RAYA SS.Custody updtD last part on 148 page - Page 31

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

202.1k

Users

95

Likes

1.7k

Frequent Posters

luvsakshi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
@Sheethal ..I understand what's your point of view ..
When i read the part i said it was not justifiable .. and when i came across with the next chapter yes his anger was justifiable ,Even she worked sorry still working with women protection home
against for DVas a volunteer doctor and councellor
I forwarded your message to her ...If she will give the answer it will be good because she has written it .. Thank you for your honest opinion ,...As she was pretty busy with her work she will give her answer with in a day or two ..Will post it soon ...Have a nice day...
😛
Oneandall thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: taashu11




i agree what you feel about the slap you are not wrong... but at the same time situations are out of control they both were out of their mind at that very movent witn their pain anger guilt and things naturally happens and are not done purposely...it was not DV it was just happened unknowingly out of mind am posting comment below hope you get that point...


it was indeed a dhamakedaar update...
it was a bit dhamaka like 5th march...
but a step ahead ram slapped priya poor
priya...
but am not atall angry on ram for slapping
priya because it showed his pain and
love...
(pain of those years he lived without priya
and love for her that made him insecure
how he could survive if he loose priya
once again its his ultimate and
unconditional love that made him do such
thing... he cant even imagine loosing
her again... so am on rams side)
and more over i know that he will pacify
priya and he will go to any extend to
rectify his mistake and manofy priya...


hope you get my point...



Taashu I understand what you are saying. Your point is that slapping your spouse is wrong but in some situations such as heated arguments in which anger, pain and guilt surface a slap happens. In that case it's natural. Maybe we come from different walks of life, different experiences but for me there is nothing natural about someone slapping their spouse because he/she provoked them with their words. NO MATTER WHAT THE SITUATION MAY BE. See where you and I differ with regards to slapping (let's forget about DV that's a by product of a slap but much more complex than that) is that you say that a slap is wrong but there are conditions in which it is right but I say that slapping your spouse is wrong no matter what the condition is. That's my general opinion about abuse within a relationship, be it one slap or one million, I still maintain my stance.

But to be specific and talk about it in terms of the update in which the slap happened. Well first of all it's just a story and I don't want to knit pick someone's creative work to bits and pieces. Ram in real BALH would not do that, especially given the fact that Raya had many heated arguments which diffused without the need for a slap (they bitterly hated each other but ram never hit Priya and Priya never hit ram). But still, you said in the update u are on Ram's side. lol by all means your opinions are respected. However, I am on Priya's side...let me explain why. First Priya did whatever she did (run away from Ram) for his well being. Did ram ask her why? NO! Ram taunted her into depression, she still wanted the best for him (waiting up for him at dinner). Did he see her love shining through than? NO! She asked him to forgive her, punish her in any way but take away the hatred. Did his mahaan love show up than to give her a chance to explain?Did she ask to be abused? NO and NO! The time the slap happened Ram found her anklet and asked her why she left him. Did he instigate the fight by not letting her explain and by continuing to repeat the same nonsense? YES!
She said how she felt and was just as angry. Ram practically ignored her, lived for peehu, she might as well be dead physically because mentally he had killed her. Was she angry too? YES! WAS HER LOVE TESTED, INSULTED TORN APART ALL AT ONCE? WAS HER ANGER JUSTIFIED? YES! Did the truth cause ram pain? Does that give him the right to cause pain to the person who was telling him the truth? NOT IN MY BOOK!
Could Ram have dragged her forcefully to the hidden room where he kept her memories which she had no memory of? OF COURSE!
So from Priya side I saw love and anger. From Ram's side I saw anger, ego, hatred and yea a tiny bit of love. He has immense love for Priya but his actions spoke otherwise so how was she to know? Without that information whatever she said was right. To convey that information to her, well there were many other methods...

My god this is so long again. But khair, my heart became lighter. 😆
Oneandall thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: luvsakshi

<font size="3"><font color="#006600">@Sheethal ..I understand what's your point of view ..
When i read the part i said it was not justifiable .. and when i came across with the next chapter yes his anger was justifiable ,Even she worked sorry still working with women protection home </font>
</font><font size="3"><font color="#006600"><font size="3"><font color="#006600">against for DV</font></font>as a volunteer doctor and councellor
I forwarded your message to her ...If she will give the answer it will be good because she has written it .. Thank you for your honest opinion ,...As she was pretty busy with her work she will give her answer with in a day or two ..Will post it soon ...Have a nice day...</font>
</font>😛



Please forward my response to Taashu and my response to her to this writer.
It's interesting how we have similar experience on the clinical front with violence against women but yet we have different opinions with regards to the tolerability of one slap. Like I said, research proves that one slap increases the chances of it turning into two, three and than next thing you know you have full on DV. But she would probably already know that with her experience right? I just don't like the slap, I see raya in this FF differently because I can't respect this Ram the same way. You know that I have read your stories from a long time even before I began writing so please don't take this as a personal attack by any means. If it is possible i would love to speak to her personally about this matter so that i can understand her theory on a slap being a right of the person who loves us and how a slap is love covered by hate Maybe she didn't explain herself properly when she wrote that as her justification but I interpreted it only as she had written it (I am talking about the writers note from last update)...of course she is busy so tell her to take her time. I am not going anywhere.. 😉
P.s. thanks Neel, your an awesome messenger.
Edited by Oneandall - 12 years ago
Mani-RK thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
hmmm i was reading all ur comments even i didint like dat slap part wateva may be the reason
i hav seen in some mves wer heroine behaves like mad i mean wen she loses her control den der husbands slap her to calm her down...instead of slapping priya he cud hav just kissed her like he did on mar12th den automatically priya will listen to him😆(its just my pov)
coz i cant digest the fact that ram slapped her
raya had lots of heated arguments but he neva slapped her not even on 5th march not on 12th mar wer she was gng on n on ..




Edited by ramsakshiroxxx - 12 years ago
rayaloveland thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Awesome updates...
Update soon
Sorry for late comments..
Siacutie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
awesum update neel one again i read it on other forum now finding it here is more easy well when u r going to updte the next part
waitng 👏
Siacutie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ramsakshiroxxx

hmmm i was reading all ur comments even i didint like dat slap part wateva may be the reason

i hav seen in some mves wer heroine behaves like mad i mean wen she loses her control den der husbands slap her to calm her down...instead of slapping priya he cud hav just kissed her like he did on mar12th den automatically priya will listen to him😆(its just my pov)
coz i cant digest the fact that ram slapped her
raya had lots of heated arguments but he neva slapped her not even on 5th march not on 12th mar wer she was gng on n on ..



mani idea is nice he shud have kiss her rather than slapped her 😆
agree with u mani

taashu11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Oneandall



Taashu I understand what you are saying. Your point is that slapping your spouse is wrong but in some situations such as heated arguments in which anger, pain and guilt surface a slap happens. In that case it's natural. Maybe we come from different walks of life, different experiences but for me there is nothing natural about someone slapping their spouse because he/she provoked them with their words. NO MATTER WHAT THE SITUATION MAY BE. See where you and I differ with regards to slapping (let's forget about DV that's a by product of a slap but much more complex than that) is that you say that a slap is wrong but there are conditions in which it is right but I say that slapping your spouse is wrong no matter what the condition is. That's my general opinion about abuse within a relationship, be it one slap or one million, I still maintain my stance.

But to be specific and talk about it in terms of the update in which the slap happened. Well first of all it's just a story and I don't want to knit pick someone's creative work to bits and pieces. Ram in real BALH would not do that, especially given the fact that Raya had many heated arguments which diffused without the need for a slap (they bitterly hated each other but ram never hit Priya and Priya never hit ram). But still, you said in the update u are on Ram's side. lol by all means your opinions are respected. However, I am on Priya's side...let me explain why. First Priya did whatever she did (run away from Ram) for his well being. Did ram ask her why? NO! Ram taunted her into depression, she still wanted the best for him (waiting up for him at dinner). Did he see her love shining through than? NO! She asked him to forgive her, punish her in any way but take away the hatred. Did his mahaan love show up than to give her a chance to explain?Did she ask to be abused? NO and NO! The time the slap happened Ram found her anklet and asked her why she left him. Did he instigate the fight by not letting her explain and by continuing to repeat the same nonsense? YES!
She said how she felt and was just as angry. Ram practically ignored her, lived for peehu, she might as well be dead physically because mentally he had killed her. Was she angry too? YES! WAS HER LOVE TESTED, INSULTED TORN APART ALL AT ONCE? WAS HER ANGER JUSTIFIED? YES! Did the truth cause ram pain? Does that give him the right to cause pain to the person who was telling him the truth? NOT IN MY BOOK!
Could Ram have dragged her forcefully to the hidden room where he kept her memories which she had no memory of? OF COURSE!
So from Priya side I saw love and anger. From Ram's side I saw anger, ego, hatred and yea a tiny bit of love. He has immense love for Priya but his actions spoke otherwise so how was she to know? Without that information whatever she said was right. To convey that information to her, well there were many other methods...

My god this is so long again. But khair, my heart became lighter. 😆




ok ok i agree with your point too what i thought was just an uncontrollable movement but i understand what you are saying he could haven explained her in may other ways than slapping...
taashu11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Oneandall



Please forward my response to Taashu and my response to her to this writer.
It's interesting how we have similar experience on the clinical front with violence against women but yet we have different opinions with regards to the tolerability of one slap. Like I said, research proves that one slap increases the chances of it turning into two, three and than next thing you know you have full on DV. But she would probably already know that with her experience right? I just don't like the slap, I see raya in this FF differently because I can't respect this Ram the same way. You know that I have read your stories from a long time even before I began writing so please don't take this as a personal attack by any means. If it is possible i would love to speak to her personally about this matter so that i can understand her theory on a slap being a right of the person who loves us and how a slap is love covered by hate Maybe she didn't explain herself properly when she wrote that as her justification but I interpreted it only as she had written it (I am talking about the writers note from last update)...of course she is busy so tell her to take her time. I am not going anywhere.. 😉
P.s. thanks Neel, your an awesome messenger.






may be you both are right and my point of view of seeing things is different as you are more matured and experienced than me so now am realising that i was wrong in judging the situation...
taashu11 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: ramsakshiroxxx

hmmm i was reading all ur comments even i didint like dat slap part wateva may be the reason

i hav seen in some mves wer heroine behaves like mad i mean wen she loses her control den der husbands slap her to calm her down...instead of slapping priya he cud hav just kissed her like he did on mar12th den automatically priya will listen to him😆(its just my pov)
coz i cant digest the fact that ram slapped her
raya had lots of heated arguments but he neva slapped her not even on 5th march not on 12th mar wer she was gng on n on ..









oh thats the best solution to this...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".