YRKKH: A Disregard for Logic — Abhir’s Parentage and Ruhi’s Baby

**Disclaimer** : This post reflects my personal thoughts and frustrations with the current storyline in YRKKH. I’m just sharing my opinion as a viewer.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

I honestly don’t understand how anyone can keep watching this show without questioning the direction it’s heading in. I appreciate that Abhinav was a good stepdad to Abhir, no doubt, and supported Akshara when Abhimanyu wasn’t around, but let's not forget that Abhir is biologically Abhimanyu and Akshara’s child. Without Akshara and Abhimanyu, there wouldn’t even be Abhir. He’s their child—biological. No Abhir means no Abhinav stepping into a fatherly role, and without that, there’s no “Abhira Sharma.” It’s Akshara and Abhimanyu’s story that forms the foundation of the current generation. That’s the heart of the third generation's story. It can’t just be ignored or brushed aside.

If the writers want to ignore that fact, why not just start a parallel plot without the Birla family and focus on Goenka's with introducing a completely new family instead of Birla's?

And the whole baby swap situation? It’s getting ridiculous. Ruhi’s baby being handed over to Abhira without her consent and making her believe her child is gone forever is just wrong. I get the drama, but this is way too much. No matter what Ruhi did in the past, she doesn’t deserve this.

Generations 1 and 2 focused on family unity, no matter the hurdles. But now? It feels like the show is just stuck in a love triangle with no real purpose.

How can fans still be okay with this kind of plot and keep applauding the serial? It’s honestly becoming a total mess, and it’s hard to understand why it’s being accepted. It feels like the heart of the show is being completely lost. Anyone else feel the same?

People will watch anything with two pretty people onscreen doing whatever the heck they wants. People don't care about morality, wrong things shown online. If there was any policing from audience, we wouldn't have rishta and anupama type show on our screen.

Lol they erase birlas cause Rajan shahi has issues with ex cast members but they can't let go of the drama so we have ruhi BIRLA, and now abhir who has also conveniently forgotten his bio dad whom he had begged to marry his mom 🤣🤣🤣 abhira knows her mom has entire family in udaipur but she didn't ask why her mom is called murderer. It's like they want to keep audience excited but don't want to bother writing anything logical. Abhirs blank surname is also funny. You can keep dads name as sharma, when as per court it was abhimanyu birla. You can keep name as sharma only no one cares 🤣🤣🤣🤣

The baby drama is ridiculous. Imagine being part of a bank robbery and showing attitude to fellow thief that I won't go to police cone what may 🤣🤣 chor ho tum saalo. You are guilty. From where you get the audacity to keep someone else's kid? Is there any paperwork? If you are such a weak man who can't handle your wife, how about never marry and live life alone in misery. Cause that's why you deserve, you good for nothing, wife's asslicker. Rohit purohit don't have any dialogues these days which is not related to supporting abhira, or bas ma abhira k khilaf kuch nahi, or abhira and baby. What is his character arc? He's there just a mouth piece like we have useless waste of space cousin bunch. Bhabhi k naam mandir kholna baki hai

We have so many characters but they don't want to give them any chance.

Aryan a cousin who's in school we see nothing. I didn't even think Manisha cares about her son until the alcohol drama, they both were too busy to defend abhira from kaveri.

Sanjay phuphasa is great actor but he has no material to work. Odd days he's nice man, even days he's bad man

Sanjays son who wants to be a dancer we don't even see him dancing 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Charu is going to have #3 attempt of love and marriage with abhir apparently. Does she have any other goal in life?

Kiara who's name I got to know today. Shes just there to glare at anyone who says anything bad about abhira bhabhi 🤣🤣🤣

Manisha Manoj cabin drama is written in one scene. Giving cabin back isn't the thing. The guy is broken inside how about give him some monologue?

Madhav is useless since forever why the actor is there?

Kaveri is apparently nice woman now who has no voice to any tamasha that's ongoing in house

All this is not to say abhira shouldn't have support system in house. As per itv rule, bahus have that one constant support in dadi, dewar loves her, sasuma sometimes love her sometimes not. But at least show some scenes to show audience why they care about each other. Put some effort? Till this day I am scratching head thinking how the hell the cousins - Aryan charu Kiara etc comes to love and defend abhira so much. Aisa kya kar diya usne Bhai tum logo k liye? Lmao Aryan don't care his father is alcoholic now. He cares bhabhi ko koi kuch nhi bolega 🤣🤣🤣 this kinda ghatiya writing needs to be called out.

But nope. Aise kaise. If you point out something you are jealous hater. Hater of who or what man? These 30-35 years old actors who are busting their ass in Mumbai? Lmao

They could have the same drama with muskan kairavs daughter paired up with Rohit and show going just like now. But i guess men aren't needed lol koi bhi ake erase krke chala jata hain. If makers had issues with Jay Soni I wonder abhira sharma ati kya 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Someone can open a youtube and make money out of this third class cringe.

How much ever we may personally disagree or question the morality/ethics of story, it still seems to be doing good for TRP and channel's business... End of the day that is all matters to them...

Originally posted by: Swathi.A

How much ever we may personally disagree or question the morality/ethics of story, it still seems to be doing good for TRP and channel's business... End of the day that is all matters to them...

Yeah, you're right. It's all about the TRPs and the channel’s business. No matter how poor the story quality is or how illogical, unrealistic, or downright ridiculous it gets, as long as the ratings are there, who cares? As long as people are watching, the content doesn’t matter...It’s all about keeping the numbers up, no matter how much sense or class the storyline has.

Male leads are not so important in yrkkh.

Naitik:

- literally vanished into thin year, Naira was declared dead during Goa leap, then came back and later actually died after Akshara's birth. But Naitik did not once visit. Hell he loved his princess Naira to the moon and back, re-lived his son's missed childhood (coma track) through his daughter. Even when Naira died, I don't think she remembered Naitik in the recall sequence during her fall from cliff. Singhania's were sidelined after Naira's death and Sirat's entry. No funeral mentions of Naitik.

Kartik:

- Though he died in plane crash, no funeral was shown. His own daughters were so traumatized with Sirat's death that they rarely talked about his and Naira's passing. Occasionally they missed him in the show but that's it. But I'm 💯 sure Sirat's name was taken more than Kartik's name. I would've been happy if Goenka's vanished like Singhania's but Sharma's have no family members to provide maayka, so sadly Vampires are still alive. Also it's not Naira vs Sirat clan, as both of them carried forward Kartik's offsprings.

Abhimanyu:

No funeral (thanks to Akshara for not informing anyone), rare mentions just like Naitik and kartik. Birla's after Abhimanyu's death = Singhania's after Sirat's acceptance.

Originally posted by: Naay

**Disclaimer** : This post reflects my personal thoughts and frustrations with the current storyline in YRKKH. I’m just sharing my opinion as a viewer.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

I honestly don’t understand how anyone can keep watching this show without questioning the direction it’s heading in. I appreciate that Abhinav was a good stepdad to Abhir, no doubt, and supported Akshara when Abhimanyu wasn’t around, but let's not forget that Abhir is biologically Abhimanyu and Akshara’s child. Without Akshara and Abhimanyu, there wouldn’t even be Abhir. He’s their child—biological. No Abhir means no Abhinav stepping into a fatherly role, and without that, there’s no “Abhira Sharma.” It’s Akshara and Abhimanyu’s story that forms the foundation of the current generation. That’s the heart of the third generation's story. It can’t just be ignored or brushed aside.

If the writers want to ignore that fact, why not just start a parallel plot without the Birla family and focus on Goenka's with introducing a completely new family instead of Birla's?

And the whole baby swap situation? It’s getting ridiculous. Ruhi’s baby being handed over to Abhira without her consent and making her believe her child is gone forever is just wrong. I get the drama, but this is way too much. No matter what Ruhi did in the past, she doesn’t deserve this.

Generations 1 and 2 focused on family unity, no matter the hurdles. But now? It feels like the show is just stuck in a love triangle with no real purpose.

How can fans still be okay with this kind of plot and keep applauding the serial? It’s honestly becoming a total mess, and it’s hard to understand why it’s being accepted. It feels like the heart of the show is being completely lost. Anyone else feel the same?

They should not have brought the Birla family

They gave a closure to Abhir .. when his mom grieved for him . It was sudden , horrific

We are supposed to feel bad for Manish instead we want Abhir to kick Manish in the face for destroying his family

If Akshara had been alive and shown to be living in mussorie .. and Abhir is found in udaipur .. it would have brought actual sympathy

If they were going to continue gen 4 as Abhira .. they should have shown Akshara walking out with Abhir and later giving birth to Abhira ..

The character Ruhi could have been played by Kairav’s daughter.. who would have technically been the same age of Abhira .

They unnecessarily brought in the Birla family .. if Abhir had existed with his mother .. in any identity but not hidden to Abhira .. Toh natural bonding hoti

Originally posted by: Naay

**Disclaimer** : This post reflects my personal thoughts and frustrations with the current storyline in YRKKH. I’m just sharing my opinion as a viewer.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

I honestly don’t understand how anyone can keep watching this show without questioning the direction it’s heading in. I appreciate that Abhinav was a good stepdad to Abhir, no doubt, and supported Akshara when Abhimanyu wasn’t around, but let's not forget that Abhir is biologically Abhimanyu and Akshara’s child. Without Akshara and Abhimanyu, there wouldn’t even be Abhir. He’s their child—biological. No Abhir means no Abhinav stepping into a fatherly role, and without that, there’s no “Abhira Sharma.” It’s Akshara and Abhimanyu’s story that forms the foundation of the current generation. That’s the heart of the third generation's story. It can’t just be ignored or brushed aside.

If the writers want to ignore that fact, why not just start a parallel plot without the Birla family and focus on Goenka's with introducing a completely new family instead of Birla's?

And the whole baby swap situation? It’s getting ridiculous. Ruhi’s baby being handed over to Abhira without her consent and making her believe her child is gone forever is just wrong. I get the drama, but this is way too much. No matter what Ruhi did in the past, she doesn’t deserve this.

Generations 1 and 2 focused on family unity, no matter the hurdles. But now? It feels like the show is just stuck in a love triangle with no real purpose.

How can fans still be okay with this kind of plot and keep applauding the serial? It’s honestly becoming a total mess, and it’s hard to understand why it’s being accepted. It feels like the heart of the show is being completely lost. Anyone else feel the same?

Abhir basically only knew Abhimanyu for a few months/up to a year. Not really the same as the person (Abhinav) who was there from day 1 of his birth, to him being 7 years old which consists of a lot of Abhirs formative experiences that shaped him into the person he is and became. By all means in the story right now Abhimanyu is only his bio dad who barely even helped raise him and Akshara's ex-husband and his relevance pretty much ends there. Abhimanyu wasn't ever really at the heart of Gen 3's story, it was Akshara and hence Abhira is the lead and why she's got nothing to do with Abhimanyu. Think of everything pre Kasauli as chapter 1 of Akshara's story and everything after as chapter 2 of her story and chapter 2 is the more important phase of her life. All of the Kasauli stuff could stand on its own because its a 2nd chance story, and we've seen a lot of these. The pre Kasauli stuff is more like added exposition for the Kasauli and onwards stuff.

What did I miss? Kahan hai Birla family? Only Birla left is Ruhi Birla Poddar. Usko bhi yaad nahi rahti she's a Birla. And Abhir toh is a Sharma acc. to his own volition. Toh where did Birla family come in between?

Honestly I just want this Gen4 to work for some time for the actors and others in the team if they are good people. Rohit finally got a mainstream show. He is talented and deserved a big break, so I am happy for him. Else I hate RS. After a year and so once actors and other positive souls get enough out of this show, then I hope this show start to do bad and closes. It’s sickening to see evil people like RS having any success and profit. More sickening is to see people supporting such an evil man just because they hate a character and love a character from previous season. I shouldn’t be surprised though. Evil stays because there are always some supporting it in one way or another.

Originally posted by: Blurlaa

Abhir basically only knew Abhimanyu for a few months/up to a year. Not really the same as the person (Abhinav) who was there from day 1 of his birth, to him being 7 years old which consists of a lot of Abhirs formative experiences that shaped him into the person he is and became. By all means in the story right now Abhimanyu is only his bio dad who barely even helped raise him and Akshara's ex-husband and his relevance pretty much ends there. Abhimanyu wasn't ever really at the heart of Gen 3's story, it was Akshara and hence Abhira is the lead and why she's got nothing to do with Abhimanyu. Think of everything pre Kasauli as chapter 1 of Akshara's story and everything after as chapter 2 of her story and chapter 2 is the more important phase of her life. All of the Kasauli stuff could stand on its own because its a 2nd chance story, and we've seen a lot of these. The pre Kasauli stuff is more like added exposition for the Kasauli and onwards stuff.

I get it, Akshara is Abhir’s mother, and Abhinav stepped into the father’s role, raising him with love. Abhir knew nothing else and lived happily, as per Akshara's wishes. But we can’t disregard the fact that Abhimanyu is Abhir’s biological father. He may not have been there at the start but he loved him equally (no need to get into why he wasn’t around — that’s been discussed already in many older posts...). And as per the court, Abhir’s surname was changed to Birla, so how can it suddenly be Sharma on his passport????.? There’s no logic in that.

Even though Abhinav was a big part of Abhir's life, past can’t be twisted like that. There’s a reason it’s called the past or history — it’s what shapes everything. In real life, if a child has two parents, both are acknowledged for their role, not erased....The story shouldn’t manipulated just because of personal preferences or dislikes.

They had the option to create a parallel storyline, forget it, continue with Abhira sharma as legacy kid with Akshara and Abhinav as the parents. But with Abhir, keep it real. He is Abhir Birla. It doesn’t matter that Abhimanyu is Akshara’s ex or that Abhir loved Abhinav as a father figure. The truth is, Abhir loved both of them we have seen it in the episodes and the story should reflect that, keeping the narrative grounded in reality.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

My whole point here is , YRKKH just doesn’t have the quality story it used to. It’s so illogical now, and they keep twisting things to make what’s illegal seem legal just to push the plot forward. It feels like they’re just adding drama without thinking it through and it’s hard to enjoy when nothing really adds up. The whole show has becoming harder to follow with all the forced twists.