RiSha12384 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
hey guys... the recent track has been unnerving me...it is raising questions in my mind about judgment and the thin line between right and wrong......... i was wondering what your opinions were...

Akshara is sticking her neck out 4 nandu's happiness...knowing full well she is throwing herself under the bus...she is risking all the relationships in her sasural for the sake of one's happiness...Is she dumb or is she selfless? She thinks with her heart first and her mind last....is that a rare quality or is it sheer stupidity....

The fact that she didnt tell naitik from the beginning ....is that a breach of trust in the marriage...?

Which kasam should have held more importance the one to her husband or the one to her nanand?


As i was thinking about this whole situation that akshara has gotten herself into...at first i was sitting and thinking how stupid can this girl be 2 put herself in that situation...the more i thought about it ...the more i found myself relating and siding with akshara..

Akshara still holds a rare quality in my opinion...the fact that she lives 4 others happiness.....she would put her happiness on the line to bring a smile some1 else's face..... the way she handled the situation may have been wrong....but i dont think what she did was wrong....she didnt want nandu 2 be miserable 4 the rest of her life...so she encouraged her 2 choose her happiness over her responsibility...

The fact that she didnt tell naitik was wrong...but her intentions weren't
(in her defense she did attempt 2 tell him)...she shouldnt have gone in as deep as she did without her husbands knowledge....

The kasam she gave to her husband should always hold more importance....but my moral dilemma comes in at this thought...part of the kasams she has given to her husband was that his family is now her's as well....and she would always ensure their happiness....so wasnt what she was doing 4 nandini part of what she promised him she would do???

Edited by aksharanaitik - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

3.2k

Users

10

Likes

57

Frequent Posters

Nandini6 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Ya u r exactly right........It is a rare quality in which she is happy if her family members r so.......... She is not selfish ......... It is not stupidity.......... it is her goodness .She dont think of her first but she thinks of others ....... this helping nature ...... one r the other day come to presence....... will be noticed. i do agree she was not wrong. Pyaar kisi ko kehe kar thodi aata hai. Naithik should understand this.hope he do so [B][/B] 😔
RiSha12384 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: nandinisharma6

Ya u r exactly right........It is a rare quality in which she is happy if her family members r so.......... She is not selfish ......... It is not stupidity.......... it is her goodness .She dont think of her first but she thinks of others ....... this helping nature ...... one r the other day come to presence....... will be noticed. i do agree she was not wrong. Pyaar kisi ko kehe kar thodi aata hai. Naithik should understand this.hope he do so [B][/B] 😔



Everyone will hopefully realize this soon enough.....but Naitik is justified with his anger....he was blind sighted by 3 ppl he trusted and loved very much...
ritu_iluvyrkkh thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
Shanta, unfortunatly I have been thinking about some of these things myself....I guess there is no right or wrong answer here and I could have argued either ways on this one...but the more I think of this, I think Akshara was wrong...agreed that we are talking about the age-old battle of the heart vs the mind here, but the bottomline is that every situation is unique and we must play by the day...
in this case I feel Akshara is a fault coz she just listened to her heart and supported Nandini selflessly for the sake of her love...she genuinely wanted Nandu to be happy and hence went leaps and bounds to make sure that she gets her true love and not compromise for the sake of the family honor & happiness...
but this is where she faltered...Nandini's situation is unique with her disability and not being married for so long and the family having just one goal to get her married etc...so she should have been extra careful and first of all tried to stay out of this...unfortunately she got involved but when Nandu and Mohit asked her not to tell Naitik, she should have been firm that she will tell him and explained the benefits of it rather than mutely saying yes to them and taking these big risks later....how can she hide such a huge thing from her husband...ok Nandu gave her promise but didnt she break that promise when she was trying to tell Naitik the nite he slept off???
and moreover she is the NEW DIL of the house...she should know her limits especially in such sensitive matters!!!
so to answer some of ur Q, I dont think Akshara was even thinking for a second how much risk she is taking by getting involved in this...she has no time & is also not that smart or matured to think about the sasural risks...so in a way she is stupid....
and about the breach of trust in the marriage, my personal opinion is that yes it was a breach of trust coz shadi ke baad we should be open with our hubbys as much as possible...she should have refused to hide this from him from the begining....especially after going through one incident of hiding the job interview thing from Naitik and how hurt he was...and also for the fact that maybe if he had enough time, he could have understood and maybe even supported their love....atleast there wouldnt be fireworks on the day a prospecive suitor is supossed to come home!!! what can we expect anyone to do then??? so I think Akshara acted dumb and stupid in this situation and Naitik is fully justified in his outburst.....
ankita2407 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5
you are absolutely right akshara is not selfish niether she is stupid, she just wanted to see nandini happy...and as she know that nandini will be happy with mohit so she helped her...........and it is not so that she herself wanted to hide it from naitik , but first it was nandini coz of whom she did that and latter it was her bad luck that naitik fell a sleep........so i don't think she ever wanted to break that trust............. and for me mohit is atleast better than that dr. coz with that dr. nandani just has to do a samjhota
yaar this is definitely a topic on which every person can have a different point of view as a person would feel that akshara was right and other may feel she was wrong
but for me though she did wrong by hiding it from naitik but her intensions were never wrong......it is just that when naitik will come to know about it he will be shocked and in that fit of rage he will not support her eventually but later on he will definitely understand her..........
Edited by joysorrow - 15 years ago
ritu_iluvyrkkh thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: nandinisharma6

Ya u r exactly right........It is a rare quality in which she is happy if her family members r so.......... She is not selfish ......... It is not stupidity.......... it is her goodness .She dont think of her first but she thinks of others ....... this helping nature ...... one r the other day come to presence....... will be noticed. i do agree she was not wrong. Pyaar kisi ko kehe kar thodi aata hai. Naithik should understand this.hope he do so [B][/B] 😔

goodness is fine but now she is married...she needs to think practically also...and she needs to remember that she is still very young and not a dadima to solve world hunger alone...so she should have told Naitik about this immediately...
and Naitik prolly would have understood after a bit of convincing that pyar ho jaata hai....I mean we are talking about the god of pyar here...but how do u expect him to suddenly accept all this especially after seeing what he saw in the park??
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: aksharanaitik

<font color="#cc0066">hey guys... the recent track has been unnerving me...it is raising questions in my mind about judgment and the thin line between right and wrong......... i was wondering what your opinions were...<br><br>Akshara is sticking her neck out 4 nandu's happiness...knowing full well she is throwing herself under the bus...

Shanta, that's exactly what she's unaware of...not once did she think of the consequences...usually we balance our relationships but if we measure, she has done everything for nandini's happiness ONLY and on the other side, her family(the in laws), her husband , the honour & reputation of the family was TOTALLY ignored ! i dun have a problem with what she did but what is surprising is that NOT ONCE did she think abt the family angle ??? she's feeling elated tht nandini has decided to be with mohit but she isn't thinking that back home the ladke wale r about to arrive and how will they handle this situation? she's not even worried?????? this is not practical !

she is risking all the relationships in her sasural for the sake of one's happiness...Is she dumb or is she selfless?


for sure, this is dumbness the root cause of which is her selflessness....i'll not blame her tht she cud not balance the relationships, it's very difficult for any girl to do it , it takes a lot of effort n knowing each other..i'm glad she was not shown to be a superhuman who can handle everything on her own....i wonder if anybody can be as selfless as akshara and even if there r they must be suffering alone in some corner of their houses like akshara is ! if u wanna keep others happy (which is in a way acting selfless , u keep others happiness on priority than ur own) then u have keep yourself happy


She thinks with her heart first and her mind last....is that a rare quality or is it sheer stupidity...


i think Shanta, all of of us, specially girls think frm their heart first and then their heads bec. we're emotional by nature...someone told me the first voice tht comes frm within u is the voice of God, the voice of ur conscience and after tht, whichever thoughts come in ur mind is the devil's voice inside u...this toh akshara also knows very well that she should have told naitik the very first day bec. everytime her conscience was telling her tht she must tell naitik...when she knew abt nandini and mohit, fine , it's her POV tht nandini should follow her heart, she supported their relationship, therez nothing wrong in tht....(and she will have to face the heat for this prolly)

.<br><br>The fact that she didnt tell naitik from the beginning ....is that a breach of trust in the marriage...?<br><br>Which kasam should have held more importance the one to her husband or the one to her nanand?<br><br><br><font color="#3300ff">As i was thinking about this whole situation that akshara has gotten herself into...at first i was sitting and thinking how stupid can this girl be 2 put herself in that situation...the more i thought about it ...the more i found myself relating and siding with akshara..<br><br>Akshara still holds a rare quality in my opinion...the fact that she lives 4 others happiness.....she would put her happiness on the line to bring a smile some1 else's face..... the way she handled the situation may have been wrong....but i dont think what she did was wrong....she didnt want nandu 2 be miserable 4 the rest of her life...so she encouraged her 2 choose her happiness over her responsibility...

i said so much abt this earlier , now i dun wanna repeat myself :( Shanta dear, she doesn't want a miserable life for nandini but whatz the guarantee tht nandini will have a comfortable life with mohit? on what basis did she encourage nandini? tht's exactly why she should have told naitik earlier or at least try to find out abt mohit's background n family first..did mohit tell her or nandini that HIS parents are also against this rishta? since naitik is the one closest to mohit, he knows him frm childhood days, he was the best judge whether or not mohit is suitable for nandini....i think if the doctor is good natured n his family is good, his age can be ignored bec. he and his family are willing to take nandini as their DIL knowing about her disability ! ALSO , NAndini's parents were happy with the rishta... this was a much better scenario than nandini marrying mohit who doesn't have a good financial background & whoz family (specially his monster mom) has made it clear that "langdi" nandini will never become their bahu ! will akshara not feel guilty to see Nandini in this pathetic state after marriage? so at least she should be knowing what she's doing...she was playing a BLIND GAME...


<br><br>The fact that she didnt tell naitik was wrong...but her intentions weren't </font>
</font><font color="#cc0066">(in her defense she did attempt 2 tell him)</font><font color="#3300ff">...she shouldnt have gone in as deep as she did without her husbands knowledge....<br><br>The kasam she gave to her husband should always hold more importance....but my moral dilemma comes in at this thought...part of the kasams she has given to her husband was that his family is now her's as well....and she would always ensure their happiness....so wasnt what she was doing 4 nandini part of what she promised him she would do???<br></font><font color="#cc0066"><br></font>

Shanta, in a joint family, and since Aksh belonged to a joint family she must be knowing it better, it's very important tht the girl blends in the family..she was told from day 1, when she stepped in the house, that the DIL has to be very careful at every step bec. it takes 1 sec. for ppl. to pull her down..logon ko baatein banane ka mauka nahi dena chahiye (tht's what Gayitri told her) ...time n again she was reminded that for them the family honour is above everything..then howcome she risked the reputation of her in laws this way? as a DIL it was her duty to think about EVERYBODY's happiness and not just one person..the decision of marriage is to be taken by elders, doesn't she know that? nandini's happiness is not only with mohit but she wants her parents blessings ALSO, doesn't akshara know this? didn't she know that her conservative in laws will have an objection to this mismatch jodi??? doesn't she know daddaji is dead against the idea of love marriage?? Naitik complained to her many times that she overrides his wishes for the family's sake, he's the last in her priority list and aksh just proved him right :((( she miscalculated Naitik's reaction, although i always said tht he will never support any kind of relation b/w mohit and any of his sisters...Aksh thought tht naitik will support them once he'll come to know but i'm glad at least he is more practical n logical...



despite of all these factors, and my belief tht aksh needed this jolt, yet i dun want her to be thrown out of her sasural and i want naitik to support her bec. of various other reasons....
Edited by _charu_ - 15 years ago
beautiful16 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
Rifat.. i agree wid ur post... being myself mayb i wont let my happiness suffer coz of others.. m too selfish..but lookng at my mom.. she did evrythng to make her inlaws happy.. sumtimes i thnk y is she soo dumb ( get really angry at her) but thn i understnd tat her happiness lies in tat... forget inlaws i've seen her doin so wid neighbours & frnz as well.. she got a earful from my dad many a times..but her nature is tat way.. & now i understnd thru akshara... she is same as my mom.. selfless... but i want her to b otherwise coz ths will only hurt her & her relationships... I hope naitik understand her (it will take time) but once he starts doin soo, his respect & love for her will b double... m sure.
-renu- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: aksharanaitik

hey guys... the recent track has been unnerving me...it is raising questions in my mind about judgment and the thin line between right and wrong......... i was wondering what your opinions were...

Akshara is sticking her neck out 4 nandu's happiness...knowing full well she is throwing herself under the bus...she is risking all the relationships in her sasural for the sake of one's happiness...Is she dumb or is she selfless? She thinks with her heart first and her mind last....is that a rare quality or is it sheer stupidity....

The fact that she didnt tell naitik from the beginning ....is that a breach of trust in the marriage...?

Which kasam should have held more importance the one to her husband or the one to her nanand?


As i was thinking about this whole situation that akshara has gotten herself into...at first i was sitting and thinking how stupid can this girl be 2 put herself in that situation...the more i thought about it ...the more i found myself relating and siding with akshara..

Akshara still holds a rare quality in my opinion...the fact that she lives 4 others happiness.....she would put her happiness on the line to bring a smile some1 else's face..... the way she handled the situation may have been wrong....but i dont think what she did was wrong....she didnt want nandu 2 be miserable 4 the rest of her life...so she encouraged her 2 choose her happiness over her responsibility...

The fact that she didnt tell naitik was wrong...but her intentions weren't
(in her defense she did attempt 2 tell him--)...she shouldnt have gone in as deep as she did without her husbands knowledge....

The kasam she gave to her husband should always hold more importance....but my moral dilemma comes in at this thought...part of the kasams she has given to her husband was that his family is now her's as well....and she would always ensure their happiness....so wasnt what she was doing 4 nandini part of what she promised him she would do???

well shanta 😛 ....to begin with.....
....i think akshi is "SELFLESSLY DUMB" in this matter.......i'm not sure whether this is a positive trait 👏 ....or sheer foolhardiness 😉 ......esp when for akshi, it is like "survival of the fittest" in Jurassic Park......😆
........kasams...both are important....BUT.....Nandini should have known that she was creating "THE GREAT RIFT VALLEY" b/w Naitik n Akshi....infact, when akshi tried to create an OPENING FOR NANDINI, THAT "NANDINI MIGHT NOT WANT TO MARRY THE DOC" in front of the dinos.....Nandini betrayed her....n Akshi should have realised at least THEN ......." THERE CANNOT BE A BIGGER ALLY THAN THE HUSBAND"...in saasland......😆
......akshi, nandini n mohit....all 3 knew EXACTLY how every other person would REACT....or rather....EXPLODE...on hearing about "LOVE STORY 2010" 🤢 ...........hence i would not term Akshara's half-baked attempts to tell Naitik the truth as sincere attempts.....she was JUST TELLING HERSELF....that she tried to tell him......if she had REALLY wanted to.....she WOULD HAVE succeeded.......NOTHING in the world could have stopped her....😛
...to answer your last question....please answer this first....."How can Akshara decide...WHO IS THE IDEAL LIFEPARTNER FOR NANDINI?.....over n above Nandini's parents, brother, etc etc??.....does she think no one else loves Nandini or cares for her?.......when Akshara HERSELF is so immature at the moment?..."
....Darling Akshara 😛 .....life is not lived on "love n fresh air" alone.......Love flies out of the window in very little time....when the harsh realities of life hit u........😛
..... Akshara if u really love Nandini....😉...u should have just arranged a meeting of nandini at "Royal Park, Udaipur"....with...Moheeet's Mom 😈......
.....😆 😆 saara love ......which nandini had for moheeet.....on the spot...vanish ho jaata 🤣....n nandini would have been happily married to the doc by now.....😉.....
Krinya thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 8

Team Critics

Posted: 15 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: beautiful16

Rifat.. i agree wid ur post... being myself mayb i wont let my happiness suffer coz of others.. m too selfish..but lookng at my mom.. she did evrythng to make her inlaws happy.. sumtimes i thnk y is she soo dumb ( get really angry at her)but thn i understnd tat her happiness lies in tat... forget inlaws i've seen her doin so wid neighbours & frnz as well.. she got a earful from my dad many a times..but her nature is tat way.. & now i understnd thru akshara... she is same as my mom.. selfless... but i want her to b otherwise coz ths will only hurt her & her relationships... I hope naitik understand her (it will take time) but once he starts doin soo, his respect & love for her will b double... m sure.



Sabi, thinking abt ur happiness is not being selfish....one has to be tactful and diplomatic while dealing with the in laws (if u wanna keep them happy..if u don't, it's ur choice, live seperate)...aksh did everything to keep them happy and in this process she did EVERYTHING which hurted them n in a way went against their tradition and tarnished the honour n reputation of the family.....isn't this foolishness? if she wanted to see them happy then "unki tarah se unhe khush rakhna padega, apni tarah se nahi"

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".