Shivika and the meaning of Family

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
This isn't intended to be a depressing topic...just some thoughts on how Shivika are coping with the current set of events, and the different interpretations of what Family means to different characters in this storyline.

Based on today's epi, the writers seem to be going with the angle that Anika feels Shivaay considered her an outsider all this time, didn't really consider her a part of his family...Keeping aside some of her outlandish statements about how she only "tolerated" his protectiveness for his family all this time cuz she thought one day he'll "choose her over family"😆, there is some validity to the argument that Shivaay has found it tough to truly pull Anika into the overall circle of family.


Even after all this time, in many cases he's used the term "MERA parivaar" rather than HUMARA parivaar...I just presumed that Anika was ok with this cuz she never raised it as an issue...she never said HUMARA parivaar...she always said AAPKA parivaar even if she treated them like her own...so this seems to be a case of expectations not clearly communicated and now Anika has turned it into a grudge in her hurt/naaraazgi. Do you walk out over a grudge like this? Do you end a a whole relationship over this? Obviously no...but the writers seem to have other plans😆


Anika technically has three sets of family right now...one is Sahil, another is her birth father HVT and a Chutki...and then there's the Oberois...lol if I was to use Anika's twisted logic, didn't she also choose her 'family' Sahil over her husband Shivaay? 😆...anytime Anika has faced a situation where Sahil was insulted or in danger, did she just take it quietly? Was she ever blackmailed with Sahil as leverage? Ah yes she was...by Shivaay himself...lol and did she give in? Why yes she did😆...by marrying Shivaay...so raising this issue of "Family v/s husband v/s wife" again and again is counterproductive...not sure if the writers will tackle that properly here.



Then there's Shivaay's point of view in all this...utterly broken and battered as he sits by Pinky's bedside, out pours his hurt and disappointment that Anika didn't have faith in him, that she didn't wait for him like she had promised she would...he almost sounded like a little child complaining to his mom...lol...it pinches even more that he was trying to do all this to spare her hurt over her father but he couldn't control things as intended and it all fell apart...the one constant in Shivaay's life over the last two years has been the fact that Anika has been there to temper him, to sambhaalo him if he falls apart...she is the only one he's shared his deepest vulnerabilities with...and today at one of his lowest points, she simply left him without a word...hence forms a grudge...he wants answers to his questions...and soon enough the grudge hardens into hatred as well...this is what happens when you let wounds fester...and Anika was beyond caring for his wounds by this point since she convinced herself there weren't any...that hers are the only wounds here...lol


Two ppl who supposedly should have learnt by now that they are each other's salvation, that they cannot exist with each other, still succumbed to ego and hurt😆


There's Anika on one hand vowing that she will never show him her face or talk to him again...lol behaving like a roothi hui biwi even though she claims there is no rishta b/w them anymore...it's almost as if she still wants to punish him even though she claims that he doesn't care about her anymore...so if he doesn't care, kyun dikhaana hai Shivaay ko naraazgi, Anika? Why so confused? 😆



And there's Shivaay on the other end...vowing to "settle scores" and make Anika pay for what she did...but isn't it obvious that more than anything he just wants to find her first cuz his life has literally come to a standstill without her?...he threw himself into getting Tej-Shakti freed from jail as something to focus his mind on...meanwhile Pinky in a coma just adds to his festering wound as he helplessly pleads with her to wake up...and there is no Anika around to put a balm on those wounds...so all they can do is fester for now...until he sees her again...then another dam will break.


In all this, love got pushed to the back...anger, ego, and hurt is now front and center...and in a stroke of irony, Shivaay just bought a cricket team in time for him and Anika to start a new "match/battle" of their own...waah waah...IPL season mein IB mein bhi IPL...Gulneet are such trolls😆😆


Remains to be seen if either Shivaay or Anika get the answers they are looking for by the end of this.



Edited by AreYaar - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

50

Views

4.9k

Users

14

Likes

343

Frequent Posters

chottekikhushi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
So after vehemently declaring that I will not be opening hotstar or going anywhwre near the tv, I finally gave into my pathetic addiction for my favourite pair and watched today's epi and came to the following conclusions.
1.Ib should be watched by people with short term memory loss to not go into depression.
2.Shivika are truly idiots but I dunno who is worse than the other.
3.And since all the butchering is done, the writers have found an excellent way to reboot the last 500 episodes.
I really dunno what is more heartbreaking, after all that these 2 have been through, Ani has somehow concluded that she is just so disposible to Shivaay that he doesn't even give her divorce but marries some random female ( under blackmail ofcourse coz she knew he was doing it for proofs to save his family) and Bua is the best judge of his character, so hey new biwi is suddenly the love of his life!! So she decides to walk out without confronting him even once, somehow even with all her insecurities or her feeling like an outsider or anything doesn't justify this stupidity to me.
Shivaay, who I initially trully sympathised with ( even though Ani is my favourite) seems to be no better and he has already held Ani responsible for all that the oberois are going through - believed that she was capable of giving evidence against his family and triggering the sequence of events which ultimately led to his mum being comatose. How different are they really?? Both were shown evidence deeming their respective partners to be guilty and both believed it! Was it Ani coz according to her everything (Shivaay and a family she considered her own had betrayed her) or Shivaay who had been blackmailed and the very person who he was trying to protect resulted in his family behind bars and his mums state. I would still say Shivaay for now coz even if its to get even, he still seems to be making attempts to find Ani but I already know that I will be eating my words coz of all the intaanse love hate thats gonna come our way, Ani tolerating Shivaay being an ass, Shivaay covering up all his hurt and being an ass - people will fall of ramps, wimdshields will be broken and water thrown and and all the while I will be pathetically biting my nails for Pinky to hear Ani's voice and miraculously recover and start talking (on friday ofcourse) and proving Ani innocent, Shivaay repenting, fast forward another 2 weeks and Bua's truth coming out and Ani repenting and new chutki drama gearing up for blackmail no.54321.
So folks, who cares if characters are butchered or MU's are contrived as long as we get a khidkitod material for next one month? **insert Billu's slow claps in parrot coloured costume**
Sigh, I rest my case.
Edited by chottekikhushi - 7 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
Hurt really does blind a person...today's epi was totally testament to that...Anika first hand saw what happened to Shivaay the last time she left...in case she's forgotten, here's some pictorial evidence again...lol



But I guess for now the memory loss must continue...she needs to conveniently forget that Shivaay can barely breathe without her...that he cannot survive without her.


That is how she can justify her own hurt and naraazgi to herself...by zoning out these facts...and waise bhi until she views the evidence again, it's easier to block out...lol...and presume in your mind that Shivaay is living a happy life somewhere without her...lol



So she thinks he abandoned her...they still haven't clarified if she thinks he never loved her either...haha I suppose they can go there too if they want to make this more contrived.
Edited by AreYaar - 7 years ago
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Reserved
But the part about lost billu made me teary you put it out so beautifully

Chalo koi toh samjha mere billu ke dard ko bhi

I toh know am gonna melt and get emotional over his dard esp him pleading to pinky oh man...

I really am weak when it comes to a shivaay being this helpess and this bechara and majboor besides i care too kuch anout pinky do this is going to pinch a lot but am prepared
Hriju321 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Was she ever blackmailed with Sahil as leverage? Ah yes she was...by Shivaay himself...lol and did she give in? Why yes she did😆...by marrying Shivaay...so raising this issue of "Family v/s husband v/s wife" again and again is counterproductive...not sure if the writers will tackle that properly here.

This is the best explanation I have come across.Annika herself gave in to blackmail to save "her family" and she is averse to understand the predicament of Shivaay?
Even if she was emotional and made a hurried judgement,did she not think over her actions once?
Shivaay wants to confront Annika and demand explanations but Annika wants to build a wall of indifference and just fade away.But she forgets that she is still married and is the legal wife of SSO.Isn't running away cowardly ? And I had for the past almost 2 years assumed that Annika is brave and faces life head on!

CVs smoked a drug causing retrograde amnesia and the result is the present scenario.😃
Edited by Hriju321 - 7 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Hriju321

Was she ever blackmailed with Sahil as leverage? Ah yes she was...by Shivaay himself...lol and did she give in? Why yes she did😆...by marrying Shivaay...so raising this issue of "Family v/s husband v/s wife" again and again is counterproductive...not sure if the writers will tackle that properly here.


This is the best explanation I have come across.Annika herself gave in to blackmail to save "her family" and she is averse to understand the predicament of Shivaay?
Even if she was emotional and made a hurried judgement,did she not think over her actions once?
Shivaay wants to confront Annika and demand explanations but Annika wants to build a wall of indifference and just fade away.But she forgets that she is still married and is the legal wife of SSO.Isn't running away cowardly ? And I had for the past almost 2 years assumed that Annika is brave anbd faces life head on!

CVs smoked a drug causing retrograde amnesia and the result is the present scenario.😃



LOL thank you :P


For now, Anika is mouthing contrived lines so no, she will not be able to see how she has never really faced the predicament Shivaay has...of trying to save EVERYONE at the same time without sacrificing one for the other...she will not be able to remember that she too has been blackmailed in dire circumstances and did choose her family and did so PROUDLY...many times she's said to Shivaay already that if you care for your brothers, I care for mine...so since when did that start to imply he doesn't care about her? lol


For now, we too are expected to forget that for nearly two years, Anika told Shivaay this was the quality she liked BEST about him...that he loves his family above all else...for now, we are expected to switch gears and know that Anika wanted Shivaay and us to read her mind all this time and understand the expectations she never verbalized😆


And yes, it's damn funny that Anika feels just walking away and total communication block out ends a relationship...ROFL no one is interested in addressing the legalities of marriage here it seems😆


Anika IS brave...and does face most things in life headon...but the rules change when things come to Shivaay and her past...then she's quite willing to walk out many times for different reasons...lol


Right now hurt and ego is utterly blinding her...so don't expect her to talk sense anytime soon😆...she's frankly being childish...and so is Shivaay in some ways.
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Hriju321

Was she ever blackmailed with Sahil as leverage? Ah yes she was...by Shivaay himself...lol and did she give in? Why yes she did😆...by marrying Shivaay...so raising this issue of "Family v/s husband v/s wife" again and again is counterproductive...not sure if the writers will tackle that properly here.


This is the best explanation I have come across.Annika herself gave in to blackmail to save "her family" and she is averse to understand the predicament of Shivaay?
Even if she was emotional and made a hurried judgement,did she not think over her actions once?
Shivaay wants to confront Annika and demand explanations but Annika wants to build a wall of indifference and just fade away.But she forgets that she is still married and is the legal wife of SSO.Isn't running away cowardly ? And I had for the past almost 2 years assumed that Annika is brave anbd faces life head on!

CVs smoked a drug causing retrograde amnesia and the result is the present scenario.😃


That is the worst part she always likes to disappear in thin air without even giving a single thought that he must be in search of answers knowing very well that shivaay needs answers usko keeda hai to getting to root he himself told her in jungle track that mujhe janana hota hai that i cannot help it it is something inbuilt in him

Yes she went and she has her reasons but plz atleast leave a little note saying as much as i am out give him some sort of closure. His pain gets multiplied like this every single time caz ek toh she leaves him 2nd without any answers as he said it too that if he won'tknow where he is wrong how will he fix it. Silence is not an answer here and forget about dignity here uska question hi nahi hai in this running away pretending to be someone else ek lamhe ke liye bhi pyar kia toh she would have left him a note a text amessage with even khanna that don't look for me even thoughshe knows it is impossible he will anyways look for her still narazgi main hi tell him offanything could'vebeen better than this utter silence every single time
Edited by naadanmasakalli - 7 years ago
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
Speaking of the legality of the marriage...someone please explain to me why Anika is randomly walking around with her MS in her hand if she says this rishta is over? :P

Matlab rishta khatam bhi hai but MS ko bhi pakad ke baithna hai? Is this child's play, Anika? lol
Arudra1009 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Hi...mostly a silent reader on the forum. You have beautifully put up perspectives from both ends. Now, what more strange turns, contrived dialogs & plot convinences are going to emerge, remains to be seen. At the end of this who learns what?
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Arudra1009

Hi...mostly a silent reader on the forum. You have beautifully put up perspectives from both ends. Now, what more strange turns, contrived dialogs & plot convinences are going to emerge, remains to be seen. At the end of this who learns what?



Hey thank you! :)


@bold: lol good question...only Gulneet can answer that...we as the audience will learn how 200 more episodes are added to a show, that's it...haha otherwise no one seems to learn anything.


Jokes apart, there is scope for validly addressing the issue of why Anika felt like an outsider and why neither her or Shivaay ever pushed for her to say OUR family instead of YOUR or MY family...but the writers will muddle it up in cheap ideas like fake Chutki/fake biwi as usual🥱

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".