Is Amit's decision of going to US justifiable?

emeraldeye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Is Amit's decision of going to US justifiable? 🤔

I've started this topic is response to another post which is 'Stupid episodes' (https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/amita-ka-amit/3564096/stupid-episodes). In that, the TM /other supporters point out that 'Why it is always the girl's responsibility to save the marriage', 'Why Amit is not doing anything to save the marriage', 'I hate Amit blah blah'. But I would like to point out that it is far from the truth. We all are not born as a feminist but after seeing so much discrimination around us we automatically and quickly go into that mode. So the moment we see some girl shedding few tears, our heart melts, we start feeling for her and ignore the actual truth. This is the case with Amita too. Just because she sheds few tears and keeps saying 'Mein apani shadi ko bachane keliye kuch bhi karungi' doesn't mean she is working hard on their relationship. So wake guys up and open your eyes. I feel Amit is doing and has already done more than required for this marriage. And let me tell you the reason behind it. ⭐️


Wedding: Yes, agreed it was Amit's big ego which dragged them into this mess. Both came to know about the facts and both had the option to back out. But Amita came and pleaded him citing her problems.😭 She scarified her happiness but she had a motive and her selfishness behind it. The motive being her reputation, her family's prestige/happiness and her brother's wedding. Do you anywhere see Amit is that list, NO. Even for one moment did she think about his life, his happiness? And what right she had to expect that he does that sacrifice for her sake?? If it had been any other guy he would have backed out without any remorse. But Amit being a good person and a perfect gentleman felt the sense of responsibility for this mess and decides to marry her. Actually he is the one who has sacrificed his life and his happiness for sake of Amita and Amita's / his family. Even on the wedding night rather than thanking him, she scolds him saying 'Ek dulhan ko kaisa lagta hain '.blah blah'. Come on Ammu, at least acknowledge his sincere effort and what he has done for you!

Relationship: Amit guards his relationship and it related secrets like a true knight. 👏 Even when Phalguni forces him to confess, he doesn't utter a word. But what about Amita, the moment something happens she is on conference with her friends. Shadi ke pehle thak yeh sab tik tha! But if Amit doesn't want that his life to be an open book for all, why doesn't she respect his view? 😕 Also Amita goes out of her way to hide his faults or mistakes and thus gaining the praises of her in-laws. But if Amit's ego is getting hurt in this process, why does she have to do that?

Misunderstandings and fights: Yes agreed, during their fights Amit was very rude but Amita was not very sweet either. 😉 Amit felt that he was insulted twice once in front of her father and in front of her/his friends. In the first scenario, Amita was not at fault but did she take the initiative to clear this MU with Amit? Did she tell who was behind it? What is the point hiding that fact if the relationship itself is in danger?😲 The second time, yes she was guilty as she acted like a typical cry baby. She acted wildly/rudely and screamed at him in front of other and thus hurting him more. 😔 And yes, she reminded him of his past. But what is the point, after marriage I don't even remember a single instance where he let his ego creep into their relationship.😲 Even in Suraj's MU scenario, till date she has not clarified anything to Amit. Yes, they are in their early stages of their marriage and their bond has not reached a stage where she can say 'I like/ love you' but at least she can stop herself from saying negative statements like 'Mein apke liye sahi jeevan sathi nahi hun aur na aao mere liye!' and 'Muje tho yeh nahi samaj mein aa raha ki aapne shadi ka faisla kyu badla?'. After hearing such negative statement and getting negative vibes which guy would be happy to spend the rest of the life with her? 🤢

Taking care: Yes, Amita had taken care of him when he had toothache and made Kichu for him.👍🏼 But Amit was not far behind in this either. Even though he kept on saying that he is doing it for the sake of humanity, we could easily see that this guy was genuinely concerned. He actually took extra care of her. He even set reminder to check whether she had medicines or not. He also bought some fruits for her and kept fasting on the day of pooja. Don't tell me, people do all this in the name of humanity. This guy has fallen for our Ammu but he is yet to realize this.😉 I feel Amit is doing and has already done more than required for this marriage. Come on Ammu baby, grow up and think maturely. He is doing what he could but what about you?

Well after reading this you can easily see that Amit has equally got affected by all this. He has done more than what a normal husband would do. He is a simple ,good man and wants to spend a peaceful life. Even after doing so much for the relationship all he is getting to hear is rejection and negative statement. He does feel suffocated in this relation and feel dejected. No wonder, he has taken this extreme decision of going to US. I somehow feel there is nothing wrong in it.

(Though personally I still want them to patch up and spend a blissful married life. And of course I do respect your views and your right to hold on to it. I may be wrong in my analysis too but this was just a sincere effort to throw some light on what has actually happened. Just because I wrote this post doesn't mean that I've started hating Amita. I do like both of them- equally. It's just that at some point of time you need to take a stand and this was one of them. Seems like as the episode getting intense and intense my post is longer and longer 😆. Dearies thanks for reading this post and bearing with me.)


Hit on like if you liked the post. Do pour in your views and opinions.😊

Edited by emeraldeye - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

806

Users

5

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

srinivasrishi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
@emeraldeye
totally agree with ur views.Iam repeating my cmts which i made in that thread.

since Amita is always saying that --"mein is rishte ko bachane keliye sab kuch karoongi" doesnt mean that she only is trying hard to save this relation.She keeps on saying these dialogues almost everytime but till now she hasnt taken any serious step.Only words doesnt mean you are only the one concerned.Till now Amit as a character is consistent in both his actions and words.He is not a guy who utters these kind of dialogues.A matured and a very practical guy.Its high time now Amita puts her words in action.Than automatically Amit will support her.(in all aspects)

These are my views.No offence.And personally i like Amit character a lot and also Nishads acting skills.

I feel this guy actually needs a short break.So i too justify his UStrip.
grintson thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
*double like* m really thankful that u posted this topic dear... i agree with every single word of urs...

its amit who has kept his every word. he has best frnds too, but he never discussed his married life with them...
even after the road fight he is not spilling poison from his mouth and showed concern for amita's leg pain and during fast.

and as for amita, it was her fault that she wanted amit to be lyk her*sapno ka rajkumar* thing.. she has no right to change him for her own sake.. amit nvr tried to change her..
in my view, the reason y amita is nt telling bout riya's foul plan is that she knows amit luvs his every family member and wil get hurt knowing this bitter truth. she does not want to risk his family's unity.

n the answer to d question dt y amita is still tryin to save her marriage is that she herself realised dt she failed 2 undrstand amit n commited some mistakes. she knows amit is concerned for her and so still has hopes. this is what a person should do.. being hopeful and +ve..
Edited by grintson - 12 years ago
amarjeet73 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
basically ou guys just want to change amita not amit
amit has right to stay what ever he is
amita need to change
Hmmm. try it on yourself
if thats help you to get your love
like if you love some one and try to change according to him and after a change he still doesnot want to love then what ???
lily.lotus.rosy thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Watching past few episodes I had the feeling that Amit is falling for Amita. But it was a big mistake on my part to think so. Amit's so called caring hubby-like attitude was an act of a businessman...since Amita had nursed him during his tooth-ache, so he had helped her when she was ill...&he even said that to her...how can a person who has feelings for someone can keep on hurting on & on??? One thing is for sure that true feelings is only from Amita's side who inspite of making mistakes had realised it & tried to rectify them...but unfortunately she is devoid of any kind of support!! Amita has tried to patch up with Amit but Amit is consistently behaving badly with her & is trying to escape. Had Amit had slightest of feelings for Amita...he wouldn't have thought of leaving her and live a separate life. So let him go to U.S. & start his life with a girl like Snehal & leave our cutie pie Ammu to start a better life.😡
However I still want Amit & Amita to be together. Kudos to Chandni & Nishad for their brilliantly realistic performances!!👏

emeraldeye thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: amarjeet73

basically ou guys just want to change amita not amit

amit has right to stay what ever he is
amita need to change
Hmmm. try it on yourself
if thats help you to get your love
like if you love some one and try to change according to him and after a change he still doesnot want to love then what ???


@amarjeet73: I'm sure whether you have read my post properly or not. Here no one is asking her to change to impress Amit. All we are asking her to do is try and understand his point of view too, clear all the misunderstanding between them, give respect to him. There are few rules of marriage which both husband and wife have to follow. If they don't follow then we can see scenarios as we saw in AKA. If you observe Amit is very mature and does everything what a perfect husband would do. But Amita is still very immature and behaves very childish.


Edited by emeraldeye - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".