Looking for logic again

alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
I am sticking with the same subject line as yesterday, so please forgive my lack of imagination


Please bear with me. I am writing this 5 mins after watching the episode, and have also been influenced by reading the live updates earlier. So my thoughts may sound confused. And I do have a bit of mixed feelings about this episode 😊



First and foremost, the episode was 'technically' superb. There was so much drama, but nothing was over the top. The acting was top-notch. So was the background music. Not the typical 'shocking' music they play whenever there is a revelation. The shock was on the character's faces. Nothing seemed forced. Hats off to the entire team!!! And the acting, WOW! Today's episode reinforced my faith and love for this serial. 👏

Completely unbiased opinion -

Raman went on listening to the whole story. He did not know whom to believe, which is quite natural. We often romanticise the relation between the lead characters in a show, but if it was a real-life situation, this (and may be worse) would have happened to Ishita. For once, I am glad they did not show Raman being weak for Ishita. I am glad he was equally worried for his sister and her family. I am glad he did not burn bridges with his sister, for someone who he had JUST met. Yes, Ishita has been shown to be a very good person, a very true and pure person. But, that is what he thought of Shagun. Shagun, someone he loved with all his heart, betrayed him for another man. He doesnt even share that kind of relation with Ishita. We think he should have trusted her, respected her. But why shouldn't he trust/respect Param and his sister's faith. Surely Simmi's faith in her marriage is far more than a shaky relationship he shares with Ishita.

About the comment he made about their relationship - I still cannot come to terms with it. No matter how much I try to justify it. I can only accept this if he blurted it out because he was out of control. He couldnt believe that Param knew. And if he knew, the only person who could have told him is Ishita. It was their secret, and theirs alone. If he was out of control and already so much confused, this would be a typical human reaction.


Simmi was the most natural character today. She was completely within her right to blame Ishita, call her names, even slap her. Again; Whether right or wrong, most of us would have done the same thing.


Coming to Ishita: She got the shock of her life today. The people she thought of as family were outrightly demeaning her, doubting her character. This would be a reality check episode for her. If she had any illusions about being a part of the family, this is when they would all shatter. Why should she have to go through this, ONLy for Ruhi. I wouldnt blame her if she just gives up on the Bhalla gang and leaves. Stop caring about them, stop caring about what they think of her.
Ishita should move out. If she does come back, again, it will be for Ruhi. But thats where her relations with the Bhalla family should stop. She has been insulted. She has been treated with utmost disrespect. No matter how convincing Param's story sounded, no one showed any faith in her. And for that, they should pay. The must suffer. The only one she could forgive is Simmi, because she was a victim too.


The wild-cards in this story... (now comes wishful thinking on my part )😆


There must be some significance to why Rinki wasnt there. I have always felt that her character was deliberately being 'subdued'. May be this is what they were saving her for?

Mihir - this is a pleasant surprise. The man Ishita hates, thinks of as spineless (we all do too) actually is the rational one here? Its good its him. BEcause he is probably the only person in the Bhalla family who isnt directly connected to this fiasco. Probably the only person who can see the goodness in Ishita, and remind Raman of it. We do need someone to talk to Raman. Try to see Ishita's point of view.

I have a feeling (and please let me be right), Raman started acting when he saw the texts. Before that, he was genuinely puzzled. But the text messages would actually convince him that Ishita couldnt be wrong. He may not love her, he may not trust her, he may not even care about her. But he knows she is smart. If she wanted to betray him, she wouldnt leave obvious clues. She did also say that her phone battery was low. Even he couldnt get in touch with her. Also, she wouldnt drag a third person (sarika). Dragging another person in your lie is very RISKY. Finally, if she had to cheat on him, she wouldnt do it so close to home. SHe may be Jhansi ki Rani, but she is NOT stupid. If he was acting, speaking out about their relationship was a shrewd move. Simmi had already read the text, and if someone later asked him; he wouldnt be able to lie anyway. But this was the only way he could make Param believe that he was on his side. BUT Yes, he would have to pay for this later. Ishita wouldnt forgive him for this.


*** If you have come so far, I would like to thank you for your patience in tolerating my random thoughts...🤗


Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

3.4k

Users

14

Likes

103

Frequent Posters

_Sapphire_ thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
Wonderful thoughts and thanks for sharing. I agree with all the points you have made.😊 Raman was being practical as he can be.
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
i will also once again copy past my comments..lik i did yday in ur post..!!

MY EPI REVIEW
First n foremost...i am PROUD of BOTH Ishita n Divyanka today..!!

Ishita
-THIS GIRL did today wht many woman cant evn DREAM to think to do..!! She FOUGHT FOR HER JUSTICE without ANYONE's support..!! But the MOMENT she saw the person which she only secretly hoped ki would support din do tht-she ws HURT THE MOST...!! i CRIED in tht moment for her..!!

i'm glad she would be stayin at Iyers and SHE SHOULD NOT return back to bhallas house till they make up for the mistake PROPERLY&PERFECTLY...Till before tht she should stay with IYERS ONL n plz for once KEEP RUHI OUT OF THIS..!! i DNT WANT Ishu to go back to bhallas for ruhi...NO..NO..!!

its abt her SELF RESPECT n DIGNITY which bhallas thrashed left right n center..!!


Divyanka-it ws one of her best acting as Ishu today..!! She AMAZINGLY portrayed the FIGHTER ISHITA...n later towards end of epi she PERFECTLY portrayed DEVASTATED ISHITA...!! Spl mention to the way she EMOTES thru her eyes...it looked SO NATURAL..!! The HURT in her eyes when Raman wanted to chk Pervert's phone..!! uff thts wht made me CRY for her..!!

Now comin to RKB..damn it Raman...agar support nahi kar sakte...toh BLOODY HELL CHUP BHI KYU NA RAH SAKE???? i'm so DISAPPOINTED..!!🥱

i KNW hes "stuck" b/w family n wife..!! his SILENCE to an extent would hv JUSTIFIED tht too...!!

bt it ws SO SICK of him to bring tht matter of he n ishu r NOT normal husband-wife infront of evryone..!!

My heart went out to Ishu today...Epi ws goin perfect...Ishu fought bravely..ws sayin evry single thing...evn Raman's actions,wordings were indicatin he ws beleiving more of Ishu...!!

bt last scene...EPIC SPOILED for me..!!

Plz CVs plz FOR HEAVEN SAKE...This time DNT RUSH n make Ishu mahan n forgiv evryone easily..!!

Its so sad na..A third person lik Mihir had BLIND TRUST on Ishu n could SAY IT ON Raman's face tht Ishita cant be wrong..!! But u raman...THT HURT in Ishita's eyes the moment Raman kinda spoke against her ws SPOT ON...As tht ws THE EXACT evn i felt..!! i would hv been much much happy if this guy ws CHUP...!!

nywz i want a FULL ON INTENSE TRACK where i WANT TO C AN EPIC REGRETTING RAMAN BHALLA n super cold Ishita..!! More than physical torture,shes way too mentally hurt..!! Raman u MUST make up for the BLUNDER u did today..!!

bt in a way,its good Raman DID THIS MISTAKE..!! The MORE SERIOUS is his MISTAKE,the MORE he CHANGES for BETTER..!! Like Adi makin Ishu say sorry to him matter,Ruhi ws HURT BEYOND LIMITS tht time n thts wht made raman realise his mistake then n it ws then he bcame A PERFECT FATHER..!!

So nw he hv hurt Ishita beyond limit...so tht means once he realise he will be FULLY SET on path to bcome PERFECT HUSBAND..!!

MY FINAL TAKE
i AM disappointed with Raman today...n i stick to it..!!

i would say SAME thing here too which i said in other threads..!!

Raman TRUST Ishita..theres NO TWO WAY abt it...Todays epi 90% scenes were CLEAR ENOUGH to show he do trust her..!!

BUT...a million dollar BUT..i CANNOT ignore the fact either ki instead of being "silent",he HAD TO SPEAK n tht too MOST WRONG things AT WRONG time..!! my disappointment LIES THERE..!!

n thts wht make Raman look doin a MISTAKE.. n thts wht would make him evn more better husband once he realise his mistake n will try evry single way to win his wife's heart back n give back the RESPECT which evryone took away frm her..!!


and y i'm this much disappointed with last scene is mujhe farak pada...!! bahut bahut farak pada..!! as the changin raman in past epis..y past epi...todays epi's 90% scenes-evrythin ws givin me hope Raman trust ishu...bt as he ws stuck b/w family n wife,hes remainin silent..!!

bt when he said this,it ws lik i ws bought to earth frm heaven..!! THE GREAT FALL DOWN i felt..!!

nywz jo hona tha vo ho gaya..nw Raman hv to WORK HARD to bring pervert's truth...and WORK HARDER to win Ishita's trust back n GIVE HER BACK THE RESPECT she DESERVES...!!
Edited by Nikki_Titli - 11 years ago
sudhi03 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
copy pasting my comments from other post
simmi, toshiji and pervert can rot in hell i give a damn about those irriating people.

But Raman kumar Bhalla i seriously didn't expected this from him. Even yesterday i justified his actions sorry but not today. I know he has a terrible past, he has trust issues, his sister's life is at stake, this marriage is just a deal for him, he doesn't love ishita i agree to all of these.

When your wife is saying that she is molested by her BIL the least you can do is show some concern for that poor women. she is literally begging to believe her but no body did. The only person she has hope is her husband when the same person questions her nothing can be more heart breaking than this. ishita never expected anything from this marriage for the first time she begged him to trust her but he didn't. Nothing can be more painful. I know raman solves this case and exposes pervert afterwards. But the hurt. the humiliation which ishita has undergone in this situation is heart breaking and unexplainable.
Edited by sudhi03 - 11 years ago
...EhSaas... thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
😃
You are doing great and difficult job finding logic in tv show

Jokes apart
nice post😃
Edited by ...EhSaas... - 11 years ago
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Nikki_Titli

i will also once again copy past my comments..lik i did yday in ur post..!!



Thanks Nikki... I just read it in another post...

On the Raman disappointment topic, we'll respectfully agree to disagree 😊

BUT I 100% agree with the future track. Ishita shouldnt easily forgive anyone (least of all, Raman) and the CVs would have to put their brains in overdrive to bring the show back and Ishra back. I think their relationship needs a good dose of respect and trust first... before we see any romance
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan



Thanks Nikki... I just read it in another post...

On the Raman disappointment topic, we'll respectfully agree to disagree 😊

BUT I 100% agree with the future track. Ishita shouldnt easily forgive anyone (least of all, Raman) and the CVs would have to put their brains in overdrive to bring the show back and Ishra back. I think their relationship needs a good dose of respect and trust first... before we see any romance



oh yes v can agree to disagree..!! thts fine

@bold..
this I COMPLETELY AGREE..!!
komsy7856 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
i agree with ur points...even i feel rinky cn b the one who helps to bring out d truth bcoz thy never show ny role of her😆
pomegranate thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Raman's reaction or lack thereof, is consistent with his character. Simmi is his sister, she is important to him so his silence is understandable. Ishita just dropped a massive bombshell on him, he just needs time to gauge the situation and react appropriately.

however, I cannot excuse him questioning her like that at the end. he basically stripped ishita of what little dignity she had left in that family. A women was at her most vulnerable position today and if her husband could not defend her, then he should have kept his mouth shut. raman cannot be excused for his lack of propriety due to his temper or his habit of blurting out things at the most inconvenient times.
Edited by pomegranate - 11 years ago
Mages thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
there is no logic in ekta show...😡...we have to go with the flow...i am used to it for decades now...

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

2 months ago

Shubhangi on KP: Really Look Forward To Work With Him Again

Why did Karan Patel tell Kasturi costar Shubhangi Atre, 'Tu khoob gaaliyan dena mujhe?' In an exclusive chat with India Forums, Shubhangi Atre,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".