CaptiveFreedom thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1
MKD: I won't ever forgive Naira
BKD: I won't ever forgive Kartik

MKD: I won't let Naira meet Kartik
BKD: I won't let Kartik meet Naira

MKD: Naira won't ever return to GV Ashi is perfect match for Kartik
BKD: Naira won't ever return to GV Rishab is perfect match for Naira

MKD: Naira betrayed us all
BKD: Kartik betrayed us all (true)

MKD: Kartik doesn't want Naira in his life
BKD: Naira doesn't want Kartik in her life

MKD: I've legal, moral and ethical right to decide for my adult son
BKD: I've legal, moral and ethical right to decide for my adult sister

MKD: Lost her son...grieved for her son when he was alive...grieved for her dead son...
BKD: Lost his first right on his son...grieved for his son when he was alive...

MKD: Held grudge was disrespectful towards anyone who reminded her
"Kartik and Naira are married couple she can't separate them forever"...
BKD: Hold grudge is disrespectful towards anyone who reminded him that "Kartik and Naira are married couple he can't separate them forever"...

The only dissimilarity is

MKD: Mental instability...OTT panic attacks...was called vamp by all...
BKD: Well known for stand of convenience...

Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 6 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.8k

Users

6

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
Writers master's in recycling storylines and scenes again and again. Rinse and repeat 20 times and claim "longest running show."

Off topic but I want Naira to get a haircut. A new updated shorter modern look.
Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
Naksh has been repeating the same dialogues for the past 2/3 weeks now. I would much rather see other character's reaction to the baby swap/ memory loss. What does Keerti have to say about it all? What are the Goenkas planning to do in the future, just sit around and wait till either Naira gains her memory back or Kartik moves on in his life? Bring back Naitik and Swarna.
We get Naksh hates Kartik and thinks he has wronged his sister, why repeat it over and over again. Now he's stooping to an even lower level by trying to fix his married sister with a guy she knew when she was 10, while her husband is very much still in the picture.

In the segments Naksh was shown saying to Kartik that he shouldn't be bothered with who Naira hangs out with, etc, etc. I get his anger but why do the cvs have to make a mockery of a relationship as pure as marriage.
Miss-Behave thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Fari_15

Naksh has been repeating the same dialogues for the past 2/3 weeks now. I would much rather see other character's reaction to the baby swap/ memory loss. What does Keerti have to say about it all? What are the Goenkas planning to do in the future, just sit around and wait till either Naira gains her memory back or Kartik moves on in his life? Bring back Naitik and Swarna.

We get Naksh hates Kartik and thinks he has wronged his sister, why repeat it over and over again. Now he's stooping to an even lower level by trying to fix his married sister with a guy she knew when she was 10, while her husband is very much still in the picture.

In the segments Naksh was shown saying to Kartik that he shouldn't be bothered with who Naira hangs out with, etc, etc. I get his anger but why do the cvs have to make a mockery of a relationship as pure as marriage.


Honestly naksh is disgusting. I don't even care anymore about the whole baby swap thing, because it seems naksh doesn't even seem to want to comprehend that the idiotic mistake karthik did was out of fear for naira's health, as he loves her so much, but here naksh is essentially taking advantage of naira's memory loss to chuck karthik out of her life and fix her up with another guy. Has he thought that if his disgusting plan of breaking her marriage to karthik and setting her up with another guy during her memory works and she gets her memory back, how will she react? Will she not resent him for taking advantage of her memory loss to make such a big decision of her life without her permission, just as karthik did? I'm sorry, but for me, what naksh is doing is just on par with karthik's impuslive decisions, only naksh is far worse given that karthik did everything out of fear, and naksh is doing it mostly out of resentment and hatred, then covering it all up with fake concern for his sister.

Today he brought up the track of naira being kicked out of the house and the goenka's not having called her back, yet conveniently forgot the entire time he stayed at the side doing nothing for his sister and only whining about his father spending more time with his sister. Did he put his foot down to get his sister her rights in that house? Nope! Did he give karthik and swarna a piece of his mind for his sister in that track? Nope! So why all this fake love for his sister now?
Posted: 6 years ago
#5
Hi All,
I am visiting/commenting on the the forum after a really long time.

Just wanted to put out there that the reason according to naksh is that he is mad at kartik for the kid kartik stole, yet we barely see naksh even spending time with that kid... so what is naksh's actual concern at this point 😕.. other than like everyone else pointed out that its pretty much just getting revenge on kartik by depriving kartik of naira and just trying to hide behind the fact that hes so concerned about nairas overall health and life..

like if you care so much about what kartik did, go spend time with the baby he took away... like you lost this initial bonding time with your baby so go be with him... like at this point your baby probably doesnt even know who you are because all day you are plotting/planning on keeping kartik away from naira... and when not plotting/planning you are hoping/praying naira never regains her memory... like go be with your wife who woke up from a coma and baby who was stolen from you... your sister is married for crying out loud let her be with her husband.. let her know the truth and decide for herself what she wants to do with her life..

i hate naksh's convenience love he has for naira... like stay consistent with your behaviour man... really hoping that when naira does gain her memory she gives him a piece of her mind for trying to set her up with someone else when clearly she is married

Anyways sorry for my rant, just needed to vent a little 😆😳
rose2015 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
I've gotten to the point when Karthik comes on screen I forward the scene. I consider him a negative male lead. I honestly don't care if Naira goes back to him or separates from him. I just want her to get her memory back and decide what she wants to do on her own. No pressure from anyone including Karthik.

Naira going back to Karthik is like an abused woman going back to her abuser.
Edited by rose2015 - 6 years ago
Ajscinesonadar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#7
Apart from story, I'm not understanding why shezad overdoing the act. Naksh as a character is gone case no comments on that, but why actor playing the character performing so badly.
I like shehzad, initially when he entered I liked also him as naksh, but now he is portraying overly not able to connect.

Is it character problem or actor?
Fari_15 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Ajscinesonadar

Apart from story, I'm not understanding why shezad overdoing the act. Naksh as a character is gone case no comments on that, but why actor playing the character performing so badly.

I like shehzad, initially when he entered I liked also him as naksh, but now he is portraying overly not able to connect.

Is it character problem or actor?


Can be both, but I have seen far more negative characters who can still be endured due to the actor's performance.

Shehzad started of fine probably because the scenes were quite simple. Maybe he is decent at performing emotional scenes, but anger is clearly not his forte.
Ajscinesonadar thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Fari_15


Can be both, but I have seen far more negative characters who can still be endured due to the actor's performance.

Shehzad started of fine probably because the scenes were quite simple. Maybe he is decent at performing emotional scenes, but anger is clearly not his forte.


@bold Yeah that's true.

I felt he is being over enthu towards this particular track. Whatever he has to tone down.

He can deliver good performance he is capable of that, but he needs to channelize his skills first.
As in this track he has more screen space after this one never know when is next track where he will get to perform with more SC. So he should utilise it properly.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".