Disappointed.... - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

2.6k

Users

12

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

Chiraiyya... thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#21
Mrunal was busy with shooting for the film she is in so we were lucky to even see her if only for a bit in the last 3 episodes. Now that she is back they can do more Arakshi scenes.
And I don't understand why a crime show can't have romance in it. If you want to watch a crime show with no romance in it then watch the shows which tell you about true crime stories. Just because its a crime show doesn't mean it has to change its genre just because there's a bit of romance in it. The romance shows that the members of ETF do have lives outside of work and we get to look into them.

Sakshi is there to report on the cases and let the public know how ETF have helped the country with them solving crimes. She helps every now and then with her contacts and useful information but she doesn't have to. She was sent there to report on them, she herself didn't go there and decide to get in their way. It's like journalists who report on the war, they endanger their lives and maybe others when they are being protected but at the end of the day its their job.
396659 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: miss_bennet

Of course, I don't say that love story is the only way to make the story interesting. I just said that it's the creator's liberty to show what they want to show in their show.(😆) If they want to show a love angle, they will, it is up to them. (Which they do intend to, because as we have already seen, the story has certainly trod on those lines).

If you wish to see something else from the story, you can certainly convey it to the CVs. We are all making our wishes, but at the end, it is all up to the creators of the show.

As for tragedy, haven't we already seen much tragedy in the show so far? Don't you think they also deserve a chance at happiness?


yes they deserve a chance at happiness but if all 5 ETF members' own stories are connected then it would be more interesting. it's only Arjun that has experienced tragedy. the rest of them are just fine.
her_story thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: Cshafkat


yes they deserve a chance at happiness but if all 5 ETF members' own stories are connected then it would be more interesting. it's only Arjun that has experienced tragedy. the rest of them are just fine.

Really, hasn't Rathore too lost two dear friends? And I see you are determined on ignoring Sakshi, but ignoring something doesn't cease its existence. She might be chirpy and smiling all the time, but hasn't she also faced tragedy in life? A parent who is in comma, on life-support, who can't even hear what you have to say, doesn't classify as tragedy? Or did you miss that episode?

Yes, I do agree that showing back stories to each of these characters would make it interesting. But that in no way means there shouldn't be a love story angle.
396659 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: miss_bennet

Really, hasn't Rathore too lost two dear friends? And I see you are determined on ignoring Sakshi, but ignoring something doesn't cease its existence. She might be chirpy and smiling all the time, but hasn't she also faced tragedy in life? A parent who is in comma, on life-support, who can't even hear what you have to say, doesn't classify as tragedy? Or did you miss that episode?

Yes, I do agree that showing back stories to each of these characters would make it interesting. But that in no way means there shouldn't be a love story angle.


i wasn't ignoring sakshi. i was talking about the 5 main characters that's why i didn't mention sakshi or lisa. arjun, rathore, aisha, chotu and shree. these 5 are the main characters. no i didn't miss that episode where sakshi was talking to her father who's in coma. showing love story angle in a show like arjun is like showing hardcore action in a show like saraswatichandra which would make no sense at all. and even if they show a little bit of romance in arjun, they should show it with the other characters not with arjun since his wife is dead.
Edited by Cshafkat - 12 years ago
her_story thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: Cshafkat


i wasn't ignoring sakshi. i was talking about the 5 main characters that's why i didn't mention sakshi or lisa. arjun, rathore, aisha, chotu and shree. these 5 are the main characters. no i didn't miss that episode where sakshi was talking to her father who's in coma. showing love story angle in a show like arjun is like showing hardcore action in a show like saraswatichandra which would make no sense at all. and even if they show a little bit of romance in arjun, they should show it with the other characters not with arjun since his wife is dead.

Oh, so you don't mind romance between other characters. I thought you said crime shows shouldn't have romance at all. Talk about being confused! And I pity you for believing that since Arjun's wife is dead he has no right to love again.

And Sakshi is as much a main character in the show as the others. And if you think you are the authority to judge what and what not should be shown in a crime show (or any other genre, for that matter), suit yourself. I have nothing more to discuss with you.
Edited by miss_bennet - 12 years ago
Mimi2609 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: Cshafkat


if they show love story, then what's the point of calling it a crime thriller? they should call it a love story. people watch it for the mind blowing cases and the amazing story not for the unnecessary love story.

For one it never was a 100% crime thriller, since its launching, be it Gorky or Shaleen, they have always said that it's a crime thriller and will have also love stories in it, by love stories they never meant 40mins of the show to be based on love, but if 2-3 minutes of the show is given for love stories, then i dont see what's wrong in it!
I'll again repeat myself even all other crime thriller be it CID or Shapath or others are gonna incorporate small minute romantic tracks!
The fans are only asking something which Gorky himself promised to give, and i dont understand why the fans are wrong...
Sakuu thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: miss_bennet

Oh, so you don't mind romance between other characters. I thought you said crime shows shouldn't have romance at all. Talk about being confused! And I pity you for believing that since Arjun's wife is dead he has no right to love again.

And Sakshi is as much a main character in the show as the others. And if you think you are the authority to judge what and what not should be shown in a crime show (or any other genre, for that matter), suit yourself. I have nothing more to discuss with you.

Harshu like i said to u before: ignore kar, koi faida nahi hoga, bas tujhe sirdard hoga
They are like little brats holding on to that tiny toy... I've also had a few discussions, koi farak nahi padhta in logo ko
they've already lost the plot because they want RaEsha, ShrIza hell even Chhotu and his 1130 waali will do.. But they just don't want ArAkshi..
I guess they've never really read a good book or seen a good crime drama on tv, it isn't just about the cases a lot of times we get to see the personal life of the ppl solving the cases as well

SK left the show for personal reasons, yet they hate mrunal.
her_story thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Sakuu

Harshu like i said to u before: ignore kar, koi faida nahi hoga, bas tujhe sirdard hoga
They are like little brats holding on to that tiny toy... I've also had a few discussions, koi farak nahi padhta in logo ko
they've already lost the plot because they want RaEsha, ShrIza hell even Chhotu and his 1130 waali will do.. But they just don't want ArAkshi..
I guess they've never really read a good book or seen a good crime drama on tv, it isn't just about the cases a lot of times we get to see the personal life of the ppl solving the cases as well

SK left the show for personal reasons, yet they hate mrunal.

Thanks for the support Sakuu🤗.
396659 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: miss_bennet

Oh, so you don't mind romance between other characters. I thought you said crime shows shouldn't have romance at all. Talk about being confused! And I pity you for believing that since Arjun's wife is dead he has no right to love again.

And Sakshi is as much a main character in the show as the others. And if you think you are the authority to judge what and what not should be shown in a crime show (or any other genre, for that matter), suit yourself. I have nothing more to discuss with you.


I pity all those people for getting angry simply because there were no romantic moments in the last few episodes. just because there were no romance in the last few episodes, you guys started complaining. this clearly proves that you guys want more romance rather than what this show is meant to show. be happy with what it's showing and don't get mad if they don't show much romance. it's pathetic how some people are so desperate to see something that's the last thing to be showed in a show. i have nothing more to discuss with you if you're gonna try to argue about why crime shows should have a little bit of romance in it.
Chiraiyya... thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Cshafkat


I pity all those people for getting angry simply because there were no romantic moments in the last few episodes. just because there were no romance in the last few episodes, you guys started complaining. this clearly proves that you guys want more romance rather than what this show is meant to show. be happy with what it's showing and don't get mad if they don't show much romance. it's pathetic how some people are so desperate to see something that's the last thing to be showed in a show. i have nothing more to discuss with you if you're gonna try to argue about why crime shows should have a little bit of romance in it.


It was said from before that it wouldn't just be a crime show, there would be other genres in it. That's why we so called "complaining" that we didn't have an Arakshi scenes. Arjun has only got a 6 month extension meaning that it might finish in February. We only get 8 episodes a month meaning that we only have about 48 episodes till the show finishes. That's not enough time to shows Arjun finding Sikander, Him finally moving on, Sakshi's past, Sameer and Aisha's relationship if the character even comes back, Shree and Liza's story and Chotuu and his crush.

We were "complaining" because we didn't even get a small Arakshi scene. We don't want this show to become a predominantly love story, we like watch the crime aspect of it. As I said in a post before, if you want to watch a crime show with no romance in it, watch programmes that are about real crime stories than watching a fictional show. We don't want the show to become monotonous which is why having a bit of romance in it adds something new to it. If you don't want to "discuss" anything about this then don't reply to any posts about Arakshi as there are quite a lot of fans who do like Arakshi and don't share your view that a crime show shouldn't have romance in it

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".