GREENER PASTURES - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

79

Views

15.8k

Users

25

Likes

389

Frequent Posters

redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: EkPaheli


Subu ...Ruby kiski yaad dilla di 😭 😆 Oh I so wish they could go there like now but will wait if I am right and the guy is even 50% like his bro Bala it wouldn't be hard to guess why she fell for him and the reason she couldn't fall for Mani was - a) he is the male her like you said and b) she was with Subu at the time - also to quote a line from one of my fav shows which is getting ruined somehow - Ying needs Yang not another ying. Ying Yang is harmony Ying Ying is a name for a panda.😆 and she knows Raavan Kumar for all his rudeness has one thing that the guy she saw Ram in didn't have - the strength to be there for her when she needed him the most ..


all people need to do to combat all this insecurity in the forum is to read these lines ... answer Apne aap pata chal jaayega ...

this is the man who has stood by her ..even when he claimed to DETEST her existence ... now that he clearly cares for her .. & also (biggest secret) LOVES HER .. what do u think he will do for HER ...

add ADITYA to the mix as well ... 😉
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: redwine1


all people need to do to combat all this insecurity in the forum is to read these lines ... answer Apne aap pata chal jaayega ...

this is the man who has stood by her ..even when he claimed to DETEST her existence ... now that he clearly cares for her .. & also (biggest secret) LOVES HER .. what do u think he will do for HER ...

add ADITYA to the mix as well ... 😉


Exactly even when he has time and again said he would not solve any problems of hers from now on - like during the Bala-Romi fiasco but ultimately he always stands by the person who is right... for all his anger issues this man has a very strong and a clear conscious and it doesn't let him deviate from the right path for long - yes he does have moments when as human he tends to err like during the accident track but he ultimately chooses to do the right thing and stand by the right person and cause even if it hurts him as it did when he knew what his sister would be living when she learns the truth of her husband or when turning over his son and ALL of this was at the point when he wasn't in love with her now that he is he would move heaven and earth for her and as for Adi... oh the kids of RKB are the biggest game changers - Ruhi and Adi, in their own way have served to bring their parents - closer in ways like nothing else could... and if this family comes together under one roof, which I am sure would happen someday it would be amazing to watch how they take the story from there esp because Adi who grew up watching so much resentment and distance between his biological parents and then lived in hostels and later with Shagun and Ashok would be exposed to a really DIFFERENT life, one which has love and family in its truest terms and I for one would be one of the frontline cheerleaders for this track - though I hope the kid hones his chops a little more by then
Ridhi. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: redwine1



Feels slightly reassured and heads home. But it still
troubles him as he knows Ishita is not someone who runs after materialistic
things. They don't matter to her. So what is it that this friend does that he may/does
not?


His wife gives him the answer. She tells him to tame down
his ego. Adds "Maine aapse choti choti cheezon maang rahi hun, koi badi
mohabbat nahin maangi".


But wasn't that what he wanted her to ask him, what he
wanted to give her?


But didn't she want that? So where does she want? Care,
thoughtfulness. And is she wrong?


He has done a lot for her which she has acknowledged every time


He has changed for the good- for her,because of her - which again
she has acknowledged time and again


So where is he going wrong? Where is he losing and why?


These questions are going to trouble him and also show him
the way. He is definitely going to set it right, win her over, how is going to
be a delightful watch, am sure.


As for Ishita - Mani, I feel, has come at the right time. He
has perfect qualities as per her, care-chivalry-thoughtfulness, but she is
clear he is not her Raman, but yet she is unable to recognize and confess her
true feelings for Raman.


Mani gently but firmly pointed out to her not to compare. That's
a true friend. I believe, he will guide her to self-discovery.


Mani is only going to be the catalyst in this beautiful
chemical reaction between husband and wife. A catalyst which will trigger and
speed up the realization yet will keep the relationship of a true friend with
Ishita without change.


A reaction which will heal both of them completely.





<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">Swathi my girl take a bow👏what an awesome post by you one of the very BEST I have had the pleasure to come across on IF I swear I have read it thrice already at last count and still can</font>


<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif">@bold - oh I love you, I really loved how you have put across this part once he sees the way the real Mani treats her when he sees him and obviously starts hyperventilating which he is doing already he is bound to have these questions in his head and also the answers to them - there is a reason Mani is shown the polar opposite of Raman - one of which is he treats Ishita like a lady, a princess no less and is chivalrous with her...and any woman does expect the man in her life to treat her so😳</font>



<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">UGH i hate u guys for pulling me in ... what a lovely thot both of u ...</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">It would be interesting at this juncture to see what was SUBBU's nature really like ..</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">Coz Mani .. who is sweet, mannered , even tempered .. a complete male Ishita ... & who knew her for so long ... she did not FALL IN LOVE WITH HIM ...</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">She has fallen in love with a polar opposite guy ... someone rude .. someone who is caustic ...</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">But someone who has a heart of GOLD ...</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">Some food for thot for all of us ... does this throw light on .. I prefer raavan kumar to ram kumar ...</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">Brilliant discussions here today guys ..</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2" color="#000099">The more we discuss these things .. the more clearer the path ahead becomes ...</font>



Hey nice discussions.
About what u said ishita has fallen for raman rather than mani,what i think ishita didn't intentionally loved raman or raman loved ishita,they were brought into the situation that is marriage and knowing indian brides they will eventually loves their spouses however they might be.so i am seeing this as love between husband and wife rather than raman and ishita.
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: -Anku-

A big fat reserve. Need to read this post a number of times. Before I can articulate my own thoughts. Wonderful Ruby 🤗 Will edit it soon.


I am sorry, I am editing so late. Been busy

Okay so your post actually leaves nothing to be said. Because you understand the track so well yourself, that its hard to put in anything after that.

But I'll just put down what I think about the track right now. Both the tracks.

Although YHM is all about IshRa. The two people's lives, behaviours and characteristics they do follow are Ishita and Shaguns. They've always highlighted the differences between them two. And the tracks that show up on our screens are a result of that itself.

Where Shagun loses, Ishita wins. Both these woman are related to one man, Raman. And like you pointed out. Where one track is all about Raman and Ishita coming closer. The other is about Raman moving on from his past. Every problem that has cropped up in their life has gotten Raman and Ishita come closer and understand each other. And the same problem has helped Raman detach from his past life a step further.

Ishita is a selfless woman, Shagun a selfish one. Her life revolves around herself and if she wants something she has to have it. Whereas Ishita does not want or expect for anything. If she doesn't get what she desires, she learns to cope with it, and if she does get something unexpected she values it.

Where one woman broke the Happy Bhalla. The other appreciates him for what he is deep down and not the mask he wears. One wounded him, the other heals him.

From whatever I've understood of the stories, tracks and the way they are connected. I see nothing but Mohabbatein, when it comes to IshRa. Of course there are issues, of course there will always be something to hamper the calm in their life. But what's important is, that they've learnt to trust, depend and heal each other and no one and nothing can take that.

The last 240 episodes have been a journey towards these lost souls healing and getting over their pasts. And that all hasn't been done for it to go waste. So when people crib and worry about the impending doom in their life. They need to stop and think, that Raman and Ishita have moved on from the dark shadows of their past. And if they ever come across their past again and are made to face an ordeal, they'll only come out stronger after realizing how much they mean to the other.



😲

Sorry bola .. the punishment to that is u gotta open the thread one saturday .. when the episode has nothing to write about in it 😉

Seriously ... love ur crispness ... i always believe a story has to follow a logical pattern .. a story need not be logical ... but its pattern has to be ...
the story ( all rumours & spoilers et all I get an update of this from Dhanashree .. who mails me about them coz i refuse to watch all this) .. is following a very logical pattern .. this story has to move in this way to progress ... note i say story ... not screenplay

all i can say at this point is ... have patience ...

alls well that ends well ...


swathibalan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: EkPaheli


Swathi my girl take a bow 👏 what an awesome post by you one of the very BEST I have had the pleasure to come across on IF I swear I have read it thrice already at last count and still can


@bold - oh I love you, I really loved how you have put across this part once he sees the way the real Mani treats her when he sees him and obviously starts hyperventilating which he is doing already he is bound to have these questions in his head and also the answers to them - there is a reason Mani is shown the polar opposite of Raman - one of which is he treats Ishita like a lady, a princess no less and is chivalrous with her...and any woman does expect the man in her life to treat her so 😳

Thanks Aani.. You made my day. Reading appreciation from a person whose writing i simply ADORE means a lot to me. Feel humbled. thank you again🤗
swathibalan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#66

Originally posted by: banana.ishra

thanks for the treat (2 posts) ruby...simply superb... how cd u do this everytime yaar...


aani - brilliant analysis...amazingly written...

swathi, let-it-go, sophee (esp the last para) - fab post...

throughly enjoyed reading all ur posts...

thank u...

thanks Anu😊
-Gan- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#67
I've been reading all the conversations...amazing...such indepth thinking!👏
liked all the various perspectives...😊
swathibalan thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#68
Loving the interesting discussion happening here and couldn't resist butting in.😛

First - Ashok - Am not sure he is a complete bully- a bully is a coward by heart, A Dudley. Sorry to disagree, just my POV😕.

I feel he is a person mean at heart. He is not a complete coward as he has achieved materialistic success in life, with obvious underhand means.
He too is self-obsessed in his own way.
In a way he is Shagun.
He feeds off her and she off him.

And probably that's the reason they are not able to live together, as one day you know there is nothing left there to leech.
There is no love. There is only selfishness. Both were after materialistic things, over what someone else had and don't care a damn on who they hurt on the way to get it.
What may vary between them is the degree of the traits.
But both are still the same- inside and outside

While Raman and Ishita - well they Appear to be different but are the same at the core. Raman, as you perfectly put it Ruby, wants to be Simply Complicated.
But that's a fence he has built around him which has made him an opposite of what he is.
Am sure, he never taunted Shagun when he was married to her, was chivalrous, caring, thoughtful - He was Mani.
Rejection has made him appear what he is today. But he cant be that way forever, esp when he has a wife like Ishita.
He wont be Mani Again, and that's good as Ishita wouldn't want that, else she would have married Mani right? Mani is a friend, a guide. not a person who makes her heart beat.
Raman will be the exact mix of sweet and spice in her life.
There were some posts on why Ishita doesn't unconditionally love Raman, should he be lovable only if he changes and becomes like her
But she does love him unconditionally, for what he actually is and not what he appears to be.
Isn't that true Love - love which sees what the other's cant, what you actually are?
Also, if love doesn't mellow a man, what does? If love doesn't bring out the best of a person, what does?
Also Love just doesn't point out your flaws but stands with you while you correct them

That brings Subbu - You nailed it Aani by saying -the strength to be there for her when she needed him the most. He wasn't there. He was a coward who ran away at the first sign of trouble.

There I go rambling again..😛



Edited by swathibalan - 10 years ago
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: swathibalan

Loving the interesting discussion happening here and couldn't resist butting in.😛

First - Ashok - Am not sure he is a complete bully- a bully is a coward by heart, A Dudley. Sorry to disagree, just my POV😕.

I feel he is a person mean at heart. He is not a complete coward as he has achieved materialistic success in life, with obvious underhand means.
He too is self-obsessed in his own way.
In a way he is Shagun.
He feeds off her and she off him.

And probably that's the reason they are not able to live together, as one day you know there is nothing left there to leech.
There is no love. There is only selfishness. Both were after materialistic things, over what someone else had and don't care a damn on who they hurt on the way to get it.
What may vary between them is the degree of the traits.
But both are still the same- inside and outside

While Raman and Ishita - well they Appear to be different but are the same at the core. Raman, as you perfectly put it Ruby, wants to be Simply Complicated.
But that's a fence he has built around him which has made him an opposite of what he is.
Am sure, he never taunted Shagun when he was married to her, was chivalrous, caring, thoughtful - He was Mani.
Rejection has made him appear what he is today. But he cant be that way forever, esp when he has a wife like Ishita.
He wont be Mani Again, and that's good as Ishita wouldn't want that, else she would have married Mani right? Mani is a friend, a guide. not a person who makes her heart beat.
Raman will be the exact mix of sweet and spice in her life.
There were some posts on why Ishita doesn't unconditionally love Raman, should he be lovable only if he changes and becomes like her
But she does love him unconditionally, for what he actually is and not what he appears to be.
Isn't that true Love - love which sees what the other's cant, what you actually are?
Also, if love doesn't mellow a man, what does? If love doesn't bring out the best of a person, what does?
Also Love just doesn't point out your flaws but stands with you while you correct them

That brings Subbu - You nailed it Aani by saying -the strength to be there for her when she needed him the most. He wasn't there. He was a coward who ran away at the first sign of trouble.

There I go rambling again..😛




Swathi ,...

ramble on love .. if this is what u do when u ramble .. i am a happy customer ...

brilliantly insightful .. & acceding to me ... PERFECT !!!!
redwine1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: KK2926

Brilliant post Ruby as always.
The way you analysed Shagun's character vs ishita's is thought provoking.
I read ur posts twice to understand better n see if i missed getting anything.

Thank you for taking time n posting ur analysis for us.
In one of ur replies u mentioned that instead of pondering about upcoming tracks if we focus on the epi definitely we will get the hints abt where this is all going.

Shagun is shallow n i think there r many ppl around us like her. Ishita to me is not so realistic. We dont find such pure souls around us. The reason why i called her is -- The way shagun used her to get back to her brother, the plan with sanjana n her mother, i wondered why they didnt show a ishita self talk abt analysing how shagun used her as a pawn. And now also she thinks that she should help her to get her Ashok. I am not trying to find logic in Indian soaps but trying to see how realistic YHM is. I feel Ishita's character progress is not shown here. In one of ur previous posts u mentioned that Ishita is a person who wakes up at night (or something) to help ppl - ruhis hospital, meeting param at night. She is a pure soul. I agree to that but what about the self respect. :))

Sorry my points are still noy in sync with Ishitas character. May be i am thinking too much hahaha
I should stop wondering n enjoy the cute moments :))

Thanks again for ur brilliant analysis. Found time now to unreserve n sorry for being late. I think i will watch YHM until u stop posting ur analysis :) because it makes me get a deeper understanding of the characters.


Hi love .. thanx for posting ur thots .. 🤗

Its so nice to get reaction from readers/viewers .. & also their POV .. so better late than never i say

Okay .. here i will be ISHITA .. & give some gyaan ...

DO NOT EVER FORGET this is a TV SOAP ... characters may seem real .. but they are NOT ..however much u may want . there is no Raman or Ishita ...
There may be some aspects of these characters u may relate to .. but some u may not .. cause this soap is viewed by millions of people .. for millions of DIFFERENT people to connect to one character .. there has to be some or the other aspect which they can relate to ..

If u see the forum .. they are disappointed simply coz they start relating to the character as real ..

Another thing . this is a story .. its a story by a certain group of people .. who have to cater to millions of people ... they will make some stuff which we like some which we can't stomach .. but over all if they hit even 75% satisfaction level . then its ok

If u look at TRPS .. the widest watched serial is DIYA AUR BAATI HUM .& Yeh rishta on Star steadily for the last 8 odd years is getting the nos .. its unbelievable .. but then we don't relate to that .. but surely theres a whole lot of people who do ..

Unfortunately soap viewership in India is primarily female .. a woman loves to see another woman in pain .. a woman loves to see .. how a nice person gets cheated & then saved .. u always want to see nice people cheated .. u want to believe ur a nice person & ur cheated .. but the hope is someone will come & save u ...

U know what may be unreal for u .. will be very real for say another ..
lets say .. have i seen a very famous socialite in mumbai .. drunk on the road .. being dumped by her husband .. YES I HAVE .. she was helped by some people who passingly knew her .. these things happen .. but to a lot it may not b relatable ...

Honestly ... never look for LOGIC in a story ... a story needs to only follow its logical pattern .. is YHM following that pattern AS OFF NOW YES .. it is ... this is the logical story progression ...

PHEW ... if raman kumar bhalla read this ..he would call me LECTURE QUEEN .. 😆



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".