Jagiya to call off his marriage-Article - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

61

Views

10.5k

Users

21

Likes

190

Frequent Posters

Mayavi-26 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21

plse cv,s i dosent want anandi to try to win back jagya, she dosent deserve a husband like this loser y shd a women stay with such a loser man, she needs to leave him immediately and move on in her life as soon as possible

she shd be independent i know sh eis licky to have in laws as bhairav and sumitra they r really very supporting in laws.
but now plse cv put anandi out of these relationship how long will she take this verbal abusement frm her husband
Edited by maya.sethi17 - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: iloveidiotbox

Sorry to say guys, but I don't agree. Its not a child marriage issue anymore. It may have been if as adults Jagya had not accepted his marriage. Hypothetically, lets say Jagya got married to Anandi the day she turned 18 and everything else in the story happened the way it did, then wouldn't Jagya be guilty of infidelity?
The true victim of child marriage are Phooli and Gauri. Even though Anandi and Jagya were married as children, even as adults, they whole heartedly accepted the relationship. Now that Jagya is allergic to everything rural, he doesn't want village bumpkin Anandi anymore. No matter how cute they look, I hate Jagya-Gauri relationship. The most vital value of any relationship is honesty, which is lacking here, so I hope Gauri never accepts him. Tomorrow if Jagya goes to US, will he find some American girl and diss Gauri for being an Indian, and would that be acceptable? Its the same case with Anandi right now.
I hope Singh family give up on Jagya and bring up Anandi as their daughter and probably train her in business like Maasa.



I agree with you......I stopped watching this show long back when they messed up the Shyam-Sugna track and post leap Jagya-Anandi were just never the JA that first were the soul of this show......but now I'm amazed reading the arguments in this forum justifying Jagya-Gauri's relationship and how chill everyone is in here with this😕

So just cuz JA had a child marriage, that gives Jagya the right to LIE so blatantly to EVERYONE and coolly walk off with another girl??? Just cuz they look "cute" together?? Amazing😆.....THIS is their way of showing the "evils of child marriage" Oh please gimme a break😆......they aren't kids anymore.....this is CHEATING, pure and simple.....this has NOTHING to do with their having had a child marriage.....last I saw a promo of this show, JA seemed to be pretty attracted to each other and about to consummate their marriage and stuff too and all of a sudden Jagya is in love with some random city bred chick?? Wow😆......so now affairs are also justified cuz JA were forced into a child marriage??? I don't think so.....the only time this show showed SOME logical tracks about the evils of child marriage were in it's first year......after that it's largely become nonsense.....and now the more I read about it, it sounds like PUTRID nonsense.
divmath thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: iloveidiotbox

Sorry to say guys, but I don't agree. Its not a child marriage issue anymore. It may have been if as adults Jagya had not accepted his marriage. Hypothetically, lets say Jagya got married to Anandi the day she turned 18 and everything else in the story happened the way it did, then wouldn't Jagya be guilty of infidelity?
The true victim of child marriage are Phooli and Gauri. Even though Anandi and Jagya were married as children, even as adults, they whole heartedly accepted the relationship. Now that Jagya is allergic to everything rural, he doesn't want village bumpkin Anandi anymore. No matter how cute they look, I hate Jagya-Gauri relationship. The most vital value of any relationship is honesty, which is lacking here, so I hope Gauri never accepts him. Tomorrow if Jagya goes to US, will he find some American girl and diss Gauri for being an Indian, and would that be acceptable? Its the same case with Anandi right now.
I hope Singh family give up on Jagya and bring up Anandi as their daughter and probably train her in business like Maasa.


Its all about how we look at it Priya ! as I see it, "child marriage" issue is very much present and whatever is being shown are the repercussions of this evil practice....Jagya never accepted his marriage (I dont think consummation is a proof of acceptance of marriage, it can be due to mere physical attraction, which was the case here)........coz he was never given a choice....according to me he was "made" to accept it since childhood...and since he was confined in his village with his family and friends following this custom..he went with the flow...whatever transpired between him and Anandi was merely due to his infatuation with her...coz he longed to be with his childhood buddy after those 5 years....and we have seen very clearly the only thing on his mind after Anandi's return to saasra was getting laid....I did not see any love there ! and hence once he moved out into a new world and met Gauri he realized he has options and eventually fell in love with her....if we go back and see he did try to avoid Gauri for a while...but finally gave in when he realized the depth of his feelings for her.....

Talking about the hypothetical situation that you mentioned, thats a totally different ball game and doesnt fit into this storyline ! Hypothesis can have two solutions or may be even more...depending on how people look at it and perspectives would definitely vary....Some of them in the forum feel Jagya loves Anandi and is attracted towards Gauri and hence what he is doing is wrong...some of them (like me) feel Jagya "never" loved Anandi and is very much in "love" with Gauri....hence, the above mentioned hypothesis can have two different solutions.....whether Jagya will be attracted towards other girls if he moves to US/UK or wherever is out of scope of this show, I believe....and its just our imagination...some think that he might get attracted to some other girl yet again and leave Gauri, while I think he will very much stay loyal to Gauri, because he finally found his true love....😊 Just a matter of looking at things from different angles !
kashish_s2 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
Hey guys. I understand what the JG relationship supporters are sayin and I understand what Jagya went through (child marriage) and all is cruel. but when they met, they were adults and they did take this relationship to the next level. whether it be due to physical attraction or love. it just doesnt matter as much cause the fact is that they did take it to the next level. Then he went and met Gauri and fell in love. Now we can argue if it is love or just a result of the sudden freedom. Again it doesnt matter cause the fact is that they do have a relationship. My point is that Jagys doesnt realise that Gauri fell in love with this present Jagya and no matter how much people run away from it, the past is important and Gauri therefore didnt fall in love with the real Jagya as she doesnt know his past. I think one of the real victims without her knowing it is Gauri. anyways so there are two facts and two decisions of Jagya in front of us. First being advancing in JA relationship and two relationship with Gauri. I think what everyone is sayin is that Jagya was an adult when he took his relationship with Anandi to the next level and it was his decisions therefore he should account for it even if it was lust. Evn if he has fallen in love with Gauri, shouldnt he have atleast taken responsibility of his decision again and told Anandi cause she does deserve the truth. She has tirelessly worked and taken care of his family and uphold her patni dharma. Didnt she deserve the truth and Gauri also. Thats my point guys? so I do think that Jagya is wrong. And if he gets married to Gauri then he's indeed definately wrong and no excuse of child marriage can excuse this.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: kashish_s2

Hey guys. I understand what the JG relationship supporters are sayin and I understand what Jagya went through (child marriage) and all is cruel. but when they met, they were adults and they did take this relationship to the next level. whether it be due to physical attraction or love. it just doesnt matter as much cause the fact is that they did take it to the next level. Then he went and met Gauri and fell in love. Now we can argue if it is love or just a result of the sudden freedom. Again it doesnt matter cause the fact is that they do have a relationship. I think what everyone is sayin is that Jagya was an adult when he took his relationship with Anandi to the next level and it was his decisions therefore he should account for it even if it was lust. Evn if he has fallen in love with Gauri, shouldnt he have atleast taken responsibility of his decision again and told Anandi cause she does deserve the truth. My point is that Jagys doesnt realise that Gauri fell in love with this present Jagya and no matter how much people run away from it, the past is important and Gauri therefore didnt fall in love with the real Jagya as she doesnt know his past. I think one of the real victims without her knowing it is Gauri. anyways so there are two facts and two decisions of Jagya in front of us. First being advancing in JA relationship and two relationship with Gauri. She has tirelessly worked and taken care of his family and uphold her patni dharma. Didnt she deserve the truth and Gauri also. Thats my point guys? so I do think that Jagya is wrong. And if he gets married to Gauri then he's indeed definately wrong and no excuse of child marriage can excuse this.



Good points.....Jagya sounds like the most disgusting ASS on the planet right now and CHILD MARRIAGE is the LAST excuse that should be used to justify his actions.....he has CHEATED on his wife, pure and simple.....an ADULT wife....this is not child's play.....and he is no child either.....he is full aware of what he is doing so let's stop justifying this in the name of the evils of child marriage.....then toh tomorrow every second man will come up with excuses of this sort....Oh I was 18 when I got married so obviously I HAVE to cheat on my wife by the the time I hit 25😕😆.....do men EVER grow up?? They can use the "I was a child when I got married" excuse for life that way, haan?😆

He is blatantly ruining two lives....doesn't matter how annoying grown version of Anandi is.....nobody deserves this kind of treatment.....I don't buy this "pure love" argument either.....he's cheating EVERYONE and is doing everything for his own selfish motives....where's the "love" in this?

This show has become SO disgusting that words also can't suffice....I sometimes wonder if Avika and Avinash watch this now and wonder HOW such sweet characters could be ruined in such a HORRIBLE manner🤢🤢🤢
divmath thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: nureat01



Good points.....Jagya sounds like the most disgusting ASS on the planet right now and CHILD MARRIAGE is the LAST excuse that should be used to justify his actions.....he has CHEATED on his wife, pure and simple.....an ADULT wife....this is not child's play.....and he is no child either.....he is full aware of what he is doing so let's stop justifying this in the name of the evils of child marriage.....then toh tomorrow every second man will come up with excuses of this sort....Oh I was 18 when I got married so obviously I HAVE to cheat on my wife by the the time I hit 25😕😆.....do men EVER grow up?? They can use the "I was a child when I got married" excuse for life that way, haan?😆

He is blatantly ruining two lives....doesn't matter how annoying grown version of Anandi is.....nobody deserves this kind of treatment.....I don't buy this "pure love" argument either.....he's cheating EVERYONE and is doing everything for his own selfish motives....where's the "love" in this?

This show has become SO disgusting that words also can't suffice....I sometimes wonder if Avika and Avinash watch this now and wonder HOW such sweet characters could be ruined in such a HORRIBLE manner🤢🤢🤢


Clearly our point of views differ here...Agree Jagya's behavior is unbearable and cannot be tolerated...he has turned into a lying swine.....but I still stand by my words...that his falling in love with Gauri is NOT wrong.....as I have said many times...just because Anandi and Jagya consummated doesnt mean Jagya loved Anandi....it can be due to physical attraction !.......he realised his love for Gauri after he moved to the city and experienced a different lifestyle, he fell in love at an age when every boy or girl does....its not his mistake, just because he was married to Anandi in childhood, he will be tied to that relationship for life? and will not be given freedom to choose his partner?...I dont think thats right ! he HAS the right to choose his life partner which I guess he is doing and I support him in that.... (not his behavior towards other's, though)

I do agree he should have told Anandi as well as Gauri about his feelings long back and not kept them in the dark....but I guess the CV's chose to drag this forever....so as I look at it...he hid the fact from Anandi because he did not want to hurt her and was scared of his family's reaction and he hid the truth from Gauri because he is scared of losing her.......specially after her outburst when he mentioned his imaginary friend....I am not justifying his lies here but analyzing this situation from his perspective....no matter how much we hate Jagya the truth is he loves Gauri, you might not buy it....but I do ! just like I dont buy the fact that Jagya loved Anandi....and coming to Anandi deserving this treatment...she very much does deserve all this...if this is the way some sense can be knocked into her dented brain so be it.....she has gone from bad to worse since leap....and this very treatment and shock was required to get her out of her "wonderland" and face the reality ! hope she does something for "herself" rather than chasing Jagya and pleasing Daadisa....
Edited by divmath - 14 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#27
@Divmath: Yes clearly our views differ DIAMETRICALLY on this, no doubt.

I do not support infidelity, period. That's the way I look at it.....nothing justifies it....no "I fell in love" arguments justify it....He is married to Anandi.....he can't choose to forget that per his convenience just cuz now he feels he's "fallen in love".....a man who can't be honest in his relationships does not deserve any respect or sympathy in my viewpoint. Nothing excuses his behavior......if choices were taken away from him, they were also taken away from Anandi.....but she being a girl in a rural area faced ten folds more pressures.....SHE didn't go out and cheat on him, did she?? A person loses all semblance of respect when they CHEAT on their spouse, in my opinion....the lowest form of behavior and I will not condone it.

The most unbelievable aspect ofcourse is how COOLLY he is going about cheating on Anandi and aaraaaaaam se enjoying his romance with Gauri without an OUNCE of guilt or shame.....How can that be justified??? This is "love"???

Anandi deserves basic respect as a HUMAN BEING atleast.....He may now find her annoying or whatever but is there no respect for the FRIENDSHIP atleast that they shared at one point either?.....nothing?.....pathetic.....A relationship born out of INFIDELITY and cheating on your spouse is something I will never condone.
divmath thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: nureat01

@Divmath: Yes clearly our views differ DIAMETRICALLY on this, no doubt.

I do not support infidelity, period. That's the way I look at it.....nothing justifies it....no "I fell in love" arguments justify it....He is married to Anandi.....he can't choose to forget that per his convenience just cuz now he feels he's "fallen in love".....a man who can't be honest in his relationships does not deserve any respect or sympathy in my viewpoint. Nothing excuses his behavior......if choices were taken away from him, they were also taken away from Anandi.....but she being a girl in a rural area faced ten folds more pressures.....SHE didn't go out and cheat on him, did she?? A person loses all semblance of respect when they CHEAT on their spouse, in my opinion....the lowest form of behavior and I will not condone it.

The most unbelievable aspect ofcourse is how COOLLY he is going about cheating on Anandi and aaraaaaaam se enjoying his romance with Gauri without an OUNCE of guilt or shame.....How can that be justified??? This is "love"???

Anandi deserves basic respect as a HUMAN BEING atleast.....He may now find her annoying or whatever but is there no respect for the FRIENDSHIP atleast that they shared at one point either?.....nothing?.....pathetic.....A relationship born out of INFIDELITY and cheating on your spouse is something I will never condone.


Dont get me wrong...I am NOT supporting infidelity here !! neither have I supported Jagya's behavior...if you have read my posts you would know that ! so we are on the same page on that aspect....

However, in this context and show I see this situation not as infidelity but as a basic right being taken away from a person due to child marriage. period !! I never said Anandi does not have a right...she does very much have a right to choose her partner.....If this same situation happened with Anandi and if the CV's had shown Anandi falling in love with someone else, I would have wholeheartedly supported her as well...! so yes our views are world's apart...just because we are looking at it from different angles....as I said earlier...there is no single optimal solution to this problem...because solutions vary based on the formulation of the problem....😊
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: divmath


Dont get me wrong...I am NOT supporting infidelity here !! neither have I supported Jagya's behavior...if you have read my posts you would know that ! so we are on the same page on that aspect....

However, in this context and show I see this situation not as infidelity but as a basic right being taken away from a person due to child marriage. period !! Hmmmm I still have to disagree.....I think it's more of a situation of a WEAK MINDED and COWARDLY person making excuses to get his way in life. A person without principles, without honor and without the COURAGE to be honest.....and since he is doing all of this in context of cheating on his wife....(no matter how it came to be), it can only be called infidelity, plain and simple.


I never said Anandi does not have a right...she does very much have a right to choose her partner.....If this same situation happened with Anandi and if the CV's had shown Anandi falling in love with someone else, I would have wholeheartedly supported her as well...LOL so even Anandi's infidelity is justified if it should so happen?? Hey bhagwaan what is Indian TV coming to *shakes head*😆.....well the point in this case is that Anandi DIDN'T do that....and she won't either....she may be a whiny crybaby but even SHE seems to have more honor and principles than this loser Jagya.....At this point the writers of this show have just made a joke out of every relationship.....especially marriage where these ppl are playing musical chairs per their convenience. .


! so yes our views are world's apart...just because we are looking at it from different angles....as I said earlier...there is no single optimal solution to this problem...because solutions vary based on the formulation of the problem....😊 Actually I think there is an optimal solution....this show should END.....it's long overdue😆.....this situation is just stupidly convoluted for the sake of it by the writers.....lame storytelling.

divmath thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
@nureat01

We will definitely not agree to each other's POV...coz as I said earlier...our perspectives are world's apart...😆 😆 and this discussion can go on endlessly....thats the fun of this forum...different mind sets and differing views ! 😊 we can never come to a consensus...you feel it is infidelity and I feel its not ! so lets leave it at that.... to each his own 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".