Created

Last reply

Replies

110

Views

11.8k

Users

37

Likes

543

Frequent Posters

-godschild- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: beckysharp



Dear Ms. Ray, welcome back ! It sure is strange that you pop up almost always when there is criticism about Shagun / Ruhi Arora ! I sure love your loyalty and ardent defense !

My one question to you, when did YHM become a triangle ? I always thought it was a love story between two embittered and rejected souls ! So why the justification of unnecessary thrusting of a character down the viewer throat may I ask ?

Yes Shagun is important but only as far as the fact that she is Raman's ex and the mother of Raman's children ! How exactly can a woman who betrayed her husband, was a mistress of another man, led her husband to doubt the paternity of his child, brain washed his other child against him, an important part of his life !

Seriously you guys baffle me ! Or maybe I have too many morals and ethics ?

Ugh ! the reformed shagun makes me wanna puke !


👏 👏 👏
Becky that was so so perfectly put 😃
We are obviously not getting an answer though.
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#42
Haven't watched or read the LU yet, but you bring up a point that's been bugging me -

Why do all the supporting cast tracks get tossed around like they are useless when Shagun gets a full blown one with attention to detail? I'm happy Shagun has a new premi or something, but what about the others?

Forget ACP, a recent addition, do Simmi/Param/Romi/Bala/Mihika/Mihir/Vandu/etc not deserve a decent & complete track? Seriously to me, the last complete track that nicely involved side characters may have been like the Mihir-Mihika engagement track (but I may be overlooking other tracks that they were well used)...

The supporting cast is so talented so they should get a justified side track that is completed like the leads & Shagun get.
ankitasen thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: DhwaniNair

Anita has a huge following. so raman's ex has alwys imprtnce, and Ishita's ex has no imprtnc bcaz he has so many bashers here


Just bracketing them as "ex" don't make them equal in IshRa life. Shagun is Raman's ex-wife with whom she obviously had physical relationship and they had two children together whereas Subbu was Ishita's boyfriend. Besides Ishita was over Subbu even before her marriage but Raman wasn't in the form of extreme hatred.
fugitives123 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: --PriyaRay--

Shagun hasn't become the parallel lead out of nowhere, she is one important angle in this triangle.



Last time I checked...she was the ex wife who left the guy 6 years before he remarried. How is she in a triangle? I wish I could physically remove my brains to accept what you're saying.

ex-wife
noun
  1. a woman to whom someone was formerly married, from whom they are now divorced.



3fra thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: fugitives123



Last time I checked...she was the ex wife who left the guy 6 years before he remarried. How is she in a triangle? I wish I could physically remove my brains to accept what you're saying.

ex-wife
noun
  1. a woman to whom someone was formerly married, from whom they are now divorced.




Two person madly in love and threed person force himself/herself in between becourse of love or intersting in she/he that call triangle correct me if I am wrong don't tell me shagun in love with raman she not but she is diffently in love with Ishita 😡
samrash27 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: --PriyaRay--

Shagun hasn't become the parallel lead out of nowhere, she is one important angle in this triangle.


why you keep on repeating the same line again and again...
do u even know what is the meaning of love triange...
ishra and shagun can never be any triangle...
CVs are just trying to push shagun in YHM by giving any stupid reason...

YHM is all about raman and ishita with ruhi as cupid...
its not abt any adi or shagun...

i dont even remeber when was the last time we got proper IshRaRu moment...

now with adi ISHRARU bond is also spoiled...
-K.13- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#47

100000% ditto to your post! I mentioned yesterday that they took what could have been as emotional & powerful as the earthquake track & repeat the magic here...

But instead we get dumbness. I like their comedy if I watch yesterday's episode without thinking of future & past episodes leading to that moment.

YHM CVs are either 2 different teams or really have split personalities. There's no other way to explain this. 🤢
ankitasen thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#48
Latest news is Romi-Sarika are again shown married, isn't it?

I suppose ACP track is scrapped...at least for now. The way Rinky is going, I won't be surprised if makers are thinking of reuniting MiMi. Plus the actors (Mihika and Raj) were not happy about the changes, specially parting away of MiMi.

Romi's role on the show is disappointing, his character has no growth whatsoever. Bala's character also falls into the same category. There's never been a single track centering on Bala-Vandu!

A reformed Shagun simply has no business here in YHM and IshRa life. If she was a vamp/grey character, her presence still could be relatable. No one is interested to watch Shagun's rekindled love life. A reformed Shagun's love life at most can have a footnote in YHM but the importance makers are giving is simply absurd. Again, I won't be surprised if ShaNoj love story takes the precedence over IshRa love story. 😡
-Silencia- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#49
About the original post and Shagun / Ruhi Arora

Let's count the no. of tracks sidelined recently:

  1. Romi-Sarika = Are they married? Are they not? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi overhears Ishita's personal conversation with her gynaecologist.
  2. Romi - Financial stability = Was it a one time thing? Or has he seriously established his business to be able to support at least his wife and kid? Does he know Ishita is Rohit's guarantor? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi wants IshRa to come closer, hence taunts Ishita.
  3. Simmi - Future = Did Simmi join the women entrepreneurship course? Is she going to join Raman's business? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi stays in touch with Raman's old colleagues who are able to reach out to her in a moment, while as Raman & others haven't been able to find her yet.
  4. Mihika - Abhishek = Is she interested in him? Or does she want to just stay friends and move ahead? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi flies across the city to save Ishita from Ashok's clutches.
  5. Abhishek - Sarika = Is there an honor killing story? Why is Sarika afraid of her brother? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi is unknowingly sharing her new home with an unknown man.
  6. Bala - Business - Romi = Has Bala been successful in establishing his coaching center? Does Romi know why Ishita asked Bala not to give business to him? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi has hits and misses with the said man, at her own house.
  7. Adi - Baby = Does Adi have any feelings towards IshRa's baby? Is he as excited as Ruhi, or does he not want it? Who cares? Shagun / Ruhi has lovely nok-jhoks with the doctor.
CVs want Shagun to be a parallel lead, even though viewers have never accepted the character so? Even then, it is fine, at least show some logical transformation. Her gradual conversion from grey to black to purer than Ganges white avatar. Where is her remorse? Her struggle? Her strength to stay away from IshRa's life - where did it come from? Her concern and longing for her kids?

Or Ruhi Arora has selective amnesia, where she has forgotten all about Shagun, but still remembers how to taunt Ishita, but because she's Ruhi now so taunts a good heart & good intentions, and pats her own back when IshRa do it, because well, she instigated.

Want to give Shagun the screen space? Fine, do it. At least justify her getting it. Even Sarika & Pammi aunty's characters justify their presence in the overall story.

This is a disrespect to Anita as well, who has a good fan following, but her character is being forced down upon everyone unwillingly and hence will never command the appreciation that might be due.

P.S. No offence meant to anyone. Personal views, reflect opinions on characters only, and carry nothing in person.
Edited by -Nidoo- - 10 years ago
-Silencia- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: -K.13-


100000% ditto to your post! I mentioned yesterday that they took what could have been as emotional & powerful as the earthquake track & repeat the magic here...

But instead we get dumbness. I like their comedy if I watch yesterday's episode without thinking of future & past episodes leading to that moment.

YHM CVs are either 2 different teams or really have split personalities. There's no other way to explain this. 🤢


@bold - EXACTLY what I said yesterday! It could have been Ishita's earthquake moment for Raman and it would have been so, so, so beautiful to watch. Also, the family bonding could've been emotionally explored, ultimately emerging stronger. But

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".