Looking for logic again - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

32

Views

3.4k

Users

14

Likes

103

Frequent Posters

Divan_Sashona thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
Most imp thing Simmi n Parmeet relation is quiet old n they both have good understanding than Why Parmeet hide these sms from simmi? or us ko pahle se kyon nahi bataya Why Simmi n all bhalla house residence did not ask this question to him they were accusing Ishita why he askied him why hide this from Simmi or Simmi itni dumb kyon ho ge why he agian asked parmeet jab ushe Ishita ki intension sahih nahi kag rahe the tu wo kyon us ki liye gift laya tha us se acha tu Raman hua itna kamzor relationship hone ki bawajod he asker her why u hide from me? n why u did not told me?
itsme_aish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
Hey I liked your post...it makes me feel very positive about the track..😊😊 Thanks dear😃😃 esp the last para of your post..You have given me a ray of hope as far as Raman's actions are concerned..but I did feel very bad for Ishu😭..How couldnt anyone trust her..she's done so much..I was expecting Mr.Bhalla and Raman to stand up for her..but I know Raman has understood she cant be wrong and will get to the bottom of this😊
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: RishuDarling

Good post, love the way you have put this into words.

And suggestions you made, also what crossed my mind.

I think later when the Bhalla's think about it... If Parmeet received text messages before why he didn't say this the first time Ishita confronted him. Or why did Ishita call Raman so many times? Where are the broken glass and table? And... Rinki was asked to call Ishita.. Why call her and wait for her if she is forcing herself on him.

Deep down Raman knows the truth.. But he is a family man. He knows all about broken families and that Simmie will devastated. He is fighting with his inner thoughts and mustering courage to go and do the right thing and kick Parmeets ass!!!!! 😡



Oh yeah... later... when realisation hits, One thing at a time... it will be priceless to watch their faces (i am being sadistic now 😆)
-kri- thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Nikki_Titli



if RKB's char is called "real" n "flawed"...then v ppl r FOR REAL..so obvious BEING HUMAN v "tend" to keep expectations n then "tend" to react when expectations arent met..!! 😛 so whos MORE REAL Kri?😆


Aapne tho pehle keh diya na? Hum complex ho gayi YHM ke saath... Main kounsi exception hoon?😉
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: dark.lig8

Most imp thing Simmi n Parmeet relation is quiet old n they both have good understanding than Why Parmeet hide these sms from simmi? or us ko pahle se kyon nahi bataya Why Simmi n all bhalla house residence did not ask this question to him they were accusing Ishita why he askied him why hide this from Simmi or Simmi itni dumb kyon ho ge why he agian asked parmeet jab ushe Ishita ki intension sahih nahi kag rahe the tu wo kyon us ki liye gift laya tha us se acha tu Raman hua itna kamzor relationship hone ki bawajod he asker her why u hide from me? n why u did not told me?



Yupp... i was just going to post this in another reply... when realisation hits them, one thing at a time, it will become so obvious...

- why did she act weird on the phone with him
- how could she text when she didnt have the phone
- why did mihir think there was something wrong
- Parmeet could have told Simmi that Ishita was making advances at him...

If Ishita wasnt so overwhelmed with her grief, she would have asked all these questions today

But, the Bhallas are in character... They always act first and then think (thats what Mrs Iyer also said). Today, it was all about first reaction.
Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: always_a_TV_fan



yupp... it was reality check for her. She thought of them as family... her look when Raman asked her for the phone was so heartbreaking. It crushed her soul😭... and , if they do something cheesy like dosa making or tamil speech as a way of apology for this... I will break something in my house😡


DT has knocked my socks off with her acting in this track... I now post comments on her page regularly 😊



i second this..!!

i want Raman,DIL SE,WORK HARDER to win Ishita's trust back n GIVE HER BACK THE RESPECT she DESERVES...!! This is the SECOND TIME he let her char get questioned..!!

First time when ishu came back home at 3am,Raman blasted at her...bt tht time he wsnt aware of truth as ishu din say nythin...Still when truth ws abt he wsnt sorry either..!! But all the pendin sorries were made up with his thank u speech in tamil..

But wht he did today,n tht too EVEN AFTER ISHU SAYING ENTIRE TRUTH,hv brought him back to square one situation..!! So he HAVE apologize when he realize his mistake..also SIRF apology se kuch nahi hoga..he HAVE to MAKE HER BELIEVE hes regrettin big time for wht he did today,bt he would do ANYTHING to make up for tht n he better prove thru by his actions..!!


Nikki_Titli thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Elite Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: krikumar.91


Aapne tho pehle keh diya na? Hum complex ho gayi YHM ke saath... Main kounsi exception hoon?😉



haha...i jst wanted to "explain" y u should nt be appalled at forum reactions..😉

nywz moral of the story...COMPLEX SHOW...COMPLEX CHARS...COMPLEX FANS..😆😆
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Nikki_Titli



i second this..!!

i want Raman,DIL SE,WORK HARDER to win Ishita's trust back n GIVE HER BACK THE RESPECT she DESERVES...!! This is the SECOND TIME he let her char get questioned..!!

First time when ishu came back home at 3am,Raman blasted at her...bt tht time he wsnt aware of truth as ishu din say nythin...Still when truth ws abt he wsnt sorry either..!! But all the pendin sorries were made up with his thank u speech in tamil..

But wht he did today,n tht too EVEN AFTER ISHU SAYING ENTIRE TRUTH,hv brought him back to square one situation..!! So he HAVE apologize when he realize his mistake..also SIRF apology se kuch nahi hoga..he HAVE to MAKE HER BELIEVE hes regrettin big time for wht he did today,bt he would do ANYTHING to make up for tht n he better prove thru by his actions..!!





as a viewer, I am sooo happy this episode happened in this way. Mostly because we will get a new Raman, first time on a lower footing... begging for forgiveness from Ishita... she SHOULD NOT turn soft too easily. She should maintain her moral high ground as long as possible
PreciousPri thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#29
Here is what I wrote in Shiva's post so just pasting it again

Ok here is what I feel ... and please bear in mind people this is from an audience's POV ... no offence to anyone or anyone's opinion 😊

Well written Shivu 👏
Can I first just say well done to the entire team of YHM... firstly for taking up a sensitive topic like sexual harassment and portraying it on screen... Kudos to all the actors today who have done so well ... I also loved the BG score played in the epi today esp the one playing when IRB was saying what Pervmeet did with her in fb...not OTT at all 👏👏👏
I don't know where to start so things might come out in random order 😳...I think I will say it character wise
So first upIshita ...God my heart went out to her...if only I could give her a big big hug ... to come and have to recollect and then retell the whole story to all family members requires a whole lot of courage...not only in front of her MIL and nanad but also Romi and her FIL 👏... she was hurt yet she wanted to truth to come and she tried her best to put her matter out there...when she was slapped by Simmi there was look of shock on her face rather than pain ...she pleaded and she begged for her to be trusted ... but what caused the most pain was when RKB asked to check the phone... the woman was shattered... it was as if she had been punched in the stomach ... she expected RKB to believe her and him asking to check the phone just shattered her 😭
RKB... when IRB was saying everything he was listening intently and was shocked and flabbergasted ... as normal person would be hearing something like this to happen in their house with two people he is related to...
when Simmi was yelling at IRB that she is lying ... he told Simmi to shut up ... when Simmi slapped IRB...he shouted at Simmi... he could not stop the slapping as it was sudden... but he didn't like that either and he made sure he told Simmi about it...
After hearing the story ... when he says Ishita agar aisi baat this then how did you land up in jail??.. ab please haath jod ta hoon... mu kholo..... just notice his voice... he is all choked up...
When all are trying to stop PervMeet from leaving the house ... RKB doesn't move an inch... he stays rooted while trying to at least make head and tail of what he has just heard ...
About phone messages...after hearing the message read by Simmi wouldn't any normal person be dumbfounded and may I add hurt ... but he wanted to see for himself ... he is a shrewd and smart businessman and needs proof ... and like a rational person questioned IRB about it ... he heard IRB saying her phone was not with her... heck even he wasn't able to contact her so how could she have sent the messages
But as soon as he saw the messages ... his expressions did change... and the next line of "Kya hai yeh" please please look at his expression but also his tone of voice... it is not accusative... I can't describe it in a word... he is trying to question her ... there should have been anger in his voice right but no there is no anger ... casual toned down fake anger... Oh I don't know how to say it 🤔... but I hope you get what I mean
Maybe he saw the time of message sent and it was when he had also tried to contact IRB but phone was switched off
Right him mentioning about both of them not having any physical relation ... yes it is a private matter between two people and should not have come out in front of the family... but wasn't it obvious from the messages?? Bearing in mind we only heard one message... That phone went to Simmi and Toshiji ... had they had heard all the messages I'm sure this secret would have come out anyhow...
and him asking her ... well he knows she was the one who was insistent that this thing would remain between the two of them so she is not stupid to go and tell Parmeet and esp not write it in a message... and she is not stupid to write messages and carelessly leave behind bread crumb trails ...
Trust... now he does trust her ...and the phone message did shake him a bit ... which he why is wanted to check for himself
be it a 3 month or 30 year relationship ... trust to break doesn't take 3 seconds... and him checking the phone message is trying to confirm something that he has in mind... he is not a blindly trust guy at all... no he is a shrewd straight forward business who needs to see things in order to believe them .. just like Mihir and MMS matter... there was no proof hence he wasn't ready to blame Mihir
And he cannot let go of the fact that Simmi is his sister ... he is in a turmoil of his own
Simmi... her behaviour was justified...she is in love with her husband ... she has a small kid ... it is obvious she wouldn't want to believe IRB ...no wife can hear something like this about her husband ... and esp after reading those messages even that slap was justified... anyone would have done the same...I really liked her line that mu se nilki hui baat wapis nahin aa sakti .. so true... she is afraid for her family and uska gussa jayaz hain
Toshiji ... I don't know.. she doesn't seem to want to use her brains...she wanted it all to stay hidden... was shocked what happened today... she did acknowledge when IRB said PervMeet sent everyone for the movie while he stayed back ... she did stop Simmi in the end who was again getting aggressive with IRB... but when Simmi mentioned IRB hovering around PervMeet she was like yeah that's true...and then her saying no one in this house is like this?? what about your supoot Romi...😕
Romi... he was good today...when Simmi was getting aggressive with IRB he was the one to try and stop this ... he was also shocked and disgusted when IRB was mentioning the things PervMeet done with her ... ofcourse he is not doodh ka dhula either but he does respect his bhabhi
Mr Bhalla... was definitely shocked and disgusted...just look at his reaction towards PervMeet esp when IRB is talking about Pervmeet trying to touch her thighs while driving... and he kept throwing disgusted looks at his SIL too
My only question is .. where is Rinky?? Why isn't she here to witness all this... was this deliberate ??... Would she have said anything in relation to this??? ... I feel as a woman she should have heard what IRB was saying about Pervmeet so she herself can be alert... I don't know 🤔
Finally PervMeet... no words or comments 🤬
That's all 😆
alwaysaTVFan thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Nikki_Titli



haha...i jst wanted to "explain" y u should nt be appalled at forum reactions..😉

nywz moral of the story...COMPLEX SHOW...COMPLEX CHARS...COMPLEX FANS..😆😆



If I may interject (slightly off topic too)... I was very happy with the diverse forum reactions... this place is such a beautiful place for open minds to interact freely... I seriously respect people here. This place is quite democratic...👏

Related Topics

Ye Hai Mohabbatein Thumbnail

Posted by: Manan_Pani_fan

2 months ago

Shubhangi on KP: Really Look Forward To Work With Him Again

Why did Karan Patel tell Kasturi costar Shubhangi Atre, 'Tu khoob gaaliyan dena mujhe?' In an exclusive chat with India Forums, Shubhangi Atre,...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".