-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Some questions that Ishita needed to ask...
  • Why is Raman ok with Pihu hating Ishita but not ok with Pihu hating him for lying to her and hiding the truth from her about Ishita being her mother?
  • Wasn't Pihu brought into this world so that Ishita can have an 'ansh' of her own? Then why does it become always about how Pihu will react to Raman and not about Ishita feels about having her own biological child but not being able to call her her own.
  • Was Ruhi being kidnapped only Ishita's fault?

The surrogacy track was built on the premise of giving Ishita her own biological child... all the tracks since then has been totally anti that premise... a show about nature vs nurture has nothing about nature or nurture...
Raman the quiet emotional observant guy has been literally turned into an impulsive uncontrolled motormouth and Ishita from standing up for her rights to some abla tear shedding bechari.


Two smart individuals are now constantly manipulated by a quintessential bimbo...
Are the same creatives writing the show still ? 😆

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

3k

Users

15

Likes

229

Frequent Posters

ishra_JD_club thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
Gan well said !!!
Dont ask any logical things... jis cheez ke answet ni mil sakte uska kya faida... jo tumne pointer diye use jar ishra fan kabse uske ans chahta hei.. bt cvs are brainless sensrless hopeless unlogical...
Na toh answer milenge na toh purana yhm
Meri andar ki sari hopes are brutully murder ho gya hei
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: sweet.Aman

Gan well said !!!
Dont ask any logical things... jis cheez ke answet ni mil sakte uska kya faida... jo tumne pointer diye use jar ishra fan kabse uske ans chahta hei.. bt cvs are brainless sensrless hopeless unlogical...
Na toh answer milenge na toh purana yhm
Meri andar ki sari hopes are brutully murder ho gya hei


I was not expecting any from the cvs... just this scene of Pihu coming to know the truth about her birth was something I wanted to see .. being a mother... but instead I was left with these thoughts... this was supposed to be a watershed moment post leap... but somehow the indifference with which it was presented... just made me wonder .. while in the credits the creatives are still the same how did the ones who wrote the bringing few months are coming up with these crap that we see these days
bscorp13 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#4
She also should ask that when raman was okay telling the truth to pihu only a month back and was actually convincing ishita that they should break it to her..what has changed today...
Raman said precisely the same lines you mentioned in your post Gan..that pihu ko Janna chahiye me who tumhaara2 ansh hai..

This is not about deeper issues of surrogacy and the reason of bringing pihu into existence..
Both Raman and ishita have been made to sit at the fence in the pihu issue using the same excuse..first ishita said she will.hate me ..dont tell her now..now raman says the same thing..only his tone and language makes it more dramatic and cvs will.use that well...

No..i don't agree with raman saying oohu shouldn't know the truth ..but the inconsistency in cvs writing makes me question both ishita and raman here..since both are responsible for not breaking the truth to pihu here. Neither one can claim.tje moral high ground here😛
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: bscorp13

She also should ask that when raman was okay telling the truth to pihu only a month back and was actually convincing ishita that they should break it to her..what has changed today...

Raman said precisely the same lines you mentioned in your post Gan..that pihu ko Janna chahiye me who tumhaara2 ansh hai..

This is not about deeper issues of surrogacy and the reason of bringing pihu into existence..
Both Raman and ishita have been made to sit at the fence in the pihu issue using the same excuse..first ishita said she will.hate me ..dont tell her now..now raman says the same thing..only his tone and language makes it more dramatic and cvs will.use that well...

No..i don't agree with raman saying oohu shouldn't know the truth ..but the inconsistency in cvs writing makes me question both ishita and raman here..since both are responsible for not breaking the truth to pihu here. Neither one can claim.tje moral high ground here😛


@bold He did eh? So that tells you whoever wrote that part is on Diwali break now and the one writing now has no clue 😉😆


@underline .. absolutely agree with you.. they just put whatever down to fit their ultimate agenda: create melodrama and prolong Shagun's manipulation



3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
I don't want ishita to accept pihu after 6 months leap as her daughter .i hope ishita get pregnant & live motherhood step fully with out raman
I feel bad when I read raman leave ishita to be with sick shaggy & nutanki pihu let him he deserved both

Ishita could have her own child & live with people love her
Edited by 3fra - 8 years ago
DikshaN thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7
so true
well when it was revealed to us that pihu doesn't know about ishu being her mom
I really thought that this scene will be very significant and we will get to see divan and ruhanikas fab acting wherein ishra will be pouring out how much they missed the moments of parenting their own child together
but the scene today gave me no feels
Raman looked like an angry lion ready to pounce on his prey this expression of his u usually see when someone hurts ishu but today it was completely opposite and than they are going to romance tomorrow for their suhagraat instead of sitting and solving their problems like really???
GBSC thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
Apparently the cvs head n sj the story writer have moved on to producing their own shows.
There were even IV s of sj taking credit for the chr raman,while promoting her show.
This show is now at the hands of the interns.
With just the brief that shags should be the central chr.
Make all the other chrs dumb,especially the ml n fl,inorder to achieve that.
Forgot to add,
Make the viewers too dumb,but keep the diff fandoms happy with mini tracks introduced for their family members so that even the actors don't complain.
Anyways the 7:30 slot viewing trp aunties are themselves dumb with almost all shows having a similar sstoryline.
At the end of the day,there is no continuity to the storyline or the chr sketches.
The logic in the show is non existent.
The episodes n dialogues seem totally disjointed.
As standalone scenes or episodes, they are bearable sometimes.
ITS SIMPLY TRP DRIVEN.
When it falls,there will be scope for anything good in the show.That too briefly until the crapfest continues all over again
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: 3fra

I don't want ishita to accept pihu after 6 months leap as her daughter .i hope ishita get pregnant & live motherhood step fully with out raman

I feel bad when I read raman leave ishita to be with sick shaggy & nutanki pihu let him he deserved both

Ishita could have her own child & live with people love her


Well at the end of everything you surely can't deny that Raman loves Ishita and so does he... yes they are an odd couple who probably shouldn't be together if it were real life.

I don't know what the spoilers say... I react only to what's telecast. So let's see
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: bscorp13

She also should ask that when raman was okay telling the truth to pihu only a month back and was actually convincing ishita that they should break it to her..what has changed today...

Raman said precisely the same lines you mentioned in your post Gan..that pihu ko Janna chahiye me who tumhaara2 ansh hai..

This is not about deeper issues of surrogacy and the reason of bringing pihu into existence..
Both Raman and ishita have been made to sit at the fence in the pihu issue using the same excuse..first ishita said she will.hate me ..dont tell her now..now raman says the same thing..only his tone and language makes it more dramatic and cvs will.use that well...

No..i don't agree with raman saying oohu shouldn't know the truth ..but the inconsistency in cvs writing makes me question both ishita and raman here..since both are responsible for not breaking the truth to pihu here. Neither one can claim.tje moral high ground here😛



Pb what's the point in bringing up role swap when it doesn't matter to anyone but us who see how illogical this stretching was? In fact today questions are raised from most everyone about Raman but only 2-3 people I saw asked why Ishita didn't tell Raman what Mani told her? Yet even here we know why she didn't - same reason Raman left the mandap -

Raman is the only one wrong here and the fact he's is most culpable about Pihu not knowing the truth makes him the only super wrong one ever worth discussing

I'm at the point I don't get why there is panic over the TOI spoiler bc that effectively breaks up IshRa so Raman can't oppress and destroy things for Ishita anymore bc he's never going to be right or shown as giving a valid point without nonsensical OTTness so forever and ever will he be oppressive.

Here we'll hang onto all these past points but to on screen IshRa they become moot in a day.

Sorry for the rant but I just woke up with a headache and see literally nothing new from April 1st about the dynamics of this show so why not just go for the suicide dive on the show

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".