Why do we have a netural view of Bella?

Page

Next Last

@-dramaholic-

Inactive

+ 6

Posted: 15 years ago

Hi Guys!

Well i've read the first 3 books last summer, and i'm on the 4th one , but i stopped reading it due to school and all. 😭 But yes.. my quesiton is.. Why do we always feel for Bella and not the others?

I think because the whole series is practically written in Bella's point of view, we don't really have any other choice other than to LIKE HER. lol.. i mean personally speaking, i don't like bella for the fair reason that, she used Jacob, and kind of lead him on..Just so she could feel comfort after edward left her..

In the real word, such people aren't liked by the majority, but yet, while reading the book.. (most people i've asked, like bella..but then thinking outside the box agree she is wrong).. we acknowedge her..and feel for her.. Whyyyy?

I think Bella is the kind of charecter, you can neither hate or like.. since she has been absorbed into our thoughts since IT IS HER STORY. 😆

Whatcha all think?

Edited by DramaholicVibes - 15 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

pomegranate

@pomegranate

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

who told you that?

I hate bella. I think she is a pathetic, weak moron who falls apart after a boyfriend leaves her. what happend to women power?? us women are so weak that we always need a man to protect us? No women should cry like that after her boyfriend leaves her. how long did bella and edward know eachother?? not long enough to fall madly in love.. there is so many other things i like to mention but that would be like typing an essay, i don't have the time or energy to do that.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Zaria

@fly_chick

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: pomegranate
who told you that?

I hate bella. I think she is a pathetic, weak moron who falls apart after a boyfriend leaves her. what happend to women power?? us women are so weak that we always need a man to protect us? No women should cry like that after her boyfriend leaves her. how long did bella and edward know eachother?? not long enough to fall madly in love.. there is so many other things i like to mention but that would be like typing an essay, i don't have the time or energy to do that.

Agree- though i neither like nor dislike Bella- but she put herself out as an independant women then breaks down when her boyfriend of a few months leaves her. I don't think she deserves Jacob or Edward- she just plays with their emotions. Once Edward returned she should have stopped meeting Jake regulary but didn't and this deepened his feelings for her though i know she regarded him as a mate, it was obvious in twilight he fancied her so later in eclipse she should've kept a distance.

Quote

Esha

@eshaaax3.

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

I'm going to have to disagree. I really don't feel so much for BElla, as she hurts alot of people, especially Jacob and Charlie, yes Charlie. She is such a weak female, who makes the females look, well, pathetic just cuz her boyfriend LEft!!!???I just hate how she hurts Jaacob. I'm not talking about how she kisses him and then edward and all that....i just hate how she kept leading him on. That was totally wrong, cuz well JAke thatought he had a chance,.....but noooo. And CHARLIE!!! Omg, i feel so bad for charlie being left in the dark bout her own daughters BF!!!
Idk..i just dont like nor dislike bella.....@.@

Quote

-Alina-

@-Alina-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

Over here,I agree with most of you. I also don't like Bella but I don't hate her too. I know she had given so much pain to the people who have loved her, whether its her father, her boyfriend or even best friend....she have hurt them so much !!!! And then she called herself a strong girl and when Edward left her, she was deeply shattered !! She couldn't recovered for months, so she sort of used Jacob for merely a distraction !!!!! I really feel so bad for the people who... loved that girl...she is so confused what to do or not to do....In Eclipse when she sort of broke up with Jake...whole night she was crying, to watch her like that, made Edward to hurt more and he thought he have done something wrong !!!! She is really so bad !!!!!!

luv Alina

Quote

Mallika

@mallika_14

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Certainly.
Nobody likes her.
She's a kind of girl who can neither be detested nor liked...so i agree with you.
We all know she loved edward incredbily...but what she did after him...got feeling for jacob?..what kind of love was that?..not a true love story?
Its awfully pathetic.
I don't want discuss any further.

Quote

Sana

@XxSanaxX

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: mallika_14
Certainly.
Nobody likes her.
She's a kind of girl who can neither be detested nor liked...so i agree with you.
We all know she loved edward incredbily...but what she did after him...got feeling for jacob?..what kind of love was that?..not a true love story?
Its awfully pathetic.
I don't want discuss any further.

i agree wiv u!!

if she started feelin sumat 4 jacob while edward wasnt der den she couldnt hav luved him truli could she?

Quote

missindia26

@missindia26

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

I dont really like her much and I know a lot of people hate her a lot more

But I do think that because its written from her POV you identify with her more, and it becomes very much Bella's story

Thats why I loved in Midnight Sun reading from Edwards POV

Quote

RandomSquared

@RandomSquared

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

bella is jus like there. for most of the book i didnt like her..i mean she has her moments wen shes cute or relatable (but they are very rare). shes actually kinda mean..i was reading twilight the other day n notice how she never gave the humans a chance..they were so nice to her n she was jus like "i dont remember their names" lol

people love edward, jake and they also love bella with either of them. very few people like bella as an individual. shes kinds sorta annoying.

in the movie shes even more annoying than the book.