For a Greater Good

musicalstorm thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#1

Talking about the issue raised in the serial regarding how they raise voice and support a rape victim against all odds. Today I visited my very old posts of this forum and got an answer of it. This is definitely a sensitive issue.


There are many different view points of the society. I think they are trying to show every perspective. When we see such news in the media then we feel sad for the victim. But in the end we have to do nothing. It is the victim and the family dealing with the problem. Here some particular characters were shown to be feeling for Dimpi. But the moment they came to know that Anupama and Anuj have brought Dimpi & Nirmit home, then everyone was scared.


To be scared is the most definite reaction in such cases. I remember watching Gargi, where Gargi's father was boycotted by the society for the crime, but still she fought for her father as she trusted her father. And the victim's father was shown to be very strong and fight for his daughter. Here even Gargi's father was a criminal but still she fought for him because she didn't now the truth. The whole society boycotted that family. The moment she knew the truth she opposed her father and supported the victim. The girl in that movie almost fought for a culprit.


Now, here we know that Dimpi is victim, Anupama and Anuj have interacted with the goons. They know that those goons are demons. It is the truth. Nirmit leaving Dimpi, I didn't like it for sure. But it was to make a pair for Samar. Nirmit leaving and Samar giving support to her, is a typical ITV thing. Now how Samar and Dimpi look as a pair, I am not concerned about it right now. I am concerned that Dimpi's pain is not much shown. Her husband literally left her and she is a victim. How is she feeling emotionally I want to know.


Nirmit should not have left. But it is still to show to the society that leave you even when they love you, when you are in difficulty. Anupama's pain was shown, Pakhi's useless scenes, the shah's receiving the threats, all is fine. But what about Dimpi? I want to know how is she feeling. The makers are showing her strong but Dimpi might be sitting alone and feeling something.


Anupama should have thought about the family. But the only thing which makes me wonder that what if we are in the similar situation. I think that people dont help. People just leave like Nirmit. Its bitter thing. And when Anupama is helping, someone wants to pull her back...Always in the doing of something geater good, there is a fear of something


I remind of the great lines of Geeta, Krishna said, " That think of a greater good, do your work, if you are with truth, I am there with you, if you step back for the fear of family, then you will not be able to set an example of Dharma" I know these lines are very heavy but these lines are totally applicable in the current situation


There is a fear for the entire family, but what if same culprits repeat the crimes, that moment we will feel guilty for staying silent and not fighting...Anupama's Mahanta and her pain and her dialogues should be given a less time. But the pain and courage of Dimple should be also equally highlighted That is what I want from the CVs. Why Anupama's whole family is receiving threats? It should be Dimple's family getting to know about the condition of Dimple

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.5k

Users

3

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#2

I feel CVS are two show two types of reaction one is of victim and another is of witnesses

CVS are trying to show both mental status of victim and witnesses

Suppose I see when someone beating brutally in front of my eyes .will I not react will I not fear ? It is not possible for me to mujhe pe koi Asar hi nahi ho

Of course I will not able to sleep properly for many night if I see such incident because aise incident mere dimag mein Kai din tuk ghumne

Of course Jo victim hote hai unke pain Hota hai trauma Hota hai unke mental health pe Asar Hota hai but jo apne saamne Jo is Ghatna dekhte hai unhe bhi trauma Hota hai un pur bhi mental effect Hota hai

Waise bhi duniya mein Har Tarah ke log hote hai

Khuch log Jinhe koi farak nahi padta but khuch log hai Jinhe farak padta Har insaan ka deal karne aur face karne ka apna tareeka Hota hai

Regarding giving threat these goons have still guts to give threat when police complaint against then .they have still guts to roam freely when police are searching of them and catch them anywhere next time when goons threat at least note down the vehicle number sa

When we stand against injustice musibat to hamesha aati hai

Many social reformer unhe bahut si pareshan jhelne Padi when they are opposition wrong thing phir bhi woh galat ke liye ladte Rahe and ant mein sahi baat Sachaai ki Jeet hui

There is saying truth pareshan ho.sakta Hai but parajit nahi

As regard giving focusing on anupama because it is story demand .story is about anupama so every character will be link to anupama it is not possible for writer to side or reducing anupama character just because other facing problem

Story about anupama to yeh dikha rahe uske Jeevan mein kis Prakar ke log aa Rahe hai

musicalstorm thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: surabhi01

I feel CVS are two show two types of reaction one is of victim and another is of witnesses

CVS are trying to show both mental status of victim and witnesses

Suppose I see when someone beating brutally in front of my eyes .will I not react will I not fear ? It is not possible for me to mujhe pe koi Asar hi nahi ho

Of course I will not able to sleep properly for many night if I see such incident because aise incident mere dimag mein Kai din tuk ghumne

Of course Jo victim hote hai unke pain Hota hai trauma Hota hai unke mental health pe Asar Hota hai but jo apne saamne Jo is Ghatna dekhte hai unhe bhi trauma Hota hai un pur bhi mental effect Hota hai

Waise bhi duniya mein Har Tarah ke log hote hai

Khuch log Jinhe koi farak nahi padta but khuch log hai Jinhe farak padta Har insaan ka deal karne aur face karne ka apna tareeka Hota hai

Regarding giving threat these goons have still guts to give threat when police complaint against then .they have still guts to roam freely when police are searching of them and catch them anywhere next time when goons threat at least note down the vehicle number sa

When we stand against injustice musibat to hamesha aati hai

Many social reformer unhe bahut si pareshan jhelne Padi when they are opposition wrong thing phir bhi woh galat ke liye ladte Rahe and ant mein sahi baat Sachaai ki Jeet hui

There is saying truth pareshan ho.sakta Hai but parajit nahi

As regard giving focusing on anupama because it is story demand .story is about anupama so every character will be link to anupama it is not possible for writer to side or reducing anupama character just because other facing problem

Story about anupama to yeh dikha rahe uske Jeevan mein kis Prakar ke log aa Rahe hai


There is a rape survivor named Sunita Krishnan. I think she was a child victim. But now the purpose of her life is to give justice and support to rape victims. That lady is very strong but she has to face many big challenges. she is really a inspiration. Madad kon karta hai aaj ke zamaane mein


I think that a sensitive issue like rape is better justified in movies. In ITV there are certain limitations.


Sahi ko pareshaan hona hi padta hai, Galat bahaar aa hi jata hai.


Bolded lines: Very true


As far as Anupama is concerned, I want Dimple's monologue and I dont know how the goons know about Shahs? Baar Baar Shah's ko laana zaruri nai hai

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#4

Some pain are Unable to express with word .dimpy ko jyaada dialogue nahi diya but with her face expression yeh samajh mein aata, uske man mein Kitna dwand chal raha uske man mein bahut se sawal ghum Rahe honge woh andar se bahut tooti haiI think uske husband ne uska saath choda isne isko subse jyaada tod ke rakh diya hoga though she is not expressing her word

May be dimpy ke mono dialogue aur uski feeling court mein dikhaya jaaye

musicalstorm thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Some pain are Unable to express with word .dimpy ko jyaada dialogue nahi diya but with her face expression yeh samajh mein aata, uske man mein Kitna dwand chal raha uske man mein bahut se sawal ghum Rahe honge woh andar se bahut tooti haiI think uske husband ne uska saath choda isne isko subse jyaada tod ke rakh diya hoga though she is not expressing her word

May be dimpy ke mono dialogue aur uski feeling court mein dikhaya jaaye


I hope proper court procedures ho....

Dimpi kuchh bole, aur uski family ko bhi pata hona chahiye. TV mein aa gaya par uski family ko pata nahi hai ya phir uski family bhi Nirmit ke jaise hi hai

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#6

Waise kosha tumhari Sangeet ki practice kaise chal.rahi hai yahan indiaforum mein voice of India forum competition hua tha .tum.chaho to jub competition ho tum bhi apni singing record karke forum.mein post kar sakti ho of if singing Competition next

I will try send link of thread jahan put bahut log ne apni singing record kar ke forum mein daalna hai

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#7

Even i feel.strange ki tv mein Khabar aa gayi abhi tuk dimpy ke mother father koi bhi nahi milne aaya ?

musicalstorm thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Waise kosha tumhari Sangeet ki practice kaise chal.rahi hai yahan indiaforum mein voice of India forum competition hua tha .tum.chaho to jub competition ho tum bhi apni singing record karke forum.mein post kar sakti ho of if singing Competition next

I will try send link of thread jahan put bahut log ne apni singing record kar ke forum mein daalna hai


It is going on nice...

Competition of music? Wow

You send me the link.

musicalstorm thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Voice of India 2024 Participant Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 2 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: surabhi01

Even i feel.strange ki tv mein Khabar aa gayi abhi tuk dimpy ke mother father koi bhi nahi milne aaya ?


Kya pata ki uski family ne bhi use support karne se mana kar diya ho 😲

731627 thumbnail
Posted: 2 years ago
#10

Yes mujhe bhi aisa lag raha hai ki dimpy ke parents ne boycott kar diya dimpy ka

Related Topics

Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: Vaidehi49

5 months ago

Prem did good tday.

I wanted Prem to say this to Aryan today.😅 Finally.. Because aryan seems to just use his only dialogue ( tum bahut lucky ho, kash mai bhi lucky...

Expand ▼
Anupamaa Thumbnail

Posted by: Starwatcher01

7 months ago

Parag looks good with Anu

They should of replaced him with Vanraj or a love interest.

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".