*~khoobsurat beginning for FAK*~Reviews/IVS/UPDATES~thread 10 - Page 45

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

44.3k

Users

44

Likes

2.7k

Frequent Posters

nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: shweta_r

Guys, let's keep this thread happy...

There are different kinds of people in this world... Let us choose to be ones that spread happiness...

Waiting for BO numbers... Happy for the entire cast, crew of khoobsurat... End of the day it is a team effort that matters.

👏
TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Mid-day review:

Fantasy fiesta


Click here to enlarge image

KHOOBSURAT is actually beautiful on the outside. Here we have the pretty, spontaneous girl Mili ( Sonam Kapoor), bursting with energy and wearing gorgeous clothes, falling for the dark, reserved and drop dead handsome prince Vikramjit ( Fawad Khan), who lives in a palace.

Who wouldn't fall in love with such a story? But wait, does it have to be so simplistic that you can predict every move, every step that each of the characters are going to take? Those familiar with innumerable rom- coms being churned out of Hollywood mills would know that this script held no surprise, no twist, no nothing. A little more thought put into the script would have worked wonders for this beautiful film. Yes, Khoobsurat is beautiful on the outside, with excellent production quality and it actually transports you to a fantasy world full of silverware, antiques and palatial opulence.

This is in stark contrast to the humble and middle class setting of the original Khoobsurat that was directed by the one and only Hrishikesh Mukherjee. But alas, in spite of all the luxury, the new Khoobsurat has not really been able to fully capture the beauty of the soul of the original.

Sonam plays a physiotherapist, who happens to walk into the royal uppity world of Prince Vikramjit and his family, and as expected, she turns out to be a royal misfit in the palace. As she goes about being herself, refusing to change herself, her presence however, starts changing things for the other residents of the palace.

As the endearing and softhearted father- in- law, Ashok Kumar was a darling in the original, and thankfully, theatre actor Amir Raza Husain, who plays his counterpart here, comes close. Like Ashok Kumar's character, you wish to have someone like Husain in your family too.

Kirron Kher gets the best lines in the film and she does full justice to the role. But then she has enough practice of playing the loud- mouthed Punjabi mom by now. Looks like Ratna Pathak Shah walked out of her Sarabhai Vs Sarabhai sets to walk straight into this one. But then, no complaints. She does a tremendous job playing an independent woman with her nose high up in the air.

To think that her mother, the extremely talented Dina Pathak, played this part in the original, and the daughter has proved to be a worthy successor.

It is Fawad Khan, justifiably the darling of Pakistani television industry, who seems just the right fit for this role. He frowns, smirks and walks away with everyone's hearts with his easy charm. Sonam's performance is a tad disappointing as it tends to be one- dimensional and misses the chutzpah that one would expect from a Disney princess of this time and age. In fact, ironically even though the whole focus of the film is on her, her role in itself seemed half- baked and lazily written.

Director Shashanka Ghosh does a decent job of presenting a fantasy tale, but wish it offered a little more than what was expected from this film even before entering the theatre. Fairy tales are fantasies served with candyfloss. Khoobsurat aims to be just that, only it is less creative fantasy and dripping more of sugary syrup.

Watch it once if you love rom- coms or better still, if you are a Fawad Khan fan.

Stars: 3/5


TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Please lets not turn this thread into an Indo-Pak thread. Kindly keep this thread a happy one. Lets stick to Khoobsurat and its merits and demerits.
nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
seems like 1st day BO collections are good.
The weekend will naturally give the real picture. But 👏 to a good start.

TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Telegraph review:

TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: nevah_mind

seems like 1st day BO collections are good.

The weekend will naturally give the real picture. But 👏 to a good start.



7-8cr is double of what was predicted as best case scenario of 4-5 cr. So it would be awesome if true. But I am not sure how reliable they are...
nevah_mind thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: Sindhu_us

Hey guys I watched Khoobsurat it is not a well made film. the direction is very weak and so is the screenplay. But some moments in the movie keep u engaged. Strictly a one time watch and yes incase of Fawad fans just to see him u might think of going again. I hope the movie does well this weekend due to all the buzz around it at the moment. Fawad Khan is a far better actor than the scope he has got in this film. But as a fan and one who have waited for this movie like all of u fingers crossed that the first weekend the movie will do decent business because I don't see any scope for movie to become a blockbuster. Sorry just my POV.


Why did you think that of the direction and screenplay? Would like to hear more on your POV.
Its interesting to see how different people see the same thing and come out with different feelings.

I for one, just loved it. There were some flaws in the screenplay, but the whole product finally, made up for it. Some things I liked:
I really loved the voice overs reading the thoughts aloud. I was happy that they did that so that there was no scope for ay ambiguity. I also think this comes from the fact that I like things really clear. Specially in a romance story which has Fawad.
I thought the miss-kiss was shot beautifully. It was there, leaving one wanting to see more, but gave the whole scene without showing details.
As much has Kiron Kher has been typecast in this kind of role, her moments brought the loudest laughs in the hall.
Ratna Pathak was superb as Ranisa.

And these are just a few among a long list of other stuff.
Sindhu_us thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
Well I just pray this weekend the movie does good business because next weekend u never know it will sustain as much and after that Bang Bang releases than no scope for any other movie to survive.
divaz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago

Originally posted by: RockChicGirl



7-8cr is double of what was predicted as best case scenario of 4-5 cr. So it would be awesome if true. But I am not sure how reliable they are...


When first look came out I desperately wanted movie to make 8 crores on day 1. But with screen count that low I didnt know what a good number would be. At this point if its 8 crores I would be happy ill settle for less too but as u said we cant rely on this website. Hopefully its good. I wonder why they were so stingy with screens the movie had a good buzz.
TheRager thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
Web version of Telegraph review:

An OTT Sonam and a threadbare plot let Khoobsurat down. but, Fawad oh Fawad!

Manju 1980: Effervescent and friendly to the point of being over familiar, she will dole out unsolicited advice, but will be the first to hold out a hand to yank you out of a tricky situation. She eats without washing her hands ("moonh dhuli hui hai, Auntyji"), laughs loud enough to put a laughter club to shame, speaks in rhymes and believes that rules and regulations need to be bent and broken at times.

Manju 2014: Is now Mili. A zesty physiotherapist whose personality is as colourful as her outfits. Always ready with an opinion and with no "filter" to cap her thoughts, life for Mili is one big party " she gulps down wine like water, is forever on the lookout for a background good enough to click a selfie and makes sure she breaks some rules along the way. And yes, her mom " as quirky and dysfunctional as her " is called Manju!

Hrishikesh Mukherjee's 1980 film starring Rekha as the vivacious Manju, who overturns the lives of the Gupta parivaar and makes its disciplined matriarch have a change of heart, was a fun family film that married message with mirth. Khoobsurat 2014 " its official remake " is predominantly a fuzzy love story, merging the magic realism of a Disney film (Khoobsurat is Disney's first tryst with Bollywood film production) with the romance of a typical Mills & Boon novel.

But the love story " the best bit of Khoobsurat 2014 " kicks in much later. Before that, we have Mili Chakravarty (Sonam Kapoor), physiotherapist to the likes of Dhoni, Sehwag and Team KKR (!) who fills in for an associate on assignment " to get Shekhar Singh Rathore (Aamir Raza Hussain), the wheelchair-bound ruling patriarch of the Rajasthani town of Sambhalgarh back on his feet. So off goes Mili, but runs straight into Nirmala Devi (Ratna Pathak Shah), the strict disciplinarian of the family, who won't allow anyone to break the rules set by her " no laughing out loud, no touching the priceless antiques in her palace, giving up on dinner if you arrive at the dining table a minute later than 8pm, and not allowing her children to follow their hearts.

Mili's outrageous ways " she can't walk straight without knocking something (or someone) down and uses her colourful scarves to change the curtains of her room in the palace " find no favour with Nirmala Devi. Mili also starts off on the wrong note with her son Vikram (Fawad Khan), a man who enters an engagement as dispassionately as he brokers his business deals, his cocky tone and crisp suits reeking of arrogance and betraying little emotion. She calls him "khadoos maindak" (frog = prince, get?); he thinks of her as nothing more than an "aafat".

But Mili's feel-good personality is infectious " she forms a bond with Vikram's kid sister Divya, has beer parties with the palace help in the kitchen and gradually wins over Shekhar Singh, making sure he does his exercises diligently sitting in his wheelchair even as she raids his vintage wine collection.

And true to a Mills & Boon romance, it's not long before the blue-blooded Vikram falls prey to Mili's spontaneity and zest for life. "Hum bilkul alag hain," he keeps reminding himself, but can't stop himself from stealing glances at her from above his ledger books, waking up at the crack of dawn so that he can see her walk on the palace grounds and waiting for her to crack him up with a PJ. Their romance " unspoken, but passionate " finds its high point on a moonlit night when they lock lips for the first time, hesitating at first and then more passionate and needy. Every time they meet after that, their chemistry hits a new high, their heads and hearts giving off conflicting emotions. Theirs is the kind of romance that makes your heart soar even as you root for them.

Unfortunately, you can't root for the rest of Khoobsurat. Director Shashanka Ghosh's plot is wafer-thin " a kidnapping subplot feels a little too forced " and the film soon degenerates into just another romance. It doesn't help that Sonam overplays her Mili. Though she seems more comfortable on screen than she's ever been, Sonam manages to make her Mili more annoying than adorable. Kirron Kher " playing Mili's mom Manju " knows the overbearing Punjabi mother like the back of her hand, but save for a few fun moments, her performance has too much of a deja-vu feel. Theatre veteran Aamir Raza Hussain sparkles in his role, but Ratna Pathak Shah " stepping into the role that her mother Dina Pathak made so memorable in the original " is, unfortunately, saddled with a half-baked part... her quick transition from no-nonsense matriarch to loving mother and doting wife coming off as too abrupt. The silly and soppy climax is also a big let-down, making Khoobsurat a film you forget the moment you exit the theatre.

But if you want to hold hands with your partner and feel warm and fuzzy this weekend, then Khoobsurat should figure on your date list. That one glimpse of Vikram looking at Mili with puppy eyes... love will never be the same again.

PS: And then there is Fawad (see box)!

Five Fawad faves (Spoiler alert!)

His introduction shot: The blue pocket square. The black necktie. The stubble. The eyes. Then, the baritone.

What's better than Fawad in a bandhgala? A bare-bodied Fawad. And yes, he even makes chest hair look sexy.

The way his Vikram looks at Sonam's Mili after that first kiss... almost as if he's discovering a whole new world as he lets go of his inhibitions. Sigh!

Hopelessly in love with Mili, he tries to convince himself that she isn't the one for him. "Let's remain friends," he tells her, even as his inner voice begs: "Please kiss me."

His proposal in the middle of a paintball match... he goes down on his knees and tells her he needs her and wants to grow old with her. What's not to love?

Rekha vs Sonam

Rekha's Manju was far more mature then Sonam's Mili, evident in the manner in which she handles a crisis situation " Dwarkanath's (Ashok Kumar) heart attack. Rekha's effervescence was never over-the-top, but Sonam, in her

enthusiasm to make Mili quirky and fun, grates.

Ashok Kumar vs Aamir Raza Hussain

Aamir Raza Hussain does his bit, but is no match for Ashok Kumar's Dwarkanath " the seemingly hen-pecked husband who gives his wife an earful towards the end and makes Rekha his "girlfriend" and eventually, his "bahu."

Dina Pathak vs Ratna Pathak Shah

As Nirmala Devi, Dina Pathak was far more convincing. Pathak Sr lends layers to her strict mother and wife role, her emotions often peeking out from beneath her disciplinarian garb. Pathak Jr scoffs and frets, but fails to rise above her uni-dimensional role.

Rakesh Roshan vs Fawad Khan

Roshan's Inder was largely a side player. Fawad has more screen time and a better fleshed-out role and his Vikram's proposal to Mili " on his knees and looking into her eyes " is far more romantic than Inder's to Manju " leaving a rose in a glass on her dressing table. And when it comes to looks, we all know who wins hands down

http://www.telegraphindia.com/1140920/jsp/t2/story_18852791.jsp#.VB0HplfNng0



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".