..not make anandi feel inferior or crush her self esteem to bits and pieces the way he did..there was one dialogue a million years back when gauri was 🤔 "sensible".. tht such people want to enjoy their lives wid their girlfriends in the city while their child- wives are at home taking care of their parents.. (where did tht gauri disappear, i wonder?).. tht is the basic issue i have wid jagya..he had no fricking right to cheat on anandi..am always for one's personal choice in mates, and so i agree wid jagya abt his right to choose a mate..bt the least one can do is end his previous relation in a decent and respectful manner..and defo not in the way jagya did..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".